Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has lack of manners stopped you giving things away free?

185 replies

dottypotter · 09/08/2023 22:26

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

Somebody contacted and said they were interested. I Gave them the address etc and discussed time as you do. Seemed keen to come.

No show, no apology. Im sure not the only person to experience this. I could not be so rude though. If I could not make it I would message.

I wont bother again. Why are people so rude?
They just spoil it.
Has it stopped you giving things away free?😪

OP posts:
LondonJax · 10/08/2023 10:58

I won't bother with Facebook marketplace again because of no shows. I had one woman who 'got called into work' on three occasions so couldn't collect an item I was giving away. I didn't bother chasing her after the third excuse and she's never got back in touch. I took them to the local charity shop in the end.

That happened on two other items too, different people, so I just went to the next in line and one of those people was in their car within minutes of me saying yes. It's a pity you can't rate these people so others know whether to bother with them.

It doesn't take a minute to just say sorry to mess you about, I've changed my mind.

littleripper · 10/08/2023 10:58

Yes, and I stopped giving to Charity shops after the ones local to me started inspecting the items you'd donated and loudly discussing them in the shop doorway!!! I am sorry if you have too many baby clothes and I am sorry that one of the vests was stained, I did not notice, I am sorry. Why couldn't you leave them in the bag and thank me for the 6 complete with instructions boxes of lego. Anyway, I gave it all to a local nursery and they were v pleased.

Goldbar · 10/08/2023 10:48

Not generally. To the offender, yes.

Mummy2022FT · 10/08/2023 10:40

Made4Sunshine · 10/08/2023 06:08

I posted a pram for free and the claminent hadn't even collected it before she posted it for sale on another group.
She even used the same photo , featuring my hallway.
Needless to say, I contacted the next in line.

@Made4Sunshine

omg this is appalling!

HectorPlasm · 10/08/2023 10:38

A hospice shop in leafy Cheshire - didn't even look me in the eye when I gave them a huge bag of stuff, just a curt 'put it over there'. Nothing else for them ever.

A foodbank collection point in the same place - similar story.

My local charity shop - warm, friendly, grateful, get all our stuff

Coastalcreeksider · 10/08/2023 10:32

Coastalcreeksider · 10/08/2023 08:22

I'm giving away some plants today, both people who requested them said please and thank you in their requests and have come back to say when they will collect. Hopefully, they will turn up to pick up the plants.

In the past I've given away loads of stuff on Freecycle, furniture, pictures, ornaments etc. also, have had requests then absolutely nothing even when I've asked are they still interested. I now block them from asking for anything in future.

One now can't collect due to waiting in for delivery ...

Minimooncat · 10/08/2023 10:32

Hibiscrubbed · 10/08/2023 06:41

Facebook marketplace is a bizarre place, where manners, literacy and numeracy, and normal social interactions go to die.

Yes exactly this. I've been abused, threatened, had numerous no shows and rude messages when I haven't immediately replied to their messages within 5 minutes. I give to charity or do car boots now. Though even at a car boot people are really rude trying to haggle down from £1 to 10p for a designer top!

jlpth · 10/08/2023 09:57

I won't engage with this sort of behaviour. I now just chuck things in the bin. Shame, but things are just made so difficult by people's awful behaviour.

SunRainStorm · 10/08/2023 09:52

Made4Sunshine · 10/08/2023 06:08

I posted a pram for free and the claminent hadn't even collected it before she posted it for sale on another group.
She even used the same photo , featuring my hallway.
Needless to say, I contacted the next in line.

Cheeky bitch

thecatsthecats · 10/08/2023 09:36

If I stick something on the drive, it's a blink and you'll miss it affair before it's gone. Saves a hell of a lot of time.

We lived in an apartment block with a similar culture until the twat in the penthouse complained.

AnneElliott · 10/08/2023 09:33

I put free stuff on a local group that's heavily moderated and they enforce manners! Plus they block people from the group if they sell it on or don't turn up to collect.

Otherwise I offer on the street what's app group as I know they can walk down and collect it!

Anything metal though goes out the front and is gone in 10 minutes!

Pineappleandredcheese · 10/08/2023 09:17

A mate and his girlfriend of my ex

They didn't have much money and two boys
I asked if they'd like my ds's old clothes and they said yes

So I lugged 4 black bags to their flat (36 miles away)

No thank you,just snatched the bags out of my hands and stood going through it

all,telling me it was all 'crap and how their boys didn't wear tat like primark' (one pair of unworn shorts-rest where good quality)

They marched off with a few bits-leaving the rest all over the floor

I was fuming-if they'd said thank you,gone through the stuff and gave back what they didn't like that would have been fine'it was the pulling out,laughing and throwing it on the floor that got to me

I got a Facebook message about 8 weeks later demanding 'owt else u gt 4 ma Boiis?

Nope

SuperiorM · 10/08/2023 09:11

Iv’e used Freecycle in the past but have also felt people aren’t as friendly as you expect them to be. Mostly, I donate to our local charity shops and they are always happy to receive stuff. There are a few things they aren’t allowed to take but they are always lovely about it.

Not tried Vinted, but have used Gumtree. I offered a new Le Creuset that was too heavy to use once and some buyer kept trying to knock the price down. I ended up offering it on a work based chat platform and got rid of it straightaway. The work based platform has been useful for offering free stuff from time to time too.

Have heard a few Gumtree horror stories. Someone in our baby group had a prospective buyer who wanted her to do extra on the spot cleaning of the high chair she was selling. Very ott

Hoppinggreen · 10/08/2023 09:08

No but I don’t get into any discussions and give the item to the first people who turn up.
Will you deliver it to Timbuktu for £5? No
Can you keep it until next October? No
Can you send more photos? No

Ofcourseshecan · 10/08/2023 09:05

I give everything sellable to a charity shop. Used to offer a lot of less-sellable stuff (eg slightly worn or marked) on Freecycle but got tired of time-wasters. Interesting that people on this thread have had more luck offering items for sale than free of charge! I will try this on a local site.

liverpoolgal82 · 10/08/2023 09:05

Hillrunning · 10/08/2023 06:11

No it doesn't stop me. I give things away because it is easier tha. Ne going ro the tip/charity shop ect. Not because I want manners or thanks.

I give people gifts because I want to celebrate them. Not because I want thanks from them.

So while yes I agree that both are being rude. It doesn't change what I do because the gratitude isn't the reason I do it.

I don’t think the op mentioned wanting gratitude. She just wants people to show up and collect or let her know which is basic manners.
And as a side note if we are now living in a society where basic thank you manners aren’t the norm then what a time to be living 🤦‍♀️

Elphame · 10/08/2023 08:58

People are just getting ruder.

I don’t answer those who’s first message is “ I want this” or “mine”. They are always time wasters. Probably rude of me but I don’t much care.

Not free but I had someone complain the other day that he could get something I was selling cheaper on ebay. I suggested politely that he bought it on ebay! It sold the next day at the price I wanted for it.

Coffeeforus · 10/08/2023 08:53

I mix n match as to whether I put it on one of our local Freecycle groups or send to the charity shops. I’ve only ever had two people mess me around but the most I get is a few people asking me to deliver the item when I have already stated ‘collection only.’

My SIL asked for any baby’s clothes we didn’t want anymore so we got them from the loft and sorted through. We offered her 4 big rubbish sacks of them (all in great condition and good quality brands) and she never said thanks, so never again.

My friend has a child a year younger than mine and I text her quite a few photos of clothes I was going to give away and asked if she was interested. She said yes to all but a few hours after she collected almost all of them appeared on a local children’s selling group. I know she can do as she likes once they are hers but that was just taking the p*.

So, now any good kids clothes go to the local baby bank instead.

Work2live · 10/08/2023 08:52

I sell the odd few bits on Facebook marketplace and never reply to rude people.

I don’t expect grand shows of politeness but it’s incredible the amount of people who will just message you saying ‘10?’

In the early days when I did entertain these people I noticed a huge correlation between rudeness, and the time wasters/no-shows. Most of the polite people turn up when agreed.

FiddleMinger · 10/08/2023 08:50

Arrghh, I hate this! Someone posted on my local group asking if anyone happens to have any roof felt. As luck would have it, I has some and offered it. When they collected, I asked if they have the roof felt glue and offered to find and give them in the next few days. Every day, for the next few days, they messaged about the glue.

I got my DH to find and leave out. I messaged the guy to say I’d found it and that I’d leave in my porch the next day. The following evening I noticed the glue gone, but no email. So I sent a quick message to check if he’d indeed collected. The one word reply “yeah” has irrationally irked me since. It pissed me off because it’s not as though I’d offered to try and get rid. I thought it’d be nice to give to help with his project. Definitely think twice in future.

PinkMendinilla · 10/08/2023 08:35

It hasn't stopped me doing it if it's the easiest thing for me (say I'm not sure a charity shop will take the item) but it's a lot more work and a lot more irritating than it should be. No shows, last minute cancellations, rudeness, lateness, one really weird and intimidating guy, pressuring.

One woman was after an item, I let her know a pickup was arranged that day but she had first refusal if the collector didn't turn up. Cue an upsetting and detailed account of a relative experiencing DV. I would feel terrible for anyone in that position but she was behaving as though my free bookcase was the difference between this woman and her kids being able to set up their new life away from the abuser and not. I didn't think that was on.

Kabbalah · 10/08/2023 08:26

If it’s worth more than £50 I may put it on eBay otherwise it all goes to the tip - I simply don’t have the time or patience to bugger about.

Coastalcreeksider · 10/08/2023 08:22

I'm giving away some plants today, both people who requested them said please and thank you in their requests and have come back to say when they will collect. Hopefully, they will turn up to pick up the plants.

In the past I've given away loads of stuff on Freecycle, furniture, pictures, ornaments etc. also, have had requests then absolutely nothing even when I've asked are they still interested. I now block them from asking for anything in future.

Glarptip · 10/08/2023 08:19

Northernsoullover · 10/08/2023 07:14

I don't give any free stuff any more. I'll put a price on them. Even if an item is worth 30 quid I'll sell for a fiver. You still get piss takers but I find that there are less.
If someone wants to sell it on for more then I don't care.

Yes, advertising stuff for free attracts nutters.

I also gave that up and sell cheap, rather than gratis.

ChristmasCrumpet · 10/08/2023 08:13

I don't expect a big show of thanks if I'm giving something away for free, because most people know they are in fact saving me a trip to the charity shop/tip. It's one of those mutually beneficial things.

Anyone who wants free things delivered/any further effort just gets ignored. And if you get an influx of the instant "I'll have it!" because it's free, I simply reply "Sure, but please be aware I don't hold free items, so it's first to collect. When would you like to collect?" The time wasters don't even bother replying after that, and the ones that do, generally turn up pretty quickly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread