Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
Sally543 · 11/08/2023 11:11

A long time ago I inherited a small amount from an Aunty I hadn’t seen in years £5000. It was a lovely gift but also sad not cos the person died but cos I couldn’t help thinking if she thought to leave me money in her Will why didn’t she think/try and have a relationship while she was a live. In most cases inheritance is a gift ( not always I know)
if you or someone else gets this gift why can’t everyone be happy about it instead of being jealous .
A gift/ inheritance is lovely and can make life easier or be a nice memory but won’t make any lose easier there two difference things .

HeadNorth · 11/08/2023 10:39

ssd · 11/08/2023 08:46

Like this comment about people who didn't inherit are bitter. So im bitter am i? I wouldn't have swapped my parents with anyone here left a million quid. But dont tell me that million quid didn't make a difference.

This thread is descending into gloating and baiting others.

Well said

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/08/2023 09:54

@JonahAndTheSnai the post of mine you quote is about people who feel insulted when the existence of structural advantages are pointed out. The posts from last night will make it very clear that those people exist. That is literally what happened.

Additionally, what has happened to property prices in the UK over the last few decades is absolutely not an established trend and very much a new one. It goes way beyond the normal advantages of owning land that you mention, and certainly isn't like the 50s and 60s. We are not simply talking about 'good return'. That's an absolutely vital point here, and it simply isn't possible to discuss the issue with any accuracy when that point isn't acknowledged.

dramoy · 11/08/2023 09:49

Many people have said yes, being left an inheritance has helped them out in life and of course it's better to have an inheritance than not,

So you do agree! 👏🏻

The rest of your post seems to be saying socially mobility is a problem but not much you can do it about it or the fact it's not improving. Insightful!

5128gap · 11/08/2023 09:35

Thats a really interesting post @JonahAndTheSnai
However, I think that most people on the thread are looking for no more than an end to the denial that inheritance is both unearned (a hand out) and a privilege that puts one ahead through no effort of ones own.
While you're right, wealth inequality isn't going to end any time soon, and Joan's inheritance of a modest semi in Slough is small potatos in the scheme of things, the denial of the advantage thst brings her in the context of comparison with her peers, perpetuates the harmful myth that we're all equal really and wealth is there for the taking if we work hard enough.
Its unfortunate enough to be born into a situation of relative disadvantage, without people sitting on a cushion of inherited wealth pontificating about how hard they and their family worked for it; implying others did not, and are therefore less diligent and sensible. Plus apparently bitter and jealous to boot.

JonahAndTheSnai · 11/08/2023 09:08

*TBF there are younger people who are this stupid too. It isn't just boomers and the Silent Generation who think pointing out structural advantages is some kind of personal insult

It's so weird it's taken as some personal attack*

Seriously, I don't think anyone has tried to say structural advantages don't exist. I think many posters are confused why certain posters are splitting hairs over semantics and insisting on continuing to use terms with clear negative connotations like 'privilege', hand out', 'luck' and 'free money', which don't seem to offer any constructive purpose to this discussion. The bottom line is there's more than enough land in the UK to give everyone their own house on and plot of land. We all know that's never going to happen in out lifetimes and that Capitalism isn't going away any time soon; it's also outside the power of anyone on this thread to make that happen. The best anyone can do is look for opportunities to better their situation and stop perpetuating the myth that a electing a different Government is ever going to be the answer to solving poverty and inequality. Newsflash, the perfect socioeconomic system doesn't exist.

I'd argue that continuing the trend of using loaded terms to make people aware of just how 'privileged' they are is counterproductive in narrowing the wealth gap which I assume is something most people are in favour of? You've seen people get defensive because noone wants to give up their generational wealth which is the implication when you make statements about how fortunate it is that some people have benefitted from house price inflation whereas others haven't. I'm sure most people are intelligent enough to realise that. It's also completely unnecessary as a proposed solution because again, the most wealthy in the world could give up a small percent of their wealth, not miss it and the poorer in society would instantly have a more comfortable standard of living.

Many people have said yes, being left an inheritance has helped them out in life and of course it's better to have an inheritance than not, but it doesn't feel like a windfall or a payday when someone you love dies, so of course some people are going to get upset when you try to tell them that's how they should feel. When our landlord heard MIL had died he said 'well everyone has to die one day', whilst he was factually accurate, it's still a staggeringly crass, upsetting and rather pointless statement to make. He also proceeded to try to find out how much DH would stand to inherit, so he can know how much of a rent increase to ask for. It's precisely people with this level of wealth and lack of compassion for others in society who perpetuate the stereotype that owning a property or aspiring to generational wealth is morally questionable in someway.

People complain about the housing market and prices rocketing, but it's an established trend and certainly not a new one! Since the year dot it's been evident that owning land affords certain advantages over not owning land it's hardly a new concept. It may have surprised you that your house has risen in value so much in a short period of time, but back in the 50s and 60s, plenty of working class people were buying a house knowing full well that one day they'll make a good return on their money. Some of these are people who grew up in poverty and there was little 'privileged' about their upbringing. Unless we're going to go into how they benefitted from a free state education and healthcare. Which whilst factually accurate, everyone in the UK has had access to that in their lifetime, so it seems pretty pointless to point it out.

I intentionally studied house price histories for quite a while before buying, to spot a property which will give me a good return on my investment in a few years time. So I did 'work' on investing my money wisely. It may not have been particularly hard work, but you could argue that plenty of jobs pay very high salaries and don't require particularly hard work. It seems bizarre to keep choosing aspects of 'living in the world' to want people to check their privilege over. Given the choice, in an ideal world, I'm sure everyone would choose to be born into the life of the richest person in the world, it's pretty obvious and doesn't really need to be said.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 11/08/2023 08:48

It’s an insensitive thing to say, and of course you’d rather than your loved ones than the money. But many people lose their loved ones and get nothing in inheritance. I prefer to separate this out in my mind: ‘it’s terrible to lose the ones you love’ AND it’s lucky to inherit some money to ease the struggle’. They can be two separate issues and dealt with kind of separately, no?

ssd · 11/08/2023 08:46

Threenow · 10/08/2023 21:01

I do hope that those of you who are bitter that you didn't receive an inheritance but have managed to buy a house through working hard have set up your wills so that the proceeds go to charity on your death. We can't have your offspring inheriting anything they haven't worked for!

Like this comment about people who didn't inherit are bitter. So im bitter am i? I wouldn't have swapped my parents with anyone here left a million quid. But dont tell me that million quid didn't make a difference.

This thread is descending into gloating and baiting others.

ssd · 11/08/2023 08:43

Sweat to earn is such an insult to those of us who didn't inherit anything but had hard working parents. People here really need to choose their words carefully.

Discosnail55 · 11/08/2023 07:28

It IS lucky to start out in life with parents who do sweat to earn, and their parents maybe passed on inheritance too. Put simply, not everyone gets that. Some of us inherit generational wealth and some inherit generational trauma. You don’t choose who your parents are.

Messyhair321 · 11/08/2023 06:53

I understand what you mean however when I die I sincerely hope that my children & grandchildren will use & benefit from any money I leave them.

MadisonR · 10/08/2023 22:40

Sorry, I've not read the whole thread.

I know people who have inherited a lot of money but act like they worked hard their whole lives.
They don't want to admit they have done nothing for some reason. I just think everyone knows where your money came from stop lying.

willstarttomorrow · 10/08/2023 22:19

I think I get it OP. My daughter lost her dad aged 8, as it happened every pension and life insurance managed to wriggle out but we survived. It was sudden, it was catastrophic the impact it had on our lives and also the sudden ending of how our future looked. Everyone I know in this situation would want the life they had and the future they planned rather than a lump of cash. In these circumstances you are not lucky, you are compensated and it is not a massive windfall- it is the money that hopefully would continued to be earnt and support the family if that person was still alive.

The financial and emotional impact on children who loose a parent in childhood is huge. There is no safety net, if the other parent is working and earning an average wage then you are down to one income, no support. It is shite, even of your house is paid off, and loads of jealously around that, you are responsible for all maintenance on top of everything else and on one wage it is hard.

Any inheritance I may have is currently going down by £9000 a month in care home fees which is fine. DP is being well looked after, has dementia and has done for several years but is physically as strong as an OX. Their money and it should totally be used within their lifetime to meet their needs.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 21:55

TBF there are younger people who are this stupid too. It isn't just boomers and the Silent Generation who think pointing out structural advantages is some kind of personal insult

It's so weird it's taken as some personal attack

dramoy · 10/08/2023 21:53

But apparently the same increase in the next forty years is all those evil boomers fault .

speechless

MrsRachelDanvers · 10/08/2023 21:47

5128gap · 10/08/2023 21:32

Like many on here, you misunderstand.
No one is saying the person leaving the legacy is privileged. Its the beneficiaries who are privileged. How hard the deceased worked for their money is entirely irrelevant. You and your cousins did not work for the money. You are the privileged, not your grandparents who earned everything they had.

You’re right but it’s amazing how many people don’t understand this. I’ve heard so much about ‘work hard’-as if only well off people work hard. And the beneficiaries haven’t ‘worked hard’-they’ve just been lucky.

Noicant · 10/08/2023 21:45

GrannyRose15 · 10/08/2023 21:06

The inheritor might not have worked for the money but the chances are someone has worked for it, probably very hard.

Yes true but if we work hard for our money doesn’t mean DD lifted a finger to earn it. Now I want her to have everything because she’s my DD and I love her but of course she didn’t earn it through her own efforts. You can’t just appropriate someone elses work. If you inherit because someone you are related to worked hard it’s pretty crass to behave like you have anything to do with that.

MrsRachelDanvers · 10/08/2023 21:44

Of course it’s a handout. What else do you think it is? We don’t live forever and people who are fortunate enough to get an inheritance have it significantly better than those who don’t. Poor people feel grief and loss too.

TaraRhu · 10/08/2023 21:44

Dolores87 · 09/08/2023 14:08

Inheritance is a massive advantage in life though, significantly so if it is a large inheritance. Half a million is more money then many people will ever see.

That doesn't make the circumstances you get it any less sad but sad circumstances doesn't mean it isn't a financial privilege to be left a lot of money. Its easy to say you don't care about the money when you have the money.

The very sad fact is that all our parents will die one day. I am fairly sure if given the choice between our parents dying and us not having enough to cover the funeral and our parents dying and us inheriting half a million we would all pick the latter. Its a big help in life and generational wealth adds to big financial inequality. It is understandable people dont pretend its not a privilege just because of the sad circumstances.

This exactly ^

Of course inheritance can come with sadness it's still horribly unfair. I have a friend who inherited £1m from an uncle in South Africa thats she hardly knew. Its not all 'beloved' relatives. Having a hand out is inheritance is life changing for some people. It gives you the freedom to buy a home/sTart a business/not work. Many of us will never get that unless we work for it. What don't you understand about that?

PinkCherryBlossoms · 10/08/2023 21:42

Moneynewpence · 10/08/2023 21:38

Except fault is almost always implied. And sometimes stated outright. That rising housing prices are the responsibility of a particular generation.
Please don't pretend that doesn't happen. I didn't blame my parents for the tenfold increase in prices 1966 to 1980. But apparently the same increase in the next forty years is all those evil boomers fault .

Nah, it's not. You just jump to that conclusion because you find it inconvenient when people point out facts. The reality is that for some of you, there's no way in which you'll tolerate it being pointed out that much inheritance is unearned. Hence the burning martyr vibe.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 21:40

But apparently the same increase in the next forty years is all those evil boomers fault .

Where did anyone say that? Some of the posts on this thread are insane.

Moneynewpence · 10/08/2023 21:38

PinkCherryBlossoms · 10/08/2023 21:16

Talking about 'fault' is ludicrous.

There isn't a moral dimension to this. It's just a statement of fact. However hard they may or may not have worked to buy the property initially, people who have owned for a while are leaving estates comprised of much more than that money in real terms.

Except fault is almost always implied. And sometimes stated outright. That rising housing prices are the responsibility of a particular generation.
Please don't pretend that doesn't happen. I didn't blame my parents for the tenfold increase in prices 1966 to 1980. But apparently the same increase in the next forty years is all those evil boomers fault .

5128gap · 10/08/2023 21:32

Loverofoxbowlakes · 10/08/2023 19:20

YABU - inheritance is controversial as it perpetuates privilege

My grandad's mum was widowed when he was a tiny baby - in the 1900s there was no benefit state and they lived hand to mouth for years. After the war he moved into a prefab house with his young family and he and my grandma worked 3 jobs to build a better life for my mum and her siblings. They all learned a lot about work ethic and have bought their own homes, a legacy (care fees excepted) for me and my cousins. There is no privilege here, just damned hard work.

Like many on here, you misunderstand.
No one is saying the person leaving the legacy is privileged. Its the beneficiaries who are privileged. How hard the deceased worked for their money is entirely irrelevant. You and your cousins did not work for the money. You are the privileged, not your grandparents who earned everything they had.

dramoy · 10/08/2023 21:31

@PinkCherryBlossoms I genuinely don't understand. I wouldn't be able to buy now as my salary has not kept pace (has anyone's) & prices just keep going up. Why is there the need to pretend you have earned it & such moralistic language around it all?

PinkCherryBlossoms · 10/08/2023 21:29

TBF there are younger people who are this stupid too. It isn't just boomers and the Silent Generation who think pointing out structural advantages is some kind of personal insult, rather than simply recognition that a person purchased property at a particular time and then died at another particular time.