Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Granparent overreacting?

305 replies

Cantsleep23 · 08/08/2023 22:43

Me and my partner had a baby only 4 months ago and we both said we wouldn't be allowing her to be away from us until we feel ready ourselves, she's my partners first child. My partners stepmum, who he classes as his mum has asked if she can take our daughter out for a few hours to spend some time with her. We have said we are happy for her to come and visit her at our home or we would meet her for tea but would rather she didn't take her out without us until she's older (around the time she wanted to pick her up she would be due a bottle and a sleep) we've tried to be polite and tell her were not ready for her to be away from us yet but she's taken it the totally wrong way and has said "oh so we can only have supervised visits" and "she's our bloody granddaughter" and just not taking our feelings into consideration.
My partner works away Alot so hasn't managed to get the bond with her that he wants so he's wanting to spend as much time with her as he can before he has to work away again and I work part time so I've obviously got the bond with her
Are we being unreasonable with the grandparents for telling them they can spend the time with her while she's with us? They have 3 other grandchildren who they are "popping round to see" so why do they only want to take our baby out for a few hours? We are feeling really under pressure to have to say yes to them and let them take her but we don't want to

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 11/08/2023 13:05

Lolaandbehold · 11/08/2023 12:47

Your child, your rules but I think you're being a bit "pfb" about the whole thing. When I opened the thread I assumed you were going to say they wanted her overnight, and you not wanting to wouldn't seem unreasonable at 4 months. But they don't. A few hours while they take her for a walk, to me that would be a godsend. You do you, OP but when the shoe is on the other foot and you need them to help out when she's a bit older, don't expect them to come running.

By the when, when if you ever get to the stage where you have 2 toddlers and 1 newborn, you'll be happily handing the newborn over, at 4 weeks, never mind 4 months! :-)

A few hours while they take her for a walk, to me that would be a godsend. You do you, OP but when the shoe is on the other foot and you need them to help out when she's a bit older, don't expect them to come running.

OP is not you and many other women don’t want to be away from their babies when they’re 4 mo and this SMIL only wants to have said baby on her terms alone and is unwilling to compromise even spending time with baby with its parents present or nearby. It’s not her baby and with the way this woman is having a toddler tantrum over not getting her way, OP wouldn’t want her help anyway. Same SMiL has fallen out with other family members with a baby for the same situation. Anyone with that level entitlement over someone else’s baby doesn’t deserve alone time and shows they can’t be trusted to respect simple boundaries.

JANEY205 · 11/08/2023 13:00

Brokendaughter · 11/08/2023 12:58

It's your choice of course & if you don't feel comfortable then don't do it.
I see why you might not want someone to take your child overnight, but for a couple of hours in the afternoon one day seems a bit mean.

Just don't ask the very people you are actively stopping building a bond with your child for any babysitting in a couple of years time & then post whinging they won't take your child for the day when it suits you.

Family are family all the time, not just when you feel like using them.

I wouldn’t want someone who cut off their other grandchildren because they couldn’t have them at a specific time looking after my child anyway. Signs of a serious issue with their personality and being unhinged. So I’d have no issues there. And actually it is up to parents when their children go with other people.

JANEY205 · 11/08/2023 12:58

DiabolicalFinial · 11/08/2023 12:37

Where, exactly, did the SMIL want to take your baby (at that precise time/day/etc)? Did you ever find out where/why she wanted to take the other grandchild previously? To not talk to them for 2 years because they said she wasn’t taking out a tiny baby is just bizarre. Stick to your decisions and boundaries, OP - I think you’ll need your wits about you!

I wonder if she wanted to take them somewhere to show them off? The exact time or she has a temper tantrum is really strange. I’d be really wary of this person.

Brokendaughter · 11/08/2023 12:58

It's your choice of course & if you don't feel comfortable then don't do it.
I see why you might not want someone to take your child overnight, but for a couple of hours in the afternoon one day seems a bit mean.

Just don't ask the very people you are actively stopping building a bond with your child for any babysitting in a couple of years time & then post whinging they won't take your child for the day when it suits you.

Family are family all the time, not just when you feel like using them.

JANEY205 · 11/08/2023 12:56

Cantsleep23 · 10/08/2023 15:36

Mil wanted her at a set time on a set day, no compromise, literally her way or no way. We never physically said the word NO to her but gave her the option to come round or even meet us for some food. she lives a good 10 miles away and involves one of us doing a short motorway journey which I was happy to do but it weren't good enough. I have also found out today that the same thing happened with one of her other grandchildren and she wanted to take him off for a few hours and was told he was too young by both his mum and dad and that resulted in mil not talking to them for nearly 2 years
Yes I am happy to pay my children to look after their sister when her dad is away. She is at home last feed around 7.30 belly settled bath and bed. As crazy as it might seem, it's like our baby knows her own routine already and we don't want her routine being disrupted just so mil can have her own way

Really really strange! I have a narcissistic step MIL who overreacts like this and cut us off for a similar slight. It’s been over a year now and we don’t miss her at all and honestly are glad to be drama free! Anyone who can cut their grandchild and child off for 2 years because they were told no isnt someone that should be caring for a baby alone. It shows really worrying personality traits! Please protect your baby and yourself from someone who is happy to trample others and discard them as it suits them. Despicable really and I hope the parents of the other grandchild are wary of her too! I’m sure they are. She is batshit OP and I wouldn’t leave my child with her regardless.

Yesabsolutely · 11/08/2023 12:54

Zebedee55 · 10/08/2023 08:10

My mum never demanded anything, but she used to take DD to the park, in her pram, for an hour or two, so I could have a nap in peace and quiet.

I found it quite helpful.

This.My Mum had my babies for an hour or two regularly ,so I could have my arms back for a while .

Lolaandbehold · 11/08/2023 12:47

Your child, your rules but I think you're being a bit "pfb" about the whole thing. When I opened the thread I assumed you were going to say they wanted her overnight, and you not wanting to wouldn't seem unreasonable at 4 months. But they don't. A few hours while they take her for a walk, to me that would be a godsend. You do you, OP but when the shoe is on the other foot and you need them to help out when she's a bit older, don't expect them to come running.

By the when, when if you ever get to the stage where you have 2 toddlers and 1 newborn, you'll be happily handing the newborn over, at 4 weeks, never mind 4 months! :-)

GG1986 · 11/08/2023 12:46

You said no and that's that! If you give in then they will keep asking. She's your baby and still so little.

JANEY205 · 11/08/2023 12:46

No she’s being weird. Has she offered to take your other children out?

phoenixrosehere · 11/08/2023 12:45

AuntieJune · 11/08/2023 11:07

She's being unreasonable for demanding to have the baby alone on a particular day at a particular time.

However I don't really understand why you let your older children have sole charge of the baby but not the step-granny. Do you not want her to have the baby on her own ever, or just not now, or just not out of the house? Would she be able to babysit one evening when you're at work?

If you don't trust her to take care of the baby ever, that is a bigger problem your DP is going to need to get involved in.

If I were you, I'd seek a compromise like she comes round and looks after the baby at your house while you have a shower etc, then build up from there.

OP has already said they have offered suggestions and compromises but the Step MIL doesn’t want to and only wants to spend time with OP’s baby alone.

User3735 · 11/08/2023 12:42

That isn't a normal grandparent request in my experience. I didn't let mine go with anyone until their were at least 1, usually later. No way would I let a 4 month old go, but I did breastfeed so that made it easier to decide.

NIparty · 11/08/2023 12:40

ArcticSkewer · 10/08/2023 13:08

Again, really would you want to be dependent on someone for childcare when you go to a paid job if they are that stroppy and want everything their way or they throw a tantrum?

Why would that be a good idea?

When you have any kind of alternative at all really

I'm also assuming the times when OP is working is not the time MIL wants to "help"

DiabolicalFinial · 11/08/2023 12:37

Where, exactly, did the SMIL want to take your baby (at that precise time/day/etc)? Did you ever find out where/why she wanted to take the other grandchild previously? To not talk to them for 2 years because they said she wasn’t taking out a tiny baby is just bizarre. Stick to your decisions and boundaries, OP - I think you’ll need your wits about you!

DaisyAndDonaldDuck · 11/08/2023 12:22

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 11/08/2023 11:39

Except for 10 hours at nursery I presume...that seems to be acceptable on MN but God forbid a MIL grandparent.

Very, very few people are putting their four month old baby in nursery.

PensionPuzzle · 11/08/2023 12:18

ArcticSkewer · 10/08/2023 08:03

Asking is fine (I mean, I find it totally weird unless it's done to give the parents a rest, but I know plenty of people who do it this way).

Having a big strop and being rude - could fuck off forever as far as I would be concerned.

There's no way she is normally a lovely person then has that attitude. Start as you mean to go on as she will only be, as no doubt always, a pain in the arse.

From bitter experience I wholeheartedly agree. No harm in asking/offering, but the reaction to being told no(t yet) is a clue as to how they think that relationship should be. Stick to your boundaries and they may, over time, learn to respect them and develop a lovely relationship with the DG and you. But they may well not...

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 11/08/2023 12:16

We’ve had this with my mum and it’s a bit weird I think. She didn’t do it with my brothers kids as they are boys but she gets a bit obsessive over female grandchildren. She’s said she needs to spend alone time with my dd2 who is now 18 weeks as she needs to bond with her. My dd2 is actually technically 8 weeks due to being born at 29 weeks so is still quite behind developmentally. She can’t make bonds properly at the moment because of how delayed she is but my mum ignores this.

Mum wanted dd2 overnight. I said no. She said dd2 would be fine. She said she would co sleep with her and if she cries she’d put dd2 down the front of her nightie so she’d sleep better. Fuck me. No!

Hollyppp · 11/08/2023 12:11

How weird? Why does she need alone time with a baby??

Seaweed42 · 11/08/2023 12:09

She's not recognising that she only has a minor part in this play.
Not a starring role like the mother does.

HeyThere111 · 11/08/2023 12:08

The answer should just be the time she asked wasn't suitable.
If you are comfortable mil having her another time then offer that.
You're not being unreasonable to say no when you're not available.
You're in your right to say no anytime, but if you leave her home with teenagers, i would offer mil an alternative time she can look after baby alone

Loulaa1977 · 11/08/2023 11:54

Your baby, your rules. End of.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 11/08/2023 11:47

monsteramunch · 11/08/2023 11:09

It's reasonable to expect this when the baby is four months old and the parents don't want it?

What a staggering level of entitlement.

It's not feeling entitled; many grandparents have their young grandchildren for a few hours here and there.

It's perfectly reasonable for grandparents to ask to take them out and it's perfectly reasonable for parents to say no.

It's not perfectly reasonable for the grandparents to then kick off.

monsteramunch · 11/08/2023 11:44

Except for 10 hours at nursery I presume...that seems to be acceptable on MN but God forbid a MIL grandparent.

I've seen very, very few posts (none that I can remember in fact) where posters have said their four month old baby is in nursery.

And on threads where posters have children under one in nursery, there are always plenty of posters ready to berate them for 'not wanting to raise their own baby' and similarly horrible comments.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 11/08/2023 11:39

DaisyAndDonaldDuck · 11/08/2023 10:57

No, it isn’t reasonable to separate a baby from their mother.

Except for 10 hours at nursery I presume...that seems to be acceptable on MN but God forbid a MIL grandparent.

thecatinthetwat · 11/08/2023 11:39

My mil pushed me into this and then pushed my dc round the park in a pram for an hour crying, she then lied about it. Fil let it slip that dc was crying the whole time. If you’re not happy with it, ffs say no. It’s batshit actually.

HarridanHarvestingHeldaBeans · 11/08/2023 11:31

It doesn't matter a jot what anyone else would do, has done or thinks you should do, OP. You and your partner have decided that you aren't comfortable with this. That's all that matters. Her reaction to being told "No" would make me very wary of agreeing in the future.