Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
Jadeybabez · 10/08/2023 08:18

We've had a conversation about inheritance at work before and someone assumed I'd be getting some when the dreaded happens, I told them I wouldn't be getting anything and explained why and they said "surely you'll get something?" I said no and I'm not bothered by it. The money is just another reminder that they're not here 🤷🤷😞

Threenow · 10/08/2023 08:18

KvotheTheBloodless · 09/08/2023 14:08

I don't think anyone is saying that you wanted x or y to die, only that inheritance isn't money you earned, and really it is a hand-out.

I stand to inherit a huge amount myself, I'm not jealous, just telling the truth. It's unearned and, objectively, unfair.

Well no, obviously it isn't money the person inheriting earned, but someone earned it originally so it isn't a hand-out, nor is it unfair. Life isn't fair, some people do well, some don't, it's just life. Some people win huge sums of money, but strangely enough I never hear how unfair that is!

LakeTiticaca · 10/08/2023 08:16

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 19:43

We would like them to acknowledge that they are fortunate- in spite of their bereavement- to have received an inheritance, when compared with those who suffer the same bereavement and receive nothing.

Acknowledge to who? The inheritance police?
It's nobody else's business!!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/08/2023 07:38

fullbloom87 · 10/08/2023 00:11

It's the same for my husband and I. Both poor and completely self made. However I think your attitude is discriminatory towards disabled people and people with learning Difficulties.
Our youngest has cerebral palsy and learning disabilities, she has only us. If we were to die she would be in a dire situation without the money we've set aside for her.
Not everybody can just 'work hard' to become financially stable. Many people battle with life in a number of ways. It's not always that easy.

Nobody is arguing that's it's easy. And of course not everyone can just work hard to become financially stable, but in many ways, that's the point!

You say that your dd would be in a dire situation without the money that you've managed to set by for her, and I don't doubt that that's true. The point that people are making is that there are sadly lots of people who are left in that dire situation because their parents weren't able to set anything aside for them/pass on an inheritance.

And while life may never be "easy" for your dd, it will be a whole lot harder for people with comparable disabilities and no financial cushion, so in comparison to those individuals, your dd is very lucky indeed to have had parents who could afford to make provisions for her future.

MeridaBrave · 10/08/2023 07:34

Some people get inheritance when parents are alive. Or parents do a “dead of variation” in favour of their children when an elderly grandparent dies. People do eventually die.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 10/08/2023 06:58

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/08/2023 23:00

I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s.

Well, obviously, assume I'm very sorry for your losses, but that isn't really the point, is it? It isn't as if being poor somehow gives you a protective shield that enables you to live longer... quite the contrary, actually. People on lower incomes are significantly more likely to die at a younger age.

Consequently, the chances are that people from poorer families are actually more likely to lose their parents at a relatively young age and miss out on an inheritance, so to them, the people with the inheritance look pretty lucky.

Yep!

fullbloom87 · 10/08/2023 02:03

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 00:33

Not everybody can just 'work hard' to become financially stable. Many people battle with life in a number of ways. It's not always that easy.

I'm not sure where I said it was that easy in life for everyone. All I said was I agree with the OP that it's shit when you lose both parents at an early age and money doesn't make up for it, which it doesn't. It can't buy you your parents being there for your wedding day, meeting grandchildren for the first time etc. I then said my personal experience is I would rather have my loved ones back and not the money. I can understand why this isn't the case for everyone, based on their own life experiences and of course they're not wrong, it's subjective. I don't have any family to leave money to and little interest in changing my current modest lifestyle, so a charity will likely get a 'hand out' when I die. I stand by 'hand out' being a crass term to use in the context of someone dying. Sadly a lot of assumptions on this thread seem to be that anyone with more than a penny spare to their name has no altruistic capabilities.

Of course you would swap the money to have your loved one back. I think the point people are trying to make is that inheritance is a hand out, it's not a piece of nothing and those that receive it are very lucky they just don't realise it because most have already had money and probably handouts in the past such house deposits, help with weddings and education etc. many people with inheritance don't know what it's like to be dirt poor and it's insulting for poor people to read things like 'I don't want the money' or 'I don't need the money'
Perhaps give it to someone that desperately needs it like a family who are working hard but have struggled all their lives.

DinoRoar14 · 10/08/2023 01:52

People die. Everyone dies. Everyone's parents and loved ones will die.

Some will have some good come of that. Others just get left with the sadness of the death.

AngeloMysterioso · 10/08/2023 01:26

it's shit when you lose both parents at an early age and money doesn't make up for it, which it doesn't. It can't buy you your parents being there for your wedding day, meeting grandchildren for the first time etc. I then said my personal experience is I would rather have my loved ones back and not the money.

None of us can get back the people we lost, regardless of whether or not we inherited anything.

So would you rather lose the person you love and have money, or lose the person you love and have no money?

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 00:33

Not everybody can just 'work hard' to become financially stable. Many people battle with life in a number of ways. It's not always that easy.

I'm not sure where I said it was that easy in life for everyone. All I said was I agree with the OP that it's shit when you lose both parents at an early age and money doesn't make up for it, which it doesn't. It can't buy you your parents being there for your wedding day, meeting grandchildren for the first time etc. I then said my personal experience is I would rather have my loved ones back and not the money. I can understand why this isn't the case for everyone, based on their own life experiences and of course they're not wrong, it's subjective. I don't have any family to leave money to and little interest in changing my current modest lifestyle, so a charity will likely get a 'hand out' when I die. I stand by 'hand out' being a crass term to use in the context of someone dying. Sadly a lot of assumptions on this thread seem to be that anyone with more than a penny spare to their name has no altruistic capabilities.

fullbloom87 · 10/08/2023 00:11

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 22:42

How is it 'free' money if the parent has worked hard/made sacrifices to help to pass a legacy on to their child? Both DH and I are both from poor working class backgrounds, but were brought up with the attitude that you work hard and should be careful with money, as you never know what's around the corner. DH's father died unexpectedly when he was aged 30 and DH was just 4 years old. His mum raised 2 young children (under 5) as a single parent until they were 18, working full time. His Mum passed away unexpectedly when DH was just 40. My dad died when I was 25 and he was only 60. We have built up a business and invested carefully, without any financial input from anyone else, which has given up a comfortable standard of living and will allow us to retire at 50.

I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s.

It's the same for my husband and I. Both poor and completely self made. However I think your attitude is discriminatory towards disabled people and people with learning Difficulties.
Our youngest has cerebral palsy and learning disabilities, she has only us. If we were to die she would be in a dire situation without the money we've set aside for her.
Not everybody can just 'work hard' to become financially stable. Many people battle with life in a number of ways. It's not always that easy.

fullbloom87 · 10/08/2023 00:06

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 23:04

yeah the point is would you rather lose them in your 40s & have an inheritance or lose them
in your 40s & have zero inheritance. Presumably it's the latter...

It's hardly usual to lose both parents when you've just turned 40 , so that's a massively insensitive thing to say! Have you had both parents literally drop dead on you? We have no plans to spend the inheritance. Possibly down the line if we need care in old age it will go towards that I suppose. Otherwise it will be invested and pass down to our nephew, charity or friends children when we pass away as we don't have children. Not everyone wants to live a lifestyle full of buying stuff and going on holidays. @Mukey hit it on the head.

@JonahAndTheSnail

Well you're lucky that you don't HAVE to spend the inheritance. Many MANY people WOULD have to spend it on normal basic things like a roof and food. Good job for you that you already have what you need and can set it aside and forget about it.
Plenty of people I know lost their parents in their 20's and 30's and didn't get a penny because they were poor growing up and poor now in adulthood.
I'm sure if they had inheritance it would have taken the sting out of going back to their little rented tower block flat and meant they could take a bit of time off their 12 hour shifts to GRIEVE.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/08/2023 23:58

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 23:49

It’s interesting that none of the people talking about how their inheritance makes fuck all difference have responded to this saying that they would prefer to be bereaved and penniless as opposed to bereaved with a big wad of cash.

It’s almost as though they know they’re better off with the money, but they don’t want to say it out loud…

It's pretty self evident that one of those options is preferable to the other, and I'm sure that most people do get that.

Maybe people don't feel able to acknowledge it because they feel that it somehow suggests that their loss is somehow compensated for by the money? That isn't what anyone is actually saying, of course, but I can see why people might twist it that way in their heads. Perhaps it would almost feel disloyal to their loved ones to acknowedge that they have benefitted from the money because that seems to minimise their sense of loss? Even though the loved one would presumably have wanted them to benefit?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/08/2023 23:50

dramoy · 09/08/2023 23:42

Tbh @JonahAndTheSnail found my post incredibly insensitive so in terms of every other person in real life commenting & making her feel bad the issue may be one of comprehension.

Maybe, but it's a very sensitive subject that will inevitably bring up all sorts of complicated emotions for people, so it's hardly surprising if people take stuff the wrong way sometimes.

The fact is, it's shit to lose your parents whatever age you are and how much money they did or didn't leave you.

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 23:49

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 20:40

People need to realise that money can't buy you everything. What good is money when you have no one?

No-one plus money

or

No-one and no money

Pick one

It’s interesting that none of the people talking about how their inheritance makes fuck all difference have responded to this saying that they would prefer to be bereaved and penniless as opposed to bereaved with a big wad of cash.

It’s almost as though they know they’re better off with the money, but they don’t want to say it out loud…

dramoy · 09/08/2023 23:42

Tbh @JonahAndTheSnail found my post incredibly insensitive so in terms of every other person in real life commenting & making her feel bad the issue may be one of comprehension.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/08/2023 23:37

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 23:23

Of course you would have chosen not to have an inheritance at all because you would prefer to have had your parents around, and I'm genuinely sorry that you haven't got that. But you're still missing the point that some people don't have either. It isn't insensitive for people to point that out.

But would you actually point that out to a friend who just lost someone close to them? It's a massively insensitive thing to do without any prior mention or 'brag' from that person about an inheritance. Neither DH or I mentioned anything about an inheritance to people around us when our parents passed, but every other person seems to comment about 'think what you can do with the money', or 'did they leave you much in the will'? Even people who don't know us that well.

No I wouldn't point it out to someone who had just lost someone close to them. I think it's pretty crass to talk about money at a time like that, personally, but perhaps people are just clumsily trying to pay your parents a compliment by acknowledging what an amazing gift they have managed to pass on to you, or trying to make you feel better by finding something vaguely positive to focus on. Some people are a bit lacking in emotional intelligence and struggle to know what to say at times like that, but I don't imagine for a moment that they are suggesting in any way that you should be grateful for your loss simply because of the financial benefits.

Obviously, people should be careful about what they say to people who are grieving, but the OP's comments appear to relate more generally to any acknowledgement that people have benefitted from receiving an inheritance at any point. I think that's silly tbh. All other things being equal, people who inherit significant sums obviously do have advantages over people who lose loved ones but don't inherit. It is just common sense to acknowledge this, but it isn't meant in a disrespectful way to minimise the losses of those that do inherit. It's just a statement of fact that some people are unlucky enough to lose their parents at a young age and have no inheritance.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 23:33

But would you actually point that out to a friend who just lost someone close to them? It's a massively insensitive thing to do without any prior mention or 'brag' from that person about an inheritance

That's not what I did though.

You posted

"I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s."

which no one would disagree with but that's not the point. I then pointed out the actual point which was apparently a massively insensitive thing to say!

🤔

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 23:23

Of course you would have chosen not to have an inheritance at all because you would prefer to have had your parents around, and I'm genuinely sorry that you haven't got that. But you're still missing the point that some people don't have either. It isn't insensitive for people to point that out.

But would you actually point that out to a friend who just lost someone close to them? It's a massively insensitive thing to do without any prior mention or 'brag' from that person about an inheritance. Neither DH or I mentioned anything about an inheritance to people around us when our parents passed, but every other person seems to comment about 'think what you can do with the money', or 'did they leave you much in the will'? Even people who don't know us that well.

moggerhanger · 09/08/2023 23:22

I'm in the position of having lost my dad when I was 10, and now my mum is in a care home, dying from dementia by millimetres. So most of what I might have inherited is being spent on her care. Tens of thousands, it is, including the proceeds of the sale of mum's house. So i stand to get bog all. Call me all the names you like, but I can't help feeling slightly envious of SIL whose elderly mother died quickly from cancer, leaving SIL the house and all other assets. Oh well, that's life.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/08/2023 23:12

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 23:04

yeah the point is would you rather lose them in your 40s & have an inheritance or lose them
in your 40s & have zero inheritance. Presumably it's the latter...

It's hardly usual to lose both parents when you've just turned 40 , so that's a massively insensitive thing to say! Have you had both parents literally drop dead on you? We have no plans to spend the inheritance. Possibly down the line if we need care in old age it will go towards that I suppose. Otherwise it will be invested and pass down to our nephew, charity or friends children when we pass away as we don't have children. Not everyone wants to live a lifestyle full of buying stuff and going on holidays. @Mukey hit it on the head.

The point is, you will have choices about what to do with that inheritance. Some people don't have those choices.

Of course you would have chosen not to have an inheritance at all because you would prefer to have had your parents around, and I'm genuinely sorry that you haven't got that. But you're still missing the point that some people don't have either. It isn't insensitive for people to point that out.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 23:11

It's hardly usual to lose both parents when you've just turned 40 , so that's a massively insensitive thing to say!

No the question I asked wasn't insensitive, you just don't like it because it doesn't fit your narrative. My dad lost both his parents in his 30s.

Not everyone wants to live a lifestyle full of buying stuff and going on holidays.

the above is completely irrelevant

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 23:04

yeah the point is would you rather lose them in your 40s & have an inheritance or lose them
in your 40s & have zero inheritance. Presumably it's the latter...

It's hardly usual to lose both parents when you've just turned 40 , so that's a massively insensitive thing to say! Have you had both parents literally drop dead on you? We have no plans to spend the inheritance. Possibly down the line if we need care in old age it will go towards that I suppose. Otherwise it will be invested and pass down to our nephew, charity or friends children when we pass away as we don't have children. Not everyone wants to live a lifestyle full of buying stuff and going on holidays. @Mukey hit it on the head.

M4J4 · 09/08/2023 23:01

JonahAndTheSnail · 09/08/2023 22:42

How is it 'free' money if the parent has worked hard/made sacrifices to help to pass a legacy on to their child? Both DH and I are both from poor working class backgrounds, but were brought up with the attitude that you work hard and should be careful with money, as you never know what's around the corner. DH's father died unexpectedly when he was aged 30 and DH was just 4 years old. His mum raised 2 young children (under 5) as a single parent until they were 18, working full time. His Mum passed away unexpectedly when DH was just 40. My dad died when I was 25 and he was only 60. We have built up a business and invested carefully, without any financial input from anyone else, which has given up a comfortable standard of living and will allow us to retire at 50.

I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s.

No one is saying don’t work hard and leave inheritances.

Just please don’t make out your grief is more valuable or that your loss is greater.

Money does not bestow virtue, just virtue signalling.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/08/2023 23:00

I'd much rather have both sets of our parents alive until they're in their 90s and leave not leave us with a penny than for neither of us to have living parents when we're in our mid 40s.

Well, obviously, assume I'm very sorry for your losses, but that isn't really the point, is it? It isn't as if being poor somehow gives you a protective shield that enables you to live longer... quite the contrary, actually. People on lower incomes are significantly more likely to die at a younger age.

Consequently, the chances are that people from poorer families are actually more likely to lose their parents at a relatively young age and miss out on an inheritance, so to them, the people with the inheritance look pretty lucky.