Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cyclists who act like they own the road should pay towards it

744 replies

dreamingofsun · 10/08/2023 10:18

So cyclists get priority on the roads, and are happy to ride two abreast so they hold all the car traffic up. Shouldnt they at least pay towards the upkeep of the road?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
EldenRing4 · 14/08/2023 13:04

Also to add OP I work near the countryside, cyclists regularly stick more to the side of the road allowing cars to overtake which I'm grateful for. On narrow country roads they pull in.
Very civilised people.

The REAL solution is of course to re-architect entire areas with sufficient roads, public transport etc but that would be too expensive! It's easier for gov to pay lip service by pushing cyclists onto the same roads as cars, making up stupid rules and let the plebs fight over the scraps.

EldenRing4 · 14/08/2023 13:01

DatumTarum · 14/08/2023 10:02

Why?

To make up for the trauma of having to wait behind a cyclist of 0.8 seconds, that's why.

That is literally, what this is about.

0.8 seconds? When you're behind a cyclist on national speed limit roads for more than a mile? Give over.

What I don't understand is... cars can be pulled over and FINED for driving too slowly.
https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/motors/can-you-fined-driving-slow-24265651
https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/uk-news/drivers-warned-lesser-known-rule-27515187

Ergo, something going too slowly is a hazard.

How does it being a bicycle as opposed to a car magically make it not a hazard?
Seeing as you have to treat the former as the latter now by giving the same amount of room to overtake.

Driving too slow could land you an unlimited fine and invalidate your insurance

We focus on speed driving, but driving at a snail's pace can be dangerous too

https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/motors/can-you-fined-driving-slow-24265651

WellPlaced · 14/08/2023 13:00

Frabbits · 14/08/2023 12:55

How do you feel about people driving for leisure? Presumably you don't like those people either?

Or those who drive to the gym or exercise class?

WellPlaced · 14/08/2023 12:58

The clue is in the word ‘public’

Frabbits · 14/08/2023 12:57

Castall · 14/08/2023 12:50

@MikeRafone

ps we could make the fee 40£ which would be enough as that one do the fees the info commission charges to companies etc

so perhaps it can work.

and yes I made my suggestions clear and they are the ones you reacted too and I am sure a man with your intersect will not have forgotten that so soon ?

More cyclists on the road benefits everyone.

Lower congestion. Lower pollution. Lower wear on the roads. All the health benefits of encouraging exercise. Lower number of accidents.

We absolutely should not put cost barriers in the way of that. Mandatory insurance/registration for cyclists is a terrible, terrible idea.

WellPlaced · 14/08/2023 12:56

Tinythumbelina · 14/08/2023 12:54

I don't mind those who use the roads for a commute but I don't know any other sport you're allowed to do on pu lic roads!

Run
Walk
Hike
Ride a Horse

Frabbits · 14/08/2023 12:55

Tinythumbelina · 14/08/2023 12:54

I don't mind those who use the roads for a commute but I don't know any other sport you're allowed to do on pu lic roads!

How do you feel about people driving for leisure? Presumably you don't like those people either?

Tinythumbelina · 14/08/2023 12:54

I don't mind those who use the roads for a commute but I don't know any other sport you're allowed to do on pu lic roads!

Castall · 14/08/2023 12:50

@MikeRafone

ps we could make the fee 40£ which would be enough as that one do the fees the info commission charges to companies etc

so perhaps it can work.

and yes I made my suggestions clear and they are the ones you reacted too and I am sure a man with your intersect will not have forgotten that so soon ?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 14/08/2023 12:39

Brumbies · 14/08/2023 10:02

Cyclist Wearing a helmet doesn't make me feel better. It might th tho were they to fall off and hit their head!

That's up to the cyclist to decide. Not the impatient driver who can't be bothered to wait behind them until it's safe to pass.

As I said above, a helmet won't help me if a car squashes me anyway. Hi-vis is a lot more important (and should, in my view, be worn by pedestrians as well once the clocks go back in October).

WellPlaced · 14/08/2023 12:37

If we turn this into a helmet debate it will rumble on with no significant outcome.

It’s not the law to wear one in the UK, and most other countries. End of

MrsAvocet · 14/08/2023 12:21

OneTC · 14/08/2023 11:35

I don't wear a helmet for cycling on roads but I do wear one for single track mountain biking. When I'm riding on the road on my way to the single track with my helmet on my own personal experience is that the data checks out that people don't give you as much space and are more inclined to close pass. I find that the closer I am to ideal, ie brightly lit, wearing Hi Vis, helmet, the more drivers are willing to drive badly around you

The most conclusive evidence about the effect of helmets on cycling safety is that they encourage drivers to take the piss

Possibly depends were you live. That's not my experience. I find the majority of drivers round here are pretty considerate and there's not a lot of traffic anyway, but on our largely unlit rural roads I think it makes sense to be as visible as possible.
Obviously if you come into contact with a car at any significant speed the likelihood is that you will have multiple injuries and a helmet is not going to make a blind bit of difference to most of those - death is most likely to result from chest/abdomen/pelvis trauma and/or absolutely catastrophic head/neck injury. Therefore helmet wearing won't make any major impact. But isolated head injuries are fairly common in cyclist vs the ground incidents, and there is evidence of injury severity reduction in those circumstances. That's the reason why helmets are mandatory in racing and presumably why you wear one on your MTB?
I'm more concerned about the deteriorating state of the roads (and indeed cycle paths) than drivers where I live to be honest. My only significant accident cycling on the road in the last 30 years involved a pothole, not another vehicle, and the resulting injury was a relatively small traumatic sub arachnoid haemorrhage but that could well have been a life changing head injury in the absence of a helmet. If the only type of collision I was likely to sustain on the road was one with a car or other vehicle then I would agree that a helmet is largely pointless. But my experience is that that isn't the case.

MikeRafone · 14/08/2023 12:14

Castall

i get you don't like mine.

I don't know yours, are they nice?

Castall · 14/08/2023 12:11

@MikeRafone

i get you don't like mine.
well done for having insurance.
and thank you for telling us all and I am glad you are that responsible.

MikeRafone · 14/08/2023 12:09

i get you don't like my ideas.

I have insurance, Its renewed every year - what difference would it make to me if my bikes were also registered?

Its not a case of not liking your idea, I'm pointing out that its been answered by government as to why they won't do this and if a tory party of the rich will not do it - can't see a Labour Party doing it

Castall · 14/08/2023 12:04

@MikeRafone

you point being?
people don't agree?
ie the vested interested who sign those petitions ?

that's why we have the HOP

shame about the current party in there

i get you don't like my ideas.
that's a shame but your views on keep the status quo I feel are rather outdated and rely on common sense which appears lacking currently.

MikeRafone · 14/08/2023 12:01

@Castall

The links earlier show the outcome of the government on the petition for your suggestion

Castall · 14/08/2023 11:55

@MikeRafone

well

a. That was before aps and newer systems to be fair, so on line payments rescue the admin costs hugely.
b. Public services cost and cyclists should have insurance at the very least.
c. Yeah dogs should have a license too.

MikeRafone · 14/08/2023 11:53

DdraigGoch · 14/08/2023 10:30

Then surely it's their business whether they wear one or not.

I've fallen of my bike and hit my head twice in my life. Once I was wearing a helmet and the other time I was not. Once I ended up in hospital with concussion, they kept me there all day and once I was ok. Whilst at the hospital the doctor looked at the smashed helmet and said well that didn't stand up to much...I fell at approximately 10mph certainly no more than that and wearing a BS helmet - it did jack shit. Both times I fell they were almost replica incidents

The only reason I wear a helmet is, if I am killed by a driver I don't want my dds to suffer the police and public saying "oh if she had worn a helmet" A helmet will not protect me against a driver in a car

MikeRafone · 14/08/2023 11:44

@Castall

It'll cost more than that to administer the registration - its why they got rid of dog licences, as the cost outweighed the need

OneTC · 14/08/2023 11:35

MrsAvocet · 14/08/2023 11:21

Not equally actually. The evidence for benefit from wearing bike helmet is nowhere near as strong as for seatbelts in cars.
If someone makes an informed decision not to wear a helmet, they are not breaking the law and it is a matter of personal choice. There are not actually many countries where helmet wearing is mandatory as the statistical evidence is not that strong. Personally I do always wear a helmet - I think that on balance the positives outweigh the negatives - but even as a committed helmet wearer I acknowledge that there are arguments to the contrary. When you look at the data it is not as convincing as you might imagine.
Same goes for hi vis clothing. Intuitively, you would think it should make a big difference. Actually data doesn't support that view. Again, for myself, I never wear all black when cycling. I wear a white helmet and light or bright tops and I put my lights on in the day in all but the very brightest of weather, because my personal opinion is that when I am driving I see cyclists earlier if they are dressed brightly and have lights on. So when I am cycling I wear the things I think I'd spot early when I am driving. But I know that's anecdote not data, and that the data does not currently support legislative change.

I don't wear a helmet for cycling on roads but I do wear one for single track mountain biking. When I'm riding on the road on my way to the single track with my helmet on my own personal experience is that the data checks out that people don't give you as much space and are more inclined to close pass. I find that the closer I am to ideal, ie brightly lit, wearing Hi Vis, helmet, the more drivers are willing to drive badly around you

The most conclusive evidence about the effect of helmets on cycling safety is that they encourage drivers to take the piss

Castall · 14/08/2023 11:29

@dreamingofsun

as small 20 a year fee and helmets and insurance and a bills license/ registration fee

thats what is needed.

also get the e scooters sorted too!

OneTC · 14/08/2023 11:23

DatumTarum · 14/08/2023 10:47

Maybe the motorist responsible (that's nearly always the case) should foot the bill?

Whilst I don't agree that people should have to wear helmets most bike crashes and injuries come about through people falling off. Not in collisions with vehicles

OneTC · 14/08/2023 11:23

DatumTarum · 14/08/2023 10:47

Maybe the motorist responsible (that's nearly always the case) should foot the bill?

Whilst I don't agree that people should have to wear helmets most bike crashes and injuries come about through people falling off. Not in collisions with vehicles

MrsAvocet · 14/08/2023 11:21

Brumbies · 14/08/2023 10:41

Equally you could say wearing a seat belt should be voluntary- despite statistics showing they save lives?

Not equally actually. The evidence for benefit from wearing bike helmet is nowhere near as strong as for seatbelts in cars.
If someone makes an informed decision not to wear a helmet, they are not breaking the law and it is a matter of personal choice. There are not actually many countries where helmet wearing is mandatory as the statistical evidence is not that strong. Personally I do always wear a helmet - I think that on balance the positives outweigh the negatives - but even as a committed helmet wearer I acknowledge that there are arguments to the contrary. When you look at the data it is not as convincing as you might imagine.
Same goes for hi vis clothing. Intuitively, you would think it should make a big difference. Actually data doesn't support that view. Again, for myself, I never wear all black when cycling. I wear a white helmet and light or bright tops and I put my lights on in the day in all but the very brightest of weather, because my personal opinion is that when I am driving I see cyclists earlier if they are dressed brightly and have lights on. So when I am cycling I wear the things I think I'd spot early when I am driving. But I know that's anecdote not data, and that the data does not currently support legislative change.