Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable, me or my manager?

213 replies

Kowaii · 08/08/2023 21:44

My line manager absolutely loves our job. Which is fair enough.
She made a weird comment on Saturday about the person who worked there before me didn’t “care” about the job, just came in at 9 and left at 5 and that was that. I thought this was odd as it’s literally a 9-5 job.
On Monday morning I got to work and had a load of emails from her that has been sent the previous night. I thought maybe the time was just wrong in the emails.
Today she’s called a meeting with me asking why I didn’t respond to the emails sooner. I said I didn’t see them until I got to work.
She questioned why I want signed in to my work stuff on my personal phone as I then would’ve seen the email was urgent and responded.
Turns out she expects me to basically be “at work” pretty much 24/7. I’ve said I absolutely will not be looking at emails on my time off and directing my work number to my personal number (wtf!).

She seemed genuinely shocked by this. I said I’m paid 9-5 so I will be working 9-5 and no, I don’t think about work when I leave the office. She seems to have made her life about this job.

Aibu to think this is crazy and I’m not being a twat by not having any of my work on my personal phone? I don’t see what I could do from home anyway without my work computer in front of me!

OP posts:
AnSolas · 09/08/2023 15:50

theemmadilemma · 09/08/2023 13:35

Standard policy these days is you use your own device. Only very Senior people have a work phone, and that is due to the requirements on them.

Logistically, there is more to do in getting a physical device back from an employee. In either case, one the domain access is removed, they will no longer be able to access email.

In terms of documents/data, the risks are no different that an employee downloading to a USB in the office... law and other factors cover this risk.

I am aware of the cost saving decisions
(from the tec the network fees and asset management etc )

I am old enough to have went through the processes where companies moved from strong inhouse security systems to weak security on non-company assets.
Proposed solutions included Ee's giving IT staff free access to all the data personal phones and laptops with permission to brick the phone/laptop when the employee left. A compromise was reached and the companies spent the money to buy secure tec and/or web based solutions which managed access etc. on personal tec

Lots of people on MN use third party apps for work. Ones like whatapp still dont allow 2 accounts off the 1 number so what an employee agreed to in a data policy becomes important.

Standard policy these days is you use your own device
To provide work tools needed to carry out a role
And if system security is poor Ee obtains data in the course of employment not direct action in breach of law

Only very Senior people have a work phone, and that is due to the requirements on them.
To provide work tools needed to carry out a role

The only difference should be senior people are paid extra out of hours

However its a business risk when the senior people bring their business number to a new organisation because their phone log is IP and future calls inwards are to the new organisation

In the OP's case she is being asked to provide a work tool and to provide free hours work and be on call 24/7

MeridianB · 09/08/2023 15:46

Unless anything like this was in your JD or contract then she's just dreaming.

I'd ask her to email you details of what she expects and then forward this to your hiring manager or your boss's manager.

What do your colleagues say/do about these demands?

HarLace1 · 09/08/2023 15:39

She's absolutely unreasonable. Clearly no life, sad really!

DottyLottieLou · 09/08/2023 15:33

If she wants you on call then she should pay an on call rate.

floribunda18 · 09/08/2023 15:30

Dummycrusher · 09/08/2023 15:25

What industry do you work in? Although yes, technically, people don't have to work past their legally contracted hours, in some industries you simply can't escape it and you would screw over your colleagues if you stubbornly stuck to 9-5. Agency-side work, law, big business etc. Sometimes you just need to be a bit flexible.

It's not usually expected in law, unless you are a duty solicitor or work for a law firm with a toxic work environment.

Even in a city law firm, I only ever had one client who rang me after hours. And she was a workaholic fuckwit. I moved on quickly.

Dummycrusher · 09/08/2023 15:25

What industry do you work in? Although yes, technically, people don't have to work past their legally contracted hours, in some industries you simply can't escape it and you would screw over your colleagues if you stubbornly stuck to 9-5. Agency-side work, law, big business etc. Sometimes you just need to be a bit flexible.

AlwaysJumping · 09/08/2023 15:13

Fuck no.
Agree to email her and get her to confirm that despite only being paid 9-5pm she wants you to be on call outside of work and do emails and work on your personal phone. Covers you, can tell next job you go to you left due to this.

Rubiconmango · 09/08/2023 15:12

Kowaii · 08/08/2023 21:44

My line manager absolutely loves our job. Which is fair enough.
She made a weird comment on Saturday about the person who worked there before me didn’t “care” about the job, just came in at 9 and left at 5 and that was that. I thought this was odd as it’s literally a 9-5 job.
On Monday morning I got to work and had a load of emails from her that has been sent the previous night. I thought maybe the time was just wrong in the emails.
Today she’s called a meeting with me asking why I didn’t respond to the emails sooner. I said I didn’t see them until I got to work.
She questioned why I want signed in to my work stuff on my personal phone as I then would’ve seen the email was urgent and responded.
Turns out she expects me to basically be “at work” pretty much 24/7. I’ve said I absolutely will not be looking at emails on my time off and directing my work number to my personal number (wtf!).

She seemed genuinely shocked by this. I said I’m paid 9-5 so I will be working 9-5 and no, I don’t think about work when I leave the office. She seems to have made her life about this job.

Aibu to think this is crazy and I’m not being a twat by not having any of my work on my personal phone? I don’t see what I could do from home anyway without my work computer in front of me!

You are absolutely not being unreasonable! She sounds like an entitled has no life whatsoever, controlling, demanding tantrum nasty piece of work! I've worked with people like her, who to be fair have never been as direct. I don't know how old you are but I'm in my 30s and I promise you, don't ever succumb to this lowly nonsense ever. Work is just work. We exchange time for money. And you're just a number. The only time you should be almost always reachable, is when you're I'm a partnership, on the board of directors or being paid undoubtedly handsomely! 35k is peanuts!

Sleepydoor · 09/08/2023 15:04

It really depends on what your job is.

Minime88888888 · 09/08/2023 15:04

She needs to stop this...emails should not be sent out of working hours....if she wants to draft them then, fine but send them within working hours. If she can't get the work done within the time frame...9-5pm.....she is inefficient. This is a classic move to appear more productive, it's not but some people fall for this.

talknomore · 09/08/2023 15:04

Please point out to her that your employer isn't insuring you to work outside of your working hours. What would happened if something happened to you when you were performing your tasks ourside of your working hours?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 09/08/2023 14:59

RoadSignFool · 09/08/2023 08:58

How is it rude to get something land in your inbox when you are asleep? It’s entirely normal in international companies, much ruder to tell my colleagues in Texas they can’t email me during their working day!

Quite clearly not talking about international emails are they.

TiredButDancing · 09/08/2023 14:54

while I think OP's manager is crazy and unrealistic, some of the theories on this thread about people emailing out of hours are bizarre.

It's rude because

  • it sets an implicit expectation/culture of out of hours working
  • it's obliquely a way of signalling/bragging the hours you are willing to put in
  • some people might accidentally open it and then get stressed out by something they can't resolve until the following morning

This is simply not true in most places in 2023. I often send and receive emails out of work hours for lots of reasons, NONE of which are highlighted above. Mostly it's because
a) I work with people in lots of different time zones
b) both I and many of my client contacts work flexibily to adapt to personal lives, working needs or even the corporate's requirements. I have a number of firms who strongly discourage meetings/calls over lunch time for anyone working at home, for example. And a lot of contacts who tend to either start and finish early or start and finish late.

In my case, I'm self employed and during the holidays, I've been working a few hours middle of the day usually then sometimes logging on in the evening to pick up comms I missed during the latter part of the "working day" because I was swimming with DD or at a movie with DS....

notquiteruralbliss · 09/08/2023 14:48

I work in an industry where sometimes it is necessary to do planned or unplanned work out of hours. However, if you are on call, you will be paid to be contactable by phone and able to jump online if needed. If you get a message or call when not on call responding is on a 'best efforts' basis and you can charge for any OOH work done.

wizzyderbyshire · 09/08/2023 14:44

Some people send, and respond, to emails outside of normal working hours - that is their choice and the way they work. You do not have to respond if it doesn’t suit your schedule.

bonzaitree · 09/08/2023 14:30

Youre paid 35,000 so you act your wage, ie you work 9-5. If something needs finishing until 5:20 every now and then so be it.

if you were paid £135,000 the expectation would be a lot higher understandably.

floribunda18 · 09/08/2023 14:29

I'd tell her to email me in work hours only and I certainly won't be responding after 5pm or before 9am.

CharlieMaccy · 09/08/2023 14:26

I work in a management position and I'm lucky to be able to work really flexibly. I do check my emails out of my work time but that's my choice as it enables me to be flexible around my kids. I think it's pretty awful for her to expect you to do the same - and would be inclined to take this to her manager if you can, otherwise perhaps time to look elsewhere. If this is the culture of the place it sounds very toxic.

InSpainTheRain · 09/08/2023 14:25

Unless it's 6 figures I wouldn't be dragged into that! For 35k that's bonkers! Of course you work 9-5 otherwise you are heading for burnout and working for free.

Arniesleftleg · 09/08/2023 14:24

My ex boss was the same. He was an egotistical, misogynistic, megalomaniac. He owned the company, sat up till 2am emailing, woke up at 6am expecting a response. Best days work I ever did was telling him to shove it!

LittleMissUnreasonable · 09/08/2023 14:10

It's always the managers expecting the same from their staff who are probably on considerably less money.

You often hear how the 'big boss' on 100k wants everyone running around like blue arsed flies, doing extra hours and answering emails at 10pm. They always seem confused how their employees, on 30k ,funnily don't have the same level of commitment as them.

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 14:00

AliceOlive · 09/08/2023 13:15

Are you punking us?

Which part is a problem?

Tabitha2721 · 09/08/2023 13:57

yanbu. You need to keep work and personal separate and I really don’t agree with having work stuff on private phones. Not only is it an information security nightmare, but it blends the two and makes a work life balance impossible! She can’t project that unrealistic expectation on you if you’re contracted 9-5. I would be bringing this up with higher ups so it doesn’t cause future issues to be honest.

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 13:57

Well, it depends entirely on the job, but on your salary I wouldn't expect that level of responsibility, no. Most jobs don't require that level of commitment, but there are some that do.

How urgent was the email she sent you on Sunday night? Was it a work emergency?

Aprilx · 09/08/2023 13:51

It really depends on what your role is and to an extent what you are paid.