Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
Zebedee55 · 10/08/2023 12:13

To be fair, some who do inherit do come from poor families.

My family came from very poor Eastend backgrounds - their "wealth" came from work, opportunities back in the day, and, yes, from house price increases.

So, it's a matter of luck, occupations, and house prices.

And, of course, whether they needed to pay for care, in later life.

Of course, I and my children, have benefitted from my inheritances, but having been unexpectedly widowed in April, I'm just not feeling the joy at the moment..🙄

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 10/08/2023 11:52

Can't agree with this tbh. People from poor families also lose loved ones and it's painful. And they don't get any inheritance. So inheritance is, of course, an unearned advantage and should be seen as such. No sense pussyfooting around it.

5128gap · 10/08/2023 11:44

LakeTiticaca · 10/08/2023 08:16

Acknowledge to who? The inheritance police?
It's nobody else's business!!

We are on a thread started by a beneficiary who wants to challenge the view of inheritance as free money/a handout. People are pointing out why inheritance is indeed free money, and in some cases getting a little frustrated with those who refuse to see it as such, and who argue (entirely irrelevently) that someone (who isn't them) has worked for the money; and that being gifted it on that person's death, doesn't make them more fortunate than those who don't recieve an inheritance.
The acknowledgement of the comparative good fortune of beneficiaries, and of the unearned nature of the money is sought within the context of the discussion.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 10/08/2023 10:01

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:43

Those who have not inherited may not be "lucky" in that aspect but they may be massively lucky and privileged in many, many other ways

I would argue those who inherit are far more likely to be lucky in other areas of their lives too though as socioeconomic factors impact health, wealth, education etc.

Exactly this! ^ In my experience - and from people that I've seen and know - people who don't get inheritances are the ones that come from economically poor families. Families who don't have wealth and don't have land, and don't have assets. Not even a house. Many people who don't inherit come from parents who rented their home.

The ones who inherit, are the ones who come from quite wealthy families with assets, properties, money... I mean, it's pretty bloody obvious, really, isn't it? Hmm

For the record, I lost both my parents by the age of 30 and I got fuck-all inheritance. My husband lost both of his by the age of 27 and he got fuck-all inheritance too. We also got absolutely no parental help raising our children, (as we had no parents!) and no financial support or buffer, like our peers did.

I saw many of our peers handed 10s of 1000s of £££ of help from their parents, and them dropping the kids off at their parents for weekends and full weeks while they had a trip away or night out to themselves. Several of them got massive lump sums for house deposits, and yep, big fuck-off inheritances. We had no financial support and no emotional or moral support, no parents by 30, and fuck-all inheritance from anyone EVER.

So don't anyone try and tell me that people who lost a loved one and had a big inheritance are not more fortunate than me. Of COURSE it's shit to lose your loved one, but to lose them and then get half a million quid, leaves a less bitter taste in your mouth than losing them and getting jack-shit.

I am hiding this thread now because it's making me angry and upset, that someone sitting with a sum of money in the bank in the mid 6-figures, and who has been left property, is trying to tell me they are 'no more fortunate than me......' Hmm

Some people on here have accused those of NOT receiving any inheritances or financial help - ever - of being bitter and angry. Are you actually fucking surprised? Hmm It's the unfairness of it all. People being handed tons of money that they never earned, and getting break after break, whilst other don't have a pot to piss in.

Anyway I'm OUT. As I said, the thread has pissed me right off. Hiding the thread now.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:53

@realitytransurfing I think you are struggling with your comprehension. Saying something is unfair, privilege, unearned doesn't equal bitter. Why would you think that?

Its interesting that its only wrong when they arent benefitting from it.

Myself & plenty of others have said we benefited from it but still recognise we are lucky/had that privilege?

realitytransurfing · 10/08/2023 09:47

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:40

I think the people bitter about others inheriting are being massive hypocrites personally. If they found out tomorrow, completely unexpectedly, that a distant aunt or whomever had left them 200k, are they saying they'd donate it all to charity then? seeing as its so morally unfair and against their strong ethical principles, surely thats the right thing to do.

Who is bitter though? My 6 fig inheritance helped me on the ladder, I can recognise that privilege that is the difference.

And it wasn't earned it came from huge house price inflation.

Literally all the people saying inheritance isnt fair, its wrong, its giving people un-earned privilege etc- those people. Its interesting that its only wrong when they arent benefitting from it. If they really think its wrong and morally abhorrent then they'd give it to charity/someone more deserving of it.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:43

Those who have not inherited may not be "lucky" in that aspect but they may be massively lucky and privileged in many, many other ways

I would argue those who inherit are far more likely to be lucky in other areas of their lives too though as socioeconomic factors impact health, wealth, education etc.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 10/08/2023 09:42

fullbloom87 · 09/08/2023 14:19

Most of us have lost someone we love and grieve in the exact same way as you have, but we don't all receive inheritance.
At least someone who inherits £500k after losing a loved one won't also have to go through that grief whilst trying to put food on the table.

I've gone through awful grief whilst being homeless with 3 children one with cerebral palsy and epilepsy. If I'd received £500k it would have helped my children for the rest of their lives.

Try going through grief AND poverty at the same time and come back to me...

You can inherit and still be in that position. Inheritance can often take months, even years to come through. You don’t get the money instantly someone dies. So though there may be some mental relief knowing that in the future you won’t have to worry so much, those early days of grief can still be while trying to make sure that you can feed and house your children.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:40

I think the people bitter about others inheriting are being massive hypocrites personally. If they found out tomorrow, completely unexpectedly, that a distant aunt or whomever had left them 200k, are they saying they'd donate it all to charity then? seeing as its so morally unfair and against their strong ethical principles, surely thats the right thing to do.

Who is bitter though? My 6 fig inheritance helped me on the ladder, I can recognise that privilege that is the difference.

And it wasn't earned it came from huge house price inflation.

AngeloMysterioso · 10/08/2023 09:39

LakeTiticaca · 10/08/2023 08:16

Acknowledge to who? The inheritance police?
It's nobody else's business!!

Well, the people on this thread for example. Several people are claiming they’re no better off at all even though they have in some cases 6 figure sums of money. It’s simply not true. All other things being equal, the person with a load of money is better off than the person without any.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:38

I agree but I am saying its not being acknowledged. Its all about money isnt it?

Yep, some people are definitely not acknowledging that inheritance is a privilege or this thread. I'm not sure why in a conversation about inheritance we should be talking about health privilege etc.

realitytransurfing · 10/08/2023 09:36

I think the people bitter about others inheriting are being massive hypocrites personally. If they found out tomorrow, completely unexpectedly, that a distant aunt or whomever had left them 200k, are they saying they'd donate it all to charity then? seeing as its so morally unfair and against their strong ethical principles, surely thats the right thing to do.

Bollocks they would.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 09:33

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2023 09:30

I inherited £350k when my mum died six years ago aged 93. She had dementia and her death was a release. That money meant I could take advantage of my employer’s early severance scheme and retire comfortably at 58. I have been very lucky I grant that. But I also feel like the money was a compensation from the universe after having been through the pain of infertility, DH having cancer (all ok now) and caring for my mum. You lose them twice with dementia - once when their mind goes and again when their body dies.

So sorry. Dementia is such a cruel disease. Watching my mum disappear incrementally broke my heart.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 10/08/2023 09:30

Threenow · 10/08/2023 08:18

Well no, obviously it isn't money the person inheriting earned, but someone earned it originally so it isn't a hand-out, nor is it unfair. Life isn't fair, some people do well, some don't, it's just life. Some people win huge sums of money, but strangely enough I never hear how unfair that is!

It probably wasn't earned originally by anyone, given what's happened to house prices in the UK over the last few decades. People are leaving substantial estates because they happened to buy a property at a particular time.

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2023 09:30

I inherited £350k when my mum died six years ago aged 93. She had dementia and her death was a release. That money meant I could take advantage of my employer’s early severance scheme and retire comfortably at 58. I have been very lucky I grant that. But I also feel like the money was a compensation from the universe after having been through the pain of infertility, DH having cancer (all ok now) and caring for my mum. You lose them twice with dementia - once when their mind goes and again when their body dies.

mangochops · 10/08/2023 09:22

Privilege' is all relative though isn't it? You could argue that everyone on this thread is in the top percentile of people on Earth as we're fortunate enough to have shelter, internet access in our homes, access to free education and healthcare etc. I recognise that I'm privileged to have been born in this country and the advantages it has afforded me. I know how shit it is to live hand to mouth and do my best to live modestly and donate to charities. The truth is there's always someone worse off than you and I don't understand the desire to weaponise the subject of inheritance. Some of the posts have a similar tone to the Daily Fail articles vilifying benefits claimants

This exactly.

mangochops · 10/08/2023 09:20

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:05

I agree but equally, I would argue you are lucky and privileged to have your parents with you to an old age (I did not). Money is not the only thing in life which involves "luck" or privilege is it?

No one has said money is the only privilege just that it is a privilege. And obviously there are degrees of privilege eg white privilege is a bit more of a thing than parents present at wedding day.

I agree but I am saying its not being acknowledged. Its all about money isnt it? This entire thread is minimising other privileges and luck (even people who have talked about other aspects) and focusing solely on calling those who inherit as "lucky", as if other factors in life dont make a person lucky either. Those who have not inherited may not be "lucky" in that aspect but they may be massively lucky and privileged in many, many other ways.

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 09:07

Of course you would swap the money to have your loved one back. I think the point people are trying to make is that inheritance is a hand out, it's not a piece of nothing and those that receive it are very lucky they just don't realise it because most have already had money and probably handouts in the past such house deposits, help with weddings and education etc. many people with inheritance don't know what it's like to be dirt poor and it's insulting for poor people to read things like 'I don't want the money' or 'I don't need the money'
Perhaps give it to someone that desperately needs it like a family who are working hard but have struggled all their lives.

And again, posters making assumptions without reading posts. First, I've already said twice, we plan to pass most of the inheritance onto friends, our nephew and charity. I've not had any inheritance from parents or financial help whilst they're alive with house deposit etc, DH is the same. I have friends and family in similar situations, so I don't think it's that unusual. I've spent most of my adult life living in bedsits in high crime areas, working multiple jobs and not eating at times to better my situation. Purposefully chose to settle in an area where house prices are low. I didn't inherit anything from my Dad when he passed away when I was in my 20s as it quite rightly went to my Mum. I hope it all gets spent on her living a long life. I do have sympathy for the people who are in difficult financial circumstances and have to pay for a loved one's funeral, that must be especially awful.

DH's Mum passed away very suddenly at a young age (had only just retired) a few months ago, so he should receive a modest inheritance (nowhere near half a mill)! Again, I would hardly describe her life as 'privileged' in that she was widowed young and had two sons under 5 to raise on her own. They spent most of their early lives living hand to mouth and relying on credit cards.

'Privilege' is all relative though isn't it? You could argue that everyone on this thread is in the top percentile of people on Earth as we're fortunate enough to have shelter, internet access in our homes, access to free education and healthcare etc. I recognise that I'm privileged to have been born in this country and the advantages it has afforded me. I know how shit it is to live hand to mouth and do my best to live modestly and donate to charities. The truth is there's always someone worse off than you and I don't understand the desire to weaponise the subject of inheritance. Some of the posts have a similar tone to the Daily Fail articles vilifying benefits claimants.

I don't see how it's not distasteful for people to make uninvited comments about what someone who has been recently bereaved will do with their inheritance/how fortunate they are which is what the original post was about. If you feel that way about your own personal situation, then of course that's fine for you to talk about it in that way. I wouldn't dream of telling DH how privileged he is to have just two surviving blood relatives in his early 40s. Maybe once the grief has settled he'll check his privilege. Similarly if a friend is telling me they can't pay their electric bill, I wouldn't tell them 'yes, but at least you are privileged enough to have experienced living in house with electricity'.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 09:05

I agree but equally, I would argue you are lucky and privileged to have your parents with you to an old age (I did not). Money is not the only thing in life which involves "luck" or privilege is it?

No one has said money is the only privilege just that it is a privilege. And obviously there are degrees of privilege eg white privilege is a bit more of a thing than parents present at wedding day.

Clefable · 10/08/2023 09:00

mangochops · 10/08/2023 08:44

I agree but equally, I would argue you are lucky and privileged to have your parents with you to an old age (I did not). Money is not the only thing in life which involves "luck" or privilege is it? People are acting as if luck/privilege only applies to money and it absolutely does not. If you grew up in a loving home you are lucky, and privileged, if you had access to a decent education you are lucky and privileged, if your parents got to be there with on your wedding day you are lucky, if you did not experience a life limiting illness you are lucky, if you havent had to care for parents through illness or disability you are lucky. Yes, those who inherit after losing parent young are luckier than those who also lost loved ones young and did not but this seems to be morphing into some kind of luck competition where money is the only thing being lauded as important. Its not.

This is a much better way of saying what I clumsily trying to say earlier. There's a lot of being 'unlucky/lucky' when it comes to your parents life and death that isn't just to do with money. I don't think I would say to someone who had recently lost their mum in their late 80s 'gosh you're lucky, I lost mine before she was 70!' because it's crass, but yes they are more fortunate than I am in that respect.

There's also the fact too that parents living longer or healthier parents sometimes involves financial gain that isn't inheritance, such as childcare for grandchildren instead of using paid childcare, which makes a huge difference financially at generally the toughest time of a young family's life.

It's impossible to get into top trumps because everyone's lives, circumstances, relationships are different. People who have been left money are more fortunate than those who haven't in that one small sphere, but that sphere joins dozens of others where those people may or may not also be lucky or unlucky.

ImpeckableChicken · 10/08/2023 08:48

I’ve lost both parents, I’m in my thirties and it breaks my heart to think I could have another 40 years on this earth without them here.

I have inherited a good amount which means I should be able to get on the property ladder, and I won’t have to work til I die (private renting). So I’m a bit more optimistic about the future. I’ve never relied on them for money in my adult life so I feel like the inheritance is their final way of looking after me.

But I’d still rather have them both here. I miss them terribly 😔

mangochops · 10/08/2023 08:44

fullbloom87 · 10/08/2023 02:03

Of course you would swap the money to have your loved one back. I think the point people are trying to make is that inheritance is a hand out, it's not a piece of nothing and those that receive it are very lucky they just don't realise it because most have already had money and probably handouts in the past such house deposits, help with weddings and education etc. many people with inheritance don't know what it's like to be dirt poor and it's insulting for poor people to read things like 'I don't want the money' or 'I don't need the money'
Perhaps give it to someone that desperately needs it like a family who are working hard but have struggled all their lives.

I agree but equally, I would argue you are lucky and privileged to have your parents with you to an old age (I did not). Money is not the only thing in life which involves "luck" or privilege is it? People are acting as if luck/privilege only applies to money and it absolutely does not. If you grew up in a loving home you are lucky, and privileged, if you had access to a decent education you are lucky and privileged, if your parents got to be there with on your wedding day you are lucky, if you did not experience a life limiting illness you are lucky, if you havent had to care for parents through illness or disability you are lucky. Yes, those who inherit after losing parent young are luckier than those who also lost loved ones young and did not but this seems to be morphing into some kind of luck competition where money is the only thing being lauded as important. Its not.

1967buglet · 10/08/2023 08:37

DinoRoar14 · 10/08/2023 01:52

People die. Everyone dies. Everyone's parents and loved ones will die.

Some will have some good come of that. Others just get left with the sadness of the death.

100% yes

Fairyliz · 10/08/2023 08:35

I’m an executor for an old lady who doesn’t have any children, so I know her will is split five ways between nieces and nephews.
A couple of the nieces are very good and visit her on a regular basis, but she hasn’t seen one of the nephews for about 15 years (he lives 10 miles away).
If she died now he would probably inherit about £100k; think that makes him lucky!

1967buglet · 10/08/2023 08:31

anothergrievingsister · 09/08/2023 18:25

A number of PPs are conflating what it means to inherit from parents who lived a long full life with what it means to inherit from someone you loved deeply who died prematurely. You are always luckier than someone in the same situation who did not inherit, but the two situations are very different. The second is much, much more difficult.

We have had both. DH’s dad died at 70, and he never met me/saw his son married as we married later. It was hard on DH. His mum is 90. When she passes, it will be hard on the both of us. My paternal grandfather though died at 53 of lung cancer. It was hard on my dad. My mum died at 80 of COVID, no funeral was possible. My dad died at 80 of colon cancer, and the last few months were horrific. All situations weren’t great. Inheriting from relatives has always been bittersweet, particularly when it has caused family rifts.

I’ve had two friends in the past year die young, one at 57 due to a brain tumour, and the other at 60 due to pancreatic cancer; we were writing a book together with with some other scholars. We ‘inherited’ a book to finish on his behalf, and he was with us till the end online.. his deterioration was shocking but his spirit was strong. I’m not sure measuring grief in degrees is possible. I just grieved in all cases.