Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?

413 replies

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

OP posts:
Lentilweaver · 09/08/2023 11:59

You lost me at sinking refugee boats. Good god! Sadly there are going to be more like them in the future.

I don't think you can change them.

Rosiem2808 · 09/08/2023 11:57

Perhaps those grandparents are feeling this way because they never claimed benefits ? There are lots of people who never work a day in their lives and live off benefits making a career out of it getting benefits for all sorts of things besides the basics

MorePressureMoreRelease · 09/08/2023 11:55

RosesAndHellebores · 09/08/2023 11:47

Between us DH and I have worked for more than 70 years. We will both get our full state pensions and generous private pensions. We will continue paying tax until we die. We have put in a huge amount and I have no objection to providing benefits for those who need them. I do object to those who don't need them getting more than they should.

I have an underlying chronic health condition and the NHS has denied me optimal treatment for it because the bar has been raised by NICE. I am funding a two year course of anabolic injectables personally to help prevent further deterioration to my bones. I am lucky that I have the £2400 handy.

I think it would be helpful if every baby started with a personal state spends account to which could be added the cost of medical care and education, then benefits and pensions, with the tax and NI payments added throughout their lives. It would then be clear who were net contributors to society and what individuals had cost compared to what they put in.

The idea of a personal 'pot' is too simplistic and goes against the concept of society. We coexist with others and gain the benefits of shared resources. What comes with this is a responsibility towards those who are less able to succeed in this society. This may be because of health, education or societal disadvantage. It would create an even more tiered system than that which we currently have.

As for the OP. My MIL is the same. She's too old at 80 to change her views. However I remind her that she came over on a boat (from Ireland) as a child and is also an immigrant. The only difference is the colour of her skin.

SueVineer · 09/08/2023 11:54

Spectre8 · 09/08/2023 11:51

It doesn't matter what anyone thinks about whether any of us have paid e ought in. The social contract has been set, we pay x and in return you get y. So yes people who pay it have paid in.

I'm just because how much u paid in isnt close to what it may really cost is an issue for government policy its not down to the individual who has no control over it.

Like any insurance, you pay an amount decided for you and in return you can claim x y z. Eveb if what you claim is more than what you paid in. Thats the agreement.

The other points yanbu about.

The point is that ops grandparents think they’re entitled to all the benefits they get but that others are not. Because they think they “paid in” enough for their benefits even though they didn’t. That’s why it’s relevant - because they think it gives them an entitlement that others shouldn’t have.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 11:53

What some people seem to think is that their taxes and NI go into a separate shoebox for them. It doesn’t work like this. Any welfare benefits including pensions can only be paid from current state revenue, ie generated from taxes and NI of people currently working. Where there are shortfalls in workers as there are in many sectors this affects the amount of revenue. So immigration is important to the pensions that people are currently receiving today

Why don't people get it? And unfortunately the pyramid is tipping upside down.

SueVineer · 09/08/2023 11:52

macshoto · 09/08/2023 11:45

Sadly not too unusual.

The misnomer of 'National Insurance' makes people think they are paying into an insurance fund, where instead successive governments have managed a 'pay as you go' system. Instead of investing our oil revenues to create a funded system, and/or a Norwegian-style sovereign wealth fund, unfortunately we spent them.

The older generation need to understand that, and that everything they take - in state pensions, benefits and healthcare, is being paid for by their children and in some cases grand-children.

There’s also the issue that ni is effectively a tax that is only paid by workers. So wealthy pensioners are also paying much less tax on their income than workers.

Spectre8 · 09/08/2023 11:51

It doesn't matter what anyone thinks about whether any of us have paid e ought in. The social contract has been set, we pay x and in return you get y. So yes people who pay it have paid in.

I'm just because how much u paid in isnt close to what it may really cost is an issue for government policy its not down to the individual who has no control over it.

Like any insurance, you pay an amount decided for you and in return you can claim x y z. Eveb if what you claim is more than what you paid in. Thats the agreement.

The other points yanbu about.

RosesAndHellebores · 09/08/2023 11:47

Between us DH and I have worked for more than 70 years. We will both get our full state pensions and generous private pensions. We will continue paying tax until we die. We have put in a huge amount and I have no objection to providing benefits for those who need them. I do object to those who don't need them getting more than they should.

I have an underlying chronic health condition and the NHS has denied me optimal treatment for it because the bar has been raised by NICE. I am funding a two year course of anabolic injectables personally to help prevent further deterioration to my bones. I am lucky that I have the £2400 handy.

I think it would be helpful if every baby started with a personal state spends account to which could be added the cost of medical care and education, then benefits and pensions, with the tax and NI payments added throughout their lives. It would then be clear who were net contributors to society and what individuals had cost compared to what they put in.

macshoto · 09/08/2023 11:45

Sadly not too unusual.

The misnomer of 'National Insurance' makes people think they are paying into an insurance fund, where instead successive governments have managed a 'pay as you go' system. Instead of investing our oil revenues to create a funded system, and/or a Norwegian-style sovereign wealth fund, unfortunately we spent them.

The older generation need to understand that, and that everything they take - in state pensions, benefits and healthcare, is being paid for by their children and in some cases grand-children.

SueVineer · 09/08/2023 11:43

LovelyJubbly12345 · 09/08/2023 11:24

What?

So are you saying when you are a pensioner, and you have paid ta and NI for 40+ years, you won't really deserve a pension, because the current work force are actually paying your pension? I don't get your point at all.

Op, they HAVE paid in all their lives. And now they get to retire and be in receipt of a pension. And the same will happen to you.

I have no idea what you're annoyed about (apart from the migrant thing).

Young peoples taxes are paying the current pensioners pensions and other benefits. It sounds like ops grandparents were never net contributors. Also young people already have to wait much longer and contribute more before they can get a state pension. That’s if there is a state pension at all when they get there.

the state pension is around 10% of all government spending and there are significant pressures on public finances. Yet pensioners (the wealthiest demographic - many of whom are millionaires) got a huge increase in state pension- higher than eg nhs workers. I’m not far off pension age but I can see how unfair that is.

the problem is that pensioners vote and younger people don’t. They need to sort that.

midlifecrash · 09/08/2023 11:42

What some people seem to think is that their taxes and NI go into a separate shoebox for them. It doesn’t work like this. Any welfare benefits including pensions can only be paid from current state revenue, ie generated from taxes and NI of people currently working. Where there are shortfalls in workers as there are in many sectors this affects the amount of revenue. So immigration is important to the pensions that people are currently receiving today

floribunda18 · 09/08/2023 11:40

LovelyJubbly12345 · 09/08/2023 11:24

What?

So are you saying when you are a pensioner, and you have paid ta and NI for 40+ years, you won't really deserve a pension, because the current work force are actually paying your pension? I don't get your point at all.

Op, they HAVE paid in all their lives. And now they get to retire and be in receipt of a pension. And the same will happen to you.

I have no idea what you're annoyed about (apart from the migrant thing).

I'm not sure where I said or implied that they did not deserve a state pension. Just pointing out the reality that the current workforce are actually supporting them in their retirement.

I very much hope that state pension is actually a thing in 20 years time and that they don't keep moving the goal posts as to when you can receive it. At least there are fewer of us to support in Gen X.

Rosiem2808 · 09/08/2023 11:40

I'm a pensioner. I don't get full pension due to some glitch when I was not working when I had children. I also am one of those women who didn't qualify for my pension until I was 66.
I struggle with money after having worked all my adult life. This is not the fault of any government. My own personal circumstances caused my current situation and there is nothing I can do about it. I do not get enough money to pay my fuel bills and am having to use savings to top up my pension. I receive three quarters of the state pension and a tiny works pension which together make up the full state pension.
I am not grumbling but I have worked hard and at the age of 68 I am looking for work as my savings are dwindling.
It's not ideal but I am not complaining. I am grateful for my pension, but wish it could be the full amount.
I think people who complain are usually the ones who are better off anyway !

cansu · 09/08/2023 11:39

Agree but they will never see it. My parents are exactly the same. They don't say things like sink the boats but they have little sympathy and think that immigration is a problem. They don't for example consider the number of people from overseas working in and propping up our health and social care sector.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 11:38

So are you saying when you are a pensioner, and you have paid ta and NI for 40+ years, you won't really deserve a pension, because the current work force are actually paying your pension? I don't get your point at all.

Op, they HAVE paid in all their lives. And now they get to retire and be in receipt of a pension. And the same will happen to you.

How will the same happen to anyone under 40?
Pension age is moving out although healthy life expectancy hasn't increased, prescriptions won't be free for over 60s as now. NHS won't be the same model, etc, etc,

Lots of people who get pensions now haven't paid 40 yrs of tax & NI. And for those that did the contributions weren't exactly high. I paid NI as a 17 yr old with a holiday/weekend job.

olivehaters · 09/08/2023 11:36

You know paying in isn't just about taxes. My Dh is a high rate tax payer. He also earns money from foreign corporations putting money straight into the economy. My dad worked abroad for quite a few years. Some people questioned whether he should be able to use the nhs. But all the money he earned he sent back home being spent in the uk economy. i work for the nhs so I probably don't pay in as much as i get out but Contribute to society in other ways by doing a job that helps others. Many public servants pay in less than they get out. But they are still contributing. Volunteers, carers. These people also contribute to ouf society.

Basketballqueen · 09/08/2023 11:36

It's frustrating but if you explained the economics of buying a house now on current salaries versus what they earned/paid they probably wouldn't listen.

My otherwise sensible Ddad ventured the opinion that the council are building new houses specifically for illegal immigrants, just them no-one else. It's straight off a small boat into luxury accommodation with all benefits according to him.
.His local council haven't built new housing in over 30 years for anyone. Logically his knows this but his mates and the local rag he reads trot out this nonsense all the time.
He also knows that some refugees are being housed in an old hotel that had closed and re-opened just for this purpose. He's outraged about that too even though it's a dump with no facilities that had gone bust. Never stayed there, never wanted to but now it's been 'taken' for 'illegals'.

I asked him which it was? Are they getting purpose built flats, or being housed in a 1 star dump?

I hope to fuck we are never in a position where we have to flee our country an rely on the charity of others.

MrsKeats · 09/08/2023 11:36

This makes me so annoyed too.
All the 'Oh we worked hard to retire early' crap.
Yes as your state pension kicked in at 60.

SueVineer · 09/08/2023 11:35

UnderHisEyeOverMyDeadBody · 09/08/2023 10:35

YANBU.

I hate it when people say things like “I’ve paid in, so I deserve it”.

No, Jessica, you haven’t and won’t ever have put enough in “the system” with your low paid job for all of two years, council house and three kids, and neither did your parents.

The majority of people are not net contributers and take out far more than they can ever hope to put back in.

This. It’s the entitlement that gets me. You’re right- in their situation would indicate that they are net takers from the state. Same with a lot of pensioners- if you argue against the state pension for the wealthy, they are up in arms as they claim “they paid in”. Yet often nothing like enough for a state pension.

Tomatina · 09/08/2023 11:34

Well obviously their views sound unpleasant, racist and selfish. But I hope you won't make the mistake of assuming a whole generation (millions of people) are like your grandparents. That's as silly as the people who say 'all millennials are snowflakes blah blah'.

Jamtartforme · 09/08/2023 11:31

LakeTiticaca · 09/08/2023 11:28

I assume you will turn down any inheritance they may leave you in their will.

It’s not the inheritance OP has a problem with. It’s the refusal to acknowledge the privilege they have had and instead chalking their situation up to their own ‘hard work’. There wouldn’t be an issue if they acknowledged they’ve been very lucky compared to others.

MagpiePi · 09/08/2023 11:29

They do know that pensions form the biggest proportion of the welfare benefits that are paid out? It's not the 'scrounging single mums' or refugees who are pushing welfare spending so high!

LakeTiticaca · 09/08/2023 11:28

I assume you will turn down any inheritance they may leave you in their will.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 09/08/2023 11:27

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/08/2023 11:13

Ultimately it’s the fault of a taxation system which continues to break taxation down into income tax and national insurance - the latter giving many people the idea that there’s some sort of designated pot in their name in government coffers which they’ve paid their “stamp” into and that’s where their pension and benefits are coming from. Everything just goes into the same place, so we need to make that clear and stop giving the impression otherwise.

This is a bit of an over simplification - some benefits including state pension are contingent upon contributions, and specifically NI contributions.

LovelyJubbly12345 · 09/08/2023 11:25

tax and NI