Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?

413 replies

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

OP posts:
dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:48

Another huge problem with the social contract is the demographic changes. I think in the 60s it was 5 workers to 1 pensioner now it's 3:1 but it's forecasted to be 2:1 How you fund social care & the NHS with that ratio I have no clue.

Jamtartforme · 09/08/2023 12:48

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 12:41

But the vast majority of pensioners have worked all their lives, paid and are paying all the taxes asked of them. Just like OP’s grandparents. Just what do you actually want of us? Apart from conveniently dropping dead on the our 66th birthdays?

Sorry but that simply isn’t true. I’m not judging in a moral sense, it’s just a fact.

Only 57% of women of working age actually worked in the 1970s. It hovered around this figure until the late 90s.

You can’t say the VAST majority of women worked all their lives, otherwise who were all these women out of work?

User6424678852 · 09/08/2023 12:46

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:42

Yes, I remember being one of the younger people frustrated about it back in the early 90s.

Personally I think housing/childcare etc costs have changed a lot since then.

I’m pretty sure that can be accepted as fact rather than opinion.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:44

But the vast majority of pensioners have worked all their lives, paid and are paying all the taxes asked of them

Is there statistics that show most of todays pensioners worked all their lives?

Just what do you actually want of us? Apart from conveniently dropping dead on the our 66th birthdays?

I'm confused why you have conflated me saying not every pensioner has worked & paid taxes all their lives = kill them all at 66...

CerberusWoof · 09/08/2023 12:44

There is a generally agreed social contract, codified through law and taxation, that includes able-bodied people of working age now paying a portion of their income to support those who can't support themselves (children, the elderly, the infirm, the unemployed) now. That's how it works.

When your parents were younger they were part of this system. They may have been net contributors, despite being provided with a council house, I don't know. Now that they're old, they're still part of this system.

So yes, they're right in that they paid in when they were (maybe) on the giving end of the system, so it would be unfair for them not to be supported now that they're definitely on the receiving end.

However they're wrong, in that none of that makes them any more entitled to what they receive than the other various beneficiaries of the state - children needing schools, the unemployed and low paid needing housing benefit etc. As others have pointed out, there is no ledger balancing what they paid in 50 years ago with what they receive now (and if there were they might be surprised how lucky they actually are), only a ledger balancing what other people pay in now with what they and all other recipients receive now.

The large scale societal factors affecting that - the aging population, the exponentially increasing burden on the NHS and social care, the changes in the nature and economy of housing etc - are realities that we all have to accept, and that will have an effect on that balance.

Not that I'd expect them to be able to understand or accept any of this, of course.

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 09/08/2023 12:43

Oh, and I’m still paying tax so in effect, part funding my own state pension.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:42

Yes, I remember being one of the younger people frustrated about it back in the early 90s.

Personally I think housing/childcare etc costs have changed a lot since then.

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 09/08/2023 12:41

I have been in receipt of a state pension for five years. Before this I worked for forty-seven years with no breaks in employment, paying tax and NI for all this time. These deductions from my salary were helping to pay for other people’s children’s healthcare and education. I was also helping towards the maternity care of women and also child benefit. As a child free woman I didn’t benefit from any of this. However, this is how society works. We contribute towards the care of others and in the main it’s reciprocal. Just keep this in mind while you insinuate that pensioners are scrounging off you.

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 12:41

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:36

But the minute they became pensioners they became hardworking people who have paid in all their life.

It's a really strange narrative, everyone denigrated the work shy, feckless etc but apparently these never existed in the past & some in fact are todays pensioners 😱

But the vast majority of pensioners have worked all their lives, paid and are paying all the taxes asked of them. Just like OP’s grandparents. Just what do you actually want of us? Apart from conveniently dropping dead on the our 66th birthdays?

User6424678852 · 09/08/2023 12:41

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:38

It’s a social contract.

I think a lot of younger people are frustrated because they feel the social contract is broken i.e they can't afford housing, lack of social housing, can't afford childcare or to have dc, wage stagnation etc.

Yes, I remember being one of the younger people frustrated about it back in the early 90s.

However, it is a social contract that is still in place.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:38

It’s a social contract.

I think a lot of younger people are frustrated because they feel the social contract is broken i.e they can't afford housing, lack of social housing, can't afford childcare or to have dc, wage stagnation etc.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:36

But the minute they became pensioners they became hardworking people who have paid in all their life.

It's a really strange narrative, everyone denigrated the work shy, feckless etc but apparently these never existed in the past & some in fact are todays pensioners 😱

MotherofGorgons · 09/08/2023 12:36

Nothing to do with them being elderly. Plenty of elderly people don't support children drowning or people being on benefits. If that bit is true.

User6424678852 · 09/08/2023 12:36

You are conflating a lot of different things, so your AIBU is unclear.

They sound like unpleasant people so YANBU to dislike them ir their opinions.

However WRT benefits for older people YABU. It’s a social contract. Some people will get more out than they paid in (like your parents) and some will pay more in than they get out.

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 12:35

SuperiorM · 09/08/2023 12:30

Sorry, but yes they did pay in and expect the system to work. Successive govts - sadly not all nasty Conservatives - have undermined this.

Exactly. Successive governments of both persuasions have completely failed to plan for the biggest generation growing old, yet somehow it’s the fault of people who had no control over the time of their birth. Crazy.

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:35

Absolutely this!!! This thread is hateful and the people posting vile things about elderly people are everything and worse than the things you are calling op's grandparents!

Hateful? 🙄

BoredZelda · 09/08/2023 12:35

I think the biggest irony they seem to miss is, whilst they bang on about being treated fairly and getting all the thinks they think they deserve, the younger generations are paying for it, and will continue to, in a way that will leave them worse off than today's pensioners. And yet they still call the younger generations "entitled".

I also think of their youthful days, in the 70s and 80s where benefits were easier to get, the iconic dole bludger was really a thing, and large numbers were on sick pay (a government con to keep unemployment numbers low). Two or three generations of families who never worked again after the heavy industry shut down. But the minute they became pensioners they became hardworking people who have paid in all their life.

I think it's great we no longer have big numbers of pensioners in poverty. We really do look after our old people better than we used to. I just wish it wasn't at the expense of the young and other vulnerable people.

gettingoldisshit · 09/08/2023 12:32

MrsMarzetti · 09/08/2023 11:07

You slate them but my god you are not so bloody wonderful yourself. To rip your Grandparents to shreds on SM is beyond low, maybe you would rather they gave up the myriad of health treatments ( i take it you won't ever use the NHS) One day they will be gone and when you stand at their graves your scathing attack may just come back to haunt you.

Absolutely this!!! This thread is hateful and the people posting vile things about elderly people are everything and worse than the things you are calling op's grandparents!

cloudydays97 · 09/08/2023 12:32

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

If they're this discriminatory be honest and tell them, go NC don't just post on Mumsnet. Will you be happy to accept an inheritance from them? Just wondering how far your morals go

LakeTiticaca · 09/08/2023 12:32

My late DF, who was born in the 20s into a family of 11, no inside bathroom, toilet, central heating no NHS or welfare handouts, lost his father as a young child through terrible illness caused by poor working conditions (no health &safety back then)had a favourite saying to us kids: "you lot don't you're born"
How right he was.
I don't know what he would think of all these illegal immigrants complaining because they don't like the accommodation they have been provided with.
My guess is his opinion would be like the MP, F.Off back to France if you don't like it!!

TheGreyRockess · 09/08/2023 12:31

Do they read the Daily Mail or the Express? Some readers' minds get poisoned and they turn into entitled, self interested ladder-pulling racists.

SuperiorM · 09/08/2023 12:30

Sorry, but yes they did pay in and expect the system to work. Successive govts - sadly not all nasty Conservatives - have undermined this.

MotherofGorgons · 09/08/2023 12:29

If you are as condemnatory to others as you are to your older relatives, and can only tolerate views aligned wholly with your own, then you will have a poor, unenriched life.

I don't think I am very judgy, but I do require that people I spend time with not applaud little kids drowning because they had the bad luck to be born in the wrong country. Guess my life will be devoid of rich meaning.

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 12:29

dramoy · 09/08/2023 12:20

I started paying tax when I was 18 and will still be paying it until the day I die.

Is that not the same for many others?

Of course it is. It also means that it’s entirely true for me to say that I’ve paid in all my life. I don’t understand why this fact is apparently so contentious.

LemonTT · 09/08/2023 12:28

I think there are very few people who were borne in the 1940’s and grew up in council housing (limited at that time anyway) who inherited generational wealth in red wall areas as described in this post.

The OPs grandparents situation is very unusual a doesn’t tell us much about much. The wealth disparity and inequalities in this country are between the SE and basically everywhere else apart from a few university cities.

The working classes did not create the gap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread