Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

At what age do you think children benefit from nursery

60 replies

Emeraldrings · 09/08/2023 19:08

I don't want this to turn in to a nursery bashing thread but I do want to ask at what age do you think babies/children benefit from nursery? I don't mean just enjoy being there but when they actually start learning and benefiting socially from being there.
Would I be unreasonable to remove my son if I felt nursery wasn't benefiting him? He's actually 3 but is more at the older baby stage (so probably around 18 months with no guarantee he'll progress). I can't decide if nursery is a good idea or not, especially if he might not progress like his peers.

OP posts:
RadoxRita · 09/08/2023 23:26

Child clinical psychologist here. The research suggests 3 years.

Sunshineclouds11 · 09/08/2023 21:56

don't think he hates it but I see the other children interacting with each other and chatting away. DS simply doesn't do that.
If a staff member can sit with him he will play for maybe 4 or 5 minutes but they quite often just don't have the staff for it and once they move away he will just go away and play by himself again

This was my son. Also suspected on the autism spectrum.
It hurt me also, I used to hate thinking of him playing on his own but you know he was happy. He tried his best.
Nursery applied for funding so his key worker can do work with him 1-2-1. I can't for the life of me remember the name of it though but hopefully someone can correct me!
It's took time but he has started to playing along side others, on occasions playing with them.
Nursery have done a lot of work with him and I've up'd the time he's spend with children outside of nursery to help.

fricli · 09/08/2023 21:13

I'd say 2-2.5 years. I'm sure there was research to show that it benefits from age 2, and that's why low income families are offered free nursery hours from age 2. I've sent mine from 2y3m and 2y4m, they had to start in a September otherwise I would have preferred 2y5m. We did daily toddler groups or classes before that, which were great for some social interaction but still allowed one to one support from a caregiver.

Surgarblossom · 09/08/2023 21:11

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 09/08/2023 19:10

It totally depends on the child. My son was in nursery from 9 months until he started school and it was massively beneficial to him. Why do you not think it’s not beneficial to your child?

Same

SausageinaBun · 09/08/2023 21:02

Mine started at 6-8 months and I think they benefitted straight away. But it probably depends on what the alternative is like. I love my DDs, but I'm not great with babies. My desire to play, sing, make a mess etc is minimal and I am not anywhere near as patient as the nursery staff. So my DDs had a fantastic time at nursery doing lots of child centred activities. If I parented like the lovely nursery staff then home would have been just as beneficial.

Wenfy · 09/08/2023 20:59

Nursery (if it can meet their needs) can often help SEN and disabled kids a lot. But depends on the nursery. Be selective and ask lots of questions

PuttingDownRoots · 09/08/2023 20:56

My eldest (with speech delay) started at 16 months and it did help her language... plus there was evidence for the HV that she understood language but just didn't speak (she did have non verbal communication). She enjoyed it from day 1... but it was 2 mornings a week. So it was one of a range of experiences, along with toddler groups and being at home.

Emeraldrings · 09/08/2023 20:51

So looks like 18+ months is most usual but I suppose I'm just worried incase he doesn't progress from being at this stage. My DD2 has autism and although the signs aren't exactly the same (DD masked until she was about 8) I can see similarities. I know it's not the end of the world but I just feel drained by everything. I actually cried at work today because I just feel like I'm running on empty all the time.

OP posts:
Emeraldrings · 09/08/2023 20:01

Fleur405 · 09/08/2023 19:38

if I understand your post your son has developmental delays is that right? So did my son. We sent him to nursery from 12 months as we (and his paediatrician) thought being around other kids may encourage his development. I don’t think that really worked but he did have significant learning disabilities. I think it really depends on the child and the nursery. Our nursery were great with his additional needs and our son did enjoy it there. He loved being around other kids and the sensory room they had - so I suppose that is a benefit in itself. But developmentally I don’t think it really made a difference to him.

I would just talk to nursery and see what they think. We had quarterly meetings with the supervisor of the baby room and the manager to discuss his needs and progress.

Sorry if I have misunderstood your post!

This is pretty much it. The padeateic team my DH, me and Senco suspect he may have autism as he's had a massive regression with language and social interaction, although neither were really within the "normal " range.
He seemed okay in toddlers but he's gone back in preschool. He seems happy enough. I don't think he hates it but I see the other children interacting with each other and chatting away. DS simply doesn't do that.
If a staff member can sit with him he will play for maybe 4 or 5 minutes but they quite often just don't have the staff for it and once they move away he will just go away and play by himself again.
He's waiting for SALT but of course there is a huge waiting list.
I have to work but think I might have to look for something with less hours as I'm not convinced any nursery would benefit him

OP posts:
Purplepeaches123 · 09/08/2023 19:51

It’s hard to say isn’t it. None if my kids went to nursery or pre school. They just started in reception. Eldest is severely autistic so a little different but the younger two are both bright, sociable kids (now teens) that settled into reception with no issues. My eldest was in some sort of intensive home based therapy from 3 before starting school at 4.

Alarae · 09/08/2023 19:47

Slightly different as my daughter started with her childminder from 11 months, but she was ready for a larger setting from about 2.5.

She's actually only moving this September (at 3.5) as I couldn't get a place in time as the largest intake was September and I elected not to try for it last year, which I did regret in the end.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 09/08/2023 19:43

Neither of mine went until they were pre-school age and the funding kicked in. It was 12.5 hours per week then iirc. It certainly didn't hinder them in anyway that other children had been in day nursery before starting at the school nursery.

We did lots of toddler groups and meeting up with friends as well.

powerpufff · 09/08/2023 19:41

Former nursery nurse
This is my experience
Nursery is necessary for babies under 2 if the parents need childcare and this can be a wonderful and nurturing place for them. Do I think it is more beneficial than staying home with primary care givers ( mum, dad, nanny etc) absolutely not- babies do not need nursery at all but if parents need childcare this is a great option. The children who benefit from a nursery setting and who in my opinion should go are 18 months + year olds. At that age they require social interactions with other children, playing, communicating, sharing, learning and testing boundaries in a setting different to their home
So for babies there is no added benefit
But the benefits increase when the child is between lets say 2 and 3 cause they can fully participate in the nursery experience and it prepares them for school
The reality is parents need to work and nursery can be a safe and nurturing place for any age so I am not against very young babies going at all
This is purely my experience: for babies it is best for them to develop a very strong attachment to their key worker or primary caregiver, unfortunately nurseries have high staff turnover and I have seen babies change their key worker often, this causes lots of stress to the babies ( i have seen babies cry non stop with distress and generally it takes them longer to adapt)
This was my experience in the baby room
The preschoolers seemed more resilient to changes as they were more aware and they could express themselves with words

AmazingSnakeHead · 09/08/2023 19:39

Depends on the child! I sent mine a little too early, looking back. I'd wait until they can walk and talk a bit, then I think it's all good.

Fleur405 · 09/08/2023 19:38

if I understand your post your son has developmental delays is that right? So did my son. We sent him to nursery from 12 months as we (and his paediatrician) thought being around other kids may encourage his development. I don’t think that really worked but he did have significant learning disabilities. I think it really depends on the child and the nursery. Our nursery were great with his additional needs and our son did enjoy it there. He loved being around other kids and the sensory room they had - so I suppose that is a benefit in itself. But developmentally I don’t think it really made a difference to him.

I would just talk to nursery and see what they think. We had quarterly meetings with the supervisor of the baby room and the manager to discuss his needs and progress.

Sorry if I have misunderstood your post!

WimpoleHat · 09/08/2023 19:31

2.5/3, I think. More from the point of view of encouraging a bit of independence than anything else. Reception classes used to be all about that - now that most children go to nursery, it has changed - so I think school must be a massive leap for a child who has never been in a pre school or nursery setting at all. Apart from anything else, it gets them used to being in an institutional setting and having to deal with a range of other kids, some of whom they might not like/get on with. Doesn’t need to be all day or every day at that age, but I think it is beneficial for them.

calmcoco · 09/08/2023 19:30

I don't think they do if the alternative is a positive home environment or quality childminder.

If the alternative is a negative home environment or bad childminder, then they will benefit.

NumberTheory · 09/08/2023 19:29

I don’t think there is any harm at younger ages at all, but I think children from the age of about 2, generally, benefit from increased social interaction. You get that in a nursery but it could also be provided by a SAHP who organized a lot of outings and activities with other children.

If a parent isn’t particularly interactive with their child or has other issues with parenting then nursery is likely to be more beneficial from an earlier age.

But children aren’t all the same (and neither are parents) so for an individual child it will always depend.

Thinkinpinkin · 09/08/2023 19:29

I think from 2 onwards. My girl started when she was 2 and had a decent vocab for her age, could understand simple commands etc

Sunshineclouds11 · 09/08/2023 19:29

Mine started at 2.5 and it hugely benefited him in regards to socialisation, speech and other developments.
Any earlier and I personally don't think he would have gained as much straight away.

Follow your gut.

SensitiveB · 09/08/2023 19:27

Ours struggled with nursery as didn’t seem emotionally ready at 2 and I still regret trying a whole term before listening to DS. He’s 12 now and remembers hating being away and told me he wasn’t ready to be away from me yet . I think I was the same as a child as developed an anxiety (elective mutism) around then! He also never enjoyed playing or toys and his nursery didn’t understand when I told him what he enjoyed at home eg dot to dots and learning numbers.

i am taking our youngest to lots of playgroups and will try when he’s 2 but won’t push it if he doesn’t seem ready.

continentallentil · 09/08/2023 19:27

About 2.5 I think, bit younger if an early developer

But I think they benefit from some time in toddler groups certainly from 18 months

This is not to say that a good nursery is bad for under twos - just that is falls under childcare rather than development/educating

MrsHsGirl · 09/08/2023 19:24

I started sending my little boy when he turned 2. He hadn't been away from me before so struggled a bit with the transition which I think was harder due to him being that bit older, but the nursery were really helpful and it didn't take too long.

He has come on an incredible amount in a really short space of time since being there. His speech, social skills and confidence have all improved massively.

irrationallypink · 09/08/2023 19:24

2.5 up, personally

TropicalTrama · 09/08/2023 19:21

I don’t think there is any benefit for under 2s. That’s not to say that it’s bad for them to go- I’d say it’s neutral, you do it because you need childcare to work or get stuff done which is of course fine. However, they definitely don’t miss out on anything if they don’t go when they’re under 2 because they’re all still in the solitary stage of play. At 2 they begin to do parallel play ie playing the same thing but alongside each other (not yet properly playing together) and I think some 2 year olds really benefit from nursery but personality dependent. Interaction during play starts at age 3 and coupled with preparation for school I think that’s the age where they really miss out if they don’t go.

So in short child dependent but somewhere between 2 and 3.

In your case, no I wouldn’t keep a 3YO at home unless there were SEN concerns. I might look for an alternative setting if I felt the current one didn’t suit or wasn’t good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread