Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my ex employers can’t do this?

187 replies

Wowsharona · 09/08/2023 17:00

I recently accepted a settlement to leave my job after discriminatory comments were made to me on two occasions after announcing my pregnancy.

it was a good offer so didn’t want to go into a long drawn out tribunal process whilst pregnant.

I left last week, today I received a message from an ex colleague asking if my mother was ok. I was confused as my mother died years ago in my early teens.

turns out after I had been paid off and left (was an abrupt leaving due to the situation) 2 days after I had officially gone an email was sent from my work email address saying goodbye to everyone and telling them I was leaving to take care of my sick and elderly mother!

it ended with ‘I’m sorry this is abrupt but for my own mental health I am requesting no one reach out via linked in as I’d like to put all my energy into my family’

I’m absolutely fuming, AIBU to think although yes my email address is technically their property they can’t pretend to be me and email everyone?

OP posts:
Qbishy · 10/08/2023 19:30

ElizaAgainn · 10/08/2023 19:28

Probably about the best way to handle it - ie the "someone is pretending to be me" type email out to everyone possible one way or another. They'll probably find out - but they havent got a leg to stand on, as it's probably some sort of offence in law to impersonate someone else without their consent. If anyone says anything to you = you just pretend complete innocence and that you honestly thought it was some sort of prankster that had sent out the fake email from you. They won't dare admit it was really them....

Don't do any of this either! Until you have spoken to your solicitor. What they have done is really, really serious. And you are going to get some more money from them.

Qbishy · 10/08/2023 19:29

timetoringthechanges · 10/08/2023 19:25

You can reply to ex-colleague that your mother has been dead for many years as that is fact and will not be covered in the compromise agreement. They cannot stop you talking to ex-colleagues unless it is about the agreement.

You then need to meet ex-colleague and tell her face to face (i.e. no proof of communication) that you cannot say anything but she may wish to google what a "compromise agreement" is and that mostly people have obvious reasons for needing them "cradle bump"....

Emphasise you are unable to say anything or tell her anything....

No, don't do this. This colleague clearly likes to talk, and will tell everyone what you told them to look up. That is a clear breach of your NDA.

Just get back to your solicitor, and let them handle it. Don't muddy the waters by talking to people.

ElizaAgainn · 10/08/2023 19:28

towriteyoumustlive · 09/08/2023 17:16

One way to handle it would be to put a message on LinkedIn that someone has sent an email round pretending to be you, and that you certainly didn't leave to look after your sick mother as she died many years ago, and unlike the email that said not to contact you, you look forward to keeping in touch with all the lovely people you worked with.

The message can always be deleted at a later date if needs be...

Probably about the best way to handle it - ie the "someone is pretending to be me" type email out to everyone possible one way or another. They'll probably find out - but they havent got a leg to stand on, as it's probably some sort of offence in law to impersonate someone else without their consent. If anyone says anything to you = you just pretend complete innocence and that you honestly thought it was some sort of prankster that had sent out the fake email from you. They won't dare admit it was really them....

Qbishy · 10/08/2023 19:27

Dear god that is appalling. The upside is, you're about to get some more money from them... Get onto your solicitor pronto!

timetoringthechanges · 10/08/2023 19:25

Wowsharona · 09/08/2023 17:17

Yes unfortunately it’s a very lengthy NDA/settlement agreement so I’m not sure whether I can comment or even reply to my ex colleague

You can reply to ex-colleague that your mother has been dead for many years as that is fact and will not be covered in the compromise agreement. They cannot stop you talking to ex-colleagues unless it is about the agreement.

You then need to meet ex-colleague and tell her face to face (i.e. no proof of communication) that you cannot say anything but she may wish to google what a "compromise agreement" is and that mostly people have obvious reasons for needing them "cradle bump"....

Emphasise you are unable to say anything or tell her anything....

Nain5 · 10/08/2023 18:58

I have a sked my dh who is studying cyber security on this for you. You need to get legal advice they would appear to contravened the 2006 Fraud and also the Computer Misuse Act 1990. What they have done is wrong and quite frankly disgusting. Hope all goes well with your precious baby, all the best xxx

Gardengirl108 · 10/08/2023 18:55

Just a thought, are you still able to log into your work email? Your ex employers sound pretty sloppy, so may have left your account open (they certainly did for at least 2 days after you left). You may be able to see the email yourself. If so, just don’t forward it anywhere - print or take pics.

CKL987 · 10/08/2023 18:54

I'd suggest you call Acas for advice.

lto2019 · 10/08/2023 18:53

GoodChat · 10/08/2023 18:47

She did sign an NDA. She said that in her second post.

Ahhh in that case ignore me! When you signed the nda - did you have to go through it with a solicitor - you maybe be able to ask them if the company can just make up why you left. To be fair - you might just be better saying nothing and being glad you are out of there. I don't think you would be doing anything wrong to say your mother died x years ago and leaving it at that.

GoodChat · 10/08/2023 18:47

lto2019 · 10/08/2023 18:43

I would email and copy in all and say - it has come to my attention that this email was sent and I would like to make it clear this is wholly untrue. X bosses knows the true reason why I have left and have chosen to lie. My mother died in 19xx and I am not caring for any ailing relatives. If anyone would like to contact me - please do feel free to contact me via Linkedin or X.
Unless you signed a none disclosure as part of your settlement - I would also tell them the real reason you left but if you can't say the real reason you can call them out for lying.

She did sign an NDA. She said that in her second post.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 10/08/2023 18:45

That's terrible advice lto2019. Luckily I think the OP is too sensible to take it.

lto2019 · 10/08/2023 18:43

I would email and copy in all and say - it has come to my attention that this email was sent and I would like to make it clear this is wholly untrue. X bosses knows the true reason why I have left and have chosen to lie. My mother died in 19xx and I am not caring for any ailing relatives. If anyone would like to contact me - please do feel free to contact me via Linkedin or X.
Unless you signed a none disclosure as part of your settlement - I would also tell them the real reason you left but if you can't say the real reason you can call them out for lying.

chillikate · 10/08/2023 18:40

When I left a past role with a similar agreement, the wording of the business announcement about my departure was included as part of the contract. Neither party could deviate from "the story". Did you not have similar?

NippySweetie16 · 10/08/2023 18:37

A settlement agreement generally includes an agreement as to how - if at all - the issue will be communicated. If it didn't then your lawyer was lax in my view. Ask advice from ACAS. Your former employer has acted in an outrageous way!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/08/2023 18:23

Wow! I’m very sure that’s illegal but I think you should seek legal advice as to how to handle

OVienna · 10/08/2023 18:23

There is speculation about your departure (probably made worse by the email, in fact.)

I do wonder if it didn't happen quite as the person who contacted you described though. Have they been in touch again?

exaltedwombat · 10/08/2023 18:18

Did your settlement include a gagging clause? No discussing the case with colleagues or anyone else, just take the money, get out and shut up?

If so, although this email was wrong, making a case of it might be more trouble than it's worth. Were you represented by a union, or by a legal professional with whom your communications would be seen as privileged? Even then, you could be opening a can of worms.

Gardengirl108 · 10/08/2023 18:11

Sorry ‘talking’ not taking.

Gardengirl108 · 10/08/2023 18:11

Wowsharona · 09/08/2023 17:17

Yes unfortunately it’s a very lengthy NDA/settlement agreement so I’m not sure whether I can comment or even reply to my ex colleague

Your agreement likely also covers you taking about the very existence of the agreement, so you are on very sticky ground even mentioning it publicly (i.e on here). It’s likely to have a very short list of people you can talk to about it (solicitor/DWP/HMRC/Dr). So I would seriously consider if you want to delete this thread. The advice given earlier which was to seek advice from the solicitor who dealt with your agreement is spot on because what they have done is appalling. Good luck.

Loobieloogold · 10/08/2023 17:59

Hi - HR manager here. This is not on. Yes, the settlement agreement you have will be very lengthy, however the majority of this is technically "standard" terms. There will be more things, as standard, weighted against yourself that you have effectively agreed to accept a lump sum (plus any other terms) in order to NOT raise a claim against them. This will be even more heavily weighted that on acceptance you will not raise any future actions against them in relation to discrimination , whether indirect or direct, and any other associated claims, as this appears to be the main reason for the settlement. Please please please speak with the lawyer that you used to check over and sign the agreement and explain the situation, with evidence of this matter. Presenting as impersonation and misrepresenting you fraudulently and misuse and electronic transmission of your name within a company that you are not employed by.

1967buglet · 10/08/2023 08:46

JanieEyre · 10/08/2023 08:38

It can't apply to conduct that happens after the date of the agreement. And it wouldn't be clever of the employers to seek to recover their money, because it would leave the NDA free to disclose their discriminatory conduct.

Employers always bank on employees, current and former, not knowing the law. I am a union rep, and have seen all sorts of things employers have tried to do. Best she let her solicitor handle it and put an end to the nonsense so she can move on with her life.

JanieEyre · 10/08/2023 08:38

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/08/2023 21:30

They'd be able to get the money back. That's the point of an NDA - it's payable on condition of silence.

It can't apply to conduct that happens after the date of the agreement. And it wouldn't be clever of the employers to seek to recover their money, because it would leave the NDA free to disclose their discriminatory conduct.

Katrinawaves · 10/08/2023 08:20

Newusernametostayanon · 10/08/2023 07:56

I said probably precisely because damages for distress are a possibility though an unlikely outcome as 1) query whether this is a misuse of info claim as the issue is with use false info rather than misuse of true info; 2) costs to pursue such a claim are probably disproportionate to any possible damages; and 3) the OP seems to want to clarify the situation not go for damages.

No one expects to get fulsome legal advice from Mumsnet but there are cases like this where other MNers have relevant experience which can help the OP get started. Unnecessarily aggressive responses like yours put people off helping which is a shame.

You aren’t helping when you say you are a lawyer and give legally incorrect advice though! Which you have continued to do! There is no reason for the OP to believe either of us of course but I’m also a lawyer with more than 20 years experience in this actual area of the law!

McKennitt v Ash is the authority you need to look at to satisfy yourself that I am 100% correct when I say that the info disclosed does not need to be true and in fact the claimant does not need to specify whether the info is true or false. It just needs to be the kind of information which has a character of private information.

As I have advised already, the likely damages award here is in excess of £20k and the OP would also be entitled to payment of her legal costs. So no the costs of pursuing this would not be disproportionate to what she would recover. Nor are they limited by the actual financial loss incurred by the claimant (that’s not even the starting point for assessing them).

OP did not at any point say her only or even her main objective was to clarify the situation. She rightly said she was outraged by her former employer’s actions and asked for advice on what to do.

@Wowsharona have a read of this Advice note from the leading barrister’s chambers dealing with this kind of issue. Unlike a random on the internet you can at least be confident they are who they say they are and have the knowledge and experience in this area of the law. @Newusernametostayanon may or may not be a lawyer in real life but if she is, she very clearly does not practice in this area of the law and she has given you negligent advice and for whatever reason of her own she is persisting in doing so even when this has been pointed out to her.

https://www.5rb.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Privacy-law—misuse-of-private-information.pdf

https://www.5rb.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Privacy-law%E2%80%94misuse-of-private-information.pdf

1967buglet · 10/08/2023 08:14

When you sign an NDA, you agree to reveal nothing about the conditions of the settlement. If you do, you yourself can liable for legal action from your employer. Best she gets solicitor advice and let the solicitor handle it.

Newusernametostayanon · 10/08/2023 07:56

Katrinawaves · 09/08/2023 19:29

This is just incorrect and you should not be holding yourself out as a lawyer and giving advice outside your area of expertise (if you are in fact legally qualified at all).

The primary award for misuse of private information is for the distress which has been caused by the disclosure. If this has caused actual financial loss, then the amount of that loss can be ADDED to the claim. It is not necessary for there to have been any loss caused by the breach in the first instance.

I said probably precisely because damages for distress are a possibility though an unlikely outcome as 1) query whether this is a misuse of info claim as the issue is with use false info rather than misuse of true info; 2) costs to pursue such a claim are probably disproportionate to any possible damages; and 3) the OP seems to want to clarify the situation not go for damages.

No one expects to get fulsome legal advice from Mumsnet but there are cases like this where other MNers have relevant experience which can help the OP get started. Unnecessarily aggressive responses like yours put people off helping which is a shame.