Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has lack of manners stopped you giving things away free?

185 replies

dottypotter · 09/08/2023 22:26

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

Somebody contacted and said they were interested. I Gave them the address etc and discussed time as you do. Seemed keen to come.

No show, no apology. Im sure not the only person to experience this. I could not be so rude though. If I could not make it I would message.

I wont bother again. Why are people so rude?
They just spoil it.
Has it stopped you giving things away free?😪

OP posts:
bctf123 · 10/08/2023 11:36

dottypotter · 09/08/2023 22:26

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

Somebody contacted and said they were interested. I Gave them the address etc and discussed time as you do. Seemed keen to come.

No show, no apology. Im sure not the only person to experience this. I could not be so rude though. If I could not make it I would message.

I wont bother again. Why are people so rude?
They just spoil it.
Has it stopped you giving things away free?😪

It is selfish.
I was abroad once and despite my tour guide's instructions I gave money to some young children. At that point I was mobbed and the kids followed me to my coach and in the end took 20 quid
After that I never give to people on the streets which has saved me a lot of money. I just say sorry several times until they disappear. The UK is full of beggars and chancers now and I don't want to give them money for a full hearted meal

Holidayvibes · 10/08/2023 11:35

Yes happened to me loads. What I do now is dependent on what it is I list it for £5/£10 when the person comes I then say it’s free. Normally very taken aback and grateful. I just tell them when I list for free always get no shows.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 10/08/2023 11:35

Some really shocking tales of rudeness here! My favourite is the mum who wanted the giver of children's clothes to pay for the taxi to send them to her one town over!

The lack of gratitude and downright bizarre requests is definitely rudeness and entitlement, some seem to be an attempt to retain dignity. Demanding free delivery and critiquing items as a way of saving face showing they aren't a charity case.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/08/2023 11:34

I won't engage with this sort of behaviour

Nor I

It's not stopped me giving away stuff for free, and happily many people are lovely, but rudeness is instantly deleted and/or ignored
Even if rude requests start up after they arrive for whatever-it-is I'll simply turn my back and shut the door - they may or may not be bewildered or offended, but that's for them to work out not me

sequin2000 · 10/08/2023 11:30

I agree that a small charge is more likely to result in genuine buyers. Olio is so much better than facebook as you can review collectors.

BertieBotts · 10/08/2023 11:27

YY way too annoying.

I will message a small group of friends to see if anyone there wants something for free. Because I know people won't mess around, plus I am actually likely to see them.

Other than that I leave it out as there is a place in our estate where people leave things/pick them up. Or baby items, next to the community centre on a day that there is a baby group there. If nobody attending the group wants it, the workers will take it and find a home for it.

If I have no luck here then I donate to charity shop.

I occasionally sell stuff on marketplace, if it's big/bulky and worth more than a fiver.

I sell outgrown children's clothes on vinted, that is quite good.

purplecorkheart · 10/08/2023 11:24

Yes it has. In my former workplace we had chairs that we needed to get rid of as they were unsuitable for what was needed. We advertised them and a man came to collect. Walked in and wanted also to take desks etc that people were sitting at. He got very aggressive when he was told no.

Oliotya · 10/08/2023 11:24

I give away loads on Facebook. Best is our local Buy Nothing group, but marketplace works too. Stuff gets left on doorstep at agreed time, if they don't show, gets brought back in and reposted.
I give stuff away because I hate waste and need space in my house. Manners and gratitude aren't really relevant. It's not an act of benevolence. I'm also not bothered if they turn around and sell it.
Charities and charity shops are far more fussy and require far more effort on my part.

Forgoodnesssakewhatnow · 10/08/2023 11:23

I was giving away some unused garden fence panels. I got a response saying ‘I need these first thing in the morning because my gardener starts work.’

I ignored it because there were no manners and twenty minutes later received ‘Did you get my message?’

erm l, yes I did. But you can sod off.

Northernladdette · 10/08/2023 11:21

That and “Can you deliver?” 😩😩

hippygirllucky · 10/08/2023 11:21

I've also had someone take free baby clothes only to find her flogging them on market place a few days later. Technically her choice but it annoyed me because another mum might genuinely have needed them and she just wanted to sell them.

User6424678852 · 10/08/2023 11:20

JusthereforXmas · 10/08/2023 11:08

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

If its something you are essentially going to bin but you decided to make yourself warm and fuzzy by claiming to 'protecting the enviroment' you would give it away instead but now aren't going to because people didn't grovel and praise you enough for giving them your unwanted trash... you might be an egotistical twat thats not that 'nice'.

I agree!

YABVU OP. If you are getting rid of something then it’s on you to ensure it is reused if possible, and recycled if not. Not just sent to landfill because people weren’t polite enough to you. If there was a no-show, try again.

On a more positive note, I find Gumtree much better for general manners than freecycle.

hippygirllucky · 10/08/2023 11:19

I once had a person send me a blow by blow of their journey to my house "I've just finished work, getting in my car", "I'll be 20mins", "10 mins away" and then never show. It was the weirdest thing.

PinkMendinilla · 10/08/2023 11:19

Those saying people shouldn't have to show gratitude as they're saving a journey- well no, I'm not looking for gushing thanks, tears or an inner feeling of warmth. Just simple politeness and sticking to plans or letting me know if they can't do so, as with any other interaction. It does seem a bit of a no mans land for civility.

Bookworm20 · 10/08/2023 11:19

Yes. recently gave a load of childrens clothes and toys to a friend of a friend who was stuggling for money. All good stuff and would be the right age for her dc (she has 4 of them and clothes would have fitted the oldest 2).
Not a word of thanks or anything when she picked them up. Just a mutter of 'these will come in handy'. I just thought, would it have killed you to add a thanks to end of that sentance.

The next lot will be going to the charity shop.

I couldn't collect something for free from anyone and not be able to say thankyou. Its sort of automatic. But obviously not with some people.

HowToRedeem · 10/08/2023 11:18

Yes, definitely.

If I do it now I stick to a strategy the most important part is not giving out my full address until just before they need to leave to collect it. e.g. I tell them I live at NG2 1 and that if they text me x mins before the pick up time I'll give them the full address. That pretty much stops no shows.

oakleaffy · 10/08/2023 11:17

Igniteyourbones · 10/08/2023 08:02

I wanted to pass on my much loved children’s cotbed to someone in need. It was a lovely cot from John Lewis still in great condition. So many memories of my 4 babies sleeping in it. I posted it online asking if anyone knew someone pregnant or with a new baby that didn’t have much money and would appreciate a free cot. A lady arranged to come pick it up, put all the dismantled pieces into her car……. Then as she was walking away said “Thanks this will be great for my dog, she’s a bit wild and is a biter, so will be great for keeping her in.” Then jumped in the car and drove off. I was so upset, that’s not at all what I intended when giving it away.

That's awful! And completely unsuitable for a nasty, snappy dog.

Why didn't she train her mutt? Plus, a wooden cot could be bitten through by a dog very easily, or jumped out of.

She sounds nuts. Most people would buy a dog crate or train.

Give0fecks · 10/08/2023 11:11

Yes repeatedly. Whenever I’ve listed anything I get requests for providing free delivery - sometimes upto an hour away - and then abuse when I decline. No I’m not going to make an hour round trip to give you something for free. Especially when you don’t say please.

JusthereforXmas · 10/08/2023 11:08

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

If its something you are essentially going to bin but you decided to make yourself warm and fuzzy by claiming to 'protecting the enviroment' you would give it away instead but now aren't going to because people didn't grovel and praise you enough for giving them your unwanted trash... you might be an egotistical twat thats not that 'nice'.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 10/08/2023 11:08

I offered two Stairgate's.

Some guy messaged me and said

"Where do you live? I want them"

I didn't reply because it was so fucking abrupt.

He followed it up with

"hello? I will take them."

nah you fucking won't.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/08/2023 11:08

Made4Sunshine · 10/08/2023 06:08

I posted a pram for free and the claminent hadn't even collected it before she posted it for sale on another group.
She even used the same photo , featuring my hallway.
Needless to say, I contacted the next in line.

Nooooo! So cheeky!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/08/2023 11:07

Use olio that's the best one for manners

Prinnny · 10/08/2023 11:07

Yep. Was giving away an item, woman messaged I gave her the address then she said her husband would pick up it when he finished work at 10pm, I said no sorry too late but I’m happy to keep it until convenient she said okay I’ll let you know when. The next day some man turns up knocking on my door we have a ring cam, he couldn’t speak English just kept shouting ‘bike now’, tried to explain through the doorbell we weren’t home, he then starts walking around the back of the house, peering over the gate etc for a good ten mins before leaving. The woman then messaged me hours later saying my husband has just been why are you not in!!! She was swiftly blocked!

LinaM20 · 10/08/2023 11:06

We’ve got a great local Facebook group. The admin is really strict and repeat non collectors are removed from the group. She also won’t let you receive until you’ve given, even if what you’ve given is cardboard boxes, carrier bags, coat hangers etc, people still want them for various things. We’re a village group and you’ve usually got a mutual friend with the other person so that helps too.

Someone once asked for wood as she was building a chicken coop. I said I had an old shed she could have as long as she came and took it down etc. she did. She was really pleased with the wood and I was really pleased to get rid of the shed!

1mabon · 10/08/2023 11:02

I gave someone a young person a gift of £200.00, never had a thank you.