Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

At what age do you think children benefit from nursery

60 replies

Emeraldrings · 09/08/2023 19:08

I don't want this to turn in to a nursery bashing thread but I do want to ask at what age do you think babies/children benefit from nursery? I don't mean just enjoy being there but when they actually start learning and benefiting socially from being there.
Would I be unreasonable to remove my son if I felt nursery wasn't benefiting him? He's actually 3 but is more at the older baby stage (so probably around 18 months with no guarantee he'll progress). I can't decide if nursery is a good idea or not, especially if he might not progress like his peers.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JenniferBarkley · 10/08/2023 10:45

Ours went from 10 months, enjoyed it from the start and I felt really benefited from about 2 when they started to play more with the other kids (DC1 hit this stage a little earlier than DC2).

But in the case of SN I think you just have to trust your gut. What would the alternative be? If he is likely to start at mainstream school, is it worth him being used to the busy environment of a nursery room to help with the adjustment even if he isn't gaining socially? Would a different setting have more time to develop his language skills? Very hard for anyone to advise tbh.

Clefable · 10/08/2023 10:42

I think it's very child dependent and not just about age but developmental stage (which is obviously linked to age but not always).

DD1 probably from around 2, I would say.

DD2 I think will be a bit earlier due to her temperament; she loves group settings, lots of activity, she's incredibly active so enjoys having a climbing frame etc inside in nursery. She's about to turn 14mo and seems to really love being at nursery, we've entirely skipped the crying on drop-off phase we went through with DD1. Whether it's benefiting her or not in a developmental way I can't say, but I don't think it's worse for her than being at home either way, just different.

Bunnycat101 · 10/08/2023 10:31

I think there is little point comparing with neurotypical children. You’d potentially get better advice from people who have had similar additional needs to contend with and pros/cons. I’d imagine it would be easier within a nursery v home setting to access support and get things in motion before school.

The research says 3. Mine benefited much earlier. My eldest had a best friend in the baby room but that isn’t typical.

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 09:55

Cluborange666 · 10/08/2023 09:47

Autistic people get very overstimulated (one of my kids is autistic) so I can’t see that nursery would be enjoyable for them from that point of view.
Personally, I’m not a big nursery fan anyway. My kids went to school without it and didn’t cry etc as they were all nearly 5 when they started so we had a strong bond, they had no separation anxiety and they could tell the time so they knew when I’d be coming to collect them etc.
I do get that nursery is useful for other things but I know that my autistic child, even now at almost 18, is exhausted by busy surroundings and happiest when engaged in quiet, solitary activities.

I have an autistic child who loved nursery and it was actually good for her because she was non-verbal at the time, and it taught her other ways to communicate with her friends. This helped massively when she started school because she was able and willing to communicate with people, and then as her speech came in those friendships deepened. DS has ADHD and nursery has been a godsend for him because they tailor activities to use up his energy productively. ASD is such a large spectrum but by and large I do think nursery can help - you just need to find the right one.

Cluborange666 · 10/08/2023 09:47

Autistic people get very overstimulated (one of my kids is autistic) so I can’t see that nursery would be enjoyable for them from that point of view.
Personally, I’m not a big nursery fan anyway. My kids went to school without it and didn’t cry etc as they were all nearly 5 when they started so we had a strong bond, they had no separation anxiety and they could tell the time so they knew when I’d be coming to collect them etc.
I do get that nursery is useful for other things but I know that my autistic child, even now at almost 18, is exhausted by busy surroundings and happiest when engaged in quiet, solitary activities.

DinnaeFashYersel · 10/08/2023 09:37

Mine went to a childminder from age one to get the at home child care and nursery from 3 until they started school at 5.

From 3'they were following the early years curriculum (Scotland) which prepares them for school at P1.

Onceuponatime56 · 10/08/2023 05:53

I currently have a two year old who comes home having learnt loads from nursery. She has been there since 9 months and like others the benefit was almost immediate. She gets to experience lots of things we don’t do at home - daily messy play, large garden equipment, circle time in a group , interaction with older and younger kids

rand0mstuff · 10/08/2023 05:30

Not sure there is any point asking a general forum asking this question when your DC has special needs. It's a totally different ballgame...

DD1 (severe ASD) was in nursery from 11 months and I do not think there was any benefit - she would have been much better off at home with me 1:1. She had no speech, no interest in peers no staff for intense 1:1. she was usually outside on her own on a trike when I came collect her. In the end of the day, I had to work, I had no help or support network. Bills needed paying. looks like your situation is similar so don't beat yourself up. We can only do, what we can do.

Bliss1221 · 10/08/2023 04:32

My kids have never been to a nursery or a school, they are confident when it comes to talking to adults,playing with peers, etc- i notice times are changing with parents wfh many decide to home ed their children, its great cant imagine it any other way,we get to spend a lot of time together,for example when other kids return to school we will be going on holiday for 3 weeks in september, we prefer it that way no queues anywhere etc. Perhaps trial taking your child out and see how it works out for your family?

fullbloom87 · 10/08/2023 04:12

I used to work in nurseries and I wouldn't say there's any benefit until they're at least 2 years old. Before then babies still need mum and a nursery can't replicate that. I know lots of mums have no choice but if they did have a choice I definitely wouldn't recommend putting them in as a baby because they don't get anything out of it and staff will fluff the details of their day because they don't want to risk losing a customer.

WandaWonder · 10/08/2023 04:07

For me it was one when they could walk

OlympicProcrastinator · 10/08/2023 04:06

Completely depends on the child and the nursery. Literally every scenario will be different.

Overthebow · 10/08/2023 03:03

Going by my dds experience I would say 1.5 yrs. she’s been at nursery since she was 10 months but it was around 1.5 that she really started benefitting socially and developmentally. They learn so much at nursery, sitting down to eat with their friends all together, learning to do carpet time, learning from the more advanced talkers, potty training together, specialist activity and language coaches coming in to give them lessons altogether, different cultures. Way more than I could give my dd at home myself.

ChangingMode · 10/08/2023 02:57

In general from age 3, maybe 2.5.

Some children, never. One of my kids has autism (which wasn’t diagnosed til later) and I realise now, she’d have been better not attending. We sent her from just before she was 3 as we were told it would be good for her. In hindsight, it wasn’t.

Lancrelady80 · 10/08/2023 02:39

He was also eligible for free hours from 2 due to his developmental needs, so someone somewhere thinks early intervention/ education is sufficiently beneficial to deserve funding.

Lancrelady80 · 10/08/2023 02:36

My gut instinct was 3. However, ds had developmental delays which were evident from a few months old. Paeds really pushed to get him to nursery aged 2, despite me being an early years teacher and SAHM.

Key worker 1 was a bit lost with him - lots of "we went for a walk outside to calm down" rather than actively engaging and helping him progress. She left and his second key worker was AMAZING.

So paeds clearly think nursery at 2 years old is a Good Thing, but it totally depends on the staff in my experience.

Saschka · 10/08/2023 00:25

DS definitely actively enjoyed it from 18 months. He might also have enjoyed being at home, but he liked the messy play and art activities, liked the garden (we don’t have one), and liked their massive range of toys. And actually really really liked the predictable structure. As he got older (3ish) he loved the songs, the trikes, the trips to forest school, and watering the plants in the garden etc.

He parallel played until he was about 4, so didn’t gain much enjoyment from the other kids being around (it was good that he had to share, wait his turn etc, but he would have been just as happy without them until he started making actual friends when he was about 4).

elliejjtiny · 10/08/2023 00:24

It depends. My eldest went two days a week from aged 2.5 and it was great for him. Lots of stimulation and activity with adults whose job it was to play with him rather than being at home with his knackered mum and poorly baby brother. I managed to organise it so more appointments for his brother were while he was at nursery too as they tended to unsettle him. My youngest went to preschool every morning from when he was 3 as he was the only one of my dc not in school by then so he was bored without his brothers. My 2nd and 4th did a couple of mornings a week at preschool from 3.5. My 3rd didn't go at all as there wasn't a local preschool around then. I think some children need it and others don't but as long as they are getting the opportunity to be away from their main care giver for a couple of hours regularly and spending time with other children learning to share etc then it's fine. My 3rd was monitored more closely when he was 3 and 4 by the HV because he wasn't in preschool which was fine but she always said although he would probably enjoy pre school he was doing absolutely fine without it.

Howandwhy · 10/08/2023 00:21

My child was genuinely ready at 2 and needed more than family could give at that point. We could see the benefits almost immediately. Had I of sent him before that and it would have been for work reasons rather than that he needed it. Mind you, for his first two years we were always out at baby groups etc.

cherish123 · 10/08/2023 00:17

Depends on the child.
Beneficial from 2.5 to 3. ???

Yellowlegobrick · 10/08/2023 00:12

Btw op if you need childcare, nursery isn't the only option.

Some children with SEN/delays do better in a smaller setting like a childminder. My DS childminder had two children with additional needs, one with a brain condition causing cognitive & social problems, another with suspected autism, both thrived with her.

Yellowlegobrick · 10/08/2023 00:08

Nursery applied for funding so his key worker can do work with him 1-2-1. I can't for the life of me remember the name of it though but hopefully someone can correct me

Its called High Needs Block Funding.

Yellowlegobrick · 10/08/2023 00:07

Three years but the nursery/kindergarten phase should be 3-7 years with school starting after that.

I'd agree with around age 3 for nursery but think the vast majority of children do well at school from age 5. Reception is really like a transition to school so i would not count it as full school - EYFS is more comparable to what is counted as preschool/maternelle/kindergarten in other countries, its irrelevant that its delivered in the same building as ks1 & 2.

Slouching · 09/08/2023 23:56

For a NT child I would say there's no real benefit until they are three and home will always be the superior option (assuming home isn't abusive/chaotic). I'm not judging by the way, I've sent my DDs before then but I was under no illusions that it was in their best interest - it wasn't, but it had to be weighed up against other factors. As these things usually do.

For a child with developmental delay I would be very cautious. Some nurseries have truly great staff but almost all don't have enough staff to meet children's needs in a way you would hope for. I wouldn't send him full time unless I really didn't have any other choice. Little and often and then build it up if he's coping/not falling apart when he comes home?

Sorry to hear how draining things are right now OP 💐

DrCoconut · 09/08/2023 23:31

When they have to go so their parent(s) can work to keep a roof over their head. The alternative doesn't really work.