Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has lack of manners stopped you giving things away free?

185 replies

dottypotter · 09/08/2023 22:26

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

Somebody contacted and said they were interested. I Gave them the address etc and discussed time as you do. Seemed keen to come.

No show, no apology. Im sure not the only person to experience this. I could not be so rude though. If I could not make it I would message.

I wont bother again. Why are people so rude?
They just spoil it.
Has it stopped you giving things away free?😪

OP posts:
alwaysmovingforwards · 10/08/2023 13:44

Hillrunning · 10/08/2023 06:11

No it doesn't stop me. I give things away because it is easier tha. Ne going ro the tip/charity shop ect. Not because I want manners or thanks.

I give people gifts because I want to celebrate them. Not because I want thanks from them.

So while yes I agree that both are being rude. It doesn't change what I do because the gratitude isn't the reason I do it.

Yeah I'm the same.

Additionally I don't think the world is perfect. A fair % of people are just a bit thick, not organised, have other things that crop up, are rude, greedy, ungrateful, have no empathy or understanding or others or just generally twatish..
Always has been always will be.
To not understand that, think everyone should be like them and get stroppy when they're not.. well it must make planet Earth a very frustrating place to live 😂😂

HeadChog · 10/08/2023 13:32

I once offered a large boxed celebration cake (all covered in pick iced roses) from Sainsburys which IIRC I paid £18 for but it was due to pass its best before date that day or next day. I'd over catered for a family party and no way would I have got through this cake before it went stale, so put it on my local FB group and said first to come and get it could have it, and to make me a an offer re price (allowing people to offer according to their means).

This cake got so much attention - I had long messages with tales of woe: one person was disabled and wanted it delivered, a gay man insisted I sold it to him because it was pink "and everyone knows the gays love pink", a woman said she wanted to treat her sons as she couldn't get them to sit down and talk to her but maybe this cake would tempt them. In the end the woman with sons could get to me first. She swung by in a very nice open-top car, looking like Stifler's Mom, and when she had the cake in her hands, told me (a) her sons were actually in their twenties and (b) she'd got no money on her, so gave me a handful of change from her parking pot - about £1.70.

I felt exhausted from all the emotional baggage I'd had dumped on me, not to mention aggrieved that it hadn't gone to a genuinely needy person or that I hadn't at least recouped a reasonable amount for it

Now I name my price. I do not enter into negotiations. And I eat any leftover cakes.

letloz · 10/08/2023 13:31

I give everything away for free rather than chuck it if possible. Yes, you get the odd rude no show/no apologies
But most people do show up, and are very grateful. Why punish all the nice people because of the behaviour of one?

TokyoStories · 10/08/2023 13:29

I've supposedly got two people coming today to collect things, but neither has confirmed after I sent my address yesterday and one of them had no manners at all in her messages. I'm pretty confident neither will show up.

InSpainTheRain · 10/08/2023 13:18

Yes OP, rudeness has stopped me giving away stuff for free! We have a local facebook page where people give stuff for free. I had quite a few things from my parents's house when they passed away and I used to put a few things on there (vases, tea set etc). There was some argument about who had got what and a woman ended up banging on my door repeatedly shouting that I'd promised her a cut glass vase and she wanted it. I hadn't promised it at all and had already had several items free. She was literally crying and pouting at my door. I just gave up, came off the facebook group never gave anything else away! I either donate to charity if I think it's really nice or junk it. Too much hassle. A couple of people were actually lovely though - one lady had a teaset and she sent me a pic of her table all laid with it for her birthday tea - that was nice to know it was used and appreciated!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/08/2023 13:17

I was abroad once and despite my tour guide's instructions I gave money to some young children. At that point I was mobbed and the kids followed me to my coach and in the end took 20 quid
After that I never give to people on the streets which has saved me a lot of money. I just say sorry several times until they disappear

Depending on where you were and if the children genuinely had nothing, there's a way round that ... if you're going to give, do it just as you get on the bus, in the car or whatever to save the follow-on hassle

SunnyFrost · 10/08/2023 13:10

Pineappleandredcheese · 10/08/2023 09:17

A mate and his girlfriend of my ex

They didn't have much money and two boys
I asked if they'd like my ds's old clothes and they said yes

So I lugged 4 black bags to their flat (36 miles away)

No thank you,just snatched the bags out of my hands and stood going through it

all,telling me it was all 'crap and how their boys didn't wear tat like primark' (one pair of unworn shorts-rest where good quality)

They marched off with a few bits-leaving the rest all over the floor

I was fuming-if they'd said thank you,gone through the stuff and gave back what they didn't like that would have been fine'it was the pulling out,laughing and throwing it on the floor that got to me

I got a Facebook message about 8 weeks later demanding 'owt else u gt 4 ma Boiis?

Nope

Sorry but this made me snort. I would struggle to compose a reply to that message 🤣

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/08/2023 13:05

Elphame · 10/08/2023 08:58

People are just getting ruder.

I don’t answer those who’s first message is “ I want this” or “mine”. They are always time wasters. Probably rude of me but I don’t much care.

Not free but I had someone complain the other day that he could get something I was selling cheaper on ebay. I suggested politely that he bought it on ebay! It sold the next day at the price I wanted for it.

Isn't that the sort of bollocks they come out with on those American/US style lockup auction programmes? I'd block anybody who says it, gives a bloody great Britain's Got Talent spiel about the traumatic reasons why they must have it or has any of the selling shows in their likes.

However, we generally don't have stuff to give away that isn't fit for the bin, so it's a fairly academic rant these days...

FrostieBoabby · 10/08/2023 12:56

Yes, I've totally given up and tip everything that isn't for the local charity shop. During covid a FB Marketplace lady promised she was coming to collect a perfectly good kids wardrobe that evening, DH and I carried it out the house, wiped it down with antibacterial spray to keep everyone safe etc. DH went to work and the lady kept messaging saying I'm on my way but never turned up leaving me with a wardrobe sitting on the driveway for hours as i couldn't move it on my own. Naturally it then pissed with rain hours later and ruined it and the perfectly decent expensive wardrobe ended up the tip.

Never again, being kind and generous isn't worth the hassle.

twelveerasers · 10/08/2023 12:51

I give my stuff to local hospice shops as I can't be bothered to engage with people on these selling sites.

I can't understand the ones that are always asking if people are giving away specific things then a week later looking for something else for free I never see them offering anything - it's all I want, I want

My mum and dad when they were in their late 70s gave away a settee and I was really angry to find out that the two of them had carried it to this persons house 10 minutes walk away - because the man had a bad back and couldn't lift things!!

BrightYellowDaffodil · 10/08/2023 12:48

User6424678852 · 10/08/2023 11:20

I agree!

YABVU OP. If you are getting rid of something then it’s on you to ensure it is reused if possible, and recycled if not. Not just sent to landfill because people weren’t polite enough to you. If there was a no-show, try again.

On a more positive note, I find Gumtree much better for general manners than freecycle.

Bollocks to that. Yes, if I can give something a new lease of life by finding a new home for it then great. But I'm not being messed about from here to Christmas by people who want you to deliver/never respond to messages/can't be bothered to read the description/are generally rude/don't turn up. Life is too damn short.

I've advertised stuff and if it goes quickly, great. Otherwise it's going to the tip (ours does have a recycling bit where you can ask the staff if the things you have can go in there, so that's a final chance I suppose) or the charity shop.

Solmum1964 · 10/08/2023 12:41

ohsoso · 10/08/2023 07:29

Spent all of yesterday putting stuff on Freecycle. I never do fastest finger first as it’s the same few people on our local freecycle who comment on everything! I usually give to those who are polite and say thank you and arrange speedy collection

I agree with this method.

FoodFann · 10/08/2023 12:39

If you’re giving something away for free, put in your advert that you won’t hold the item. Then, reply to all the ‘is this still available?’ questions with ‘yes’. Even if you’re promising the item to ten people. Only one or two will be genuine, and in my experience it will be the most grateful one. The rest just got over excited about a bargain.

I give lots of things away, and have had very grateful people, who even send me pics of the items afterwards (a plant they resurrected and a dog bed with their happy little dog in it!). Don’t be put off from doing something nice, but deffo don’t say the item is sold until it has actually left your property.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 10/08/2023 12:33

I Freecycle loads of stuff and yes, some people are utter arseholes. A lot seem to have the attitude that they’re doing you a favour by taking the item off your hands, rather than you’re doing them a favour by gifting them something for nothing!

In fact, placing no monetary value on things seems to really bring out the cheeky fuckers and choosing beggars, and make some people unbelievably awkward, picky and rude - to the extent that several times I’ve just thought sod this, and sold the item on eBay instead.

I also used to do the ‘first come, first served’ thing to try to be fair to people but I now wait for all the replies and pick the person who seems nicest, politest and least likely to dick me around.

ScribblingPixie · 10/08/2023 12:25

We've started doing a combination: put stuff outside and also put it on Freegle and Gumtree saying message if you want to collect it & we'll tell you the address where you can find it. Can't be arsed to do more than that when I'm giving it for free.

fyn · 10/08/2023 12:22

I definitely have skipped over people to next in line. I gave away an Xbox 360 last Christmas, the amount of shitty messages I got from people!

HalloumiLuvver · 10/08/2023 12:16

Kabbalah · 10/08/2023 08:26

If it’s worth more than £50 I may put it on eBay otherwise it all goes to the tip - I simply don’t have the time or patience to bugger about.

I wince when I read stuff like this. I know people have a lot going on in their lives but we all do need to make as much effort as possible for the planet and environment. I know stuff that's already made may end up in landfill eventually but if one or two more people get use out of an item, that's one or two less being bought new and helping reducing demand on resources.

NannyGythaOgg · 10/08/2023 12:14

Hillrunning · 10/08/2023 06:11

No it doesn't stop me. I give things away because it is easier tha. Ne going ro the tip/charity shop ect. Not because I want manners or thanks.

I give people gifts because I want to celebrate them. Not because I want thanks from them.

So while yes I agree that both are being rude. It doesn't change what I do because the gratitude isn't the reason I do it.

This is my view too.
Some people being rude doesn't stop me being me.

And I've had some lovely experiences.

I gave away an old tumble dryer through facebook and the single parent who picked it up was so so grateful. I don't do it for gratitude but it does help to make it feel worthwhile

Qwerty21 · 10/08/2023 12:14

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 10/08/2023 07:00

Offered a bag of girls clothing in my village Facebook group for free. Someone got in touch and asked if she could have it and I said yes. She said she didn't drive and asked if I could drop it off. I assumed she was local, said yes and asked for her address. She sent an address miles away which would have taken about 45-60 mins to drive to depending on traffic.

Explained I wasn't spending time and petrol driving all that way to drop them off. I said I was happy to drop off locally or she could send a friend/relative to pick them up.

She got back in touch and said she'd arranged someone to collect them in a taxi. We agreed an acceptable time for the collection, then on the last message she said the taxi driver would prefer being paid in cash when he got here to cover the round trip.

Told her I wasn't paying for a taxi to send them to her. Got a lengthy sob story about how she's a single parent and life is tough etc etc. Totally ignored the fact that I'm also a single parent and I can't afford to spend money on taxis to get rid of things I don't need.

Sent them to a charity shop instead.

That's seriously outrageous whose really that rude 😮

Ap24 · 10/08/2023 12:04

We put things on our front lawn, post on Facebook saying free for collection, no holding and saying that I will be out for the day. We are home but I just ignore the messages and no one has ever knocked on the door yet.

user1477391263 · 10/08/2023 12:04

I will always feel a bit sad about the baby changing table I gave away though. Beautiful solid wood Mamas and Papas thing, I'd got it through a free ad myself and it had loads of life. A lady came to get it to put her plants on in her greenhouse. :(

I don't see what's wrong with this? A solid wood frame sounds like a nice thing for putting plants on, and it will be seen by more people than it would be if it was just used as a changing table. Personally I never used a changing table anyway.

NYE2023 · 10/08/2023 11:57

I’ve used Freecycle a lot to get rid of things we don’t need that our local charity shop won’t take but are still perfectly good to use. Without exception I’ve found it brilliant - all the recipients have been really pleased and all have said thank you .

kurotora · 10/08/2023 11:52

Yes, you get really crappy people who are rude or no shows for free items. Or the ones who clearly really don't need it, or are going to use it for a purpose unintended. But I keep doing it just for the ones that DO need it, that do appreciate it and for whom it's a huge help. And of course, to keep things out of the tip.

I will always feel a bit sad about the baby changing table I gave away though. Beautiful solid wood Mamas and Papas thing, I'd got it through a free ad myself and it had loads of life. A lady came to get it to put her plants on in her greenhouse. :(

Loopylooni · 10/08/2023 11:51

I tend to leave outside - usually big toys or scooters etc, always get taken. Clothes etc goes to the Marie Curie shop.

Saltybanana · 10/08/2023 11:44

Urgh, yes - had so much stuff to get rid of from my hoarder father’s house when he died - like you, I didn’t want to just tip everything, so advertised loads of items for free - with varying degrees of success, mostly poor.
Now, I take things to charity shops, donate to organisations or to people I know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread