Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH's friend said this during my wedding

315 replies

orangeberry · 08/08/2023 16:47

I have just got married.

DH has a friendship group consisting of himself, Sarah, Vanessa and Jessica (not real names). They have been friends for a long time.

At my wedding, during the reception, Sarah said "Vanessa should have been the best man anyway". This was in earshot of me as I came to mingle with their table and thank them for coming.

DH's best men were my brother and my FIL, DH's father.

DH has reached out to Vanessa and Jessica and Vanessa has stressed that the best man comment did not come from her and they are both horrified by Sarah's actions on the wedding day. Vanessa and Jessica both said that Sarah put a real downer on the whole evening and tried to drag everyone down with her; she was miserable.

I'm upset by the comment Sarah made about Vanessa being the best man when my DBro was one of DH's best men and he gave such a lovely speech and they have a great bond. I'm more upset that she chose to say that during my own wedding reception!

AIBU to reach out to Sarah to let her know that I am hurt?

OP posts:
Wenfy · 09/08/2023 13:45

It’s strange he chose your family members as best men instead of his actual friends. Did you influence the decision?

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 09/08/2023 13:42

OriginalBliss · 09/08/2023 13:16

Well, I'm going to say it, DH should have married Sarah. Or possibly Jessica. And had Vanessa as best (wo)man either way.

😂😂

OriginalBliss · 09/08/2023 13:16

Well, I'm going to say it, DH should have married Sarah. Or possibly Jessica. And had Vanessa as best (wo)man either way.

WisherWood · 09/08/2023 12:15

Why use fake names then tell everyone you are on here they’re fake

Well you can't use real names because it's revealing.

If you use fake names but don't say they're fake, people say 'oh, you've used names, are they fake?'

If you replace names with letters, people say 'oh it's very confusing all this A, B, C nonsense, why can't you just use fake names?'

Ditto if you use something like 'best friend' or 'groom's best friend'. That just gets confusing, apparently.

So fake names seems like a good option. Until someone starts querying that one as well.

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 11:35

Yes, most people agree it's best to let it go now.

BlastedIce · 09/08/2023 11:29

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 11:23

Yes, I agree it's best not to do anything @BlastedIce. I don't think it's'very strange to be uoset by it, that's all. But much better to leave it now.

And I do think is extremely strange and very controlling to want to “reach out”, which is essentially tell them off.

I think it’s strange to be concerned about a single comment and extremely precious.

So we will have to agree to disagree.

Although the vote is 93% that OP is BU, which is quite telling.

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 11:23

Yes, I agree it's best not to do anything @BlastedIce. I don't think it's'very strange to be uoset by it, that's all. But much better to leave it now.

BlastedIce · 09/08/2023 11:18

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 10:32

The phrase 'new bride' is a well used one It's a thing, it's not something pp made up to echo 'new mum'?
(You can check if you dont believe me. In fact I recommend you do.)

Getting married is a stressful time, whatever @BlastedIce thinks, and it takes many people a bit of time to settle down into routine life again. It's also a special time in someone's life and so it's traditional not to behave in a way that might upset the bride (and groom) on their day.

That said I think OP is worrying too much now
about Sarah's remark. I understand why she's upset, but I don't think she should contact her about it. She should let it go now in my opinion.

Whatever I think is what I think, people are allowed different opinions?

You don’t seem to understand that.

I have been a bride, but I wasn’t a bridezilla!

No excuse for the “new bride” to still be going on about it and reaching out to say she was upset, unless of course she wants to stop the friendship between her “new groom” and his friends.

Not one mention of what he thinks about this, they’re his friends after all.

Could you imagine the uproar if he contacted his wife’s best friends to tell them off for upsetting him over a trivial comment?

He would be called over bearing, controlling and rude, justifiably so.

When does the “new bride” is allowed to act differently end? The first anniversary?

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 11:15

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea
The wedding day itself is more elaborate than ever though. And most people aren't practised at organising large events. I think it's quite normal for newlyweds to hope everything went ok afterwards and to replay events in their minds (maybe most especially because it's not the first time they sleep or live together, usually, so not so focused on that side of things).

I know after my wedding I was a bit upset because I had overheard the choir ( friends of my dad) cross and complaining that I had arrived late at the church and so had delayed their journey to a later event on the same day. ( I wasn't very late and wasn't aware of the other event. Still justifying myself!) Anyway, I was quite upset by it I remember. I was also concerned about someone not having turned up. I had so wanted everyone to be happy and enjoy the day and to aporove of how we'd organised things (bit unrealistic I know, but it was an emotional time). I was also very happy btw, but there were definitely a few things I worried about too. I don't think it's that unusual.

KarmaStar · 09/08/2023 10:46

Non event stop causing trouble and have the decency to move and and keep quiet.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 09/08/2023 10:42

I don’t think it’s weird to choose family as best men. Certainly no weirder than choosing a female best friend anyway, which would also be a slightly unusual choice.

And if Sarah has a problem with it then the person she should speak to is your DH. And she’d have had plenty of time to whinge about it to their mutual friends before the wedding. There wasn’t any obvious need to discuss it at the wedding!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/08/2023 10:42

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 10:32

The phrase 'new bride' is a well used one It's a thing, it's not something pp made up to echo 'new mum'?
(You can check if you dont believe me. In fact I recommend you do.)

Getting married is a stressful time, whatever @BlastedIce thinks, and it takes many people a bit of time to settle down into routine life again. It's also a special time in someone's life and so it's traditional not to behave in a way that might upset the bride (and groom) on their day.

That said I think OP is worrying too much now
about Sarah's remark. I understand why she's upset, but I don't think she should contact her about it. She should let it go now in my opinion.

I understand what you're saying, but 'new bride' was used to describe a status change. It's not really that anymore as (generally) women's lives don't change post marriage anymore. It's not like the woman is going through a big change with new things to learn and get used to. She (usually) hasn't just left her family home for the first time, learned what happens on the wedding night, has a new set of expectation etc on her, must suddenly be responsible for domestic work etc.
Nowadays, nothing changes. So technically yes she is still a 'new bride', that category doesn't carry the same stress and expectations as it previously did.

I do agree that a wedding can be stressful, but usually that's in the build up. Post wedding should be just happiness. The pride of a job well done and the feeling of love and wedded bliss. If you're stressed straight after the wedding I'd be worried that something was wrong.

UnsolicitedOpinions · 09/08/2023 10:36

Wavessea · 09/08/2023 08:20

Why use fake names then tell everyone you are on here they’re fake

I think the OP is wrong - both making too much of it and it’s weird to have your bride’s brother instead of your best friend.

However, using fake names and saying you’ve changed the names is totally normal. Everyone would of course assume the names were fake anyway, but there’s no harm in saying you’ve changed the names.

Unless you think now that knowing the name could be anything at all except Vanessa is too big a clue?

Grandomens · 09/08/2023 10:32

MiddleParking · 09/08/2023 07:08

‘New bride’ is ridiculous because it seems to attempt to echo the phrase ‘new mum’. The latter having actual practical connotations for which allowances should (perhaps) be made, and the former not being in any way a thing.

The phrase 'new bride' is a well used one It's a thing, it's not something pp made up to echo 'new mum'?
(You can check if you dont believe me. In fact I recommend you do.)

Getting married is a stressful time, whatever @BlastedIce thinks, and it takes many people a bit of time to settle down into routine life again. It's also a special time in someone's life and so it's traditional not to behave in a way that might upset the bride (and groom) on their day.

That said I think OP is worrying too much now
about Sarah's remark. I understand why she's upset, but I don't think she should contact her about it. She should let it go now in my opinion.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/08/2023 10:18

PoseyFlump · 08/08/2023 20:15

Then you're not reading hard enough. I agree with the OP

I think Sarah timed the comment to hurt and ruin the evening. Her friends said as much. Wouldn't be surprised if Sarah wants to be more than just friends with the DH.

TBF if a comment like that (said in a private conversation) could ruin the wedding, then it wasn't a very good wedding.

I couldn't have given a shiny shit what people were saying at my wedding or about my wedding. I was too busy have fun with my "new groom", my family and my friends. I know for a fact that it wouldn't have been to everyone's taste and people possibly thought I should have done things differently, had different people doing different things etc...but I honestly don't care. If I had heard a comment I probably would have told them to quit whinging and have fun.

Also what a weird leap to assume that Sarah fancies the H.

frumpalertt · 09/08/2023 08:50

God, so much madness and paranoia in this. Mumsnet is really NOT a normal place is it?

Fwiw, weddings are just weird events, people say and do strange things around the ritual of it all, and without knowing the people a ton better it is pretty much impossible to determine why Sarah might have said that.

I do think is is healthy and positive if there is a place to recognise platonic friendships in weddings - and chosen family. It's nice when that can happen, and something a lot of heterosexual culture misses out on. I would normally expect the best man not to be from the bride's family, but hey, if they are truly best mates there's nothing wrong with it.

Threenow · 09/08/2023 08:39

It's a non-event, just forget about it.

Guiltridden12345 · 09/08/2023 08:33

Yeah this is nothing op, stop over analysing and have a wonderful marriage!

Wavessea · 09/08/2023 08:20

Why use fake names then tell everyone you are on here they’re fake

QueenCamilla · 09/08/2023 08:13

I have suspected for a while that I have nothing in common with "The Wedding" people. OP's thread just cements it.

I'll start asking about people's weddings as a way of sifting chuff from seed.

QueenCamilla · 09/08/2023 08:09

Yep, your husband should "reach out" and apologise about ignoring his best friends on his wedding day. Sarah clearly thinks it was a cuntish thing to do and I agree.
A gold star to you for "welcoming them with open arms". Whoda' thought it was even a possibility to be so warm and welcoming... 🙄

AnImaginaryCat · 09/08/2023 07:57

Well!! This is seriously not acceptable behaviour. I wouldn't bother reaching out to that wagon Sarah. I suggest just going straight for the kill.

I mean, it should be easy. Your husband (or shall we call him your new groom?) has all ready done a reconnaissance and it seems Vanessa and Jessica will be on board. Either of them a sharp shooter?

I do suggest before you go through with it that you do some research and find out if someone didn't like the cake or the flowers. Might as well do a job lot.

Or alternatively, you could realise you've already made too much of it and just let it go. This doesn't mean you're benefiting Sarah by the way, dropping it will benefit you more.

Krickley · 09/08/2023 07:56

Well if she is his best friend then perhaps she should have been best man? That aside, just let it go, its not worth falling out for

Inkpotlover · 09/08/2023 07:55

Loads of remarks will have been made behind your back at your wedding. Like it or not, people can be judgemental! Someone won't have liked your dress. Others will have turned their noses up at the food. Thought your first dance song was naff. And someone definitely made an aside that they thought they deserved to be 'best woman'. The point is, so what? There's a saying that what people think of you is none of your business. If you let this one off-the-cuff sour your memory of your big day then you are being ridiculous. Let it go.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 09/08/2023 07:52

Well tbh it's weird he chose 2 members of YOUR family to dot he job. Maybe your husband's friend thinks you were a bit controlling? In any case there is nothing you need to do about it, it was just a comment and she is entitled to her opinion.