Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my ex employers can’t do this?

187 replies

Wowsharona · 09/08/2023 17:00

I recently accepted a settlement to leave my job after discriminatory comments were made to me on two occasions after announcing my pregnancy.

it was a good offer so didn’t want to go into a long drawn out tribunal process whilst pregnant.

I left last week, today I received a message from an ex colleague asking if my mother was ok. I was confused as my mother died years ago in my early teens.

turns out after I had been paid off and left (was an abrupt leaving due to the situation) 2 days after I had officially gone an email was sent from my work email address saying goodbye to everyone and telling them I was leaving to take care of my sick and elderly mother!

it ended with ‘I’m sorry this is abrupt but for my own mental health I am requesting no one reach out via linked in as I’d like to put all my energy into my family’

I’m absolutely fuming, AIBU to think although yes my email address is technically their property they can’t pretend to be me and email everyone?

OP posts:
Katrinawaves · 10/08/2023 22:45

We’d have to see the actual wording of the email but I’m not sure that the email would be found to be defamatory

Would it lower the OP in the estimation of right thinking members of society (which is the legal test) to believe that she had given up her job to care for a seriously ill close family member even at short notice. I’m not at all sure that would meet the test. The fact that it’s untrue is irrelevant if it’s not defamatory.

The second bit might get over the line depending on how it was phrased. Or it might not. “I’d prefer you didn’t reach out to me on LinkedIn during this stressful period as all my focus is on caring for my mum” is not defamatory. “My mental health is shot to pieces and l can’t cope with engaging with anyone on LinkedIn” probably is. So it depends where along the spectrum the actual message falls.

But even if the meaning of the email is defamatory it needs to pass the serious harm test to be actionable and again I am not at all sure the OP will get over that hurdle. There isn’t a serious harm test for a privacy claim which is why it’s often preferred over a defamation claim.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 10/08/2023 22:38

Wtf! Speak to the lawyer who handled the settlement agreement, they could maybe write a letter to them for you

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 22:37

PlanetJanette · 10/08/2023 22:25

Haven’t read the full thread but the other route here is to claim that this amounts to defamation.

The company has falsely claimed you left abruptly for personal reasons and had mental health difficulties to the extent that you were unable to maintain professional relationships after you left.

Both of those things would stand a very good chance of meeting the threshold for defamation. And the company would have no valid defence that I can think of.

Interesting angle. It defo could have implications for future networking/job prospects if your employer spreads mistruths about your mental health within your industry.

PlanetJanette · 10/08/2023 22:25

Haven’t read the full thread but the other route here is to claim that this amounts to defamation.

The company has falsely claimed you left abruptly for personal reasons and had mental health difficulties to the extent that you were unable to maintain professional relationships after you left.

Both of those things would stand a very good chance of meeting the threshold for defamation. And the company would have no valid defence that I can think of.

prh47bridge · 10/08/2023 22:17

You should have had advice from a solicitor before signing the settlement agreement. If you didn't, you can ignore it. It isn't binding on you. If you did, consult them as to whether this is a breach of the settlement agreement and what you can do about it. The agreement may have limited your ability to take action against the company for this, although it is clearly unacceptable behaviour by them.

Hawkins009 · 10/08/2023 22:11

Wowsharona · 09/08/2023 17:00

I recently accepted a settlement to leave my job after discriminatory comments were made to me on two occasions after announcing my pregnancy.

it was a good offer so didn’t want to go into a long drawn out tribunal process whilst pregnant.

I left last week, today I received a message from an ex colleague asking if my mother was ok. I was confused as my mother died years ago in my early teens.

turns out after I had been paid off and left (was an abrupt leaving due to the situation) 2 days after I had officially gone an email was sent from my work email address saying goodbye to everyone and telling them I was leaving to take care of my sick and elderly mother!

it ended with ‘I’m sorry this is abrupt but for my own mental health I am requesting no one reach out via linked in as I’d like to put all my energy into my family’

I’m absolutely fuming, AIBU to think although yes my email address is technically their property they can’t pretend to be me and email everyone?

Google seems to be a mix of answers, on the face of it, I'd say it's impersonation and unethical, as for the legal side, that's out of my qualifications.

perfectstorm · 10/08/2023 21:49

Check your home/contents insurance in case you have legal cover on there. Quite a few people do and forget that they have it - it will cover legal action in this situation I suspect.

Can recommend a fantastic, fantastic employment solicitor if that helps.

pollymere · 10/08/2023 21:47

You should've agreed in your settlement about what would be announced as your reason for leaving and agreed on the text. I left my job because "I wished to support my son going to College". Which was true.

Ironically, they failed to say in my NDA that I couldn't mention the illegal meeting which resulted in my heart attack - only that I couldn't say that was my reason for leaving. Check your Settlement paperwork as it should be in there. Did you perhaps agree to something without realising?

I would presume you are also free to contact the ex-colleague and put them straight as to their confusion...

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 10/08/2023 21:43

daisychain01 · 10/08/2023 21:09

Personally I would consider suing them for the potential damage to your reputation.

yup you'd really be onto a winner there, suing for "potential" damage or potential anything for that matter. Good luck with that one, hopefully the OP will get proper RW legal advice meanwhile ....

I think “potential” anything isn’t a good idea to go after. But if her previous employers are lying about why she left and also about the fact that her mother is still alive when she died many years ago, that is stressful and upsetting, not only to OP but also to anyone else who knows about this, eg a brother , her father etc.

Then there’s the GDPR aspect as someone else mentioned.

I worked for a short time with data risk legal team in a large accounting firm. We were shown a video on data risk and what could be at risk. I’m not in touch with them now but they would say data risk and GDPR has been broached. If I have to undertake GDPR training which I have had to do, then the company should be aware of fines, if any, which can be imposed for breaches.

Iwanttogotoiceland · 10/08/2023 21:41

Shocking. Get straight on to your trade union for legal advice.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 10/08/2023 21:35

CPRMummy · 10/08/2023 20:19

That is absolutely crazy! I'd contact a solicitor citing that this has brought up your Mother's death and is harmful to yours and your baby's health due to stress. The settlement you've had should be the tip of the iceberg!

The stress to OP and her unborn baby can’t be proven though really. If she develops a stress related condition due to this then her company could argue that it could be down to any stress, not just this stress they’ve caused her.

PoseyFlump · 10/08/2023 21:28

CPRMummy · 10/08/2023 20:19

That is absolutely crazy! I'd contact a solicitor citing that this has brought up your Mother's death and is harmful to yours and your baby's health due to stress. The settlement you've had should be the tip of the iceberg!

And telling everyone the OP has mental health issues. This is unbelievable. I hope they pay a hefty price for this shit.

Imsureitsprobablymebut · 10/08/2023 21:21

Ask them to forward you the email, then seek legal advice.

daisychain01 · 10/08/2023 21:09

Personally I would consider suing them for the potential damage to your reputation.

yup you'd really be onto a winner there, suing for "potential" damage or potential anything for that matter. Good luck with that one, hopefully the OP will get proper RW legal advice meanwhile ....

TunnocksOrDeath · 10/08/2023 20:50

Personally I would consider suing them for the potential damage to your reputation. You may have mentioned your mother passing away to several people who have now received a mail, supposedly from you, claiming that she's alive and in need of care. They've made you out to be a liar, which could impact you professionally down the line. You need a correction and a public apology at the very least.

Jellifulfruit · 10/08/2023 20:34

Jesus, that’s outrageous. I’d be absolutely fuming. It’s a (albeit softer level of) fraud.

Trying81 · 10/08/2023 20:29

You would usually agree wording of any leaving statement as part of a settlement agreement; is it definitely not in there hidden away?

I had similar, again maternity related and they took out the wording relating to my maternity leave in mine - frustrating but apparently that was allowed as was a minor immaterial change

In all the clauses which say you can’t disclose anything on social media etc, there may be one also agreeing what the company can / cannot say

I would speak to whichever lawyer acted for you, you may have to pay them though as your ex employer only has to pay for your legal advice when signing the settlement agreement - but I highly doubt you’ve signed anything which gives your ex employer the right to send an email
on your behalf which is untrue

Lamelie · 10/08/2023 20:25

FishNetz · 09/08/2023 17:11

Have you agreed not to share information in exchange for settlement? if not I’d email or text the colleagues you know stating that very strangely someone has sent an email from your old work account, you didn’t write it and what it claims is fictional, your mother passed away x and the reason you left abruptly was due to discriminatory comments around your pregnancy. You’d like to keep in touch with everyone.

It’s awful they have lied and lumped fictional mental health and parental death into the equation. I wonder if there is some work legislation to deal with these lies?

There’s time for that later but for now @Wowsharona dont do that, you need legal advice before you approach anyone.
Are you a member of a union? If not contact ACAS, and Pregnant then screwed.

CPRMummy · 10/08/2023 20:19

That is absolutely crazy! I'd contact a solicitor citing that this has brought up your Mother's death and is harmful to yours and your baby's health due to stress. The settlement you've had should be the tip of the iceberg!

ihadamarveloustime · 10/08/2023 20:03

CantFindMyMarbles · 10/08/2023 20:01

This is actually a huge violation of GDPR.
Id be making formal complaints and saying I will now be going to tribunal despite settlement

That's an interesting take as well! Hadn't thought of GDPR obligations.

ihadamarveloustime · 10/08/2023 20:02

I can't even!

Surely the non disclosure applies to their side as well and they can't make something up like this to tell everyone!

I'd take legal advice with the solicitor you used for the (first) settlement package.

CantFindMyMarbles · 10/08/2023 20:01

This is actually a huge violation of GDPR.
Id be making formal complaints and saying I will now be going to tribunal despite settlement

anon666 · 10/08/2023 19:48

Just to add, normally with an NDA and severance package you will agree your "reason for leaving" and any statement. They can't just make one up!

anon666 · 10/08/2023 19:47

I've experienced some pretty shitty treatment from crap employers but that has really shocked me.

They've impersonated you with false information. That's quite serious in my book, I'm conflict averse (not worth the effort) but that would have me contacting my union/a lawyer.

Thinking2022 · 10/08/2023 19:41

i would call a reputable law firm like Fox williams who usually offer one hour free advice. this will let you know if you have a claim and if so how to bring it without legal representation. is your friend able to forward the email to you?