Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Massive baby - what would you do?

286 replies

AnxiousMamo · 08/08/2023 20:53

I’ve just been diagnosed with gestational diabetes after baby was measuring 6lb at 34 weeks. All of the measurements were 85th centile plus, with the stomach measurement being off the scale (!)

My first baby was 8lb 15oz, and this one looks set to be even bigger. First DC I had to be induced which was awful and I ended up with an episiotomy, ventouse and I was unable to urinate afterwards for a week (I needed a catheter). It was pretty traumatic, although I was able to look after DC and be mobile straight after birth which was good.

I have another scan next week when I will be 37 weeks, and they will compare measurements and the consultant will advise me. They have given me two options - induction at 39 weeks or an elective caesarean. Both carry risks. With induction there is the risk it won’t work, I may need intervention again, tears, episiotomy and shoulder dystocia for the baby. With a caesarean there are the usual associated risks. The consultant did they that as I have had a big baby previously, that is a good sign for a vaginal birth.

I am wondering if any others have been in this situation and how it went for you, what did you decide? How was the birth?

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
Lookingatthesunset · 11/08/2023 23:59

It just depends. I'm 5'3" and apparently have a small pelvis. I was brought into hospital to be monitored with my first when a scan showed that the placenta had pretty much been used up. Induction was tried twice and didn't work, so it was straight to elective c/s. Baby was 8'7.5 and obs said that I would never have been able to birth them naturally.

2nd was another c/s. This baby was 9'5.5. I still remember the obs' forehead going red with the effort of hauling them out! He said he thought baby would be big but not that big! 3rd, the same, elective c/s and another 2 oz heavier.

They were all born at 38+4... I can't imagine the monsters they'd have been if I'd gone overdue! I didn't have GD either.

Personally I'd go elective c/s. You can plan to have your older child minded. You know when you are going in. I know I don't have the experience of vaginal birth to compare but now I am old and glad I don't have any damage 'down there'!! I imagine trying for a vb and ending up with an emergency c/s must be way worse than having an elective.

And tbh, they are all adults now and it really wouldn't matter if they had had to pull them down my nose lol!

HollaHolla · 11/08/2023 23:35

With the greatest of respect, an 8lb baby isn't THAT big, unless you're tiny, or slender of hip.
My tiny, '4 11'' mother, fired out three of us, all over 9lb. My brother was the smallest at 9lb 4oz. No issues. Obviously a bit painful, but gas and air did the trick.

One of my besties is a gynecologist - and she says a good birth is a live mother, and live baby. It's as simple as that. So, if you want a C section, do it. They wouldn't have it on the table, if they didn't think it was a real possibility,

BeckiP85 · 11/08/2023 23:29

I've got 3 children. With the first I had GD and needed insulin for my fasting overnight readings and he was born naturally at 40+6 at 7lb15oz, but I had a 3B tear. My second, I didn't have GD (was tested 3 times), I had an elective c-sections at 39+3 and he was 7lb6oz. With my 3rd I had GD again and i needed insulin again for my fasting levels. She was born at 39+3 via c-section again and she was 7lb8oz. My c-sections were fantastic, id do it again tomorrow. No major pain, went to soft play the next week. My last one had a harder recovery as I was sterilised at the same time so I had more pain but still great no problems. The worst part of a c-section in trapped wind!

ReadingSoManyThreads · 11/08/2023 23:13

Hibiscrubbed · 11/08/2023 22:45

I’m not sure telling her to call ignore doctors and just squat, is a particularly good idea.

At no point did I say to ignore doctors, for goodness sake, don't be ridiculous. I was giving advice that is helpful that is rarely given to women by caregivers.

Hibiscrubbed · 11/08/2023 22:45

ReadingSoManyThreads · 11/08/2023 22:31

Ventouse and episiotomy were more likely down to positioning than size. One of mine was 8lb 15oz and was so easy to birth. Another was 7lb and due to awkward positioning and inpatient doctors, ended in emcs 🙄

Generally, they say bigger babies are easier to birth, but the key is all in your position to let your pelvis open up. Medicalised births often have you on your back which are not conducive to natural vaginal births. Remaining upright, squatting or on all fours will help to birth baby no matter how big or small.

They love to fearmonger with the big baby card. Don't let it scare you.

I’m not sure telling her to call ignore doctors and just squat, is a particularly good idea.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 11/08/2023 22:31

AnxiousMamo · 11/08/2023 17:53

@CurlewKate They want to induce me and/or elective section because I have gestational diabetes and the baby is measuring big. Not just in weight but large abdominal circumference in comparison to limbs / head. So that will mean induction + glucose monitoring in labour, at the least. I’m also having a private Group B Strep test as I had this last time, so depending on the result it may also mean antibiotics in labour (IV).

Before I knew about the diabetes and induction I was keen to let nature take its course and have a natural water birth. Now I know the baby is measuring big, it’s reminding me of the birth of my first DC, who was 8lb 15oz and needed ventouse and episiotomy to be delivered.

Ventouse and episiotomy were more likely down to positioning than size. One of mine was 8lb 15oz and was so easy to birth. Another was 7lb and due to awkward positioning and inpatient doctors, ended in emcs 🙄

Generally, they say bigger babies are easier to birth, but the key is all in your position to let your pelvis open up. Medicalised births often have you on your back which are not conducive to natural vaginal births. Remaining upright, squatting or on all fours will help to birth baby no matter how big or small.

They love to fearmonger with the big baby card. Don't let it scare you.

AnxiousMamo · 11/08/2023 17:53

@CurlewKate They want to induce me and/or elective section because I have gestational diabetes and the baby is measuring big. Not just in weight but large abdominal circumference in comparison to limbs / head. So that will mean induction + glucose monitoring in labour, at the least. I’m also having a private Group B Strep test as I had this last time, so depending on the result it may also mean antibiotics in labour (IV).

Before I knew about the diabetes and induction I was keen to let nature take its course and have a natural water birth. Now I know the baby is measuring big, it’s reminding me of the birth of my first DC, who was 8lb 15oz and needed ventouse and episiotomy to be delivered.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 11/08/2023 15:40

@AnxiousMamo I may be misreading- but are you saying you think you are certain to have a more medicalised birth than you want? Is that just because of the predicted size of the baby, or are there other issues I missed?

NotAMug · 11/08/2023 15:02

This is purely anecdotal but I have a group of friends who are doctors, we were at a dinner party and they were all there, I had a c-sec with my 2nd and they were chatting about giving birth and they said if they were given the choice even without complications they would have a section every time. My assumption for this feeling is that because they are doctors they are only ever in attendance when things go wrong but my point is that I would personally always have a c-sec if offered when things may not be quite right as these days it is a pretty safe option and recovery can be really quick. My recovery was much quicker than from my complicated natural birth.

Soverymuchfruit · 11/08/2023 14:28

AnxiousMamo · 11/08/2023 11:41

@Jellycats4life A few people have told me about the c-section ‘pouch’ though! Which is a silly (and vain) reason not to have a section if that’s what is best for me and baby.

Trying not to sound judgy to anyone here, and obviously I don't know what size you are. But I think you only really get that 'pouch' if you have quite a lot of belly fat. I don't have one (size 12-14), and nor does my (I think size 16) friend. At least I've never noticed her having one, she's gorgeous!

Echoing that the scar is really not a big deal, it's hidden in your pubic hair.

As for ELCS recovery: it's not nothing, you don't want to be running after and picking up a toddler. I had difficulty getting out of a low sofa while holding my baby. So we made a safe space to briefly put the baby down on the sofa next to me, just literally while I was standing up, and we put a big cushion on the sofa so I wasn't so low. It's that sort of scale of things. For a couple of weeks. And there's no pain if you take your painkillers on schedule.

thecatsthecats · 11/08/2023 12:30

AnxiousMamo · 11/08/2023 11:41

@Jellycats4life A few people have told me about the c-section ‘pouch’ though! Which is a silly (and vain) reason not to have a section if that’s what is best for me and baby.

You also don't get to choose "no c section" as an outcome, since it might happen anyway!

The only option you can actually choose is an elective c section, and the only one you can really rule out is induction. All the others might happen without choosing them.

Guh.

phoenixrosehere · 11/08/2023 12:22

Nubnut · 10/08/2023 12:27

this is mad!
How common is this?
I was told by my hospital that I could get an ultrasound at 39 weeks to try to predict weight, but actually a very experienced midwife would be more accurate estimating with her hands.

I was coerced with our first into an induction for a “big baby” because they diagnosed me with GD (32 weeks) but it was diet-controlled, sugars had remained normal during testing, urine normal throughout pregnancy, as well as checks on my placenta at 38 weeks showing no issues. They wanted to induce me at 36 weeks but I refused because there was no evidence beyond baby “looking big”. Before my GD diagnosis, the consultant was speaking of induction at 20 weeks because they (only them) thought there was IUGR, but we got a second opinion from a fetal specialist in IUGR that said there was no evidence supporting this and baby was healthy. At 24 weeks, same consultant said baby was looking big. GTT at 28 weeks, I passed. Several appointments over two weeks 36-38 telling me I was hurting my baby by not inducing and quoting stillbirth stats (outdated ones that had no relevance to my pregnancy). 38 weeks, baby looked to be close to 8lbs via ultrasound was their reason for induction. Induced at 39 despite me asking for my bishop score beforehand because I didn’t want to proceed if it was low which means a higher chance in induction failing. Told they had to induce me first. The pessary was painful going in that I was in tears. As expected, it failed, 3 cm in three days, horrendous care from the consultants, emer cs, and a blue baby that was not disclosed until after we reported them. Son was a whopping 6lb 14oz.

Hospital couldn’t explain to us why induction was pushed after looking through everything and concluded it had been absolutely unnecessary. No apology from any of those consultants. Do recall someone being pushed into retirement though.

AnxiousMamo · 11/08/2023 11:41

@Jellycats4life A few people have told me about the c-section ‘pouch’ though! Which is a silly (and vain) reason not to have a section if that’s what is best for me and baby.

OP posts:
Jellycats4life · 11/08/2023 09:41

I don’t want a scar on my stomach my whole life

I know you don’t really mean “stomach” but most c section scars are so low down, below the public hair line, they’re basically invisible. Mine is so thin and fine I really do struggle to find it 🤣

AnxiousMamo · 11/08/2023 08:57

@Nubnut I don’t fancy the scar either nor the recovery afterwards (though lots of people have told me it’s fine)! I’m just worried about risk to the baby and further damage to myself, tearing along the episiotomy for example, and I’m not sure how I calm these concerns. I would be devastated if anything happened to the baby, or if I ended up damaging myself further or worse down below, or if it ended in an emergency c-section anyway. If I could have the natural, water birth that I envisioned it wouldn’t even be a question. As it stands, I’ll be hooked up to an induction and glucose drip, as well as being monitored throughout. It will be very medically managed. I also had Group B Strep last pregnancy, and I am paying for a private test this time around, so there’s also the possibility I will also be hooked up to a third (!) IV of antibiotics. I really wish I was not in this position having to choose between two births I do not want.

@CaptainJackSparrow85 Thank you, I’ve heard that lots of people have had positive elective caesareans, which is very reassuring if I decide to have one.

OP posts:
CaptainJackSparrow85 · 11/08/2023 08:00

Not the same situation but I had a big baby and a bad tear first time round and was offered a c-section to prevent further damage. I stressed for ages about the risks of a c-section and the disadvantages to the baby of being born by c-section.

The c-section was a beautiful experience with a far easier recovery than my vaginal birth and DC2 is generally healthier than DC1 (much less prone to minor illnesses).

Nubnut · 11/08/2023 07:45

In your position (as I probably will be in 8 weeks time) I would try for a vaginal birth and prepare for it as thoroughly as I could.
My personal reasons would be:

  • benefits to the baby of the microbiome
  • easier recovery making breastfeeding start easier
  • I don’t want a scar on my stomach my whole life
  • I’ve done it before and I can do it again
Everyone will have their own personal list like this, it’s individual choice. Good luck.
AnxiousMamo · 10/08/2023 23:43

@Soverymuchfruit Wow, thank you so much for this information. I am off to do more research now. Interestingly, I’ve just had another look at my babies measurements - the head circumference is 70th centile whilst abdomen is greater than 95th centile (off the scale)! Limbs are all 85th. Those measurements definitely fit with GD and also suggest a greater risk of shoulder dystocia.

I am still torn and in two minds. I’ve spoken to some people in my personal life and their opinions are really mixed too - some think I should try induction and vaginal whilst others are telling me that I should have the elective caesarean and recovery and pain is really not that terrible.

OP posts:
Soverymuchfruit · 10/08/2023 14:08

Yes. As I understand it, if the body is large relative to the head, there's a much bigger risk that the body gets stuck when the head is already delivered. This is shoulder dystocia and is dangerous. It is also associated with gestational diabetes that has gone undiagnosed because the baby has had too much sugar. And if you're looking at shapes on a screen, you might not translate that into weights quite right, but you really can see if the abdomen is unusually big relative to the head. So if they say big abdomen, believe them and take that seriously.

But the OP should definitely talk this through with her specialist, I'm just describing my understanding from a couple of years ago, I might have got some of it wrong!

Nubnut · 10/08/2023 13:04

mean, I mean

Nubnut · 10/08/2023 13:03

@Soverymuchfruit this is interesting. So you meet large abdomen relative to small head? That ratio?

Soverymuchfruit · 10/08/2023 12:55

Btw, as a counterpoint to the messages about inaccurate scans. You said that your baby has an unusually large stomach, which makes sense as it's associated with GD. My understanding is that the relative size measurements are much more accurate than the total size ones, that is, they might get your baby's weight wrong but they are very likely to be correct about that large abdomen. And when I was reading up on it (I really was in exactly the same situation), I understood that it's large abdomen relative to head size, that gives you the risk of shoulder dystocia. And that's the outcome that potentially seriously injures both you and baby.

My baby did indeed come out at a lower percentile than estimated -- 90th rather than 99th. Maybe they were a bit out. But also, I got a better handle on the GD once I knew about it, so maybe I just stopped over-feeding the baby. Anyway I've never regretted my ELCS for an instant.

Anyway, I suggest you ask about this point about relative proportions and shoulder dystocia, at your next appointment?

ButterCrackers · 10/08/2023 12:50

A planned cs would have an easier recovery than a traumatic delivery. You’ve recovered from the latter. I’d say not to go through that again. Enjoy the birth. It’s a recovery afterwards but you’ll be up and about in no time. Also no damage to what has healed from your first birth.

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 10/08/2023 12:40

Just to add to the stories of scans being incredibly wrong. I had weekly scans at one point for my "small baby".

She was born at 40plus1 at 8lb 3oz.

Not sure what weight they would have considered to be a big baby!

W0tnow · 10/08/2023 12:36

Caesar. No question. Wouldn’t think twice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread