Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?

413 replies

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

OP posts:
cruisebaba1 · 10/08/2023 23:32

Annachristie · 09/08/2023 09:50

Why does it matter to you whether they have paid all their lives? They have done what the majority of people do.
You sound as if you resent them for wanting free bus passes and access to health care.

Exactly this!

Yellowlegobrick · 10/08/2023 23:29

Yanbu.

I hate this line of "well we paid in". Its a bit like if there's a buffet at a wedding for 100 guests. If the first 30 guests take double portions, there's nor enough left and everyone else only gets half portions. Add to this the first group then saying the group on half portions are lazy whingers for commenting that they are hungry, and you've got the gist.

They paid something in. But it was nowhere near enough to cover what they had back out, and younger generations are being expected to pay more in the make up the shortfall.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:25

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 23:24

Because you're pompously lecturing a key worker about the importance of key workers lol.

And that's my point. If we're talking about the sharing of national/communal wealth then this potentially sounds communistic/socialist.

Yes, it’s socialist. Absolutely it is. I haven’t lectured anyone, pompously or otherwise.

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 23:24

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:21

We were actually talking about wealth on a national level, not an individual one. And what business of yours is it if I worked through the pandemic and how is it remotely relevant?

Because you're pompously lecturing a key worker about the importance of key workers lol.

And that's my point. If we're talking about the sharing of national/communal wealth then this potentially sounds communistic/socialist.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:21

We were actually talking about wealth on a national level, not an individual one. And what business of yours is it if I worked through the pandemic and how is it remotely relevant?

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 23:19

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:14

Obviously you don’t if you’re doing a poorly paid but vital job. I honestly thought the pandemic would have taught us something - it was the lowest paid in our society who kept the wheels turning, we certainly discovered who society is really dependent on and it’s not highly paid lawyers and City workers. How quickly we’ve forgotten.

We're talking about 'the wealth you earn'. This by definition doesn't apply to poorly paid people because they don't acquire any wealth.

And I worked all through the pandemic. Did you?

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:14

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 23:08

If everyone contributes to the wealth they should all benefit from it.

Surely you benefit from the wealth you earn, unless you qualify for benefits? Or are we talking a communist type system?

Obviously you don’t if you’re doing a poorly paid but vital job. I honestly thought the pandemic would have taught us something - it was the lowest paid in our society who kept the wheels turning, we certainly discovered who society is really dependent on and it’s not highly paid lawyers and City workers. How quickly we’ve forgotten.

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 23:08

If everyone contributes to the wealth they should all benefit from it.

Surely you benefit from the wealth you earn, unless you qualify for benefits? Or are we talking a communist type system?

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:05

Howmuchfurther · 10/08/2023 23:02

If everyone works hard to support their own family, the country grows richer.

If everyone tries to live by Govt taking stuff from everyone else, the country grows poorer. Then human rights go too.

But you fiercely support your team. It’s human nature.

What’s the point of the country getting richer if those at the top keep all that wealth to themselves? If everyone contributes to the wealth they should all benefit from it.

Howmuchfurther · 10/08/2023 23:02

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 22:00

Those who want a small state don’t give a shit about anyone but themselves. Thatcher’s words continue to resonate with some people.

If everyone works hard to support their own family, the country grows richer.

If everyone tries to live by Govt taking stuff from everyone else, the country grows poorer. Then human rights go too.

But you fiercely support your team. It’s human nature.

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 22:42

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 22:23

OK, thanks. Just ignorant rhetoric then.

It is ignorant rhetoric. You'd never get away with saying it about other demographics.

People seem to have very short memories about these things. There were times not so long ago when it was legal to beat/rape your wife or keep people of certain ethnicities as slaves. Now it's just a different group that can be discriminated against without comeback. It's ever changing.

IMO you either respect every demographic equally or you suck it up when you find yourself on the receiving end.

TrainspottingWelsh · 10/08/2023 22:39

They sound like my pils neighbours. I’m not sure they’d go quite so far as suggesting all migrants drown, but they learnt early on that pils aren’t receptive to their vile racist opinions. I certainly wouldn’t be surprised to discover they feel they were hard done to as a generation because they were born too late to move to the Deep South and join the klan in its heyday.

As for the inability to acknowledge their luck in having opportunities younger generations don’t, imo it’s not really about their age, because plenty of other older people completely understand reality. It’s more about stupidity/ lack of critical thinking combined with an inflated ego.
Age only comes into it because they’ve had more time to convince themselves of how marvellous they are and how deserving and hard done to etc. And society in general flatters that false opinion.

If as an older millennial I went around pretending the opportunities I’ve had in life compared to most of my generation were the result of my hard work and I felt as taxpayer’s they should be happy to fund the lifestyle I am accustomed to while having less themselves, everyone would soon be very blunt about how ridiculous and entitled I am. But when older people are equally stupid society frowns on pointing it out.
We got a shit deal compared to generation x and the baby boomers. But as a whole we recognise we still had it easier than the younger millennials and generation z. Same as many older people recognise their luck. The problem is that normal people don’t tend to feature in the media or announce their reasonable opinions to anyone and everyone that might listen. It’s always Barbara banging on about how difficult it is to maintain her £600k house on just the one pension and how unfair it is when she worked part time for at least 10yrs that it could be sold to pay for her care.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 22:23

OK, thanks. Just ignorant rhetoric then.

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 22:21

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 22:07

Do you have some evidence for this or is it just ignorant rhetoric?

You've not heard the phrase 'male, pale, and stale'?

I'm not a crown defender of men by any stretch but it's always occurred to me that you couldn't say 'black and wack' as an insult like you can 'male, pale, and stale.'

And 'gammon'. Another insult based on skin colour which I've seen on here a lot.

I don't really like Tories and strong conservatives but I also hate this ennobling of the left as being morally superior when they make up the vast majority of shouty purple haired bigots who always seem to have an arrogant/patronising sense of righteousness/self importance

Usually you get some excuse about privilege and 'punching up' but try and talk about the privilege in white feminism and suddenly those same rules don't apply!

Iwantmyoldnameback · 10/08/2023 22:12

The OPs grandparents bought their council house at a reduced rate after paying a subsided rent. That's a massive handout they had and they are partly responsible for the decline of social housing.
They are in no position to gloat.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2023 22:12

DaphneDeloresMoreheadRidesOn · 10/08/2023 21:14

Ugh my dad is just the same. The way he goes on you'd think he'd worked down the pit for 25 hours a day for 40 years and was surviving on a diet of dry bread.
He went to Radley, came from a wealthy family, pays DDs school fees to get rid of some of his income and retired at 55. He spends their winter fuel allowance on Cook puddings. They bought their house in 77, so you can imagine how much it has risen in value.
todays topic was lazy, workshy teachers who have gold plated pensions taking early retirement doing all the poor old pensioners out of their money. You can't even argue with his because he's so entrenched in his views.

He doesn't sound very pleasant. Yet you're happy to have him pay your daughter's school fees?

User6424678852 · 10/08/2023 22:09

DaphneDeloresMoreheadRidesOn · 10/08/2023 21:39

I fail to see how that's relevant

Yes, I know.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 22:07

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 22:05

A lot of the left are racist and discriminate on sexual orientation and gender - e.g. hating straight white males seems to be common. __

Do you have some evidence for this or is it just ignorant rhetoric?

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 22:05

Anothermam · 10/08/2023 21:44

I just find it surprising that they are racist, anti immigration etc. and vote Labour. Those things don't go together in my mind!

A lot of the left are racist and discriminate on sexual orientation and gender - e.g. hating straight white males seems to be common. __

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 22:00

Those who want a small state don’t give a shit about anyone but themselves. Thatcher’s words continue to resonate with some people.

Howmuchfurther · 10/08/2023 21:50

Anothermam · 10/08/2023 21:44

I just find it surprising that they are racist, anti immigration etc. and vote Labour. Those things don't go together in my mind!

You don’t recall anti semitism rows?

The left views people as groups. Of course they are the ones who would close ranks against different groups.

Those who want a small State view people as individuals and so it’s meaningless for them to attack groups.

Howmuchfurther · 10/08/2023 21:47

willstarttomorrow · 10/08/2023 21:43

It is frustrating OP. My late dad was a very clever and pragmatic man and I think got it. My mum less so. The reality is that there is a generation who benefited hugely from the welfare state because it functioned very differently, many have benefitted from huge house price increases and being able to buy on one income. Yes, there were sacrifices made but for our parents, mortgages were achievable on 2-3 times one income and saving for a deposit was possible. Child care costs at the same rate as a mortgage or higher was not a thing.

Many people were able to buy council homes, now even someone at band A will have a wait of 3-5 years to get one if they are lucky. The cost of renting is so huge, saving at the rate needed for a housing deposit is out of reach for many. Whilst not applicable to everyone, lots of people had a decent work place pension. Late DH's father was a postie and his death in service paid for his younger siblings to go to university and as a consequence they have done amazingly well in life. Their mother, an amazing woman, was a refugee and herself worked very hard and was a just a joyous force for good. Compare that to the current narrative.

As for pensions.....there are lots of people out there retired on a pension that our children could only dream of. Not every one, and there remains a lot of poverty amongst more vulnerable older people, and this group have probably been disadvantaged throughout their lives and largely overlooked.

There is a certain generation who have the best of the welfare state, really benefitted from secure jobs and pensions and, if they got on the housing ladder, have done pretty well. Hopefully the majority get that and really it is just luck. The others will probably never shift. Stop buying coffee and netflix people!

It would be good if younger people who do realise this started doing something about it.

The State is a parasite which grows continually. Young people are fewer and can’t afford to support it.

Anothermam · 10/08/2023 21:44

I just find it surprising that they are racist, anti immigration etc. and vote Labour. Those things don't go together in my mind!

willstarttomorrow · 10/08/2023 21:43

It is frustrating OP. My late dad was a very clever and pragmatic man and I think got it. My mum less so. The reality is that there is a generation who benefited hugely from the welfare state because it functioned very differently, many have benefitted from huge house price increases and being able to buy on one income. Yes, there were sacrifices made but for our parents, mortgages were achievable on 2-3 times one income and saving for a deposit was possible. Child care costs at the same rate as a mortgage or higher was not a thing.

Many people were able to buy council homes, now even someone at band A will have a wait of 3-5 years to get one if they are lucky. The cost of renting is so huge, saving at the rate needed for a housing deposit is out of reach for many. Whilst not applicable to everyone, lots of people had a decent work place pension. Late DH's father was a postie and his death in service paid for his younger siblings to go to university and as a consequence they have done amazingly well in life. Their mother, an amazing woman, was a refugee and herself worked very hard and was a just a joyous force for good. Compare that to the current narrative.

As for pensions.....there are lots of people out there retired on a pension that our children could only dream of. Not every one, and there remains a lot of poverty amongst more vulnerable older people, and this group have probably been disadvantaged throughout their lives and largely overlooked.

There is a certain generation who have the best of the welfare state, really benefitted from secure jobs and pensions and, if they got on the housing ladder, have done pretty well. Hopefully the majority get that and really it is just luck. The others will probably never shift. Stop buying coffee and netflix people!

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 21:41

DaphneDeloresMoreheadRidesOn · 10/08/2023 21:39

I fail to see how that's relevant

Because you’re sneering at him but you won’t be sneering at his money when you inherit it, will you?