Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
dramoy · 10/08/2023 16:14

I agree with you though that it becomes harder for wealth to accumulate - but I'd reiterate that getting angry at family asset situations like mine is totally counterproductive.

I completely understand why people do get annoyed though when people who get help from family "wealth" fail to recognise it as a privilege. 🤷🏻‍♀️

thecatsthecats · 10/08/2023 16:01

dramoy · 10/08/2023 15:52

My birth family has enough assets so that the next generation can each buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt, and pass those assets on so that the next generation can buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt. All whilst still needing to work, getting a good education, and generally contributing to society. I don't think that that should be seen as problematic generational wealth, and I don't think that that is the cause of families who can't do that. Taking my family's (already taxed) assets doesn't remove any state dependents. We don't possess an unreasonable amount of wealth. Every family should be able to do what we do.

Problem is that we don't exist in a vacuum. And things have been skewed by asset inflation & wage stagnation. I personally think taxes are too weighted against income & as a higher income family the frozen tax bands have a big impact, no benefits etc. It's much harder to build "wealth" these days & it's not a measure of how much you sacrificed or how hard you worked.

Yes, it's certainly an advantage that my family's assets were accrued pre-21st century.

And I'm not sure if it was clear, but I also mean mortgaged properties here - the sort of generational wealth cycle that means the next generation can all put down a 20% deposit, pay their mortgage etc. And I'm conscious of the fact that a 20% deposit will not be the same figure down the line.

I agree with you though that it becomes harder for wealth to accumulate - but I'd reiterate that getting angry at family asset situations like mine is totally counterproductive.

People with nothing being told by people with everything that people with something are the ones who should share... Well fuck that.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 15:52

My birth family has enough assets so that the next generation can each buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt, and pass those assets on so that the next generation can buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt. All whilst still needing to work, getting a good education, and generally contributing to society. I don't think that that should be seen as problematic generational wealth, and I don't think that that is the cause of families who can't do that. Taking my family's (already taxed) assets doesn't remove any state dependents. We don't possess an unreasonable amount of wealth. Every family should be able to do what we do.

Problem is that we don't exist in a vacuum. And things have been skewed by asset inflation & wage stagnation. I personally think taxes are too weighted against income & as a higher income family the frozen tax bands have a big impact, no benefits etc. It's much harder to build "wealth" these days & it's not a measure of how much you sacrificed or how hard you worked.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 15:48

The people whose first thought is to spend inherited money, demonstrate why they don't have their own money.

This is nonsense

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 10/08/2023 15:47

The people whose first thought is to spend inherited money, demonstrate why they don't have their own money.

That's not necessarily true though, is it? There are lots of people who don't have 'their own money' for all kinds of reasons. Spending an inheritance unwisely doesn't change the reasons for that person's start in life.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 15:45

A close family member died when I was 22, which was extremely hard at the time, but it enabled me to get a deposit on a house (a run down house which needed tons of renovation, which I paid for bit by bit through working). I inherited some more when a further close relative died and used that to buy another equally run down house which I again renovated through working, and that house has been rented out to a family since 2015. I had one friend make a snide comment about my "property empire" - implying like everything was handed to me on a plate. Yes I inherited the initial deposits, but dealing with the renovations and planning etc has been hard graft, and I put my own savings and capital into it. I took risks that house prices would rise and it would be worth it. I have been a good landlord and provided a stable home, without rent increase, to a family for 7 years.

Isn't the point you wouldn't have had 2 properties without the inheritance no matter how you hard you crafted? The way house prices have gone there's no way I could buy in my part of London now, if I had to save for a deposit I would be priced out.

HorseyMel · 10/08/2023 15:41

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 15:38

I get that you think this is selfless but you are ultimatly benefitting from the property by living their mortgage free, leaving you disposable income to spend on holidays and cars, so it's not quite the noble gesture you are presenting it as.

Yes, I'll benefit then pass the capital on. I didn't say or imply otherwise. If you're looking to manufacture an argument out of nothing, I'm not going to rise to it.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 15:40

Snowpaw · 10/08/2023 15:35

A close family member died when I was 22, which was extremely hard at the time, but it enabled me to get a deposit on a house (a run down house which needed tons of renovation, which I paid for bit by bit through working). I inherited some more when a further close relative died and used that to buy another equally run down house which I again renovated through working, and that house has been rented out to a family since 2015. I had one friend make a snide comment about my "property empire" - implying like everything was handed to me on a plate. Yes I inherited the initial deposits, but dealing with the renovations and planning etc has been hard graft, and I put my own savings and capital into it. I took risks that house prices would rise and it would be worth it. I have been a good landlord and provided a stable home, without rent increase, to a family for 7 years.

I recognise that I was in a privileged position to be able to do the above but I also had the work ethic to make something of the money so that it will last for generations to come. I see the inheritance as precious capital which I can't touch - like I am only the custodian of the dead relatives' hard earned money (the only thing I have left of them) and I can only spend the income it makes.

I see the inheritance as precious capital which I can't touch - like I am only the custodian of the dead relatives' hard earned money (the only thing I have left of them) and I can only spend the income it makes.

And same for you. This isn't noblesse oblige, it's monetary sense.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 15:38

*there

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 15:38

HorseyMel · 10/08/2023 15:29

I agree. I would class a house purchase as "investing" rather than "spending".

I consider spending to be when you have no asset to show for what you spent.

Personally, I will invest any inheritance and pass it on when I go. It isn't mine to spend - but I am ok with investing it then passing it on. I can buy my own holidays, cars etc - and would feel bad spending inherited money on that stuff, especially as my parents live fairly modestly. But that's just me.

I get that you think this is selfless but you are ultimatly benefitting from the property by living their mortgage free, leaving you disposable income to spend on holidays and cars, so it's not quite the noble gesture you are presenting it as.

Snowpaw · 10/08/2023 15:35

A close family member died when I was 22, which was extremely hard at the time, but it enabled me to get a deposit on a house (a run down house which needed tons of renovation, which I paid for bit by bit through working). I inherited some more when a further close relative died and used that to buy another equally run down house which I again renovated through working, and that house has been rented out to a family since 2015. I had one friend make a snide comment about my "property empire" - implying like everything was handed to me on a plate. Yes I inherited the initial deposits, but dealing with the renovations and planning etc has been hard graft, and I put my own savings and capital into it. I took risks that house prices would rise and it would be worth it. I have been a good landlord and provided a stable home, without rent increase, to a family for 7 years.

I recognise that I was in a privileged position to be able to do the above but I also had the work ethic to make something of the money so that it will last for generations to come. I see the inheritance as precious capital which I can't touch - like I am only the custodian of the dead relatives' hard earned money (the only thing I have left of them) and I can only spend the income it makes.

HorseyMel · 10/08/2023 15:29

HiHoHiHoltsOffToWorkWeGo · 10/08/2023 15:25

It depends on how they spend it; if they use it to buy a house for instance, that's a pretty sensible decision. It's rather different to pissing it up a wall in Dubai.

I agree. I would class a house purchase as "investing" rather than "spending".

I consider spending to be when you have no asset to show for what you spent.

Personally, I will invest any inheritance and pass it on when I go. It isn't mine to spend - but I am ok with investing it then passing it on. I can buy my own holidays, cars etc - and would feel bad spending inherited money on that stuff, especially as my parents live fairly modestly. But that's just me.

HiHoHiHoltsOffToWorkWeGo · 10/08/2023 15:25

HorseyMel · 10/08/2023 15:22

The people whose first thought is to spend inherited money, demonstrate why they don't have their own money.

It depends on how they spend it; if they use it to buy a house for instance, that's a pretty sensible decision. It's rather different to pissing it up a wall in Dubai.

HorseyMel · 10/08/2023 15:22

The people whose first thought is to spend inherited money, demonstrate why they don't have their own money.

Zebedee55 · 10/08/2023 15:14

Akiddleetivy2woodenchu · 10/08/2023 12:51

For those who asked about people wanting to spend my inheritance for me:

”John could do with a new van - you can let him have £30,000, can’t you?”

”Janet would really benefit from going to boarding school for secondary rather than the local comp - you’d like to see her do well, wouldn’t you?” (Janet is DBIL’s child from a one night stand, and while both of her parents are inadequate in their own way, this would be a marvellous solution to her interfering with their social lives. I also overheard Janet’s mother telling DMIL exactly what she and Janet thought of me and my family, so that would be a hard no.)

”Sarah’s not going to get a holiday this year - you could pay for her and the kids to go all inclusive to Lanzarote for a couple of weeks, couldn’t you?”

Someone else wanted a new car…

Yes, you can usually rely on some of the relatives behaving like bees around a honey pot, if they think money's involved.🙄

Fuckingfuming1 · 10/08/2023 15:06

DontYouThreatenMeWithADeadFish · 10/08/2023 14:02

I know a few people who have inherited either life changing sums or had significant financial assistance early in life. I don't have issues with the money received, more the compete failure on their part to recognise the privileged position they find themselves in and the way they act as if it was down to their hard work.

It was all down to hard work, just not their’s.

DontYouThreatenMeWithADeadFish · 10/08/2023 14:02

I know a few people who have inherited either life changing sums or had significant financial assistance early in life. I don't have issues with the money received, more the compete failure on their part to recognise the privileged position they find themselves in and the way they act as if it was down to their hard work.

Akiddleetivy2woodenchu · 10/08/2023 13:54

@M4J4 I just laughed. They have no idea how much I have been left (although they know a small house forms part of the estate), so really just being chancers. Re the van, I said “Oh I am sure he can get a bank loan.”

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 13:15

*thecatsthecats · Yesterday 14:47

What I think is skewiff is where people with no assets/low income are driven to hate those with some assets/decent income, whilst being led and exploited by those with enormous assets/insane income.

My birth family has enough assets so that the next generation can each buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt, and pass those assets on so that the next generation can buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt. All whilst still needing to work, getting a good education, and generally contributing to society. I don't think that that should be seen as problematic generational wealth, and I don't think that that is the cause of families who can't do that. Taking my family's (already taxed) assets doesn't remove any state dependents. We don't possess an unreasonable amount of wealth. Every family should be able to do what we do.

But big corporations, untaxed billionaires, slum housing providers, mass asset owners - they consume an unholy share of resources that they simply do not need.

And it's awfully convenient to point fingers at those who have enough, and get mad, leaving the polluting exploitative bastards who're really pulling the strings untouched.*

100%. Divide and conqueror the masses, so noone wins apart from those at the very top.

Azaeleasinbloom · 10/08/2023 13:00

thecatsthecats · 09/08/2023 14:47

What I think is skewiff is where people with no assets/low income are driven to hate those with some assets/decent income, whilst being led and exploited by those with enormous assets/insane income.

My birth family has enough assets so that the next generation can each buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt, and pass those assets on so that the next generation can buy a house, live comfortably and healthily without debt. All whilst still needing to work, getting a good education, and generally contributing to society. I don't think that that should be seen as problematic generational wealth, and I don't think that that is the cause of families who can't do that. Taking my family's (already taxed) assets doesn't remove any state dependents. We don't possess an unreasonable amount of wealth. Every family should be able to do what we do.

But big corporations, untaxed billionaires, slum housing providers, mass asset owners - they consume an unholy share of resources that they simply do not need.

And it's awfully convenient to point fingers at those who have enough, and get mad, leaving the polluting exploitative bastards who're really pulling the strings untouched.

This.

We get side tracked, some may feel deliberately🤔, by politicians picking at debates about inheritance taxes, which often affect those not wealthy enough to avoid them, when in reality they are ignoring the large elephants in the room.

gogomoto · 10/08/2023 12:57

Well said! I have young adult DD's and hope to be around for many years to come Grin but if something was to happen to me they would inherit around £300k each, but they wouldn't have a mum of course - I know they want me more.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 12:54

@Akiddleetivy2woodenchu I hope the answer to all of them was no?! What was their reaction?

Akiddleetivy2woodenchu · 10/08/2023 12:51

For those who asked about people wanting to spend my inheritance for me:

”John could do with a new van - you can let him have £30,000, can’t you?”

”Janet would really benefit from going to boarding school for secondary rather than the local comp - you’d like to see her do well, wouldn’t you?” (Janet is DBIL’s child from a one night stand, and while both of her parents are inadequate in their own way, this would be a marvellous solution to her interfering with their social lives. I also overheard Janet’s mother telling DMIL exactly what she and Janet thought of me and my family, so that would be a hard no.)

”Sarah’s not going to get a holiday this year - you could pay for her and the kids to go all inclusive to Lanzarote for a couple of weeks, couldn’t you?”

Someone else wanted a new car…

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 10/08/2023 12:34

I lost my Mum about 5 years ago. The inheritance has enabled me to buy a new house mortgage free, keep the old one and rent it out. I've not had to worry about mortgage rate rises, cost of living increases, and have two assets to my name for the future.

All of those thing objectively make me lucky in the current climate.

However, I also miss my Mum on a daily basis, so I am unlucky.

Neither statement is false, they're just looking at my situation in different ways.

It can come across as heartless when someone comments on an inheritance, but they generally don't mean it to. People naturally try to put a positive spin on things, to try and cheer people up. Sometimes it's I'll thought out, or they don't realise that having one thing precludes the other.

Do I want mum back, yes. Do I want to be struggling for money, no. The human brain can conceptualise a world where neither bad option happens. Unfortunately reality isn't so clever.

ssd · 10/08/2023 12:19

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2023 09:30

I inherited £350k when my mum died six years ago aged 93. She had dementia and her death was a release. That money meant I could take advantage of my employer’s early severance scheme and retire comfortably at 58. I have been very lucky I grant that. But I also feel like the money was a compensation from the universe after having been through the pain of infertility, DH having cancer (all ok now) and caring for my mum. You lose them twice with dementia - once when their mind goes and again when their body dies.

Im still waiting for my compensation from the universe then.

Swipe left for the next trending thread