Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
dramoy · 09/08/2023 22:48

I think posts like the OPs come from a reluctance on the part of some people to admit they've been helped in life. There's this conceit that everything they have must be seen as deserved and earned (if not by hard work, by some comparable hardship) so they will jump through hoops to argue they're just as unfortunate as everyone else

It's really weird which I don't understand. Why are some afraid to acknowledge it, fear it will be taken away?

WhereHasTheSunGoneThisSummer · 09/08/2023 22:46

Parents are going to die, you can’t swap extra years of life for an inheritance.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 22:45

@JonahAndTheSnail how is it not free money for the recipient?

I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s.

🙄 yeah the point is would you rather lose them in your 40s & have an inheritance or lose them
in your 40s & have zero inheritance. Presumably it's the latter...

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 22:42

How is it 'free' money if the parent has worked hard/made sacrifices to help to pass a legacy on to their child? Both DH and I are both from poor working class backgrounds, but were brought up with the attitude that you work hard and should be careful with money, as you never know what's around the corner. DH's father died unexpectedly when he was aged 30 and DH was just 4 years old. His mum raised 2 young children (under 5) as a single parent until they were 18, working full time. His Mum passed away unexpectedly when DH was just 40. My dad died when I was 25 and he was only 60. We have built up a business and invested carefully, without any financial input from anyone else, which has given up a comfortable standard of living and will allow us to retire at 50.

I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s.

anothergrievingsister · 09/08/2023 22:34

@LakeTiticaca I write as a sibling beneficiary of minimal seven figures who would give it back in a heartbeat for a final hour them. I can tell you that keeping the name of my sibling, a reasonably prominent scientist who was also a significant contributor to charity, alive means more to me than someone who writes as you do is likely to be able to imagine.

To this end I have pledged about £150,000 with more to follow in accord with their values. Roughly tithing thus far after death duties. Every gift in their name helps me.

ssd · 09/08/2023 22:05

The thing is, all these people saying they'd rather have the person alive than the money...it seems to be missing the point. The person who left you the money would 100% know the money will eventually make your life easier and they'd have been delighted they were in the position to do this for you. So instead of saying how much you'd rather have the person back instead of the money (duh), I'd be thanking them every night in my prayers for them being able to leave me money.
And i wouldn't forget my humility towards those who unfortunately couldn't be left anything.

5128gap · 09/08/2023 22:04

I think posts like the OPs come from a reluctance on the part of some people to admit they've been helped in life. There's this conceit that everything they have must be seen as deserved and earned (if not by hard work, by some comparable hardship) so they will jump through hoops to argue they're just as unfortunate as everyone else; lest we think for a moment the good things in their lives have come about more easily than for others. People who feel thd need to 'justify' their inheritance often cite the work ethic of the deceased as making it 'fair', so it must be quite conflicting for those people to be in the position where their own gains are not as a result of their work.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 09/08/2023 21:48

BigBeeee · 09/08/2023 21:20

"So much bitterness and resentment on MN these days. People who inherit. Boomers. Landlords. Second home owners. Anyone not on the bones of their arse. All should be burned at the stake it seems."

Think you've misread the room. A good number of the people saying those who get an inheritance are lucky have got, or expect to get, an inheritance. Most people aren't bitter. They are saying that if you get a good inheritance you are lucky. They think that getting an inheritance in the event of a death and saying that the inheritance itself wasn't a good thing because they would rather have the person back are disingenuous. Everybody would rather have their loved ones back but not everybody is lucky enough to receive half a million in inheritance. Nobody wants anybody burnt at the stake. Half the people saying it have got or are getting inheritances. They just aren't twats pretending that half a million won't be useful.

. AMEN to that! ^

Happy Jennifer Lopez GIF by NBC World Of Dance
dramoy · 09/08/2023 21:41

Money buys security and gives you options, which goes a long way towards happiness. A PP has already shared their experience of having to clear out their Mum's belongings as she was only given two weeks by the council before they wanted the property back. Whereas someone whose parent was mortgage free doesn't have that time pressure.

it's quite eye opening that some people clearly live in complete bubbles so aren't aware that their reality is not the same as everyone else's. I know someone who had the above happen, it was awful the additional stress it put them under.

Silvered · 09/08/2023 21:25

Mukey · 09/08/2023 20:33

People need to realise that money can't buy you everything. What good is money when you have no one?
I had a fair few years after my parents died of it being just me. No parents. No siblings. No partner. No children. One uncle who lives abroad. That's it. I would spend almost every evening by myself. No one to call and tell about my day. No one to share stories with. But apparently because I had money that is what matters and I'm lucky? Really? I would have given anything to have a family of my own. But it never happened. I do now have a husband. But couldn't have kids. Spent thousands trying. You hear people say all the time when, for example, a house burns down in a fire, that at least your family are safe etc. That's really what matters etc. Everyone talks about how family is more important than possessions. But yet everyone tells me I'm really lucky because i have money. It used to really hurt to hear that. I once asked a friend if she'd give up her kids in order to have a house because she'd said she'd "give anything" to have what I had. She at least looked a bit embarrassed and said no she was glad she had them and she wouldn't change a thing even though she didn't have much money.
So while it's fine to acknowledge money may make people's lives easier in some way, it doesn't make people happy and it can't buy you what matters.

But that's not people are saying. The thread is about those who are in the fortunate position to receive an inheritance when someone dies. As PP have already pointed out, nobody is saying that you should choose someone's money over their survival. Or that the money takes away or negates the grief.

Money buys security and gives you options, which goes a long way towards happiness. A PP has already shared their experience of having to clear out their Mum's belongings as she was only given two weeks by the council before they wanted the property back. Whereas someone whose parent was mortgage free doesn't have that time pressure.

BigBeeee · 09/08/2023 21:20

"So much bitterness and resentment on MN these days. People who inherit. Boomers. Landlords. Second home owners. Anyone not on the bones of their arse. All should be burned at the stake it seems."

Think you've misread the room. A good number of the people saying those who get an inheritance are lucky have got, or expect to get, an inheritance. Most people aren't bitter. They are saying that if you get a good inheritance you are lucky. They think that getting an inheritance in the event of a death and saying that the inheritance itself wasn't a good thing because they would rather have the person back are disingenuous. Everybody would rather have their loved ones back but not everybody is lucky enough to receive half a million in inheritance. Nobody wants anybody burnt at the stake. Half the people saying it have got or are getting inheritances. They just aren't twats pretending that half a million won't be useful.

readbooksdrinktea · 09/08/2023 20:59

Money can't buy everything. But it can buy a roof over your head and pay your bills while you grieve.

Further down the line it can give you choices in your life for you and your family still here.

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 20:40

People need to realise that money can't buy you everything. What good is money when you have no one?

No-one plus money

or

No-one and no money

Pick one

Bubop · 09/08/2023 20:37

But it is a massive privilege.

Losing someone is difficult regardless of whether you inherit from them or not. But It’s incredibly short sighted to pretend that receiving an inheritance isn’t a privilege (and a little ungrateful if your family member has planned carefully to ensure they leave you something).

You might be incredibly sad at the circumstances leading to an inheritance. But you’d be just as sad without an inheritance… you just won’t have had a leg up financially.

M4J4 · 09/08/2023 20:37

23Hares · 09/08/2023 19:36

So much bitterness and resentment on MN these days. People who inherit. Boomers. Landlords. Second home owners. Anyone not on the bones of their arse. All should be burned at the stake it seems.

But who started the thread? Someone who inherited.

There’s this clamouring need in some heirs to humble brag on MN about their inheritance.

And you don’t get any more humble brag than ‘I’d give away all my inheritance to get my relative back for just one day’.

No one’s buying it.

WhereHasTheSunGoneThisSummer · 09/08/2023 20:33

Losing my relative and then inheriting are two separate things to me. The inheritance didn’t help my grief but it has bought happiness and I’ve been able to help family members with it.
Most people wouldn’t admit this but I feel really lucky to have inherited nearly 100k, I literally can’t believe it most days. I never expected it or made any life plans involving a possible inheritance.
I could have lost my relative and received nothing, obviously inheriting is better.

Mukey · 09/08/2023 20:33

People need to realise that money can't buy you everything. What good is money when you have no one?
I had a fair few years after my parents died of it being just me. No parents. No siblings. No partner. No children. One uncle who lives abroad. That's it. I would spend almost every evening by myself. No one to call and tell about my day. No one to share stories with. But apparently because I had money that is what matters and I'm lucky? Really? I would have given anything to have a family of my own. But it never happened. I do now have a husband. But couldn't have kids. Spent thousands trying. You hear people say all the time when, for example, a house burns down in a fire, that at least your family are safe etc. That's really what matters etc. Everyone talks about how family is more important than possessions. But yet everyone tells me I'm really lucky because i have money. It used to really hurt to hear that. I once asked a friend if she'd give up her kids in order to have a house because she'd said she'd "give anything" to have what I had. She at least looked a bit embarrassed and said no she was glad she had them and she wouldn't change a thing even though she didn't have much money.
So while it's fine to acknowledge money may make people's lives easier in some way, it doesn't make people happy and it can't buy you what matters.

Clefable · 09/08/2023 20:32

In fairness, it can take 6 months to a year to get the actual money in your account, so in the weeks and first few months after someone has died, it's unlikely to make any material difference to that process (bar the funeral as you can pay for that from the estate). If you had no money on Saturday and your rich grandmother who left everything to you died on Sunday, you'd still have no money on Monday. If you know it's coming, though, you can make financial decisions with that in mind, so you can use savings or whatever knowing they will be replenished at some point.

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 09/08/2023 20:26

Aquestioningmind · 09/08/2023 15:27

I think a lot of people are purposefully misconstruing what the OP said.

Ultimately, yes, the money does hep financially - no one can deny that. But it does not make the death 'easier to deal with'- that is what the OP is saying.

Loss is loss and grief is grief and boiling it down to 'but you got left money' is at it's best tactless and at it's worth disrespectful and nasty.

It does make the death easier to deal with. You can pay for grief counselling. If you aren’t coping, you can get signed off work for a while without worrying about being on statutory sick pay and the bills mounting up. You can pay for the funeral you feel your loved one deserved, to give them a proper send off. If you don’t feel you can manage to clear the house, you can pay for a house clearance company. If they owned property that you are selling, you have time, you can do it on your timeline rather than the landlord wanting their stuff out straight away. Even just little things like if you’re struggling, you can rely on a meal delivery service/cook meals and a cleaner. You will still grieve, no doubt about that, but you have options to help you grieve in a healthier and more healing way.

Questionsforyou · 09/08/2023 20:17

My mother in law died and it left us poorer.
My mum died and it enabled us to scrape together slightly enough so we could have a baby
Mind fuck though as no mum to share it with.
Doesn't feel that fortunate.

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 20:14

Clefable · 09/08/2023 19:58

But as per your PP, some people might think you are fortunate that your mum got to meet your children at all. Maybe someone who lost their mum before they had children and was also left with nothing would think you should acknowledge how fortunate you are.

In your response to a previous poster who had lost both parents pre-kids, you suggested that they had had a better time of it because at least they'd come out with money and would they like to swap?

My Dad never saw me get married or have children. My mum died when my 2nd baby was 8 weeks old and will never meet my third.

I inherited absolutely nothing. I’m still paying off funeral debt now, and my Mum died 18 months ago.

So, would you rather be in your situation, or mine?

Urgh indeed.

Perhaps that poster would have preferred a world where she came out with no money but had another 10 years or whatever of her mum and a chance for her mum to meet her children. In fact I'm sure she would, I know I would. It doesn't matter because life doesn't work like that. But suggesting that you are worse off solely because you weren't left anything ignores the fact that with inheritance comes the loss of a person, often much-loved, and perhaps you having ten more years of however long of your mum is more important than coming out with £200k or whatever.

I'm very sorry you lost your mum and your dad. I've got two pre-school children, one a baby, and lost my mum just a few weeks ago, my husband lost both of his parents before the age of 50 and they left nothing, but I found your response that previous poster in very bad taste.

Actually, the poster I was responding to in your quote said

“I've had people tell me I'm so "lucky" because I inherited after losing my mum young and then my dad not long afterwards. Yeah, so I'm so lucky I have no family left arent I? so lucky that my mum never got to see me get married or meet my children, I'm just so damn lucky.”

So as far as I can see, we are both in the same position of having lost both our parents, one of them pre-marriage and children- in my case my Dad, in the other poster’s case her Mum. So far so equal- except she got an inheritance and I did not, and she’s judging those in my position for openly stating we’d prefer to be in hers.

I know I’m lucky that my Mum got to meet two of my DC, even if in the case of my second baby it was only twice. I know that and I’ve never once disputed it, nor judged and looked down on anybody who thinks I’m lucky because their parents never got to meet their DC at all. I feel great sympathy for them and I count my blessings, however few they may appear to me.

That’s the difference.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 09/08/2023 20:03

That’s a big assumption. A lot of people work extremely hard in areas where house prices aren’t over inflated over the years

There's no area of the UK where house prices haven't significantly inflated in real terms over recent decades. It's more in some areas than others, of course, but given that people passing down inheritance are overwhelmingly going to have owned their properties for a long time before dying, it isn't an assumption at all that most of it's unearned and driven by house price inflation.

Clefable · 09/08/2023 20:03

And I do absolutely believe that being left an inheritance is fortunate. I am not arguing that at all. I feel very fortunate to have a large sum coming my way, it will make our lives a lot easier and give our children a great start in life financially. But suggesting to a PP that they've somehow gotten a better deal in life when you've potentially had 10+ more years of your mum, your mum has got to see you get married or find a life partner, meet two of your children is a bit tone deaf. You've both had a crap time. That PP was more fortunate than you to get money after losing both parents very early, you were more fortunate than them to get more time with your mum and for your mum to get a chance to meet grandchildren. What weight you put on each thing is up to you.

Clefable · 09/08/2023 19:58

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 19:43

We would like them to acknowledge that they are fortunate- in spite of their bereavement- to have received an inheritance, when compared with those who suffer the same bereavement and receive nothing.

But as per your PP, some people might think you are fortunate that your mum got to meet your children at all. Maybe someone who lost their mum before they had children and was also left with nothing would think you should acknowledge how fortunate you are.

In your response to a previous poster who had lost both parents pre-kids, you suggested that they had had a better time of it because at least they'd come out with money and would they like to swap?

My Dad never saw me get married or have children. My mum died when my 2nd baby was 8 weeks old and will never meet my third.

I inherited absolutely nothing. I’m still paying off funeral debt now, and my Mum died 18 months ago.

So, would you rather be in your situation, or mine?

Urgh indeed.

Perhaps that poster would have preferred a world where she came out with no money but had another 10 years or whatever of her mum and a chance for her mum to meet her children. In fact I'm sure she would, I know I would. It doesn't matter because life doesn't work like that. But suggesting that you are worse off solely because you weren't left anything ignores the fact that with inheritance comes the loss of a person, often much-loved, and perhaps you having ten more years of however long of your mum is more important than coming out with £200k or whatever.

I'm very sorry you lost your mum and your dad. I've got two pre-school children, one a baby, and lost my mum just a few weeks ago, my husband lost both of his parents before the age of 50 and they left nothing, but I found your response that previous poster in very bad taste.

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 19:43

LakeTiticaca · 09/08/2023 19:39

Why all the jealousy and bitterness towards those who have inherited money from family? It's not their fault that their parents accrued a large amount of money.
Nor is it their fault if someone else's parents sadly died young and left nothing.
It's not their fault that some people have low incomes and are not able to getbon the property ladder.
Nor is it their fault that some people choose to piss their money away.
Do you expect then to give the money away to someone who is deemed to be more deserving?

We would like them to acknowledge that they are fortunate- in spite of their bereavement- to have received an inheritance, when compared with those who suffer the same bereavement and receive nothing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread