Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Massive baby - what would you do?

286 replies

AnxiousMamo · 08/08/2023 20:53

I’ve just been diagnosed with gestational diabetes after baby was measuring 6lb at 34 weeks. All of the measurements were 85th centile plus, with the stomach measurement being off the scale (!)

My first baby was 8lb 15oz, and this one looks set to be even bigger. First DC I had to be induced which was awful and I ended up with an episiotomy, ventouse and I was unable to urinate afterwards for a week (I needed a catheter). It was pretty traumatic, although I was able to look after DC and be mobile straight after birth which was good.

I have another scan next week when I will be 37 weeks, and they will compare measurements and the consultant will advise me. They have given me two options - induction at 39 weeks or an elective caesarean. Both carry risks. With induction there is the risk it won’t work, I may need intervention again, tears, episiotomy and shoulder dystocia for the baby. With a caesarean there are the usual associated risks. The consultant did they that as I have had a big baby previously, that is a good sign for a vaginal birth.

I am wondering if any others have been in this situation and how it went for you, what did you decide? How was the birth?

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
Nubnut · 10/08/2023 12:27

lockdownbabyx · 09/08/2023 15:42

@AnxiousMamo I would highly recommend following the naked birth coach on instagram. She has lots of free and informative resources regarding "big" babies.

I was told my son would be a larger baby and they recommended a c section which I declined. They then recommended that I was induced which I also declined. I went into spontaneous labour at 39+3 and he was born vaginally weighing 6lb 5oz. This is my experience, however scans are notoriously inaccurate at predicting weight, especially in the third trimester.

this is mad!
How common is this?
I was told by my hospital that I could get an ultrasound at 39 weeks to try to predict weight, but actually a very experienced midwife would be more accurate estimating with her hands.

PurBal · 10/08/2023 06:50

My large baby wasn’t identified (I was measuring normally and no GD) he was born at 10lb9 and I delivered vaginally. Second degree tear. I also had a 24 hour and then 7 day catheter. However, you are more likely to need a catheter with a section, it’s needed because of the “trauma” to your bladder. In my case (and probably yours) a large head squashed it and in the case of a c section it has to be moved out of the way by the surgeons hands. Afterwards everyone (HCP / MW) would say “oh so you had a c section” and I was like “uh no” and it would be followed up by “why did you need a catheter then?” I discovered it’s because it’s far more usual with a section and it took everything in my power not to sarcastically reply “why do you think?! Because my bladder is working perfectly…?” Nevertheless I was still healed by 3 weeks PP. I live rurally so being able to drive is a necessity and the recovery from a section would have been too much, especially with a toddler too. For that reason I wouldn’t have chosen a section had I been given the option.

amyboo · 10/08/2023 06:30

FWIW, I had 3 CS for various reasons, and recovery was absolutely fine. Much easier than for several friends who had vaginal births. I'f go ELCS.

notsuchafrugalkitty · 09/08/2023 17:03

What does your gut tell you OP? I remember the feeling of overwhelm at that stage, especially following a complicated and long first delivery. Had I been offered an elective c section I would have taken it for my second, in hindsight this is what we should have argued for after the trauma of the first. Mentally there's much to be said for feeling like you have the choice and an element of control.

Ladyofthelake53 · 09/08/2023 16:49

Typos sorry, fine with second birth

Ladyofthelake53 · 09/08/2023 16:49

Mine were 9lb 11 a week early and 10lb both birn vaginally. First one i had 3rd degree tear but gine eith second one. Depends on uour pelvis i guess

AnxiousMamo · 09/08/2023 16:38

@Soverymuchfruit I have seen the website, thank you, it is very helpful and informative. I have been following the GD diet strictly!

@shams05 My consultant is female, and to be honest she was quite good. She didn’t try to persuade either way. She simply gave me the facts of induced vaginal and elective c-section, pros/cons and told me to go away and think about it. She’s seeing me again after my 37 week scan and will be able to advise more. The only thing she did say is, having previously had a big baby, it tends to be easier a second time round.

I do understand what people are saying about scans being inaccurate, however, with my last pregnancy they did accurately predict that my baby would be macrosomic. This baby has also been measuring larger throughout, but it was on the recent 34 week scan that it became apparent just how large they are. Due to my last baby being big, and having gestational diabetes, and then recent scan measurements, I think it’s safe to assume that this baby is likely to also be on the bigger side.

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 09/08/2023 15:46

Hmm, 98th percentile for me, 94th for the baby. Maybe not so bad then!

thecatsthecats · 09/08/2023 15:43

That's another thing to add to my pros and cons list - I'm 5'9" with broad hips. Hopefully this means my "big" baby has a bit more room.

lockdownbabyx · 09/08/2023 15:42

@AnxiousMamo I would highly recommend following the naked birth coach on instagram. She has lots of free and informative resources regarding "big" babies.

I was told my son would be a larger baby and they recommended a c section which I declined. They then recommended that I was induced which I also declined. I went into spontaneous labour at 39+3 and he was born vaginally weighing 6lb 5oz. This is my experience, however scans are notoriously inaccurate at predicting weight, especially in the third trimester.

PumpkinPie2016 · 09/08/2023 15:28

My son was 9lb 6oz (I am slight in build and only 5ft 2in tall!).

I went in to labour but despite many hours of contractions and drip, I ended up with an emergency c-section.

Had I had another baby, I would definitely have gone for elective section.

thecatsthecats · 09/08/2023 15:26

roseotter · 09/08/2023 15:00

@thecatsthecats yes, that makes more sense. But by your logic, OP should go for an elective C. She’s already had a vaginal birth with complications previously, and an elective c section has a more predictable set of risks than a vaginal.

If that's the conclusion she reaches, sure.

The whole reason that I'm on this thread is because I'm in a very similar situation and am not yet decided!

I'm hoping things will be clearer nearer the birth for me. This thread is providing useful context and information.

@Soverymuchfruit - yes, thank you, that's what I currently think re: inductions. There are some local factors too that skew me towards an ELCS (badly mismanaged vaginal births resulting in disability appear to be a regular news feature...), but they won't be relevant to everyone.

Soverymuchfruit · 09/08/2023 15:15

I would add which is what I thought @thecatsthecats was saying that the benefit of an "ideal natural" birth (uncomplicated vaginal) over a well-managed calm "medicalised" birth is not that big. Really what matters is that mother and baby are both unharmed by the process. And so, the advantage of either over a traumatic birth (for mother or baby) is huge!

And what's a well-managed calm medicalised birth? An ELCS is one, unless you're very very very very unlucky. There might be other form of this too, I don't know. But it seems that an induction of a very large baby, quite likely doesn't fit this description.

roseotter · 09/08/2023 15:00

@thecatsthecats yes, that makes more sense. But by your logic, OP should go for an elective C. She’s already had a vaginal birth with complications previously, and an elective c section has a more predictable set of risks than a vaginal.

thecatsthecats · 09/08/2023 14:37

roseotter · 09/08/2023 13:42

@thecatsthecats this sounds quite flippant tbh, and minimising the experiences of women with significant birth trauma (mental or physical). My first birth was a awful, required me to have years of therapy, and has left with permanent injuries that effect me every day so no, I wouldn’t consider that “minor”

Well, I didn't mean it to be from that angle.

More in the sense that there's a lot of conflicting information and anecdotes, and no guarantees that whatever choice you make will be based on the "right" information.

There's no amount of research you can do that will make it the "right" choice, so for me, it's a case of making the decision on as narrow a set of criteria as possible, and trying not to worry about the rest.

Women shouldn't have to feel the responsibility for getting that decision right by making a series of deep, complex and ultimately unknowable medical calls, and that at the end of the day, there are no medals for having given birth a particular way.

Not that having had a traumatic birth is minor or unimportant - only to avoid winding yourself up trying to "beat the system" and prevent one.

Soverymuchfruit · 09/08/2023 14:14

Btw have you found this wonderful site? Put together by those with experience of the condition, tons of evidence- and experience-based advice, support and recipes!
https://www.gestationaldiabetes.co.uk/

Gestational Diabetes UK • Gestational Diabetes UK

Gestational Diabetes UK is dedicated to offering support and evidence based research to women diagnosed with gestational diabetes in the UK and Ireland

https://www.gestationaldiabetes.co.uk

roseotter · 09/08/2023 13:42

thecatsthecats · 09/08/2023 11:19

Another thing to add in general is that it feels like a huge decision, however, really, you are choosing about a very small amount of your child's life and your own medical history.

Try and neutralise the decision if you can - make it small and practical, and focus on the outcomes that really matter.

For me, this is a healthy baby, and health consequences that I can manage.

@thecatsthecats this sounds quite flippant tbh, and minimising the experiences of women with significant birth trauma (mental or physical). My first birth was a awful, required me to have years of therapy, and has left with permanent injuries that effect me every day so no, I wouldn’t consider that “minor”

Tulipblank · 09/08/2023 12:55

AnxiousMamo · 09/08/2023 11:11

@Tulipblank Did you have an induction? It seems like (anecdotally) most people who have inductions end up having issues with instruments or tearing, as was the case with the birth of my first DC. I will definitely be induced again this time if I go for a vaginal birth.

Yes, induction with first. Natural with second. Induction was pretty rubbish.

shams05 · 09/08/2023 12:54

Are your consultant and midwives advising the same thing? I can imagine a male consultant saying vaginal would be easier with a second baby.
I'm sorry I have no experience in regards to c sections and larger babies as mine were all tiny, the only thing I can say is those growth scans were never accurate or even near accurate for me in all 4 of my pregnancies where baby's growth was monitored.

peachgreen · 09/08/2023 12:41

DD was measuring large (no GD, just a big baby) and I went in for an induction but then the doctors suggested a section so I went for that. So glad I did, she was 10lb 13oz, 98th centile for height and head size, and totally stuck in my pelvis. Would have ended in a section either way. Recovery was fine.

That said: it made it harder to breastfeed and I did end up with bad PND which could have been related. But all in all, no regrets.

Nubnut · 09/08/2023 12:37

Monkeymonkeymoo · 09/08/2023 08:05

There are some risk factors that you can control:

  • Diet- Low in sugar and refined carbohydrates. Choosing complex carbohydrates and pairing them with protein or fat to slow the absorption (e.g. rather than just having toast you have it with egg and avocado and choose a wholemeal bread).
  • Exercise- Trying to do 10-20 minutes exercise after each meal (even just a walk is fine).

Longer term things like your weight will affect your risk of gestational diabetes (and type 2 diabetes).

However there are lots of risk factors that you can’t control (genetics, ethnicity, age).

I also had no risk factors and a borderline result on the GD test and ended up having very bad gestational diabetes and some of the complications that go along with it. Even with a very strict diet and exercise regime I still needed medication and eventually insulin. So sometimes it’s just bad luck.

It went away within hours of my son being delivered though. Although I am higher risk for getting it again in future pregnancies and for getting Tupe 2 diabetes so I’ve been working on my lifestyle and losing a bit of weight before getting pregnant again (my BMI was the higher end of healthy going into my last pregnancy and it’s now the lower end of healthy).

Thanks very much, this is so helpful. It's really kind of you to write such a useful message.

Lindtnotlint · 09/08/2023 12:31

Sounds not dissimilar to my story. I would strongly recommend a C-section. I have done both - as in, first baby was a traumatic vaginal, second baby was an “ok” vaginal but still ended up with further reconstructive surgery as perineum didn’t recover well after minor stitching. Third was a C-section and absolutely lovely by comparison. Planned sections are fab IMHO.

HamBone · 09/08/2023 12:15

phoenixrosehere · 09/08/2023 11:21

I’d go for the elective c-section.

I never understand why an induction is pushed if they think the baby is going to be big enough to possibly get stuck in the birth canal and you end up needing a rushed emergency c-section.

@phoenixrosehere In my case, it was to have DS early, before he reached DD’s proportions. 😂
I had no trouble birthing a 7lb 12 oz baby, whereas I did with a 9lb 10oz one.

I think that’s also the logic behind the OP’s offer of an induction, but she has the added complication of GD. A c-section might be safest for her.

Bigbabymomma · 09/08/2023 12:07

I've had 5 massive babies when you take into consideration their gestational age. Diagnosed with GD for last 3, fairly confident I've had it with all.

36w5 8lb4oz Natural, induced after waters broke.
37w2 8lb2oz Natural
38w2 9lb1oz Natural, induced.
38w6 10lb Natural, induced.
35w1 6lb12oz Emergency c section.

My 2 biggest were induced and we're by far my easiest labour and deliveries.

Soverymuchfruit · 09/08/2023 11:53

I had a similar situation with my first (and only) though measurements were even bigger, and medical advice what that shoulder distocia was a big risk. Had a lovely elective section. What is glorious isn't the hour you spend in the operating theatre I mean I had a ball but maybe it isn't your thing but the whole afternoon you can then spend cuddling your baby, when you're happy and rested and not in pain or dealing with complications or anything. The way they come out is such a small part of the story of your lives together, as long as you're both unharmed by the process. (Which does not sound a given if you opt for the induction).

Yes you then need to heal, but you want to spend those weeks cuddling on the sofa, anyway. As long as you have someone else to help with your older child.