Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?

413 replies

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

OP posts:
Howmuchfurther · 13/08/2023 10:12

Sabrinasummersamples · 13/08/2023 09:29

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

People say this as though it's a benefit for people today. The truth is you HAVE to go to university now to even be considered for jobs that you could walk into without a degree in the 90s. And then be left with the benefit of a massive £50k loan to pay off throughout your working life. It's absolutely not a benefit. It's another thing that's harder for young people today.

Exactly right.

A 22 year old graduate now has the same opportunities as a 16 year old school leaver in the 80s.

At least they are getting over the head full of false expectations they were give ten years ago.

Lots of excellent, high status employers are being sensible and taking school leavers again. I’d do that unless the degree is a prestigious one.

AIBot · 13/08/2023 09:55

Sabrinasummersamples · 13/08/2023 09:29

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

People say this as though it's a benefit for people today. The truth is you HAVE to go to university now to even be considered for jobs that you could walk into without a degree in the 90s. And then be left with the benefit of a massive £50k loan to pay off throughout your working life. It's absolutely not a benefit. It's another thing that's harder for young people today.

I agree, and it’s largely down to employers to change that culture. Hiring school leaver apprentices is more tricky because it is often difficult to discern who is most suitable as none of them have much experience. You end up interviewing a lot of young people, and trying to see beyond their nervousness to who they really are.

It is tempting for employers to hire a new graduate because they are more mature than a school leaver, not much more expensive and have some knowledge / proven interest if the degree is appropriate; but they still need training and supervision.

Companies for sure need to get off their backsides and offer more in house training with day release at college.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 09:33

Sabrinasummersamples · 13/08/2023 09:29

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

People say this as though it's a benefit for people today. The truth is you HAVE to go to university now to even be considered for jobs that you could walk into without a degree in the 90s. And then be left with the benefit of a massive £50k loan to pay off throughout your working life. It's absolutely not a benefit. It's another thing that's harder for young people today.

i completely agree. But we kept being told how wonderful it was the it was free. It wasn’t that wonderful if hardly anyone could get a degree. And that closed the door in the face of people who would really have benefited from higher education.

Sabrinasummersamples · 13/08/2023 09:29

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

People say this as though it's a benefit for people today. The truth is you HAVE to go to university now to even be considered for jobs that you could walk into without a degree in the 90s. And then be left with the benefit of a massive £50k loan to pay off throughout your working life. It's absolutely not a benefit. It's another thing that's harder for young people today.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 09:26

Moglet4 · 13/08/2023 09:13

They’re actually official figures, but ok. I have never said life was easy for everyone but the fact is that there were far more opportunities available with far better packages long term (admittedly more for the boomer generation than people born in the 70s). My objection to the poster was declaring that everyone born after 1980 is lazy and that people simply worked harder in the 70s. That shit needs to be shot down.

How can they be official figures when you say People work their backsides off but bring home less of their pay than for many generations before which is demonstrably untrue as income tax alone was 13% higher.

How were there more opportunities when only 5% of the population was educated to degree standard? Previous generations would have killed for the opportunities people take for granted today.

Every generation has its challenges and it’s just divisive and pointless to point the finger at any other generation and weep that it’s harder for you. It’s different.

Moglet4 · 13/08/2023 09:13

They’re actually official figures, but ok. I have never said life was easy for everyone but the fact is that there were far more opportunities available with far better packages long term (admittedly more for the boomer generation than people born in the 70s). My objection to the poster was declaring that everyone born after 1980 is lazy and that people simply worked harder in the 70s. That shit needs to be shot down.

Howmuchfurther · 13/08/2023 08:54

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 08:37

When I started work in 1972 basic rate income tax was 33%, it’s now 20%. Take home pay was less - a lot less.

My rent (only 50% because I shared) was 40% of my take home pay.

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

Of course it’s hard now, only an idiot would deny that. Equally life in 1970s UK was far from the land of milk and honey you portray, not least because your figures are wildly inaccurate.

Yes. “Atlas Shrugged” was a popular novel in the 1970s for a reason and it certainly wasn’t writing talent.

My parents thought everything would continue to get steadily worse. They had no hope, much as we haven’t now.

5% going to university and degree requirements for professional jobs approximated to a means test preserving middle class jobs for middle class people.

Tony Blair destroyed the value of degrees so that everybody is now competing for historically middle class jobs. Everyone who wants to be a graduate is a graduate so graduate wages are down and graduate working hours/competition are up.

I work the same job I did 20 years ago, for less money nominally.

Times were hard in the 1970s, easier in 80s and 90s and are now getting steadily harder.

If you want life to be easier and things to be cheaper, you need to cut what Govt takes out.

This is not just tax. Govt has also imposed burdensome regulations. People need to be employed and take time to make sure regs are complied with. This is a production cost for both goods and services and makes everything more expensive.

Howmuchfurther · 13/08/2023 08:42

Moglet4 · 13/08/2023 07:46

If that is your observation of people under 45 then you must be moving in teeny tiny circles. People work their backsides off but bring home less of their pay than for many generations before and with everything being proportionally a hell of a lot more expensive. In the UK in the 70s it cost 4.1 times an average income to buy your average house; it is now 8.9 times. Average rents were 10% of your wage in the 70s- it’s now 30-45%. That is why people find it difficult to save enough. It cost nothing to go to university. Fees alone are now 30,000 for students. That’s just 2 areas and it’s the same in every single part of people’s lives. Nobody is waiting for handouts but without some help, most will be unable to have what the generations before them were all able to have or won’t be able to have them until a lot later. It’s not their fault and it doesn’t make them lazy!

“Help” is always the opposite of helpful.

Either it costs you more in the long run or it benefits one group at the expense of another, increasing cost over all.

You need cheaper housing. Cut planning permission, red tape, taxes on builders.

You need higher wages and lower taxes. ESG is designed to do the opposite.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 08:37

Moglet4 · 13/08/2023 07:46

If that is your observation of people under 45 then you must be moving in teeny tiny circles. People work their backsides off but bring home less of their pay than for many generations before and with everything being proportionally a hell of a lot more expensive. In the UK in the 70s it cost 4.1 times an average income to buy your average house; it is now 8.9 times. Average rents were 10% of your wage in the 70s- it’s now 30-45%. That is why people find it difficult to save enough. It cost nothing to go to university. Fees alone are now 30,000 for students. That’s just 2 areas and it’s the same in every single part of people’s lives. Nobody is waiting for handouts but without some help, most will be unable to have what the generations before them were all able to have or won’t be able to have them until a lot later. It’s not their fault and it doesn’t make them lazy!

When I started work in 1972 basic rate income tax was 33%, it’s now 20%. Take home pay was less - a lot less.

My rent (only 50% because I shared) was 40% of my take home pay.

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

Of course it’s hard now, only an idiot would deny that. Equally life in 1970s UK was far from the land of milk and honey you portray, not least because your figures are wildly inaccurate.

Moglet4 · 13/08/2023 07:46

If that is your observation of people under 45 then you must be moving in teeny tiny circles. People work their backsides off but bring home less of their pay than for many generations before and with everything being proportionally a hell of a lot more expensive. In the UK in the 70s it cost 4.1 times an average income to buy your average house; it is now 8.9 times. Average rents were 10% of your wage in the 70s- it’s now 30-45%. That is why people find it difficult to save enough. It cost nothing to go to university. Fees alone are now 30,000 for students. That’s just 2 areas and it’s the same in every single part of people’s lives. Nobody is waiting for handouts but without some help, most will be unable to have what the generations before them were all able to have or won’t be able to have them until a lot later. It’s not their fault and it doesn’t make them lazy!

Seymour5 · 12/08/2023 12:49

@Oldsu I know there are winners and losers, but DH’s contribution record (no SERPS, no contracting out) would, after 2016, have qualified for the full new state pension. Mine is less anyway, broken contribution record (no NI credits for being a SAHM back then), contracted out reductions etc. I’m just glad that my adult children will be able to retire early, and won’t be dependent on state pensions.

Like many pensioners, I misguidedly thought that any occ or private pension would provide a better income in retirement. It has simply meant we pay full council tax, and don’t qualify for Pension Credit. We are just a few ££ better off than those reliant on means tested benefits. The new state pension would have meant a better outcome for us and others like us.

Oldsu · 12/08/2023 09:33

Seymour5 · 11/08/2023 09:00

I remember paying income tax at that rate. I also remember the ‘brain drain’ when the top rate was around 90% in the 60s.

DH and I are state pensioners. I also have an occupational pension, not a big one. Having that extra income means we don’t qualify for pension credit. Our incomes are both below the personal tax allowance. Because we retired before 2016, our pensions are about £50 a week less than more recent retirees. Old basic is around £156, New pension is over £200.

@Seymour5 'Because we retired before 2016, our pensions are about £50 a week less than more recent retirees. Old basic is around £156, New pension is over £200.'

A lot of people think that but in fact it is not entirely true is it? many older pensioners get way more than the basic due to paying into the second state pensions SERPS alone at 23/24 rates can give someone up to £204.68 a week extra while Graduated Retirement Benefit is also extra, it is also not true that people retiring after 6th April 2016 automatically get the higher rate, people retiring now are still in the transitional phase with their NICs pre 2016 making up the calculations the governments own figures indicate that at the moment only 44% of recent pensioners get the new full rate.

It would also depend on how the occupational pension was funded, if it was funded through your NICS in other words you were contracted out of SERPS you and your employer would have paid a lower rate of NI or you would have paid full NI with some diverted into the Occupational Pension, when this happens the state pension is less because effectively you paid in less, this is one of the reasons older pensioners only get the basic not just because they reached pension age pre 2016

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 09:25

Sabrinasummersamples · 12/08/2023 09:20

@Blossomtoes here's a link to the article. You can believe it or not, but I find it hard to imagine the FT is lying https://www.ft.com/content/c69b49de-1368-11e9-a581-4ff78404524e
@Harrypewter I don't think anyone is saying it's the "fault" of the baby boomers that they're so wealthy? Just that they can't suggest that it's right, fair and deserved.

I didn’t say I didn’t believe it. That article confirms that the wealth is predicated predominantly on property prices which is what I said. You might technically be a millionaire on paper if you own a house “worth” that much but that’s all it is unless you liquidate it - and then where do you live?

As for the FT lying, well we all know statistics can be manipulated to suit, don’t we?

Sabrinasummersamples · 12/08/2023 09:20

@Blossomtoes here's a link to the article. You can believe it or not, but I find it hard to imagine the FT is lying https://www.ft.com/content/c69b49de-1368-11e9-a581-4ff78404524e
@Harrypewter I don't think anyone is saying it's the "fault" of the baby boomers that they're so wealthy? Just that they can't suggest that it's right, fair and deserved.

One in five UK baby boomers are millionaires

Analysis of ONS statistics shows extent of intergenerational wealth inequality

https://www.ft.com/content/c69b49de-1368-11e9-a581-4ff78404524e

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 09:19

Boomers saw unprecedented wage increases and gains of upto 5000% on property values.

Blimey, where were those houses for a fiver in the 70s and 80s? Everyone who bought before 2009 has seen similar increases, not just boomers. Definitely not 5000% though, that’s absurd.

Harrypewter · 12/08/2023 09:14

Sabrinasummersamples · 12/08/2023 08:45

According to the financial times 1 in 5 baby boomers are millionaires. Or at least that's what a 2019 article shows. They were the only generation to see wealth grow in the 10 years before. Gen X saw a 5% drop, millennials saw a 2 % drop (from a smaller base obviously).

Boomers saw unprecedented wage increases and gains of upto 5000% on property values.
However this is hardly their fault.
They're comparatively wealthy.
They are also a sizable group, we've never had the cross generations mixing like this before. It does cause issues.

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 08:58

Sabrinasummersamples · 12/08/2023 08:45

According to the financial times 1 in 5 baby boomers are millionaires. Or at least that's what a 2019 article shows. They were the only generation to see wealth grow in the 10 years before. Gen X saw a 5% drop, millennials saw a 2 % drop (from a smaller base obviously).

Given that that growth in wealth is predicated on the increase in house prices, I find it very difficult to believe that anyone who bought before 2009 saw a decrease in wealth. That includes most of Gen X. There’s a massive difference between being a millionaire with liquid wealth and one owning a £1 million house, those boomers fit into the latter category.

User6424678852 · 12/08/2023 08:56

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 08:19

Housing benefit - universal based on income
Cost of Living payments - what are those?
Support for Mortgage Interest - pensioners are very unlikely to have a mortgage
Free TV license - no pensioners get those any more but they all used to
Council tax discount - everyone who lives alone gets it, students don’t pay it at all
help with hospital transportation costs - never heard of that
Warm homes discount - universal
royal mail redirection - you’re struggling now

I’m not struggling for anything. Not sure what point you are trying to make.

You are misinformed - for example yes, you do get a free tv licence if you get pension credit. This is the point the previous poster was making - pension credit widens access to other benefits.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?
Sabrinasummersamples · 12/08/2023 08:48

TL:DR if you are retired and rely on your state pension and the NHS, opposing the immigration of young fit migrants and future tax payers is very dumb.

Also very selfish. As is opposing the building of new homes because you don't want your road to become "busy"

Sabrinasummersamples · 12/08/2023 08:45

According to the financial times 1 in 5 baby boomers are millionaires. Or at least that's what a 2019 article shows. They were the only generation to see wealth grow in the 10 years before. Gen X saw a 5% drop, millennials saw a 2 % drop (from a smaller base obviously).

Ginmonkeyagain · 12/08/2023 08:45

The thing people don't really appreciate is the funding of the NHS and state pensions mainly relies on the working generation paying for the one above (many people become a net cost to the NHS in the last years of their lives) the aforementioned social contract.

That made sense when the welfare state was created. Most people did not live to great old age and until the 2000s the retired/retiring generations were sigificanly reduced in number by two world wars.

Therefore the retired generations being supported by workig generations below were much smaller. The problem we have now is threefold - people are living longer but often in poorer health, the baby boom generation (those born 1946 - 1965) is huge and beginning to move in to retirement and ill heath, Gens X and Y (those born 1966 - 1990), the ones who will be supprtinv the retiring boomers, are litedally smaller as the birth rate fell a lot in the seventies and eighties.

What is known as the dependency ratio - the number of non working people being supported by working people is starting to look a bit shaky.

So whilst the boomers did their bit and paid it forward their burden it was tiny compared to the burden their children and grandchildren will have to shoulder.

TL:DR if you are retired and rely on your state pension and the NHS, opposing the immigration of young fit migrants and future tax payers is very dumb

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 08:42

Pottedpalm · 12/08/2023 08:23

You are wrong. Society needs highly paid, well qualified professionals. The pandemic situation showed that, surprise surprise, lower paid workers were needed to maintain the food chain. It did not show that they are more valuable to society than surgeons, dentists etc, who remember were not allowed to work, as the current health crisis clearly shows.

If you really think that there’s no point in engaging with you. Society would have collapsed without care workers, retail workers and drivers. Surgeons continued to work in other healthcare roles, while dentists are clearly not seen as essential because there are so few NHS dentists hardly anyone can get an appointment any more.

Pottedpalm · 12/08/2023 08:23

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2023 23:14

Obviously you don’t if you’re doing a poorly paid but vital job. I honestly thought the pandemic would have taught us something - it was the lowest paid in our society who kept the wheels turning, we certainly discovered who society is really dependent on and it’s not highly paid lawyers and City workers. How quickly we’ve forgotten.

You are wrong. Society needs highly paid, well qualified professionals. The pandemic situation showed that, surprise surprise, lower paid workers were needed to maintain the food chain. It did not show that they are more valuable to society than surgeons, dentists etc, who remember were not allowed to work, as the current health crisis clearly shows.

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 08:19

Housing benefit - universal based on income
Cost of Living payments - what are those?
Support for Mortgage Interest - pensioners are very unlikely to have a mortgage
Free TV license - no pensioners get those any more but they all used to
Council tax discount - everyone who lives alone gets it, students don’t pay it at all
help with hospital transportation costs - never heard of that
Warm homes discount - universal
royal mail redirection - you’re struggling now

Pottedpalm · 12/08/2023 08:16

macshoto · 09/08/2023 11:45

Sadly not too unusual.

The misnomer of 'National Insurance' makes people think they are paying into an insurance fund, where instead successive governments have managed a 'pay as you go' system. Instead of investing our oil revenues to create a funded system, and/or a Norwegian-style sovereign wealth fund, unfortunately we spent them.

The older generation need to understand that, and that everything they take - in state pensions, benefits and healthcare, is being paid for by their children and in some cases grand-children.

As their contributions paid for the generations before them.
pretty sure the single mothers on benefits are contributing very little to any ‘pot’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread