Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 19:25

*No one has said that but the fact remains wealth from housing is a huge factor when talking about inheritance & it's been one of the easier ways of building wealth in recent years due to the economic factors here.

"What are you hoping to achieve by attempting to" pretend it doesn't matter?*

That it's pretty pointless to keep saying 'privilege' for no apparent reason. There's no universally accepted scale of privilege you can use to rate an individual's life experiences and choices and I'm sure that's not a society most people would want to live in. If you feel your inheritance is a privilege and it makes you feel good saying that then crack on. Honestly, if you tell someone with no money how privileged you are that inherited a property purely based on your parent's luck, what do you expect their reaction to be? That's nice of you to acknowledge your privilege? Then what do you do, just get on with your day? Are you proposing a privilege tax to redistribute wealth or something?

It's the same principle as when the tabloid press whips the general public into a frenzy about benefits claimants. The issue isn't what the plebs are inheriting or not, but the 1% at the top who have so much wealth that they can't spend it in their lifetime and we can't even comprehend it.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 10/08/2023 19:20

YABU - inheritance is controversial as it perpetuates privilege

My grandad's mum was widowed when he was a tiny baby - in the 1900s there was no benefit state and they lived hand to mouth for years. After the war he moved into a prefab house with his young family and he and my grandma worked 3 jobs to build a better life for my mum and her siblings. They all learned a lot about work ethic and have bought their own homes, a legacy (care fees excepted) for me and my cousins. There is no privilege here, just damned hard work.

anon666 · 10/08/2023 19:12

YABU - inheritance is controversial as it perpetuates privilege and puts you ahead of the queue in life.

If you are lucky enough to benefit from this you can't be surprised to get a bit of envy in return.

In my opinion the level of inheritance following the recent decades of housing market hyperinflation is disruptive in a meritocracy. It's also an unhelpful way to distribute resources in a society.

Confusedmummytotwo · 10/08/2023 18:53

The saddest thing about inheritance is the siblings that take it as their god given right.

I’m 30, lost both my parents in the last two years and my siblings are appalling and were to our parents and now they are creating all manner of mess and hurt as they aren’t happy with the inheritance they were left and wanting more.

Inheritance brings out the worst in people; Greed and jealousy.

The ones that are inheriting always want more and the ones that aren’t are always jealous about the other and quite often Greed comes out in them too.

Beentheredonethat123 · 10/08/2023 18:36

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 14:29

Sorry, I should have probably phrases this better, I was referring more people who lost their loved one earlier than expected and not through old age.

So someone in their 20s being orphaned but "it's okay as they have money now".

And I understand the "loss with inheritance VS loss without inheritance" being different. I was referring more to "loss with inheritance VS no loss and no inheritance" argument.

I get it OP.
To lose a parent early in life when they are still young, isn't the same as the posters bleating 'Oh everyone loses their parents eventually '.
Losing a parent at/before you're 30 is far, far harder than losing a parent when you're older yourself and theirs was an age related death.

Fuckingfuming1 · 10/08/2023 18:28

landbeforegrime · 10/08/2023 18:19

It's interesting that people see it as fortunate and lucky when you inherit money. Is it so unusual that this is not the norm - why isn't it the perception that those who don't inherit are unfortunate or unlucky, rather than it being a priviledge etc. if you do inherit. I'm from the UK and my grandparents grew up very poor and working class, so this isn't a cultural thing. Just I was brought up to think it's kind of expected each generation will work and save to leave something for the next.

My poor, Nanna and grandad had absolutely nothing really their whole lives. They left their 6 children, £300 each, which is probably the equivalent of two grand now, which my mother promptly spent on a new sofa. But she doesn’t plan to leave anybody a penny. Hasn’t felt any financial obligation to any of her children since they were 16 years old.

I’d love to know what was happening with my auntie’s wills but obviously people don’t share that

PinkCherryBlossoms · 10/08/2023 18:27

dramoy · 10/08/2023 17:50

However, the idea that wealth can only be generated through inheritance/property price inflation is simply untrue and not a useful one in encouraging social mobility.

No one has said that but the fact remains wealth from housing is a huge factor when talking about inheritance & it's been one of the easier ways of building wealth in recent years due to the economic factors here.

"What are you hoping to achieve by attempting to" pretend it doesn't matter?

Yes, nobody thinks it's the only way. The reason property price inflation keeps being brought up is because multiple posters have wrongly claimed that inheritance must be earned wealth that will have been taxed, which obviously is complete bollocks.

exaltedwombat · 10/08/2023 18:21

Come on, you know the answer to this. It's just casual jealousy. Walk on.

landbeforegrime · 10/08/2023 18:19

It's interesting that people see it as fortunate and lucky when you inherit money. Is it so unusual that this is not the norm - why isn't it the perception that those who don't inherit are unfortunate or unlucky, rather than it being a priviledge etc. if you do inherit. I'm from the UK and my grandparents grew up very poor and working class, so this isn't a cultural thing. Just I was brought up to think it's kind of expected each generation will work and save to leave something for the next.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 17:50

However, the idea that wealth can only be generated through inheritance/property price inflation is simply untrue and not a useful one in encouraging social mobility.

No one has said that but the fact remains wealth from housing is a huge factor when talking about inheritance & it's been one of the easier ways of building wealth in recent years due to the economic factors here.

"What are you hoping to achieve by attempting to" pretend it doesn't matter?

dramoy · 10/08/2023 17:44

Is it?

yes statistically it is but if you have data suggested it's got easier that would be great to read?

So you don't need to have mega bucks handed to you on an 'inheritance' plate to succeed in life.

No one has said that, again the comprehension!!!! It's far easier to accrue wealth if you have it, that doesn't mean it's impossible...

You can think others haven't 'earned' their money because you didn't, but it's ridiculous to claim it's only possible to accrue wealth through inflated property prices!

I haven't said this at all. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Dramatic · 10/08/2023 17:41

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 14:30

The anecdote about my friend's dad (although he lost his parents when they were elderly) was more to pinpoint that even a life-changing amount of money hasn't made him feel lucky or privileged in any way.

But he is privalaged, whether he likes it or not.

Zanatdy · 10/08/2023 17:36

We all lose parents but don’t all inherit - so some go through the loss with no money coming their way which will make life easier. It’s a privilege and big leg up no matter how devastated the person is.

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 17:32

No, but you surely wouldn't claim that everybody who works really hard becomes successful or wealthy? There is an element of luck, plus some people have aspects of their start in life which will disadvantage them a lot more than just having gone to a bog-standard comprehensive school.

Becoming successful boils down to being able to spot opportunities, otherwise known as creating your own luck in life, it doesn't happen blindly. And yes, in some cases, people will inherit a family business. However, the idea that wealth can only be generated through inheritance/property price inflation is simply untrue and not a useful one in encouraging social mobility. Yes, there will always be someone better and someone worse off than you in life. Someone who got a better education than you, had a more supportive family, etc. How do you even begin to evaluate who ranks higher than someone else on the scale when everyone's goals and values in life are different? Why would you want to? What are you hoping to achieve by attempting to do so? If you're fortunate to live in the modern Western society, the fact is you are more fortunate than the majority of the world who live in poverty and have very little opportunity to do anything to improve their situation.

belleadele · 10/08/2023 17:15

I’ll be honest, both my parents had died by the time I was 40 and I inherited £0 (feels like I’m in the minority)and I’m definitely a bit envious of people in the same situation, who did inherit. On the other hand I’m super lucky in other ways so I’m not complaining.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 10/08/2023 17:06

So you don't need to have mega bucks handed to you on an 'inheritance' plate to succeed in life.

No, but you surely wouldn't claim that everybody who works really hard becomes successful or wealthy? There is an element of luck, plus some people have aspects of their start in life which will disadvantage them a lot more than just having gone to a bog-standard comprehensive school.

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:40

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:40

My uncle was born in Pakistan is an accountant and did well because of racism. PWC didn’t want to hire black accountants in Africa and so offered Indian and Pakistani men traineeships and moved them to Africa. This was in the 40s-70s

But he still had no inheritance

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:40

Fuckingfuming1 · 10/08/2023 16:31

My uncle is Pakistani and an accountant and he’s doing rather well.

My uncle was born in Pakistan is an accountant and did well because of racism. PWC didn’t want to hire black accountants in Africa and so offered Indian and Pakistani men traineeships and moved them to Africa. This was in the 40s-70s

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/08/2023 16:39

It's much harder to build "wealth" these days & it's not a measure of how much you sacrificed or how hard you worked. Is it? I'd argue it's much easier to become socially mobile nowadays, with having the privilege of the internet at home and at your finger tips. It brings so many more options to generate income and educate yourself. Far easier than when my Dad was starting out in life back in the 50s as a child, having to work as a farm hand to help put food on the table before and after school when money was scarce. DH and I wouldn't have been able to accrue wealth nearly as quickly as we have done if we had been born in the 1940s!

DH and I started out with £3000 to our names 13 years ago to set up a business (money that we'd saved from our paychecks) and now have close to a million in assets (not including our house) through investing wisely and working 51 weeks a year. Noone told us what to do or how to do it, we figured it out for ourselves. Both of us went to bog standard comprehensive schools in rural northern villages, which I doubt would be considered a 'privileged' education by many people on here. So you don't need to have mega bucks handed to you on an 'inheritance' plate to succeed in life. You can think others haven't 'earned' their money because you didn't, but it's ridiculous to claim it's only possible to accrue wealth through inflated property prices!

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 16:38

@Wenfy

My fil earned $2 a day for the whole family. Despite this all his kids, including my husband, are at least masters educated. They did this by working hard, by going without, without any assets because their grandfather’s only asset (a business) had been forcibly taken from him by the British government and handed off to a politician just before colonialism. There were times the entire family was living on the street.

That's disgusting. Fucking cunts. And you've got their descendants talking about what a privilege it is to pass the capital on to their children.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 10/08/2023 16:37

I received an inheritance after the very sudden and unexpected death of my mum.

Yes, I'd like her back but that's not going to happen.

I also would NOT want her to suffer a long, drawn-out and ultimately painful and humiliating death due to the many lifeglimiting conditions she was suffering from, at great cost from her moderate estate.

As it happens, we didn't need to spend a penny on care as her death happened so suddenly (complications and sepsis) and we shared enough inheritance to manage our mortgages and put some by for the grandkids. Pennies from heaven.

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:35

Snowpaw · 10/08/2023 15:35

A close family member died when I was 22, which was extremely hard at the time, but it enabled me to get a deposit on a house (a run down house which needed tons of renovation, which I paid for bit by bit through working). I inherited some more when a further close relative died and used that to buy another equally run down house which I again renovated through working, and that house has been rented out to a family since 2015. I had one friend make a snide comment about my "property empire" - implying like everything was handed to me on a plate. Yes I inherited the initial deposits, but dealing with the renovations and planning etc has been hard graft, and I put my own savings and capital into it. I took risks that house prices would rise and it would be worth it. I have been a good landlord and provided a stable home, without rent increase, to a family for 7 years.

I recognise that I was in a privileged position to be able to do the above but I also had the work ethic to make something of the money so that it will last for generations to come. I see the inheritance as precious capital which I can't touch - like I am only the custodian of the dead relatives' hard earned money (the only thing I have left of them) and I can only spend the income it makes.

I think due to inheritance people have lost the meaning of ‘work ethic’. What you describe is privlege not work ethic. I’ll give you a couple of examples of what it means:

  1. I grew up in a free school meals house, abusive parents, managed to cut them out briefly to go to uni (while working part time) where I was averaging 95% per module and (in my final year) had guaranteed a prestigious civil service internship. Then my grandparents (who raised me) became sick, my parents wouldn’t take care of them, and at 21 I had to drop out to help them. By the time I wasn 22 I lost 2 beloved family members. I had to drop out of uni firstly to care for them, and then had to find a job to pay for their funerals - they were in the mortuary for nearly 2 months while I worked minimum wage jobs and paid rent and supported my siblings. I started working full time, nights, whatever I could to develop expertise in what was going to be my graduate area. A friend of mine told me to cold call a few investment banks to see someone might hire me as a PA. They did and within 3 years, after working 75 hours a week, I was in the field I had trained for but not graduated.
  2. My fil earned $2 a day for the whole family. Despite this all his kids, including my husband, are at least masters educated. They did this by working hard, by going without, without any assets because their grandfather’s only asset (a business) had been forcibly taken from him by the British government and handed off to a politician just before colonialism. There were times the entire family was living on the street.
Fuckingfuming1 · 10/08/2023 16:31

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:23

There is an element of white privilege to this. Rich white people have built their lives and their descendants’ lives through inheritances. Often by making sure that poor people and people of colour lose out. If we made everyone whose family tree goes back to the advent of colonialism (some like David Cameron’s ancestor actually had a direct hand in it) pay recompense you would see a massive turn about.

From my perspective every penny I own will go to DS but I don’t trust the government so I’m also investing in him so when the time comes he won’t need an inheritance.

My uncle is Pakistani and an accountant and he’s doing rather well.

thecatsthecats · 10/08/2023 16:28

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:23

There is an element of white privilege to this. Rich white people have built their lives and their descendants’ lives through inheritances. Often by making sure that poor people and people of colour lose out. If we made everyone whose family tree goes back to the advent of colonialism (some like David Cameron’s ancestor actually had a direct hand in it) pay recompense you would see a massive turn about.

From my perspective every penny I own will go to DS but I don’t trust the government so I’m also investing in him so when the time comes he won’t need an inheritance.

There's an element of white privilege, sure, and an element of other privileges too.

I'm not sure the analysis of how my English ancestors subjugated my Irish and Welsh ancestors would come out though... The bloodlines meet in me.

Wenfy · 10/08/2023 16:23

There is an element of white privilege to this. Rich white people have built their lives and their descendants’ lives through inheritances. Often by making sure that poor people and people of colour lose out. If we made everyone whose family tree goes back to the advent of colonialism (some like David Cameron’s ancestor actually had a direct hand in it) pay recompense you would see a massive turn about.

From my perspective every penny I own will go to DS but I don’t trust the government so I’m also investing in him so when the time comes he won’t need an inheritance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread