Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?

413 replies

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

OP posts:
SequentialAnalyst · 14/08/2023 12:02

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 19:46

The behavior of the pensioner cohort combined with FPTP and the UKs tax structure are economically crippling the country.

Is that simple enough for you?

But what's the point of blaming us? Do you think others of my generation are going to read your post? And then go "Oh no, I've got it all wrong."

Do you blame me individually?

BoredZelda · 14/08/2023 12:01

I am 61 and still working, still paying a mortgage. I have never voted Tory and I am getting sick of all this cunty ageist wank.

Sure, but in your demographic most people did, which is why you have the triple lock.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 14/08/2023 09:48

ilovesooty · 14/08/2023 07:08

when one group votes themselves

I'm receiving a state pension. I never voted for the party that instigated the triple lock.

I am 61 and still working, still paying a mortgage. I have never voted Tory and I am getting sick of all this cunty ageist wank.

ilovesooty · 14/08/2023 07:08

when one group votes themselves

I'm receiving a state pension. I never voted for the party that instigated the triple lock.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 21:00

The UKs public sector pension liabilities are about 3 TRILLION £££. Thats more than the entire GDP of the UK but its kept off the balance sheet as it is paid "as it comes due

Interesting you should say that as it’s the only area for which borrowing has decreased in the current financial year.

Table 1: Public sector net borrowing by sub-sector
Public sector net borrowing by sub-sector May 2023 compared with May 2022, £ billion, UK
Sub-sector Dataset identifier
code May
(£ billion) Change on a year ago
2023 2022 £ billion Percentage
Central Government -NMFJ 20.9 10.1 10.7 105.8
Local Government -NMOE -2.3 0.2 -2.5 -
Sub-total: General
Government -NNBK 18.6 10.3 8.3 80.3
Public Corporations -CPCM 0.0 0.0 0.1 -
Public Sector Pensions -CWNY -0.3 -0.2 -0.1 -24.3
Sub-total: Public Sector ex
BoE and Banks [note 1] -CPNZ 18.3 10.1 8.3 82.2
Bank of England -JW2H 1.7 -0.7 2.4 -
Sub-total: Public Sector ex
[note 2] -J5II 20.0 9.4 10.7 114.0
Public Sector Banks -IL6B -0.8 -0.8 0.0 0.4
Total: Public Sector -ANNX 19.2 8.5 10.7 125.0
Memo: Central government
net cash requirement [note 3] M98R 17.0 11.5 5.5 47.8
Source: Public sector finances from the Office for National Statistics

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 20:44

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 20:05

What’s crippling the country is the bunch of incompetent, avaricious charlatans who are pretending to run the country while lining their and their cronies’ pockets. The insane amount of our money paying the national debt. Taxation that’s at its highest for 70 years. Liz Truss cost this country £30 billion in 49 days. Looking at a group of the population and blaming them is exactly what they want, while you’re busy doing that they’re getting away with God knows what.

The UKs public sector pension liabilities are about 3 TRILLION £££. Thats more than the entire GDP of the UK but its kept off the balance sheet as it is paid "as it comes due".

State Pension is now £125bn (10% of public spending and 5% of GDP) and increasing due to triple lock and demographics.

Take it from a highly experienced global professional in the actuarial world that has been doing pension valuations for 20+ years:

Its not the £30bn one off cost that cripples you.

Its the long-term pension costs that do.

Every single time.

This invariably happens when one group votes themselves outsized retirement benefits, and the demographic balance becomes skewed, while the economy goes into an economic tailspin.

And thats the UK right now.

Those costs have started to crowd out spending in:

  1. Education
  2. NHS
  3. Capital Infrastructure
  4. Local authorities

There is no magic money pot when you cannot borrow more (like right now in the UK).

The existential choice now for the UK is:

Do we keep uprating state pensions via the triple lock and reduce:

Education funding in real terms
NHS funding in real terms
LA funding in real terms
Childcare funding in real terms
Capital Infrastructure in real terms.

Thats what the country has come to. Thats why buildings are falling apart, class sizes are 30+, and Drs are striking due to low pay. These things have been eroded slowly over 15 years in real terms to fund the extra benefits for the pensioners (and win power via FPTP).

The UK is very close right now to reaching the problem Greece had with their own pension system given markets will not allow the UK to borrow more to finance non-productive investments.

The grim reality is that the UK is basically broke and poor, and its not a situation that will be solvable in even a decade.

The transition to a poorer country (in real GDP per capita terms) will be brutal for many, specially at the lower end of the income distribution. This is also why these folks need more help vs the pensioners (who are now the wealthiest cohort in the UK. Even more so than working people).

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 20:05

What’s crippling the country is the bunch of incompetent, avaricious charlatans who are pretending to run the country while lining their and their cronies’ pockets. The insane amount of our money paying the national debt. Taxation that’s at its highest for 70 years. Liz Truss cost this country £30 billion in 49 days. Looking at a group of the population and blaming them is exactly what they want, while you’re busy doing that they’re getting away with God knows what.

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 19:46

SequentialAnalyst · 13/08/2023 19:43

Do fuck off with the generational blame. What on earth is the point of doing it?

The behavior of the pensioner cohort combined with FPTP and the UKs tax structure are economically crippling the country.

Is that simple enough for you?

SequentialAnalyst · 13/08/2023 19:43

Do fuck off with the generational blame. What on earth is the point of doing it?

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 19:39

Sabrinasummersamples · 13/08/2023 19:20

@TheThinkingGoblin absolutely no political party is going to be taking anything away from pensioners to give to other groups when pensioners are the only ones who are guaranteed to actually vote. And if they did add for instance adding NI into regular taxation so that pensioners pay the same tax rate on their earning as everyone else (or heaven forbid pay tax on their wealth!) Into their manifesto then they wouldn't get voted into power anyway.
What we need in this country is compulsory voting. But again the grey vote wouldn't vote for that so it'll never happen. Sorry!

Agreed that it will never happen if Starmer starts floating it to the country now. Best thing to do is wait and let reality sort it out.

Economic reality has the nice habit of punching through even the toughest mental reality distortion fields which is what will happen over the next 24 months.

When pensioners get another 6-7% triple lock increase next year in April 2024 (set using September 2023 inflation), how do you think people will see this when they are now being thrust into working poverty?

Its not just the lower income folks either. It will be young working mothers, and many children.
The contrast between the poorer working folks and children with the pensioners will keep getting worse.

And when these folks ask for help what can Starmer say....that there is no money?

Will be a bit rich when he just handed out another large income boost to the pensioners.

If people think the animosity towards the pensioners is bad now, it will get much worse over the next 24 months as the rate rises start hitting working families due to fixed term mortgages expiring.

So we would then have mortgage free pensioners receiving 6-7% more in state benefits while working folks with mortgages and children are getting much poorer.

The clamour do then do something about the triple lock will be immense (because its obviously unfair).

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 19:27

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 19:17

You don't even have a basic understanding of the problem, and to boot, you will twist yourself into a veritable pretzel generating outlandish ideas to solve problems primarily because you are allergic to the reality that "pensioners need to pay in more".

I leave it to others to compare our solutions to the issues you outlined to judge which are outlandish. There are far better ways of solving problems than solutions based on spite, envy and malice.

Again, you don't seem to have much of a clue.

The Drs are striking over PAY. Do you not understand this?

A few asylum seekers being sent to work in the NHS will not change the realities on the ground for JDs or GPs.

£100k student debt
£15/h rates
£2k/year professional fees

Etc.

People of your generation have essentially sucked the NHS dry, and the professionals there are totally fed up. They have endured 15 years of this and have reached the end of the road.

10+ years of study and work with high levels of stress are so poorly compensated that they cannot even afford to buy a home or start a family. This compares to places like Ireland were they make 3x more or Australia (5x more). And those countries are actively recruiting them.

So now you will only get emergency care only.

If you want more than that, then you will have to pay up.

Its that simple really. This is the world your generation has created so enjoy the fruits of tour labours.

Sabrinasummersamples · 13/08/2023 19:20

@TheThinkingGoblin absolutely no political party is going to be taking anything away from pensioners to give to other groups when pensioners are the only ones who are guaranteed to actually vote. And if they did add for instance adding NI into regular taxation so that pensioners pay the same tax rate on their earning as everyone else (or heaven forbid pay tax on their wealth!) Into their manifesto then they wouldn't get voted into power anyway.
What we need in this country is compulsory voting. But again the grey vote wouldn't vote for that so it'll never happen. Sorry!

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 19:17

You don't even have a basic understanding of the problem, and to boot, you will twist yourself into a veritable pretzel generating outlandish ideas to solve problems primarily because you are allergic to the reality that "pensioners need to pay in more".

I leave it to others to compare our solutions to the issues you outlined to judge which are outlandish. There are far better ways of solving problems than solutions based on spite, envy and malice.

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 19:14

This is why I find it largely pointless to discuss these things.

You don't even have a basic understanding of the problem, and to boot, you will twist yourself into a veritable pretzel generating outlandish ideas to solve problems primarily because you are allergic to the reality that "pensioners need to pay in more".

Thats why the only solution is to ignore pensioners in general and legislate away their extra benefits (which are making everybody else poorer) out of existence.

I really do hope Starmer understands this as well and he is playing the long game.

Its the only way forward now for the country

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 19:06

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 18:55

  1. We need subsidised childcare in a hurry as its hampering women from working and damaging the economy.

To fund this you make every employer pay women equally, crack down on absent fathers and incentivise employers to set up high quality nurseries

2. The NHS is near collapse because the pensioners do not pay in (no NI) and heavily use the system.

The NHS is near collapse became it has a huge shortage of qualified staff. To address this you allow qualified doctors and dentists awaiting assessment as asylum seekers to work. You make it a condition of NHS funded training that at least five years are worked in the NHS post qualification and you don’t write off student debt if they emigrate. You also reopen step down beds so older patients aren’t readmitted as fast as they’re discharged.

3. Local Authorities are broke

You fund extra revenue by updating the banding system from 1991 home values to 2022 home values, and you add in a few more upper bands. And the all the young families will pay shedloads more council tax as well as sky high mortgages and extortionate childcare

Fixed it for you.

I think I have heard it all now.

Your "grand plan" to fix the massive lack of Drs (GPs and specialists) is to let asylum seekers (who are not medically qualified to practice in the UK and are few and far between) work in the NHS.

Amazing. Duning-Kruger springs to mind after that gem.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 18:55
  1. We need subsidised childcare in a hurry as its hampering women from working and damaging the economy.

To fund this you make every employer pay women equally, crack down on absent fathers and incentivise employers to set up high quality nurseries

2. The NHS is near collapse because the pensioners do not pay in (no NI) and heavily use the system.

The NHS is near collapse became it has a huge shortage of qualified staff. To address this you allow qualified doctors and dentists awaiting assessment as asylum seekers to work. You make it a condition of NHS funded training that at least five years are worked in the NHS post qualification and you don’t write off student debt if they emigrate. You also reopen step down beds so older patients aren’t readmitted as fast as they’re discharged.

3. Local Authorities are broke

You fund extra revenue by updating the banding system from 1991 home values to 2022 home values, and you add in a few more upper bands. And the all the young families will pay shedloads more council tax as well as sky high mortgages and extortionate childcare

Fixed it for you.

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 18:45

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 08:37

When I started work in 1972 basic rate income tax was 33%, it’s now 20%. Take home pay was less - a lot less.

My rent (only 50% because I shared) was 40% of my take home pay.

Only 5% of people went to university, now it’s almost 50%. Most people started work at 16.

Of course it’s hard now, only an idiot would deny that. Equally life in 1970s UK was far from the land of milk and honey you portray, not least because your figures are wildly inaccurate.

The effective tax rates were a lot lower back in 1972.

If you earn from £50k to £60k now you are looking at 85% marginal rates due to the removal of child benefit.

Its even worse from £100k to £120k now.

100% marginal tax rate with removal of tax free childcare and tax free emount of 12.5k.

On short, people earning £50k to £150k are carrying the entire country.

Its a massive tax burden and people are naturally fed up.

TheThinkingGoblin · 13/08/2023 18:40

BoredZelda · 09/08/2023 18:39

But the vast majority of pensioners have worked all their lives, paid and are paying all the taxes asked of them. Just like OP’s grandparents. Just what do you actually want of us? Apart from conveniently dropping dead on the our 66th birthdays?

Recognising the privileges you've had which today's young people don't, would be a start. Realising that to keep giving you all the things you think you are entitled to, the rest of us are working longer, paying more and are getting less. I would disagree that it is a vast majority who have paid tax as women were far less likely to be working 50 years ago. Sure they were raising children and that's an important role, but not only would there have been a tax advantage for married couples back in the day, but it is a fallacy to say they were paying tax. Indeed, Martin Lewis has recently been banging the drum for women saying they needed to check they claim all the years of NI they missed being out of the workforce.

I will reiterate, I think it is important to look after pensioners whether they "paid in" or not, but it is also important to recognise who that is at the expense of, and to stop calling the younger generations entitled.

They don't care.

That is the conclusion that I have reached. Its entitlement fueled by a lack of education and close to zero critical thinking skills (like OPs parents).

So, what to do?

You do what you do to a toddler that throws tantrums. You take their goodies away.

  1. We need subsidised childcare in a hurry as its hampering women from working and damaging the economy.

To fund this you legislate away the triple lock in favour of a sustainable uprating of state pensions using demographics and economic and financial metrics.

  1. The NHS is near collapse because the pensioners do not pay in (no NI) and heavily use the system.

To fund better pay for Drs and Nurses, along with investment into more places to train more you introduce a graduated NI tax for pensioners based on income.

  1. Local Authorities are broke

You fund extra revenue by updating the banding system from 1991 home values to 2022 home values, and you add in a few more upper bands.

And voila,

The UKs economic problems are on the way to being improved.

EffortlessDesmond · 13/08/2023 18:12

Fortunately, lots of us boomers are familiar with t'Internet and computers so not entirely helpless. FFS, I have had a computer on my desk since 1983!

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 18:10

Catusrusty · 13/08/2023 18:08

There's been a lot of these dog whistle ageist posts recently, haven't there?

Yes and there will be a lot more. Boomer bashing seems to be becoming something of a sport. 🙄

EffortlessDesmond · 13/08/2023 18:10

I'm one of the horrible old boomers... I don't think my GenZ kid will turn down anything coming down the line, even though it hasn't arrived in my bank account, because I have two living near-nonagenarian parents.

Catusrusty · 13/08/2023 18:08

There's been a lot of these dog whistle ageist posts recently, haven't there?

Prelapsarianhag · 13/08/2023 17:56

I am sure you will refuse any inheritance from these horrible old people.

EffortlessDesmond · 13/08/2023 16:32

I don't believe the innate intelligence of the population has changed much since the 1970s (or since the 1790s). But the insistence that more degree level qualifications would benefit the whole economy has back fired big time. Instead you get corporate HR departments just using the filter of first degree to sack off a sizeable chunk of applications. A friend in grad recruitment HR for IBM in Brussels said that they checked the degree and the university and round-filed any one short of the level. And anecdotally, I recruited for my (entry level) replacement in NYC publishing, offered my preferred candidate and my boss decided on a candidate from an Ivy League college who was an incompetent waste of space. For an editor's job, with rudimentary errors in SPaG. You couldn't make it up!