Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Introverts are selfish

114 replies

Opti46 · 09/08/2023 09:58

Aibu to feel introverts are selfish? I am speaking as an introvert who doesn’t like to attend large gatherings, finds socialising difficult and exhausting etc.. but I can’t help feeling selfish as if I just stay in and keep myself to myself it means I don’t attend any family/work/social gatherings.

OP posts:
Itsnotrightbutitsok · 09/08/2023 10:46

Yes introverts are selfish, but what’s wrong with doing what’s best for yourself?

I do think people should make an effort to see the people they love etc but why put yourself in a position that takes a massive toll on your MH regularly just to please others.

HAF1119 · 09/08/2023 10:45

There is probably an element of selfishness to anyone doing what they enjoy most. Be that going out and being extroverted, or staying in/quiet. But then who would enjoy life if they didn't choose to do what they actually like? And why should anyone not enjoy life?

The only selfish person in a bad way would be someone who told someone to do things they don't enjoy just because they want them to. So if the introvert told their extrovert friend to not attend an event and stay at home with them and read books, if if the extrovert tried to convince the extrovert to go to a busy event because they want them there. In those instances their selfishness would be negative for others, but just doing what you enjoy most I think is healthy

Random789 · 09/08/2023 10:44

To be honest, your opening post and your thread title makes me a bit angry. I know you are kind of playing devil's advocate, and that it is yourself that you are criticising. But I don't think it is very helpful to project your own self-lacerations onto objective reality - i.e. to represent your subjective feelings of guilt as if they were evidence of an objective reality of selfishness.

Whether someone is introverted or extroverted their social behaviour can be selfish or unselfish or somewhere in between, depending on how well they monitor their behaviour, empathise with others' needs and adapt as far as is reasonable/possible to accommodate others in a compromise that suits everyone.

But introverts are more lilely to be experiencing significant mental pain throughout this process of monitoring, empathy and compromise. Which deserves a bit of compassion.

GrandHighPoohbah · 09/08/2023 10:43

I wouldn't say introverts are selfish, they are doing what they feel comfortable with. But on the flip side I find it annoying when they want to be included socially without doing any of the heavy lifting in terms of hosting or contributing to conversation.

studentgrant · 09/08/2023 10:43

I don't believe extroverts make introverts feel guilty. Introverts should own their feelings. And hold their head up about them.

Kazzyhoward · 09/08/2023 10:43

I'm a long term introvert because of hearing problems. It's been much later in life that I realised I had a problem with my hearing and got hearing aids, which help, but don't fully cure the problem.

When I was a teen, I thought it was normal not be to able to hear/understand the lyrics of a song, or not to be able to hear other people talking at a loud event such as a party or disco. My default become just to smile and nod when someone was trying to talk to me. It wasn't necessarily all about it being loud either, sometimes I couldn't cope when in a group of people all talking at pretty normal volume - couldn't "tune myself in" to anyone, so just sat there silent and disengaged when everyone else to chatting away. I also got bad headaches etc in loud places and would often have to excuse myself and leave early.

I was too young to understand at that time that it was all about my hearing problems. I got into the behaviour/habit of being pretty anti social. Even at work, I hated offices with several people in as I couldn't concentrate with the perpetual background noise. I was fine in a 1-2-1 situation with other staff or clients, but I'd struggle in even a small meeting with just 3 or 4 people. I just never realised it was because I could hear one other person clearly in a quiet place, could concentrate on what they were saying, and inter-act properly, which are things I couldn't do with more people.

I now know it was all down to the hearing loss and I'm starting to build up social confidence again, now that my hearing aids improve the problem. Still not good in loud situations, such as a big party or football match etc where there's lots of people talking around me and background noise, etc., but I'm getting better at relatively smaller/quieter groups where I can actually hear what they're saying most of the time and can participate.

Because I could hear people on a 1-2-1 basis, it never twigged to me that I had a hearing problem.

theyareonlynoodlesmichael · 09/08/2023 10:41

Gettinagoldtoof · 09/08/2023 10:35

Agree with this. But there is a real blur, isn’t there. Extroverts get their energy from being around people and introverts from being alone.

Yes. And not everything is clear cut because our brains are complex. I am an introvert but I do love a good party. Even extroverts sometimes want to spend some downtime alone. Its not constantly 'You are wither X or Y and there is no in between.'

JMSA · 09/08/2023 10:40

mrlistersgelfbride · 09/08/2023 10:11

No, I think extraverts are more selfish by talking too much and making people listen to them.

Right, because that's not a generalisation Confused

Cowlover89 · 09/08/2023 10:40

Nope

JMSA · 09/08/2023 10:39

I'm an introvert and love my own company. My ideal weekend is one where I have no social plans at all.

But yes, if you shy away from friends and family forever, that is selfish really. Relationships require nurture and shouldn't be taken for granted. So if there's an occasional family party, I might not be wild with excitement over it, but will push myself to go for my loved ones.

I know this sounds morbid, but I do wonder if I'll one day regret my lack of effort Sad

SamW98 · 09/08/2023 10:39

I’m naturally introverted but many people are surprised when I say that because I’m very social with I’m with the right people.
If I feel comfortable then I love socialising but equally I adore taking time out in my own space.

Friends who know me well will poke me outside of my comfort zone but won’t ever push me too hard.

Though possibly what goes against what sone people think makes an introvert, I genuinely don’t care what random people think of me. I do weigh people open before I open myself up but really if you don’t like me, I don’t care.

CandyLeBonBon · 09/08/2023 10:38

CoffeeCantata · 09/08/2023 10:27

I'll get flamed for saying this, but here goes.

I'm an introvert but people laugh when I tell them that, or that I'm very shy. I've always had to be a 'front of house person' in my work when really (if those Morison aptitude tests had been available in my schooldays) I'm by nature a back-room boffin. In those days the culture was very much "Just get on with it - like it or lump it!" and the idea that you were allowed to get out of things because you were shy wasn't acceptable.

So I suppose I faked it till I made it and find it ironic when people think I'm confident and even extrovert. Just occasionally I have to be open with people and tell them I can't do certain activities - but that's only come in recent years with the more accepting attitude and openness about these things. For example, my hobby often involves tours (choir) of several days' duration. Even though I'm on the committee and really am expected to go (I sense disapproval that I don't) I've had to explain that I just can't cope with being with a large crowd of people for 5 days without a lot of down-time. The organiser also asked me to share a room with a complete stranger and was stunned when I said no! The thought of being with 70 not-very-close people for 5 days and not having at least a single room to retreat to would have driven me crazy.

If it was for work (and I have had to do this kind of thing for work) then I'd suck it up and go, but not for a hobby. My work excursions cost me dearly in terms of stress and took a good week or so to get over. Extroverts maybe wouldn't understand this.

This sounds exactly like me. I've learned to do events and people etc but I need lots of down time in between.

Incidentally I think it's odd to frame either extroverts or introverts as 'selfish' - they are who they are. If you're conflating toxic behaviours with those traits, that's what the problem is, not the introvert/extrovert personality type.

Many extroverts are kind and empathetic. Some are not. Some introverts are also kind and empathetic. Some are not.

Elsiebear90 · 09/08/2023 10:38

I think both can be selfish, extroverts can push people into doing things they are not comfortable with and introverts can use it an excuse to not show up for people and let people down.

Hopefully most people find a balance. I’m more of an extrovert, my best friend is an introvert so when we get together she just comes over to mine for dinner or I go to hers for dinner, I don’t push her into coming to big group events with other friends or going out to bars etc. She also always shows up for important events, like hen parties, weddings, birthdays etc.

Magneta · 09/08/2023 10:37

Not selfish to manage your energy levels, but selfish perhaps if your only parameter is your own comfort and you never push yourself or put yourself out for anyone else's sake.

Building and maintaining connections is also really important for long term mental health.

Also I think that if we want to call on society for healthcare, security, amenities then we need to engage and contribute to it in some degree, if we can.

Sigmama · 09/08/2023 10:36

Surely everyone has to compromise sometimes, be they introvert or extrovert, in order to get along with others

Gettinagoldtoof · 09/08/2023 10:35

theyareonlynoodlesmichael · 09/08/2023 10:34

Introvert doesnt mean quiet, and extrovert doesnt mean loud. This is such a common misconception.

Agree with this. But there is a real blur, isn’t there. Extroverts get their energy from being around people and introverts from being alone.

theyareonlynoodlesmichael · 09/08/2023 10:34

Introvert doesnt mean quiet, and extrovert doesnt mean loud. This is such a common misconception.

Gettinagoldtoof · 09/08/2023 10:32

Obviously it’s a bit of a rude thing to say. But I’m going to say something that could upset too. As someone who has learned to be an extrovert I can’t help but think there’s something in this.

If someone is very shy it’s because they care what others think. If they could realise the world didn’t revolve around them, they might see that other people are actually more bothered by themselves and that they’re not that important and come out of their shell a bit. Learning to be outgoing and confident takes realisation that you’re just not that important in the grand scheme of things.

Being with someone who is painfully shy and anxious about how they come across can be very boring.

pollykitty · 09/08/2023 10:32

I don’t know if selfish is the right word. I do think if you are avoiding all gatherings on the claim of being introverted then you need to suck it up and stop being an ahole. I am 100% introverted but know that it’s not ok to miss a family wedding or my parents’ 50th wedding anniversary or a friend’s birthday drinks unless I have a very good excuse. It’s not the same as just declining a random night out or drinks at the pub after work. I’m tired of people wjo are actually socially avoidant of saying they are introverted. Introversion doesn’t mean you avoid everything all of the time.

Pista41 · 09/08/2023 10:32

Most introverts find a balance (I’m one).

But no, I’ve literally only now become to get rid of the guilt that I need to ringfence alone time as well and can’t do everything - the message that it’s selfish is an awful one to spread IMO.

You could equally argue it’s selfish for extroverts to guilt trip people into doing everything they want to do!

IamfeelingConfused · 09/08/2023 10:28

introverts are often introverts as they have sensory and social issues and find social situations draining. I have inattentive adhd - I have to work harder to read body language signals of people I don't know well - and harder to make small talk.

CoffeeCantata · 09/08/2023 10:27

I'll get flamed for saying this, but here goes.

I'm an introvert but people laugh when I tell them that, or that I'm very shy. I've always had to be a 'front of house person' in my work when really (if those Morison aptitude tests had been available in my schooldays) I'm by nature a back-room boffin. In those days the culture was very much "Just get on with it - like it or lump it!" and the idea that you were allowed to get out of things because you were shy wasn't acceptable.

So I suppose I faked it till I made it and find it ironic when people think I'm confident and even extrovert. Just occasionally I have to be open with people and tell them I can't do certain activities - but that's only come in recent years with the more accepting attitude and openness about these things. For example, my hobby often involves tours (choir) of several days' duration. Even though I'm on the committee and really am expected to go (I sense disapproval that I don't) I've had to explain that I just can't cope with being with a large crowd of people for 5 days without a lot of down-time. The organiser also asked me to share a room with a complete stranger and was stunned when I said no! The thought of being with 70 not-very-close people for 5 days and not having at least a single room to retreat to would have driven me crazy.

If it was for work (and I have had to do this kind of thing for work) then I'd suck it up and go, but not for a hobby. My work excursions cost me dearly in terms of stress and took a good week or so to get over. Extroverts maybe wouldn't understand this.

Lyricallie · 09/08/2023 10:27

I agree with a previous poster who said it can be used to justify bad behaviour on both sides. I’m a classic extrovert and sure I get disappointed when my introverted friends cancel last minute etc. but I’m never rude about it as they’re my friends. I think as long as there is give and take and compromises can be made.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 09/08/2023 10:26

Dotjones · 09/08/2023 10:02

Clearly YABU. If anything extroverts are selfish because they inflict themselves on others whether they like it or not. Introverts shouldn't feel pressure to "perform" for others on demand.

For me as an individual I don't think I'm selfish if I am quiet or avoid an event because it's not like I'd have anything worth saying and nobody would miss me anyway. So it's not selfish me not attending, if anything it's the opposite - I'm doing them a favour by being absent.

you clearly have an issue with self-esteem. EVERYONE has something worth saying.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 09/08/2023 10:22

Elepunt · 09/08/2023 10:06

No you aren't being selfish, I think both introverts and extroverts need to sometimes compromise and push their comfort zones if they want to maintain friendships etc though, or if they have children it's important to still take them out.

Yes, this. It’s important to keep up the “practice” of socialising. It’s a skill that you can learn a bit even if you’re an introvert. Eventually you will NEED to interact in a group, for the sake of someone else, and if you have refused to go anywhere for years then you’re just going to find that more difficult and stressful than it needs to be.

I’m thinking things like an elderly parent having a big birthday party where you know a lot of the people or even if you don’t , your parent wants to introduce you to their friends etc.

of course, the obvious thing is a parent’s funeral. That is the time when you will simply HAVE to suck it up and speak to people. It really is very rude to ignore guests at a wake and to sit in a corner on your own only talking to one or two other guests so you have no choice but to interact.

Swipe left for the next trending thread