Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable, me or my manager?

213 replies

Kowaii · 08/08/2023 21:44

My line manager absolutely loves our job. Which is fair enough.
She made a weird comment on Saturday about the person who worked there before me didn’t “care” about the job, just came in at 9 and left at 5 and that was that. I thought this was odd as it’s literally a 9-5 job.
On Monday morning I got to work and had a load of emails from her that has been sent the previous night. I thought maybe the time was just wrong in the emails.
Today she’s called a meeting with me asking why I didn’t respond to the emails sooner. I said I didn’t see them until I got to work.
She questioned why I want signed in to my work stuff on my personal phone as I then would’ve seen the email was urgent and responded.
Turns out she expects me to basically be “at work” pretty much 24/7. I’ve said I absolutely will not be looking at emails on my time off and directing my work number to my personal number (wtf!).

She seemed genuinely shocked by this. I said I’m paid 9-5 so I will be working 9-5 and no, I don’t think about work when I leave the office. She seems to have made her life about this job.

Aibu to think this is crazy and I’m not being a twat by not having any of my work on my personal phone? I don’t see what I could do from home anyway without my work computer in front of me!

OP posts:
IamnotSethRogan · 09/08/2023 17:45

Well it depends what field you work in but we're having a security revamp at work and they said we're not to even have our emails on our work phones so I think they'd blow a fuse if they were on our personal phones.

RoadSignFool · 09/08/2023 17:41

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 09/08/2023 14:59

Quite clearly not talking about international emails are they.

But what does the impact of an email landing in your inbox differ depending on where the sender is located?

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 17:38

theemmadilemma · 09/08/2023 17:12

I'm old hat too. And I'm not sure what you're arguing... you asked what happened to data stored on the phone, I gave some info because you seemed to have no comprehension. Actually seems like you do. :shrug:

I told the OP she was correct and did the right thing.

Yep :)

Joevanswell · 09/08/2023 17:38

Make a stand as others say, my dh worked for a big four accountancy firm and was not allowed to leave when my baby dd was admitted to hospital ( very very poorly and kept in best part of a week)and nearly missed my planned cs as he had to attend a conference call despite weeks of notice and being on paternity leave. He started job hunting the next day, his old boss has been promoted multiple times as this work culture was encouraged and no he wasn’t on mega money

RoadSignFool · 09/08/2023 17:37

Tabitha2721 · 09/08/2023 13:57

yanbu. You need to keep work and personal separate and I really don’t agree with having work stuff on private phones. Not only is it an information security nightmare, but it blends the two and makes a work life balance impossible! She can’t project that unrealistic expectation on you if you’re contracted 9-5. I would be bringing this up with higher ups so it doesn’t cause future issues to be honest.

It’s really NOT an information security nightmare. It’s very, very common.

And when I am not in work and do not feel like looking at work emails, I just don’t open the work email app. It doesn’t send me notifications. It’s no more intrusive than having the Mumsnet Talk app on my phone!

LizzieLoO37 · 09/08/2023 17:24

She is making it a toxic workplace by her bad time management. Don't do work stuff outside of your contracted hours unless you have a written agreement you will receive extra pay or benefits. Don't let this force you into working more hours for free. Who gets to burnout the fastest is a competition nobody wins.

FloofCloud · 09/08/2023 17:17

Check what your contract says. Personally I don't expect any of my team to read outside of office hours unless prearranged due to business needs, which is pretty rare.

FrenchandSaunders · 09/08/2023 17:16

I work with someone like this but she lives alone and is a bit lonely I think so has made her job her life. Fine for her to crack on with that, but I'm not doing it.

Blogdog · 09/08/2023 17:15

Having work applications and email on personal phones should be at the option of the employee. If your job requires you to have these then they need to provide an appropriate device.

Having suffered a pretty severe burnout from a professional role due to constant overwork and lack of resourcing I now refuse to have anything work related on a personal device. It’s all fair and well saying you don’t have to read work communications but when they are mixed with personal emails and notifications are flashing up constantly during non-work hours it is very difficult to switch off. Now I carry two phones during the week but the work one goes into a drawer once I get home and all weekend. I value my own mental health too much to allow that crossover.

theemmadilemma · 09/08/2023 17:12

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 15:50

I am aware of the cost saving decisions
(from the tec the network fees and asset management etc )

I am old enough to have went through the processes where companies moved from strong inhouse security systems to weak security on non-company assets.
Proposed solutions included Ee's giving IT staff free access to all the data personal phones and laptops with permission to brick the phone/laptop when the employee left. A compromise was reached and the companies spent the money to buy secure tec and/or web based solutions which managed access etc. on personal tec

Lots of people on MN use third party apps for work. Ones like whatapp still dont allow 2 accounts off the 1 number so what an employee agreed to in a data policy becomes important.

Standard policy these days is you use your own device
To provide work tools needed to carry out a role
And if system security is poor Ee obtains data in the course of employment not direct action in breach of law

Only very Senior people have a work phone, and that is due to the requirements on them.
To provide work tools needed to carry out a role

The only difference should be senior people are paid extra out of hours

However its a business risk when the senior people bring their business number to a new organisation because their phone log is IP and future calls inwards are to the new organisation

In the OP's case she is being asked to provide a work tool and to provide free hours work and be on call 24/7

I'm old hat too. And I'm not sure what you're arguing... you asked what happened to data stored on the phone, I gave some info because you seemed to have no comprehension. Actually seems like you do. :shrug:

I told the OP she was correct and did the right thing.

Canisaysomething · 09/08/2023 17:10

It totally depends on whether this is a career job where you're hoping to work your way up or whether it's a job with limited earning potential. If you were a junior lawyer on 35k and ran out of the door at 5pm every day you wouldn't last long.

MarshaArt · 09/08/2023 17:07

Asiatoyork · 09/08/2023 02:47

It’s bad management to email over the weekend or late at night - emails should be scheduled for the next working day (there’s a button for this.)

This practice really confuses me, but I think it’s because I never assumed in my working life that if someone sends an e-Mail out of hours that I would be expected to pick it up, let alone respond. I might add a note to my e-Mail sig or something as I didn’t realise people feel pressure to respond out of hours!

Agree. It might suit me to receive their email earlier depending on when I wanted to work. Flexibility means different things to different people. If people feel they need to reply then the culture is the issue, not the timing of an email.

GuinnessBird · 09/08/2023 16:45

The manager sounds like a bootlicker, the OP on the other hand has good boundaries.

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 09/08/2023 16:39

If you're contracted for specific hours, then that's what you do. It sounds as though you 'go to work' physically and your work laptop lives at work. So you don't have access to work email etc if you are not at work.
Check your contract though because if it says something vague like 'additional tasks as directed' or there's a hint of extra hours in busy periods, then she may well be able to expect you to work overtime.

Fraaahnces · 09/08/2023 16:25

So there’s no HR? Join a Union. I’m pretty sure they’d have a lot to say about this shit.

Viviennemary · 09/08/2023 16:24

She is nuts. But folk like her don't change and are a nightmare to work with. Can you apply for a different position in the company. I think its ok to send emails out of hours as long as you don't expect a reply.

ememem84 · 09/08/2023 16:13

In my old job it was expected I was on call and monitoring emails all the time - I had a call once from manager as to why I hadn’t sorted out the emails from a particular client. I responded that it was Friday evening and I was at home. She told me to check my blackberry because that’s what it’s for. I left soon after.

current job is 9-5. I check emails outside of this occasionally on my phone. But generally stick to 9-5. No issues if anyone emails me outside of this though - I typically only respond once I get to the office.

SerafinasGoose · 09/08/2023 16:10

If your contracted hours are 35-38 hours and your usual working window is 9-5, then that's what you work. Oddly enough my own employer has just threatened to deduct 100% for 'working to contract'. They rely on staff goodwill - in my sector people are pretty dedicated and will usually provide it - well, they've just lost mine.

Any emails I send during the evenings I pre-set to send at 8 the next morning. It's never a good thing to be on call for anyone 24/7. Good for you, OP. Don't be a people pleaser: you never get any respect for this IME.

notacooldad · 09/08/2023 16:09

Why should a manager have the emplyee's personal phone number at all? If they want to contact the employee about work then they should supply a work phone and pay for it.For me it is a two way street. My manager has my number and I have hers.It’s useful when she needs a shift stopping, telling me I can start later, skiing me to go straight to a venue ( thus saving me time) I can ring asking if I can swop a shift, finish sooner, take leave at short notice, let her know if something has happened that she needs to be ware of while I’m on shift ( eg one of our children taken into police custody, child being smitten to hospital, gone missing etc)
We happen to have an excellent manager who is fair, never asks us to do anything she wouldn’t do and has proven time and time again that she has our backs.
it’s mutually beneficial.

Echobelly · 09/08/2023 16:05

My personal view is I'm not working if I'm not being paid those hours unless it is genuinely something that must be sorted out right at that time and cannot possibly wait. I don't think I've ever worked in a job where such an event could occur.

Your boss is welcome to keep her own hours, but she cannot expect others to keep them; truly professional people recognise this. I work with a few people who have email signatures along the line of 'I may sometimes email you out of hours but this does not mean I am expecting a response until normal office hours' and that's totally fair.

I do think jobs that expect all-hours response need to be transparent about this at interview stage (in my case so I can walk the hell away from them!) and I know that many places are. But I would always assume working hours are working hours unless told otherwise upfront.

ManchesterLu · 09/08/2023 16:04

Nah, you do what you're paid for.
I'm the same, switched off between shifts. There might be the very, very odd occasion where there's an emergency and I'd help out - I'm not a knob head - but it wouldn't be a regular thing.

JadeIsMyFaveColour · 09/08/2023 16:00

I work shifts and am low paid, by the hour. I do so because it fits around my other obligations.

A few weeks ago one of the managers got a bit uppity with me because when asked to download the latest work communication system onto my phone, I declined. Apparently I should be joyous about being able to scroll and scroll down what’s happening and join in, when I’m not working.

My company already gave me doing a managers job for no more pay. I do a good job, but as soon as my shift ends, my brain is elsewhere.

Some companies just don’t get it do they? Pay us properly and we may see it as a career, rather than a job to pay the bills.

helloooitsmeee · 09/08/2023 15:56

I was much like your manager, in that I would have my work emails on my personal mobile, checking in on the business outside of my work hours, even took my laptop on holiday with me once! This wasn't any pressure put onto me by my boss, I just genuinely loved the company!

I still do love the company, but I've had to reign it in, especially after I had my daughter. My time with her is so precious, and others within the company wouldn't respect that (would facebook message me on the weekend about work stuff!) Now, unless I'm doing planned overtime, I switch off the minute I leave the building. A lot of my stress and anxiety has gone since doing so!

JudgeJ · 09/08/2023 15:56

Doggymummar · 08/08/2023 21:47

Depends what your job description says. If you are supposed to be on call then you are being unreasonable, if not your manager is.

Why should a manager have the emplyee's personal phone number at all? If they want to contact the employee about work then they should supply a work phone and pay for it. When mobiles were first being used in the '90s I refused to supply my employer with the number, they had my landline and that was enough.

Catza · 09/08/2023 15:51

I used to have one of those managers. He would send me an email at 4am and expect me to be ready with an answer by the opening hours that morning. My sleep was terrible, my stress levels through the roof.. it's a firm no from me, especially for the pay. They also seemed to think that it was OK to expect people to come in for training and staff meetings on their day off and not to be compensated for it in either pay or TOIL. Their argument was that they organised/paid for training and therefore we must be there. I since moved into public sector and, honestly, this has been the best decision. The money is rubbish but there is no way I will ever go back to private sector with its unrealistic expectations and constant demand on your personal time.
In fact, in my first month on the job I got a massive bollocking from my supervisor for checking and responding to emails in the evenings and weekends. They told me that if the workload is too much, I need to let the management know so that we can source extra staff. I nearly cried.