Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable, me or my manager?

213 replies

Kowaii · 08/08/2023 21:44

My line manager absolutely loves our job. Which is fair enough.
She made a weird comment on Saturday about the person who worked there before me didn’t “care” about the job, just came in at 9 and left at 5 and that was that. I thought this was odd as it’s literally a 9-5 job.
On Monday morning I got to work and had a load of emails from her that has been sent the previous night. I thought maybe the time was just wrong in the emails.
Today she’s called a meeting with me asking why I didn’t respond to the emails sooner. I said I didn’t see them until I got to work.
She questioned why I want signed in to my work stuff on my personal phone as I then would’ve seen the email was urgent and responded.
Turns out she expects me to basically be “at work” pretty much 24/7. I’ve said I absolutely will not be looking at emails on my time off and directing my work number to my personal number (wtf!).

She seemed genuinely shocked by this. I said I’m paid 9-5 so I will be working 9-5 and no, I don’t think about work when I leave the office. She seems to have made her life about this job.

Aibu to think this is crazy and I’m not being a twat by not having any of my work on my personal phone? I don’t see what I could do from home anyway without my work computer in front of me!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cotonsugar · 14/08/2023 13:54

Sounds like she doesn’t have much of a life outside of work herself.

Hilsberry · 12/08/2023 10:38

Are you being paid to work outside of your contractual hours? Is there anything in your contract that says there would be an expectation to be available beyond 9-5 for which suitable remuneration or time off on lieu would be paid? If the answer is no then she’s a chancer and she herself is heading for burnout. If she continues with this sort of insinuation she could be looking at harassment.

jeaux90 · 11/08/2023 11:27

@Iwant2stayanon totally agree.

I'm also senior and run a team, I actively encourage a work life balance for my team.

I never send work emails out at the weekend, I don't expect response out of hours if I am working late. They often do go above and beyond but this is their choice, not an expectation.

Your manager sounds like she has never ran a team before to me.

Iwant2stayanon · 11/08/2023 11:20

I am in a very senior position and there is a huge difference between showing willing and what the OP describes. The behaviour is indicative of a low level manager who has no idea how to lead. If they did, they would have awareness of how to create the right culture and work/life balance for their team.

mumindoghouse · 11/08/2023 09:56

We have really good schedule send set up on our work emails so emails are not received when someone is emailing after core office hours and also to alert a sender if emailing on a NWD so they know a response unlikely.

I agree with advice to confirm the conversation in writing with your line manager.

You could, before doing so, seek advice rather than action from HR ( to try to take the conflict out but at the same time raise a flag). Then you would be sure of your ground when sending the email.

It is unreasonable to expect responses outside contractual hours especially on Sundays.

RoadSignFool · 11/08/2023 09:04

Aprilx · 11/08/2023 08:39

Still can’t really tell if a little bit of extra hours is reasonable or not. As I said, people starting out in a profession generally do have to show some willing to go the extra mile. If OP is embarking on a career, rather than taking a job, I am not sure the 9-5 and not a second more attitude will help.

There is a huge difference between an employee showing a bit of willingness to work beyond contracted hours when business needs dictate and the scenario OP describes here: she was emailed on a Sunday (presumably not having been pre-warned that something important was going on that weekend that might require her attention) and then her manager berated her on Monday for not having replied on Sunday. That’s out of order even in the high pressure, high expectation world of City law that I inhabit. Nobody is expected to check emails at weekends on the off chance- if there is a chance of something coming up then they will be warned specifically on Friday, and any request over the weekend will include a clear deadline for response and a cursory “apologies for disturbing your weekend but it’s really important we do blah blah blah straight away”, probably a phone call too.

This woman sounds batshit. Probably taking out her own stress on OP.

That said, my response might have been more along the lines of being clear that (a) expecting a response on Sunday was unreasonable (b) criticising me for not doing this unreasonable thing was ridiculous when no such expectations had never been communicated, but I might have said “if you do need my help out of hours, let’s come up with a set of guidelines and a process by which I might be able to accommodate that in an exceptional case eg prior warning of possible need for out of hours work in circs beyond manager’s control , contact by phone not email and a recognition that I may not be available.

Aprilx · 11/08/2023 08:39

Iwant2stayanon · 11/08/2023 06:24

@Aprilx true but doesn’t look like that is the case here. OP is a midwife who has moved on into a new profession. It’s the way this has been done in terms of the behaviour and what’s been said that is the issue here I think.

Still can’t really tell if a little bit of extra hours is reasonable or not. As I said, people starting out in a profession generally do have to show some willing to go the extra mile. If OP is embarking on a career, rather than taking a job, I am not sure the 9-5 and not a second more attitude will help.

Ukrainebaby23 · 11/08/2023 08:05

Sounds like you are in a new job, she's either trying to impress you or scared you'll do a better job than her so she's making you feel inadequate.
I think you have to take a different approach, or find a new employer, or put up with her on your back, not quite sure what the answer is but think outside the box a bit. But don't give in lol.

Iwant2stayanon · 11/08/2023 06:24

@Aprilx true but doesn’t look like that is the case here. OP is a midwife who has moved on into a new profession. It’s the way this has been done in terms of the behaviour and what’s been said that is the issue here I think.

highinthesky · 11/08/2023 03:29

Kowaii · 09/08/2023 19:06

35k is peanuts!

wow that’s a bit of an unnecessary comment.

Thanks all. I’m entering a new career after being a midwife for 5 years (so I know all about working outside of my hours and going above and beyond!)

I have absolutely no intention of doing anything other than my 9-5 hours and I’ve made that very clear that after my healthcare background I basically just want to have a job I don’t have to think about. I’m good at my new role, and I’m doing very well at it and that’s enough for me.

This is useful additional detail.

YANBU but your OP did suggest a work-to-rule mentality, which I would struggle with.

Start looking for something else, stat - perhaps in a less desk based job? You're not going to be there for as long as 2 years, in which case can be dismissed with no good reason (under English law).

Welshmonster · 11/08/2023 00:44

This is probably why the previous person left. Set your boundaries out now. Some people have no existence outside of work.

maybe ask if there is an overtime form to complete for hours worked over contracted hours.

does your manager have a manager? If so speak to them.

also follow up in an email your understanding of the meeting you had. Ask for them to write down their expectations in writing and they won’t as they know it’s naughty.

Teenagehorrorbag · 10/08/2023 22:01

It's fine to send emails any time that suits you, but you shouldn't generally expect a response until normal working hours. If the person is in a management role then yes, they may need to field some calls outside hours, but would probably need a whatsapp message to say 'sorry, have sent you an urgent msg, please can you check?'.

I used to work in a management role and was happy to take calls at any time - provided it wasn't inconvenient. But you can't be expected to see emails 24/7. I now work part time and irregular hours (low paid), so colleagues don't know which of my 9 hours a week I'm online. So I try and check in regularly, but always ask people to call or whatsapp if it's anything urgent.

For £35K you probably need to be slightly more accommodating than clockwatching 9-5, but your boss absolutely can't expect you to look at emails late at night, just on the offchance!

Cowlover89 · 10/08/2023 21:56

Yanbu

pollymere · 10/08/2023 21:40

I had a job where I was expected to answer my phone 24/7. We didn't really have emails as much as we do now. I was part of a Crisis Team and also sometimes had to be at work for 6am (if I did I got put up in a hotel the night before).

The important thing was - I earnt 10K more than most a year for my job accountability. If you do a proper 9-5, then this shouldn't be an expectation of you. I worked 36 hours a week and got overtime and time off in lieu if I worked outside of 9:15 to 17:30. And a fat salary, a Company Credit Card and a Company Mobile Phone when it was barely a thing.

I'd be explaining that you don't have this accountability level and so won't be available outside 9-5. If they wish you to be, then you need to have a contract and renumeration that matches that.

mumindoghouse · 10/08/2023 20:56

I can’t see that you are contractually required to respond.
if work want you replying to emails round the clock, they should provide the equipment.
Work is a contract. You do X hours of Y. We pay you £. Any overtime should be stipulated in the contract and that must be reasonable.
There’s been too much trading on our goodwill to do that bit more for free for the benefit of the service user, at no cost to the service provider but at personal cost the employee.
personally I think we should all just say no! You want more time, you pay and you pay even more if unsocial hours

Birdy8 · 10/08/2023 20:55

I think she’s insane, a dictator! In my experience women bosses are just as bad as men, all the talk about sisterhood is crap - they don’t really support you unless you’re part of their inner clique. Sadly I had to leave my job for my own sanity.

moaningmyrtle4 · 10/08/2023 20:49

YANBU

unless you have some sort of on call Rota when occasionally need to be on call, unless you WANT TO you do not need to check your emails When not at work

I check before I go to bed as I work in a global org to check if anything important for the next day but that’s it

OhcantthInkofaname · 10/08/2023 20:22

So you "work to live" and not "live to work"? Good for you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/08/2023 20:20

Not for a 35k job you’re not on call outside of your working hours!

CPRMummy · 10/08/2023 20:16

I'm not "on-call" 24/7 and I'm self employed! Go over her head and question it with HR or her management. She's totally unreasonable and sounds like she has no life but thinks that's normal for everyone.

Kowaii · 10/08/2023 19:31

Its not law or a charity. I’m not going to put it on here as it’s quite specific and you never know she might be on here.

But it’s not a job that it is expected to work outside your contracted hours. She is the ONLY person in the office who is like it. Except our CEO but that is obviously expected.

OP posts:
Dummycrusher · 10/08/2023 19:21

I have several friends who work in law and they consistently do more than their contracted hours. Especially the City one!

SharonEllis · 10/08/2023 19:07

Doggymummar · 08/08/2023 21:47

Depends what your job description says. If you are supposed to be on call then you are being unreasonable, if not your manager is.

And if you are supposed to be on call you should be paid for it.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 10/08/2023 19:07

Tell her putting work emails on a personal device is a potential GDPR breach. Your personal phone does not have the same security level.

Aprilx · 10/08/2023 19:06

Iwant2stayanon · 10/08/2023 18:54

That’s absolutely ridiculous and she is unrealistic. She clearly has nothing else in her life. There is no way for £35k I would be available for work all the time. It’s very poor leadership and management of your teams health and well-being to expect them to behave in that way.

It still depends upon what she does. If she is a young trainee professional, then out of hours work could still be expected.