Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance treated as a 'hand out'

463 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 13:59

I constantly see posts and hear comments about people inheriting money and it being treated like a massive privilege and an exciting thing. Almost said in jealousy sometimes. For example some of the things I've heard are;
" Well at least you'll benefit from the money"
"X is so lucky to have a head start"
"X didn't work hard, it was all inherited"
" They want do they found buying a house easy with the inheritance money"

I find all the disparaging comments about people inheriting money having it easy really disrespectful. I certainly remembered feeling disgusted when I was younger (and I lost someone very close) that people acted though I've been given a massive hand out in life. I'm pretty sure most people would want their mum/dad/partner back and don't give 2 hoots about the money.

My friend's very working class Dad in his 60s has just inherited half a million from his parents estate which significantly changes his life. He doesn't care. Just wants his parents back

OP posts:
Happilyobtuse · 09/08/2023 18:05

@dramoy - Well no one said one is not lucky to receive an inheritance how much ever it is. And yes it is just dependent on the family you were born into etc. but that is pretty much like everything else in life, like access to education, good health care, or physical attributes like looks etc. I am very grateful for my inheritance but I also know that I would rather have my parent back in a heartbeat. And ppl who are jealous about this would be jealous about everything. Life isn’t fair or the same for everyone and trying to make it so is almost impossible!

daisychain01 · 09/08/2023 18:01

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:31

I think if you inherit you should keep it to yourself, the ‘if I could give it all back for just one day’ mawkish sentimentality is crass.

Be interesting to know if anyone does give it away?

I think there was a thread asking "is it possible to decline an inheritance"

whether it is possible or not, someone actually creating a thread about it, will I guarantee, already has a decent stash in the bank, or the inheritance is for £100 and they're virtue signallers just wanting to make the point on MN.

Hocuspocusnonsense · 09/08/2023 18:01

I can see your point but realistically inheriting money does make a difference and does make many things eg buying a house easier.

My friend inherited £120k from grandparents, she didn’t need to save for a House deposit.

Another friend was given £400k from her parents as an early inheritance so she didn’t need to get a mortgage!!

Both lump sums changed their lives.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 09/08/2023 17:57

YABU. The bereavement happens regardless. The money is a windfall. I find it a bit odd when people talk about inheritance being unfair just because you haven't earned it yourself. Providing for your children / family is surely a normal and reasonable thing to do, whether they get that benefit when you are still alive or not.

NotAMug · 09/08/2023 17:55

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 14:30

The anecdote about my friend's dad (although he lost his parents when they were elderly) was more to pinpoint that even a life-changing amount of money hasn't made him feel lucky or privileged in any way.

Sorry missed this, for some reason when I selected show all OP posts it didn't show anything

NotAMug · 09/08/2023 17:54

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 14:29

Sorry, I should have probably phrases this better, I was referring more people who lost their loved one earlier than expected and not through old age.

So someone in their 20s being orphaned but "it's okay as they have money now".

And I understand the "loss with inheritance VS loss without inheritance" being different. I was referring more to "loss with inheritance VS no loss and no inheritance" argument.

I am confused though, you mentioned someone in their 60s inheriting from their parents but would rather have their parents back. Presumably parents were in their 80s/90s so seems odd to use that as an example? Have I totally read your post wrong?

It is really sad when younger, DHs mum was in her 60s and she had just retired, and he totally would have taken her being around over inheritance. It was around £150k so not half a mil though.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:52

@Happilyobtuse but you can leave up to 1m before your descendants pay tax. That's plenty in my view. And the vast majority haven't worked hard for that, it's driven by inflated house prices.
So much moralising with the "work hard", "save money". Plenty do this & wont have much of estate to leave for a number of reasons.

fullbloom87 · 09/08/2023 17:51

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 14:29

Sorry, I should have probably phrases this better, I was referring more people who lost their loved one earlier than expected and not through old age.

So someone in their 20s being orphaned but "it's okay as they have money now".

And I understand the "loss with inheritance VS loss without inheritance" being different. I was referring more to "loss with inheritance VS no loss and no inheritance" argument.

It depends what your parents are like. In my case I would have rather lost my parents young and gained inheritance then endure the abuse and end up in poverty. It's probably hard for you to understand because you obviously had nice parents that you would prefer to keep over money.

Happilyobtuse · 09/08/2023 17:49

@dramoy - So if you work hard all your life and are careful with your money do you think you should get to leave it to your children or would you rather just give it back to the government?!

lousyatchoosingnames · 09/08/2023 17:49

KvotheTheBloodless · 09/08/2023 14:08

I don't think anyone is saying that you wanted x or y to die, only that inheritance isn't money you earned, and really it is a hand-out.

I stand to inherit a huge amount myself, I'm not jealous, just telling the truth. It's unearned and, objectively, unfair.

This

Dolores87 · 09/08/2023 17:49

Dolores87 · 09/08/2023 17:48

Tbh i find it hard to scoff at the money doesn't buy you happiness thing, it always feels like something that doesnt know poverty would say...BUT i do agree with you that yes it doesnt buy you happiness, but being given a huge amount of money, especially half a mil like in the original post is a big big leg up. No it doesn't buy happiness but it absolutely is a HUGE advantage. 500k would buy a house right out in many areas. It would open up private therapy, support with childcare, of travel. There are so so many advantages in life to having money.

  1. The thing is everyone's parents will die. Its sad but its going to happen to everyone. Were not talking about dead parents leaving money vs alive and supportive parents really we are talking about dead parents leaving in this case significant money and dead parents leaving someone with nothing.

I would argue that both parental support and money are advantages in life and one being preferable to someone doesn't negate the fact the other is also an advantage in life. Personally i dont have either. Its really insensitive to tell someone whose parents have just died that they were lucky to get money, but that doesn't change the fact then when the inevitable happened (because it happens to everyone), as incredibly sad that it is for most people, it is lucky that someone was given a lot of money vs not getting anything.

Excuse all the typos. Im tired and DD interrupted me twice 😂

M4J4 · 09/08/2023 17:48

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 17:46

My Dad never saw me get married or have children. My mum died when my 2nd baby was 8 weeks old and will never meet my third.

I inherited absolutely nothing. I’m still paying off funeral debt now, and my Mum died 18 months ago.

So, would you rather be in your situation, or mine?

Urgh indeed.

Flowers
Dolores87 · 09/08/2023 17:48

Appleofmyeye2023 · 09/08/2023 17:11

I think you could also argue that

  1. money doesn’t make people happy and some people frazzle away that “massive advantage” so it’s not an advantage.
  2. having your parents /siblings etc around you into mid life or later life is also an advantage. There’s the emotional support you can gain, but also the hands on practice support until they get too old to do that. I gain massively from both my DB, especially since divorcing, and would rather have their support alive in practice than money if they died. On the converse my mum died relatively young, when my kids were very small . I didn’t inherit anything as obviously went to my dad, but I have missed her badly. Have gone through some tough times where having her support would have benefitted my mental health massively.

money is not the only thing that buys “massive advantage “. We just find it difficult to quantify the rest

Tbh i find it hard to scoff at the money doesn't buy you happiness thing, it always feels like something that doesnt know poverty would say...BUT i do agree with you that yes it doesnt buy you happiness, but being given a huge amount of money, especially half a mil like in the original post is a big big leg up. No it doesn't buy happiness but it absolutely is a HUGE advantage. 500k would buy a house right out in many areas. It would open up private therapy, support with childcare, of travel. There are so so many advantages in life to having money.

  1. The thing is everyone's parents will die. Its sad but its going to happen to everyone. Were not talking about dead parents leaving money vs alive and supportive parents really we are talking about dead parents leaving in this case significant money and dead parents leaving someone with nothing.

I would argue that both parental support and money are advantages in life and one being preferable to someone doesn't negate the fact the other is also an advantage in life. Personally i dont have either. Its really insensitive to tell someone whose parents have just died that they were lucky to get money, but that doesn't change the fact then when the inevitable happened (because it happens to everyone), as incredibly sad that it is for most people, it is lucky that someone was given a lot of money vs not getting anything.

AngeloMysterioso · 09/08/2023 17:46

mangochops · 09/08/2023 15:45

Yup- same here. I've had people tell me I'm so "lucky" because I inherited after losing my mum young and then my dad not long afterwards. Yeah, so I'm so lucky I have no family left arent I? so lucky that my mum never got to see me get married or meet my children, I'm just so damn lucky.

Urgh. I agree with you OP- the way people talk about inheritances is really, really gross and insensitive.

My Dad never saw me get married or have children. My mum died when my 2nd baby was 8 weeks old and will never meet my third.

I inherited absolutely nothing. I’m still paying off funeral debt now, and my Mum died 18 months ago.

So, would you rather be in your situation, or mine?

Urgh indeed.

M4J4 · 09/08/2023 17:45

Bandyarsia · 09/08/2023 17:42

It's shit to lose someone and grieving sucks.

Grieving sucks if you have £300,00 in the bank and grieving sucks when you have £2.50 in the bank.

However LIFE whilst grieving is easier with £300,000 in the bank than living and grieving when you haven't a pot to piss in.

Fact.

Exactly. You can concentrate on grieving without worrying how you’ll pay the mortgage.

SouthernLassies · 09/08/2023 17:44

@LittleMissUnreasonable You are being a little bit unreasonable.

It's tragic for someone to lose their parents when they are young. So anyone saying you were lucky to have an inheritance then is just crass.

I can't see how there is any discussion about this at all.

In RL I've never known anyone say that. I've known people 'explain' their inheritances and how it's helped them, but that doesn't mean they are happy someone has died.

Older people , who gradually accept their parents will die, may or may not benefit financially.

Most of us who are older now, see any inheritance as a bonus, but not a given.

And yes, we'd rather our parents didn't die given the choice of an inheritance or having them around.

I'm sorry you seem to have known people who were crass and with no empathy, but that isn't the norm.

Bandyarsia · 09/08/2023 17:42

It's shit to lose someone and grieving sucks.

Grieving sucks if you have £300,00 in the bank and grieving sucks when you have £2.50 in the bank.

However LIFE whilst grieving is easier with £300,000 in the bank than living and grieving when you haven't a pot to piss in.

Fact.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:41

Now having said that, when ppl say, you didn’t earn it, well that isn’t exactly true is it?! If your parent earned it by working long hours, travelling on work etc. then you probably also sacrificed by not having your parent around as much. So yes you deserve it!

These posts are getting even better.

I've earned my inheritance because my parents had a job?! 😆

berksandbeyond · 09/08/2023 17:40

Literally no normal person would think that losing someone was absolutely fine as long as they got money, but you’re incredibly naive and privileged if you don’t realise it can make life a lot easier if there’s money involved after loss. Everyone loses people, a lot of people won’t get a penny and they’ll have to go back to work the next day because they can’t afford to eat otherwise. YABU

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:39

apt!

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:39

what an about username!

Happilyobtuse · 09/08/2023 17:38

I do not think inheritance tax should exist as the money has already been taxed and it is incredibly unfair for the government to keep taxing the same money and then using it to pay benefits to ppl who would rather not work when they are perfectly capable of doing so!

Now having said that, when ppl say, you didn’t earn it, well that isn’t exactly true is it?! If your parent earned it by working long hours, travelling on work etc. then you probably also sacrificed by not having your parent around as much. So yes you deserve it!

I completely agree having lost a parent very early in life that I would rather have my parent back than any inheritance. Though it does help, and everything is definitely easier with money.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:38

money doesn’t make people happy and some people frazzle away that “massive advantage” so it’s not an advantage.

This is brilliant! Inheritance is not an advantage because some people waste it

M4J4 · 09/08/2023 17:38

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:31

I think if you inherit you should keep it to yourself, the ‘if I could give it all back for just one day’ mawkish sentimentality is crass.

Be interesting to know if anyone does give it away?

It’s always a hypothetical ’if i could…’

dramoy · 09/08/2023 17:38

@WeAreBorg 😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread