Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my ex employers can’t do this?

187 replies

Wowsharona · 09/08/2023 17:00

I recently accepted a settlement to leave my job after discriminatory comments were made to me on two occasions after announcing my pregnancy.

it was a good offer so didn’t want to go into a long drawn out tribunal process whilst pregnant.

I left last week, today I received a message from an ex colleague asking if my mother was ok. I was confused as my mother died years ago in my early teens.

turns out after I had been paid off and left (was an abrupt leaving due to the situation) 2 days after I had officially gone an email was sent from my work email address saying goodbye to everyone and telling them I was leaving to take care of my sick and elderly mother!

it ended with ‘I’m sorry this is abrupt but for my own mental health I am requesting no one reach out via linked in as I’d like to put all my energy into my family’

I’m absolutely fuming, AIBU to think although yes my email address is technically their property they can’t pretend to be me and email everyone?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ellyeth · 18/08/2023 12:01

Surely such an agreement binds both parties to "no comment"?

It is completely unacceptable for the company to make up a false reason for your departure.

Cudjoe · 11/08/2023 20:48

Oh my god!!! That is actually diabolical, I'm sure they can't do that. I would 1000% be fuming.

SaponificationQueen · 11/08/2023 20:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I had something similar many years ago. I was dealing with sexual harassment by a boss and a co-worker. An attorney got involved. I got a settlement with the caveat that I could not work for them again (as if I would want to). They were large enough and had enough subsidiaries that would not be obviously them, that we put in the word “knowingly.” So even though I was harassed, the bad actors kept their jobs and I lost mine.

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 18:27

Katrinawaves · 11/08/2023 17:58

Yes I agree with that. The most they could do would be to redact the identifying reference to the mother but they would still need to send the remainder of the email.

We were at cross purposes on that one because earlier in the thread someone else had suggested making a DSAR on behalf of the mother and complaining about misuse of fe mother’s sensitive personal data and neither of those are clearly possible.

May have been part of my posting (with poor wording) about the problem the company have on proving sourcing and permission for holding the data plus fair processing by sending the email 👍

Devilinthedeet · 11/08/2023 18:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Katrinawaves · 11/08/2023 17:58

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 16:38

@Katrinawaves On point 4 the company has data obligations if the OP makes a complaint over not been given the email or on its content the ICO will look at the company's data obligations for the information on the OP's file. So the company cant hide behind the excuse of DM being a third party data subject when they produced the email "from" the OP.

Anyway hope the OP is busy with her solicitor.

Yes I agree with that. The most they could do would be to redact the identifying reference to the mother but they would still need to send the remainder of the email.

We were at cross purposes on that one because earlier in the thread someone else had suggested making a DSAR on behalf of the mother and complaining about misuse of fe mother’s sensitive personal data and neither of those are clearly possible.

carrzeda · 11/08/2023 16:46

Don’t reply to your former colleague. Contact a solicitor or ACAS has others mentioned, if you can.

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 16:38

@Katrinawaves On point 4 the company has data obligations if the OP makes a complaint over not been given the email or on its content the ICO will look at the company's data obligations for the information on the OP's file. So the company cant hide behind the excuse of DM being a third party data subject when they produced the email "from" the OP.

Anyway hope the OP is busy with her solicitor.

Qbishy · 11/08/2023 15:54

The OP's former employers already paid up instead of going to court. I'm sure they can be encouraged to do that again.

Katrinawaves · 11/08/2023 15:29

@AnSolas I’ll try and answer your questions but I’m not sure I completely understand what you are asking for some of them. But will give it a go!

  1. Yes a defamation action is usually outside the scope of most people’s pockets - another reason why I don’t think it’s the right response in these circumstances
  2. This one I don’t understand what you are asking! The employer is the publisher. The recipients of the email are the publishees. Publication just to the OP isn’t actionable. The employer is liable in respect of publication to the recipients of the email. If the email was forwarded by an original recipient to a future employer (probably unlikely) the person who forwarded the email would be liable not the employer.
  3. again not sure what you are asking here from a legal analysis perspective. For the email to bear an innuendo meaning that the OP had lied about her reasons for leaving her previous job, the person to whom the email was published would need to know that the mother had previously died. The fact that others talk about OP’s reasons for leaving the previous role in the future on LinkedIn or elsewhere is relevant to the extent that it establishes loss (one of the heads of damages in the privacy claim I keep recommending) but it doesn’t go to what a court would determine the natural and ordinary meaning of the original email to be.
  4. the dead mother can’t assert her DP rights nor can the the OP assert those rights on behalf of the dead mother. The only DP rights which the OP can assert are in respect of information which relates to her. ie in this case her dates of employment, her caring responsibilities and her mental health. The OP can make a SAR for the email but this will be in her own name but not her mother’s.

I’m conscious that the OP hasn’t come back to the thread for several days so none of this may be helpful to her though!

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 15:10

Katrinawaves · 11/08/2023 11:19

Now we get into innuendo meaning which can be complicated and just layers on expense and uncertainty to bring a claim in defamation when that’s not necessary and not the best option.

But to answer your question to establish the defamatory meaning by innuendo the OP would need to call evidence from witnesses that they both knew that her mother was dead at the time the email was sent and that they received the email either directly or via a third party. Whether any existing employee would want to stick their head so far over the parapet for OP is debatable and I suspect this subgroup would be quite small.

Future employers unless they were the recipient of the email and knew the OP’s mother to be dead, aren’t going to come to the conclusion that she lied about her reasons for leaving the job. And that risk in any event would be extinguished by the OP having taken legal action (just not for defamation for the reasons I’ve explained) in respect of the email.

On the DP issue, the mother’s DP rights are not engaged because she is deceased but the OP does potentially have remedies for DP infringement and those claims are commonly made in parallel with privacy claims and heard together.

I think we can both agree that Court action for defamation is a rich mans game partly because it pulls in witnesses who dont want to "play"?

Future employers unless they were the recipient of the email
That is a publication argument? The company as a legal being publishes to their employees one of whom communicates the publication to the OP

Future employers unless they were the recipient of the email and knew the OP’s mother to be dead, aren’t going to come to the conclusion that she lied about her reasons for leaving the job
The risk is word of mouth via Linkedin which is about building professional reputation and using personal contact list crossover.
OP has already networked with the employees on this third party system, in some industries asking a friend directly or even asking a friend to ask their friend (<the Linkedin model) is the problem.

On the DP issue, the mother’s DP rights are not engaged because she is deceased
How the company prove that DM is not sick rather deceased and no rights attached to her medical data?

Using a SAR results in the company producing the email themselves.

Lamelie · 11/08/2023 11:21

Love Mumsnet but it’s awful for legal and employment advice.
@Wowsharona
Are you a member of a union? If not contact ACAS, and Pregnant then screwed.

Katrinawaves · 11/08/2023 11:19

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 09:37

I agree that not having the email is the first problem

however the company has a problem as OP's mother is dead

Would it lower the OP in the estimation of right thinking members of society (which is the legal test) to believe that she lied to leave a job saying she had to care for a dead family member even at short notice.

In a lot of jobs a lie on why did you leave your last job is covered under gross misconduct at point of hire.

Now we get into innuendo meaning which can be complicated and just layers on expense and uncertainty to bring a claim in defamation when that’s not necessary and not the best option.

But to answer your question to establish the defamatory meaning by innuendo the OP would need to call evidence from witnesses that they both knew that her mother was dead at the time the email was sent and that they received the email either directly or via a third party. Whether any existing employee would want to stick their head so far over the parapet for OP is debatable and I suspect this subgroup would be quite small.

Future employers unless they were the recipient of the email and knew the OP’s mother to be dead, aren’t going to come to the conclusion that she lied about her reasons for leaving the job. And that risk in any event would be extinguished by the OP having taken legal action (just not for defamation for the reasons I’ve explained) in respect of the email.

On the DP issue, the mother’s DP rights are not engaged because she is deceased but the OP does potentially have remedies for DP infringement and those claims are commonly made in parallel with privacy claims and heard together.

TunnocksOrDeath · 11/08/2023 11:10

daisychain01 · 10/08/2023 21:09

Personally I would consider suing them for the potential damage to your reputation.

yup you'd really be onto a winner there, suing for "potential" damage or potential anything for that matter. Good luck with that one, hopefully the OP will get proper RW legal advice meanwhile ....

I said "consider" and "potential" because I have no idea what the OP's existing reputation was. None of us on this forum actually know enough about it to give any better advice than "go to a solicitor with all the facts".

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 10:38

prh47bridge · 11/08/2023 09:54

No, there will not be any clause that allows the company to impersonate OP. However, I have seen settlement agreements where the employer has put in a wide-ranging clause limiting the causes for which the employee can take action against them. It is unlikely there is anything in the settlement agreement that would limit OP's rights to do something about this, but it is not impossible.

IMO the company would be in breach of their legal DPA obligations and any clause can only cover lawful actions.
A SAR is a legal right so if there is data the ICO have the duty to determine if the clause qualified as an exemption or not

I suspect that the OP would be sucessful in requesting test case for oversight of fair processing of data as a public interest as the distress caused by sympathy calls the OP (by going around telling people that a dead family member is alive) is "on par" with cold calling the OP about new windows

crazeekat · 11/08/2023 10:27

i would name and shame them!!! there is no law that u can't keep in touch with whoever tf u want. they are cheeky fks. i would PM everyone and let them know what rogues they work for. they will all suss out themselves who sent the email and who is a lair. i think they have gotten off lightly paying you off and don't want any of the other staff getting any bright ideas. absolute scum.

prh47bridge · 11/08/2023 09:54

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 09:17

Unless the OP's solicitor is stupid enough to have approved that email, there will be no clause in the agreement which allows the company or one of their employees impersonate the OP.

When an employee is given a specific email address that will fall within data protection as it ID's one person. The OP had not been an employee for 2 days when the email was sent.

Fair processing of data
How did the company obtain the data on:

  1. the OP's "sick and elderly mother"
    How did the company collect data on OP's dead mother's health?
    When did they get permission from dear mum to disclose her medical data?
    Even the OP had no authority to collect and disclose medical data of a living parent ( yes it happens but company policy should tell Ee's not to do it)

  2. the OP's " own mental health"
    How did the company collect data on the impact dear mums sickness was having on her mental health?
    When did they get permission from OP to disclose her medical data?

  3. instructions for "reach out via linked"
    When did they get permission from OP to issue instructions on her behalf?

  4. the OP "put all my energy into my family"
    How did the company obtain that little jem ?(as the agreement is to enable the OP an exit to new employment)

A lot of employers/managers use informal referrals from their contacts so the linkedin bit is a very nasty method of putting a lie in circulation of future employers while making it hard for the OP to find out

No, there will not be any clause that allows the company to impersonate OP. However, I have seen settlement agreements where the employer has put in a wide-ranging clause limiting the causes for which the employee can take action against them. It is unlikely there is anything in the settlement agreement that would limit OP's rights to do something about this, but it is not impossible.

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 09:37

Katrinawaves · 10/08/2023 22:45

We’d have to see the actual wording of the email but I’m not sure that the email would be found to be defamatory

Would it lower the OP in the estimation of right thinking members of society (which is the legal test) to believe that she had given up her job to care for a seriously ill close family member even at short notice. I’m not at all sure that would meet the test. The fact that it’s untrue is irrelevant if it’s not defamatory.

The second bit might get over the line depending on how it was phrased. Or it might not. “I’d prefer you didn’t reach out to me on LinkedIn during this stressful period as all my focus is on caring for my mum” is not defamatory. “My mental health is shot to pieces and l can’t cope with engaging with anyone on LinkedIn” probably is. So it depends where along the spectrum the actual message falls.

But even if the meaning of the email is defamatory it needs to pass the serious harm test to be actionable and again I am not at all sure the OP will get over that hurdle. There isn’t a serious harm test for a privacy claim which is why it’s often preferred over a defamation claim.

I agree that not having the email is the first problem

however the company has a problem as OP's mother is dead

Would it lower the OP in the estimation of right thinking members of society (which is the legal test) to believe that she lied to leave a job saying she had to care for a dead family member even at short notice.

In a lot of jobs a lie on why did you leave your last job is covered under gross misconduct at point of hire.

determinedtomakethiswork · 11/08/2023 09:36

I don't think your colleague should forward anything at all because it will be linked to her computer.

GoodChat · 11/08/2023 09:19

Would it lower the OP in the estimation of right thinking members of society (which is the legal test) to believe that she had given up her job to care for a seriously ill close family member even at short notice. I’m not at all sure that would meet the test. The fact that it’s untrue is irrelevant if it’s not defamatory.

I guess that depends on whether people knew her mom was no longer alive?

AnSolas · 11/08/2023 09:17

prh47bridge · 10/08/2023 22:17

You should have had advice from a solicitor before signing the settlement agreement. If you didn't, you can ignore it. It isn't binding on you. If you did, consult them as to whether this is a breach of the settlement agreement and what you can do about it. The agreement may have limited your ability to take action against the company for this, although it is clearly unacceptable behaviour by them.

Unless the OP's solicitor is stupid enough to have approved that email, there will be no clause in the agreement which allows the company or one of their employees impersonate the OP.

When an employee is given a specific email address that will fall within data protection as it ID's one person. The OP had not been an employee for 2 days when the email was sent.

Fair processing of data
How did the company obtain the data on:

  1. the OP's "sick and elderly mother"
    How did the company collect data on OP's dead mother's health?
    When did they get permission from dear mum to disclose her medical data?
    Even the OP had no authority to collect and disclose medical data of a living parent ( yes it happens but company policy should tell Ee's not to do it)

  2. the OP's " own mental health"
    How did the company collect data on the impact dear mums sickness was having on her mental health?
    When did they get permission from OP to disclose her medical data?

  3. instructions for "reach out via linked"
    When did they get permission from OP to issue instructions on her behalf?

  4. the OP "put all my energy into my family"
    How did the company obtain that little jem ?(as the agreement is to enable the OP an exit to new employment)

A lot of employers/managers use informal referrals from their contacts so the linkedin bit is a very nasty method of putting a lie in circulation of future employers while making it hard for the OP to find out

royalwatch · 11/08/2023 07:26

how strange!! What an oddly personal reason to make up!

put something on social media about remembering your dear mother and how long ago she’s died

Ukrainebaby23 · 11/08/2023 07:21

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 09/08/2023 17:03

I have no idea of what the law would say but morally that's awful. Truly awful. I'm actually angry about it on your behalf.

This, not sure it's illegal, but p--- poor.

daisychain01 · 11/08/2023 07:15

perfectstorm · 10/08/2023 21:49

Check your home/contents insurance in case you have legal cover on there. Quite a few people do and forget that they have it - it will cover legal action in this situation I suspect.

Can recommend a fantastic, fantastic employment solicitor if that helps.

The legal cover sold with household insurance tends to very prescriptive and limited to the most frequently occurring employment situation aka low risk cases that have more than 51% likelihood of success. This scenario would be assessed by a panel solicitor who would decline the case and recommend not touching a case like this with a barge pole. They never take cases forward that don't have a significant amount of accurate non-hearsay facts, with a clear cut legal basis on which to progress.

daisychain01 · 11/08/2023 07:07

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 10/08/2023 21:43

I think “potential” anything isn’t a good idea to go after. But if her previous employers are lying about why she left and also about the fact that her mother is still alive when she died many years ago, that is stressful and upsetting, not only to OP but also to anyone else who knows about this, eg a brother , her father etc.

Then there’s the GDPR aspect as someone else mentioned.

I worked for a short time with data risk legal team in a large accounting firm. We were shown a video on data risk and what could be at risk. I’m not in touch with them now but they would say data risk and GDPR has been broached. If I have to undertake GDPR training which I have had to do, then the company should be aware of fines, if any, which can be imposed for breaches.

Highly unlikely to get very far with a Data Protection Act (2018) breach unless the OP is prepared to spend time, effort and stress, and even then, no guarantee of any redress.

If the OP were to take the email situation to a solicitor, the first thing they'll want is the exact email wording, plus the person who sent it as an "officer" of the company. If all the OP has is hear-say, they would be unwise to take legal action.

A solicitor's letter to the company with accurate facts may give the employer a bit of a momentary wake-up call and clear message that their action was unethical and they'll just tear it up and throw it in the bin.