Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“We paid in all our lives”: AIBU to think, No you didn’t?

413 replies

Perlman · 09/08/2023 09:44

My grandparents are traditional red wall labour voters. Born during WWII to poor families, they live where they grew up. My grandad worked in a factory and my nan worked as a secretary. Like many of their generation, they lived in and bought their council house. Very caring people until it comes to politics. They are hugely racist and advocate for sinking any refugee boats. This is despite the fact that some of their grandparents were refugees from Russia!

They want the triple lock, free bus passes, heating allowance, increased benefits for older people, et cetera. They think anyone who isn’t old who takes benefits is a scrounger and lazy. They say young people can’t afford to buy a house because they are lazy. They have inherited several, but put down their relatively comfortable position in retirement as to their ‘hard work’.

They justify their opinions and entitlement by saying “we paid in all ours lives, it’s our money”. AIBU to think that, well no, not really. You may have paid in money through taxation but clearly they are net beneficiaries of the state. They both had low paid jobs, bought and sold on their council house for a tidy profit, have thankfully lived a long life but with a myriad of expensive to treat health problems. So no, they haven’t paid for what they’re taking!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pottedpalm · 16/10/2023 07:55

@FlemishHorse I think Mnet threw this up and I thought I was on the latest ageist shit thread about winter fuel payments

Wonkasworld · 15/10/2023 22:45

Well a according to MN, all OAPs vote Tory hmmm..

FlemishHorse · 15/10/2023 22:37

Pottedpalm · 15/10/2023 16:57

Well done, @Blossomtoes ! The ageist shit on this thread is disgusting.

A bit ZOMBIE ageist shit, though, no one will read if, why not start a new thread?

Anonymouseposter · 15/10/2023 22:16

I haven't read the full thread.
Your grandparents have some abhorrent views about refugees, OP. Sadly these views are not confined to one age group in our society and not all pensioners share them.
This is where posts become ageist. It isn't ageist to criticise your grandparents but it is ageist to stereotype all older people in a negative way.
After WW2 National Insurance was sold to the population as just that, a state insurance scheme which you paid into and drew upon in periods of sickness, unemployment and at retirement. Social security was separate, it was a cushion to provide a minimum income for those whose insurance wasn't adequate. That is why many older people say they have "paid in all their lives", because that's how they understand it.
The model was also based on a male breadwinner and housewife and women born in the 1940s and early 1950s have got caught up in the change to treating males and females as individuals.
The benefits system has changed a lot and some older people still see things as they used to be.
Some may be out of touch with the current housing crisis etc for younger people but surely most have children and grandchildren and can't really miss it.
Some older people help younger family members out a lot, some are self centered and don't chose to see what goes on . It's ageist to generalise.

pollyglot · 15/10/2023 19:27

I was at secondary school in the 1960s, when it was still the norm to draft girls into streams - professional (Latin and French), less professional(French) i.e. designed for girls going in to nursing, primary teaching, banks, Commercial (typing and shorthand, core maths) and Homecraft (human biology, cooking, sewing, typing, art). Your future career was set in stone at age 12.
By Year 13, there were 36 girls left at that level, out of a school of 1200. They were destined for secondary teaching, medicine, physiotherapy, library school, and a few pioneers in law.
Now aged 70+, most of these 36 girls, contrary to the norm to the time, worked professionally and raised children. They paid taxes...in many cases, large amounts of tax. Thing is, there are now only 24 of them alive. Isn't it generous of old people, having poured money into the pension coffers to then thoughtfully pass on without benefitting from their contributions?

NalafromtheLionKing · 15/10/2023 17:51

RosesAndHellebores · 09/08/2023 11:47

Between us DH and I have worked for more than 70 years. We will both get our full state pensions and generous private pensions. We will continue paying tax until we die. We have put in a huge amount and I have no objection to providing benefits for those who need them. I do object to those who don't need them getting more than they should.

I have an underlying chronic health condition and the NHS has denied me optimal treatment for it because the bar has been raised by NICE. I am funding a two year course of anabolic injectables personally to help prevent further deterioration to my bones. I am lucky that I have the £2400 handy.

I think it would be helpful if every baby started with a personal state spends account to which could be added the cost of medical care and education, then benefits and pensions, with the tax and NI payments added throughout their lives. It would then be clear who were net contributors to society and what individuals had cost compared to what they put in.

How would this help? Do you mean that net contributors should have higher state pensions and access to better treatments on the NHS than net beneficiaries?

Pottedpalm · 15/10/2023 16:57

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 18:55

  1. We need subsidised childcare in a hurry as its hampering women from working and damaging the economy.

To fund this you make every employer pay women equally, crack down on absent fathers and incentivise employers to set up high quality nurseries

2. The NHS is near collapse because the pensioners do not pay in (no NI) and heavily use the system.

The NHS is near collapse became it has a huge shortage of qualified staff. To address this you allow qualified doctors and dentists awaiting assessment as asylum seekers to work. You make it a condition of NHS funded training that at least five years are worked in the NHS post qualification and you don’t write off student debt if they emigrate. You also reopen step down beds so older patients aren’t readmitted as fast as they’re discharged.

3. Local Authorities are broke

You fund extra revenue by updating the banding system from 1991 home values to 2022 home values, and you add in a few more upper bands. And the all the young families will pay shedloads more council tax as well as sky high mortgages and extortionate childcare

Fixed it for you.

Well done, @Blossomtoes ! The ageist shit on this thread is disgusting.

SequentialAnalyst · 21/08/2023 12:28

So sorry about lack of formatting. First two paragraphs are a quote from @Howmuchfurther

SequentialAnalyst · 21/08/2023 12:27

He devalued degrees to the extent that a young person leaving university now has the employability of a young person leaving school with A-levels in the 1990s.

He dealt with unemployment by warehousing young people in universities and forcing them to pay for the three years they were excluded from the work place.

Well, this is true. When I went to university in the 1970s, I was one of only 5% who did so. This is one reason why the country could fund me, through the Local Authority where I was resident with my parents.

Of course, in 1997 when Blair became Prime Minister, parents of the time still wanted their children to go to university. Blair found a way for nearly 50% to do so, which of course could not be afforded through the grant system. The terms on which loans were made were fair, and there were fair thresholds for income level at which interest was payable. A friend's daughter had 2 years' loan knocked off, because she used her degree to teach for 2 years (IUIC), This gradually changed over the years, but for some people, especially those with mental health issues, it has enable them to take a degree, usually in Art from looking at my friends) without worrying about paying it back, as they know they will never earn enough to do.

It also lead to the devaluing of degrees, the multiplication of soft degrees such as media studies, the overworking of academics, and the transition of the university model from one of providing rigorous academic research and teaching to one based on business and the bottom line.

Flopsythebunny · 20/08/2023 16:40

MrsKeats · 09/08/2023 13:24

True pip and not to mention free higher education.

For the chosen few. I for many working class people, particularly women, higher education was not an option. They left school on Friday and we're expected to be working and contributing from the Monday

Howmuchfurther · 20/08/2023 16:04

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 17:02

This is why I’d never vote Tory @Howmuchfurther

What’s crippling the country is the bunch of incompetent, avaricious charlatans who are pretending to run the country while lining their and their cronies’ pockets. The insane amount of our money paying the national debt. Taxation that’s at its highest for 70 years. Liz Truss cost this country £30 billion in 49 days. Looking at a group of the population and blaming them is exactly what they want, while you’re busy doing that they’re getting away with God knows what.

I remember the Blair years when the number of children living in poverty went down every year, when foodbanks weren’t needed and NHS waiting lists were almost non existent. It’s unlikely to ever be that good again in my lifetime but t would be nice to try.

Certainly the worst human rights abuse of my lifetime was the great tyranny of 2020-2021 under the Tories.

However Blair was the second worst prime minister.

He killed hundreds of thousands and destabilised a region.

He devalued degrees to the extent that a young person leaving university now has the employability of a young person leaving school with A-levels in the 1990s.

He dealt with unemployment by warehousing young people in universities and forcing them to pay for the three years they were excluded from the work place.

He created public sector jobs. Unlike unemployment, this is a permanent cost.

Fluffypuppy1 · 19/08/2023 18:37

SueVineer · 19/08/2023 17:21

The generation we’re talking about is ops parents who would have been born well after the war.

OP is talking about her grandparents, who she says were born during WW11.

Squirrelsnut · 19/08/2023 18:11

fuchiaknickers · 14/08/2023 18:26

this with bells on

Absolutely.

JudgeJ · 19/08/2023 17:54

theyareonlynoodlesmichael · 09/08/2023 11:05

How is this ageist?

Are older family members exempt from criticism?

Of course not everyone can be criticised but it's a fact that on MN certain groups are exempt!

SequentialAnalyst · 19/08/2023 17:41

Yes, my own generation - I am early 70s. We grew up expecting our lives to be the ones our parents and their parents, the voters of post-war Britain, hoped for us. However, the world has changed so much, in so many ways. My great-aunts, who both lived till I was in my 30's, and who were among the million Surplus Women for whom there were no young men to marry, couldn't even vote until they were 28. Their lives and society changed greatly during their lifetimes. It's the same in my case. I suspect it's the same in every human being's case, if they live long enough.

My DM, who was caught out by NI as described above, is still alive. DF, whose State Pension entitlement passed to her after his death, died in 2016. This is living memory I'm talking about.

SueVineer · 19/08/2023 17:21

SequentialAnalyst · 14/08/2023 18:19

My DF was at El Alamein. In South London, my DM heard doodlebugs go over, and sometimes explode nearby, in her teens.

She also paid the Married Women's rate of NI when she was working, before and sometimes during, her marriage. It was lower because it was expected that her DH would eventually claim State Pension for both of them. This was normal.

Unfortunately, she continued at that rate after they separated, instead of paying the normal NI rate, so got only a tiny pension at 60. By this time she also had a small mortgage, and had to plead with her employer to let her continue working for a year after the then women's retirement age so she could pay it off. The right to work after retirement age is quite recent, I think?

As they never divorced, when DF died in 2016, she finally got an increased State Pension.

The generation we’re talking about is ops parents who would have been born well after the war.

Harrypewter · 18/08/2023 12:42

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2023 09:19

Boomers saw unprecedented wage increases and gains of upto 5000% on property values.

Blimey, where were those houses for a fiver in the 70s and 80s? Everyone who bought before 2009 has seen similar increases, not just boomers. Definitely not 5000% though, that’s absurd.

My parents' house was purchased for £3000 but has increased in value by over 5000%. Additionally, 20% of baby boomers own a second home, leading to a transfer of wealth from young renters to older property owners. Baby boomers own the majority of UK privately held housing wealth, with those over 65 owning £2.587 trillion in net property value.
This demographic is also causing strain on the NHS and road networks, (costing my business £78000 plus VAT annually). However, their ability to pootle about is not impacted.

Property - latest news, breaking stories and comment - Evening Standard

Latest London news, business, sport, showbiz and entertainment from the London Evening Standard.

https://www.standard.co.uk/topic/property

KimberleyClark · 18/08/2023 08:27

SequentialAnalyst · 15/08/2023 13:56

And, IF WE ARE LUCKY, the experience of being the grandchildren of people who lived through two world wars in 40 years.

My DF was in Burma during WW2. DFIL was in North Africa.

Seymour5 · 18/08/2023 08:17

TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 17:52

Your parents did not fight any war.

Enough with the delusional "war this or that"

Its a farce. The people that actually endured the war are all 90+ now.

The 60 to 80 group in no way endured a "war"

Its pure nonsense.

Mine did. Parents born pre 1910, my father was in the army from 1939-1945. I’m a boomer, he died suddenly when I was in my teens, he never had good health after WWII but never stopped working. My mother was widowed in her 50s, lived in private rented housing all her life, had to find work as a widow, went cleaning, then housekeeping til she was 70. Rationing was still in force when I was a child. Society was far less consumerist, little exposure to luxury.

I’m of the last generation where women in some employment had to resign on marriage, where there was little childcare, no child benefit for the first child, and no NI credits for SAHMs. My state pension is about half of the basic, old state pension. Fortunately I have a small occupational pension, but as pointed out earlier in this thread, that is just enough to preclude DH and I from Pension Credit and its add ons. Neither of our incomes is above the threshhold for income tax, but as a couple we can afford to pay our bills, although fuel costs were scary last winter. Very grateful for the WFA. DH has a health condition where he feels the cold more than me.

We have a small house, not worth anywhere near those of my Gen X children. But if they inherit it (no care home fees we hope) then the grandchildren will benefit. We had children fairly young, the norm for our age group, DC established themselves first, and are heading for much more comfortable retirements. They may not even get state pensions, if the government brings in means testing.

I think in general my generation did have opportunities, but I also believe we were generally resilient. Many were brought up in poor, overcrowded housing, council housing was more expensive than slums, and was unaffordable for many. Benefits were minimal, unemployment meant taking any job or losing them. The mindset was different, there was little if any entitlement. Buying a house was considered a risk, and for many by the 1980s, it was. The double figure interest rates meant repossession for some, we hung on by a thread.

Moglet4 · 18/08/2023 06:40

The figures are from the ONS. The opportunities for boomers specifically? Not paying for university if you were going (not many did, but the opportunity was there), lower proportion of income being required for a house deposit, final salary pensions…. yes, expectations and so on were different and yes, every generation has its challenges but for a generation which has had the most out of the benefit system than any other before or after them to point the finger (which is what the poster I was responding to was doing) and declare that subsequent generations are just lazy is disgusting.

SequentialAnalyst · 15/08/2023 13:56

And, IF WE ARE LUCKY, the experience of being the grandchildren of people who lived through two world wars in 40 years.

SequentialAnalyst · 15/08/2023 13:55

And we certainly have the experience of being the children of those people that lived through the war.

And the experience of being the grandchildren of people who lived through two world wars in 40 years.

For younger PP:
I suggest going on Ancestry and finding out your own ancestors. Or watch a few episodes of Who Do You Think You Are. Watch some of the Back in Time series by the BBC. Then you will have more idea of how things which are historical events to you, are still in active living memory eg in a relative of mine in their late 90s, and will be able to understand how everyone is, has been or (hopefully) will be: young, middle aged, old.

User6424678852 · 15/08/2023 11:08

DougtheSpud · 15/08/2023 10:55

That always baffles me how people who never fought in a war like to bring it up like they did. There was hardship after, sure, but it's not the same. 10 years later there was a huge boom period.

You’re right, it’s not the same.

The phrase usually used is “lived through the war”, meaning endured the hardship of the 2nd world war. Which both of my (living) parents did.

This is of course not the same as fighting in a war, which my father also did.

DougtheSpud · 15/08/2023 10:55

TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 17:52

Your parents did not fight any war.

Enough with the delusional "war this or that"

Its a farce. The people that actually endured the war are all 90+ now.

The 60 to 80 group in no way endured a "war"

Its pure nonsense.

That always baffles me how people who never fought in a war like to bring it up like they did. There was hardship after, sure, but it's not the same. 10 years later there was a huge boom period.

Seymour5 · 14/08/2023 22:49

My dad was in Le Havre, demobbed in 1945 at 41, died before he was 60. I don’t remember him ever having good health, although he worked. My parents weren’t home owners, DH and I bought because we couldn’t get a council house, being newcomers to an area in the 70s. Our house won’t pay care fees for long. We’re int’ North.

Thank goodness the DC don’t need it! We scraped a deposit, and struggled with the mortgage in the 80s. Saddens me that perhaps we should have spent more when we were young, on holidays and other nice things, but we wanted to have a house, and eventually leave its value to our DC or the grandchildren. I just hope neither of us need care.