Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has lack of manners stopped you giving things away free?

185 replies

dottypotter · 09/08/2023 22:26

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

Somebody contacted and said they were interested. I Gave them the address etc and discussed time as you do. Seemed keen to come.

No show, no apology. Im sure not the only person to experience this. I could not be so rude though. If I could not make it I would message.

I wont bother again. Why are people so rude?
They just spoil it.
Has it stopped you giving things away free?😪

OP posts:
Songbird54321 · 10/08/2023 17:56

We either tip or donate to charities. Far less hassle. There’s a family centre at the end of my road which takes loads of home stuff, clothes, toys etc which covers most things I’m clearing out. I have sold things on marketplace in the past but wouldn’t offer free items after the stories I’ve heard. Sad really as genuine people will miss out.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 10/08/2023 17:55

I put stuff on ebay for a quid with all proceeds going to Shelter. Seems a winning combination. Tried freecycle. Just could not be arsed with the time wasters.

Igniteyourbones · 10/08/2023 17:54

RumbleMum · 10/08/2023 17:42

The exact same thing happened with our cotbed - my Mum bought it for us when my eldest was born and getting rid of it was a big deal. I was so upset when the woman mentioned she was using it for her dog as she was loading it in the car. It made me realise I had to either give things away to people I knew or accept that once things are gone I can't have any influence over what happens to them.

The impolite people and the no-shows are so annoying, but they're made up for by the people who say thank you or send you messages or pictures afterwards to show how pleased they are.

Wow can’t believe the same thing happened to you! It honestly broke my heart and it still upsets me to think about it several years later. I agree with you that you have to try let go of what happens with your things when you pass them on……. but I am someone who holds real sentimental value to objects, especially where my children are involved. The only way I could part with the cot was to think of someone else’s lovely baby sleeping in it and knowing that I had done a kind thing for another family. Felt like she trampled on my heart (and I also know how dramatic and ridiculous that sounds!)

RumbleMum · 10/08/2023 17:42

Igniteyourbones · 10/08/2023 08:02

I wanted to pass on my much loved children’s cotbed to someone in need. It was a lovely cot from John Lewis still in great condition. So many memories of my 4 babies sleeping in it. I posted it online asking if anyone knew someone pregnant or with a new baby that didn’t have much money and would appreciate a free cot. A lady arranged to come pick it up, put all the dismantled pieces into her car……. Then as she was walking away said “Thanks this will be great for my dog, she’s a bit wild and is a biter, so will be great for keeping her in.” Then jumped in the car and drove off. I was so upset, that’s not at all what I intended when giving it away.

The exact same thing happened with our cotbed - my Mum bought it for us when my eldest was born and getting rid of it was a big deal. I was so upset when the woman mentioned she was using it for her dog as she was loading it in the car. It made me realise I had to either give things away to people I knew or accept that once things are gone I can't have any influence over what happens to them.

The impolite people and the no-shows are so annoying, but they're made up for by the people who say thank you or send you messages or pictures afterwards to show how pleased they are.

dottypotter · 10/08/2023 17:34

Point taken

Not everyone can leave things outside though
Not everyone has a porch or garden etc.

OP posts:
Catza · 10/08/2023 17:31

I now arrange a charity collection which makes the whole process easier. A lot of the charities will collect toys, books, small appliances and sports equipment and you can just book a collection and leave everything outside.

SherbetDips · 10/08/2023 16:09

If you use the app olio, you can report now shows as they don’t like no shows. Makes people a bit more reliable.

Btrsun10 · 10/08/2023 15:49

O just remembered that I gave away 2 3 seater sofas on Freecycle. Got the usual can you deliver messages which I ignored. Eventually I got a message from a guy who I thought was giving me a bit of a sob story about renting alone for the 1st time etc etc. Anyway, he and his dad turned up when he said they would, in a van and a box of biscuits for me.

Nononsensemumsy · 10/08/2023 15:37

This has happened to us more than once. Either that or some scanner will try it on. It’s so annoying I’m straight to the tip now, it’s more hassle than it’s worth and our local tip has a big shed for larger unwanted items that go to charity.

Hoppinggreen · 10/08/2023 15:32

Mojoj · 10/08/2023 14:24

Absolutely. My favourite is when you advertise a big item for free and you get contacted asking if you will deliver the item to them.....

Yep
the last item I put on was large and I was very clear that it was collection only and they might need a van.
I had 7 people ask me to deliver it to various locations “for petrol money”

Dacadactyl · 10/08/2023 15:28

Yes it stops me.

On olio I was giving stuff away, if anyone says "I want this" and that's all it says, I just think "tough shit" and block them.

If they can't be bothered with manners, they're not gonna show up.

I've given so much stuff away on there now I can almost guarantee who will and won't turn up by the tone of their first message.

If they're new to the app I give them a chance, but if they're not, they don't get anything from me unless they put a time and date for collection in their first message.

Baba197 · 10/08/2023 15:21

It’s so rude isn’t it. I’ve had repeated no shows, people asking if I can deliver even tho I always put collection only and the postcode on
the post! I won’t wait in now, it’s left out on the step behind a plant pot. Lots of people don’t say thank you

dottypotter · 10/08/2023 15:18

Hillrunning · 10/08/2023 06:11

No it doesn't stop me. I give things away because it is easier tha. Ne going ro the tip/charity shop ect. Not because I want manners or thanks.

I give people gifts because I want to celebrate them. Not because I want thanks from them.

So while yes I agree that both are being rude. It doesn't change what I do because the gratitude isn't the reason I do it.

Missing the point.
When they don't turn up and don't message its rude.
I arrange to be in.
I cannot just leave things outside.

OP posts:
Btrsun10 · 10/08/2023 15:14

If no please or thank you, I'm not even replying!
I once gave a trampoline away. It was scruffy but still perfectly usable.
I stated that it had to be dismantled (as I couldnt be arsed).
Woman and her husband came, took it away and afterward sent the most lovely thank you video of her 2 boys bouncing on the rebuilt, cleaned up trampoline.
They were so happy and her and the DH we so grateful.
Made me happy too 🙂

Jumbojade · 10/08/2023 15:11

When I got a new kitchen (a few years ago), I had some decent appliances to get rid of. My son put them on Facebook, as free, to get rid of them quick.

First item went within 5 minutes to someone close by. They told my son that they had arranged to buy the same item from someone else. However when they borrowed a car and went to collect it, the seller said they had had lots of interest and had changed their mind about the price and now wanted an extra £20 for it! They couldn’t afford the extra, so didn’t get it.

It was lucky for them, as they got my 2 year old washing machine, in perfect condition, for nothing. Being close by, they and my son were even able to carry it to their house. They were very grateful and actually offered the amount they had agreed with their previous seller for it, which was refused. The thanks I received, from someone who really needed it, was more than enough payment. It is apparently still working perfectly for them, over 3 years later.

MotherofWhippets81 · 10/08/2023 15:02

One of the things I hate the most though is when people tell you what you should be doing with the items you are giving away.

One of my dogs was incredibly fussy as a pup and as a result I would often end up with half eaten bags of dog food that I would end up putting on our local free site. I didn't care who had it. Whoever wanted/needed it and turned up could have it. So many times I would have PA comments about how I should be giving it to a charity and how I should be checking if people 'needed' it. WTF? For a start our local dog charity is a bunch of self congratulating wotsits who care more about the glory than they ever do about an animal but I I just wanted it taking off my doorstep or it would have gone in the bin.

In the end I ended up swapping foods with a woman with a fussy bulldog who had come to get the first lot 😁

MotherofWhippets81 · 10/08/2023 14:45

I was moving last year and offered some books for free - they were cookery and baking books - really nice expensive ones and heavy.

I had a lady ask if she could have them. Yes no problem etc.

Next message what bus would she need to catch. Told her it was a rural village, no bus stop in easy walking distance and there was no way she would carry them.

Next message said she would be getting the bus but it might take her a while as she was 9 months pregnant. Told her not to be ridiculous.

I was doing a running commentary with my mate at this point - our next guess was walking barefoot carrying a toddler.

Told me she was sending her husband round on his way back from work so I left outside under the porch. No show.

Then I got how she just wasn't sure how she was going to get them and could I help?

She lived about an hours drive away. Politely told her it really wasn't my problem to sort - she obviously thought at one point I would cave and say I would drive them to her.

Contacted the next person and she came and picked them up for her granddaughter with a thank-you and they were out of my hair. Sorted.

I've given quite a lot away but you do get messed around quite a bit but I've had lovely people turn up too. Your post just reminded me of that one as it was quite funny 😄 'she' was probably a man wanting to flog them somewhere.

BorrowsAreVermin · 10/08/2023 14:41

Elsie296 · 10/08/2023 08:05

I've stopped because of this, put some several (lovely) items on fb marketplace for free as needed to clear space. The rudeness of some people. One asked me if I could deliver, it was really out of my way but I said yes as felt sorry for her situation. Got there, knocked the door and she messaged to say 'leave it on the doorstep'.
No thank you or anything, I really wish I'd just taken it back home with me!

Now I put things for a nominal amount and I find that only people genuinely interested will reply. 9 times out of 10 I'll just tell them to take it for free when they arrive to collect it. xx

Yeah I tend to do the nominal amount thing. I had a printer on for £1 just so it didn't come up when people searched for free items. When the fella came to collect it he insisted I take the quid despite me telling him to just take it.

One time I was selling some old toys before Christmas, I had a few listings, mostly for a few quid here and there to put towards new stuff. One person asked if they could have something for free for their kid, and asked if I could deliver. Usually I'd say no but it wasn't being used and thought they must be desperate to be asking. It was a bit far away to be worth the drive so I just posted it. Think it cos me about a fiver.

Thought nothing more of it but a couple of days after Christmas they sent me a picture of the kid with the stuff I'd sent, saying thank you and she loved it. Made my day.

For that reason I try not to throw things away if they're still good, there's plenty I would give away if people ask but I do find putting even a low price on puts a lot of folk off😂

Mojoj · 10/08/2023 14:24

Absolutely. My favourite is when you advertise a big item for free and you get contacted asking if you will deliver the item to them.....

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/08/2023 14:23

JusthereforXmas · 10/08/2023 11:08

Was going to tip some things I did not need anymore but thought the nice thing to do would be to advertise if someone wanted for free. We are also encouraged to reduce waste etc.

If its something you are essentially going to bin but you decided to make yourself warm and fuzzy by claiming to 'protecting the enviroment' you would give it away instead but now aren't going to because people didn't grovel and praise you enough for giving them your unwanted trash... you might be an egotistical twat thats not that 'nice'.

What is wrong with expecting basic manners, @JusthereforXmas? I don’t think anyone is expecting grovelling and praise - just please, thank you, and the courtesy of turning up when you say you will.

Manners cost nothing.

Merapi · 10/08/2023 14:14

Yes, two instances recently.

No 1 was in the charity shop in my town. I took a couple of bags in there to donate, and was met with: "Well all right, we'll take them just this once, but no more today".

No 2 was a van driver employed by another local charity to collect some furniture from a probate house we are selling. He managed to reverse his van over NDN's garden and damage their fence. Didn't seem in the slightest bit apologetic and got quite stroppy with DH.

Igniteyourbones · 10/08/2023 14:10

On the flip side - I gave away our old fridge freezer to a lovely man who turned up to collect and and gave us a big bag of artisanal bread and cakes from his bakery in return ❤️

Greenpolkadot · 10/08/2023 13:59

We offered for sale two matching M&S sofas.Included the measurements, details and said we wouldn't deliver.
Several asked if we would deliver..or what were the measurements....FFS
One lady asked if I thought it would go through her front door...

BridgetRandomfuck · 10/08/2023 13:55

I’ve never had any problems selling or giving away online but I did stop taking to a particular local charity shop due to their rudeness. I came in with a large bag of clothes (all clean, good labels etc) and tried to attract the attention of the two ladies talking behind the till. Eventually one of them just pointed to the door at the back of the shop without even acknowledging me, and said to her friend ‘of course this time of year you get lots of people dumping their old tat on you’! They never got a donation from me again.

TallulahBetty · 10/08/2023 13:47

Made4Sunshine · 10/08/2023 06:08

I posted a pram for free and the claminent hadn't even collected it before she posted it for sale on another group.
She even used the same photo , featuring my hallway.
Needless to say, I contacted the next in line.

The HEIGHT of CF-ery. Surely no one can beat that?!