Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be desperate for 'mum friends '

139 replies

Zumma · 08/08/2023 15:52

DS is 12 weeks old. We moved to a new area last year so don't know loads of people apart from a few neighbours and acquaintances from the pub we went to before he was born.

A few people have commented about joining local baby groups etc and said it will be great for me to meet 'mum friends'. I've signed up for some already mainly as I think they'll be beneficial for DS. I'll also happily chit chat casually to other mums there as you do, but I can't imagine that I'll find really strong friendships there nor am I that bothered.

I didn't bother with an NCT group, partly due to distance of nearest one but also not keen on the idea that you all have to be 'friends' after and keep up with eachother in a Whatssapp group. A few friends have told me about various dramas with their NCT friends and it sounds quite childish and exhausting.

I mentioned this to a cousin the other day and she thought I was being antisocial and unfriendly. I've reflected on my attitude as I can see where she's coming from.

I think over the years growing up, I had some bad experiences with groups of girls (mild bullying, gossip etc) so the idea of actively seeking out groups of mums to be good friends with fills me with dread in case there's any bitchiness or horrid dynamics. I know we're all adults but it still happens - I've read a few threads on here about NCT groups and mums at the school gate to see what goes wrong. It's my idea of hell and I think it would take me back to feeling like an inadequate young girl again so I actively avoid it.

When I was younger I was often making friends with people due to having one thing in common eg on the same course or houseshare but beyond that there was nothing else so friendships were so superficial and fizzled out quickly. I imagine it's similar if the only thing you have in common with someone is you had kids at the same time?

I do have old friends of 5 or 10 years who are mums and I've connected well with them on motherhood although they don't live close by.

I'm probably overthinking the whole thing and I will obviously be friendly and chatty at the baby groups and if a genuine and nice friendship emerges then great but I suppose I'm much more selective and reserved about closer friendships these days and don't want to feel like I have to be everyone's friend and force pointless mum friendships as it hasn't worked well for me in the past. I'm also OK with my own company mostly as I often see family and old friends at weekends even though they're not local.

I'm sure as DS is older they'll be more happening with playmates and parties but for now I'm not desperately seeking out mum friends.

YABU - motherhood is a great time for new friendships and you're overthinking and missing an opportunity

YANBU - you're right to be reflective and cautious about these friendships and do what feels comfortable and genuine

OP posts:
Rufusroo · 13/08/2023 16:05

You don’t have to become instant ‘best buddies’ with the other mums you meet but it is more comfortable for you and your son to have a wider circle of people to interact with. You are sharing a common bond by having children of a similar age and it will be nice for your child to get to know the children he will be going to Nursery/School with. You may also well find that one or two of the other mums will become more than just passing acquaintances. Don’t let past experiences put you off. Find a friendly, supportive Mother&Baby group. I found they differed wildly in how welcoming they were but eventually found a lovely group and actually looked forward to going.

5128gap · 13/08/2023 09:28

I think these type of circumstantial friendships work if you keep perspective. So rather than going in with the idea of finding a close circle of supportive confidents who's company will bring you joy, you see them more as colleagues.
We're all doing the same job here and a bit of social interaction, companionship, sharing of ideas can make the day go by. You may be very lucky and amongst your mum 'colleagues' find someone you really gel with, in which case you've found a friend. Bonus!
Again, like the workplace, there can be toxicity arising from competition, gossip, and being thrown together with some individuals you don't care for. So the trick is to keep some distance, don't get drawn in to drama and don't over invest. You won't be 'working' with these people for ever, so it can all stay superficial and in perspective.

PurBal · 13/08/2023 09:18

I think mum friends come into their own with a toddler. They’re not my best buds. But my day consists of “how am I going to entertain the toddler” (was part time and currently on mat leave) and doing that with another adult is so much easier than on my own. So I’m friendly with people that work part time and have a similar aged child. I don’t see many of my other friends (those with children different ages or child free) because we’re in different places in our lives and they work. Weekends are precious family time with DH. On the flip side I’ve bonded with some friends who were once distant because we have similar age children. Very few people want to have a conversation along the lines of “I did a fart” or engage with a 10 minute tantrum because toddler ate the last of the raisins. That’s easier with mums.

prescribingmum · 13/08/2023 09:18

I am yet to experience the widespread MN classic group of cliquey, snobby, exclusionary Mums in reality.

You will find some other Mums who make great company right now when babies are little but it all tails off as you are busy in life and you will find others you just click with and make great long term friends. You have nothing to lose by going out and meeting others; even if its the former, it makes maternity leave so much more enjoyable to have some company.

Going forwards, if you make great friends and trust them, you end up helping each other out which is absolutely invaluable

mrsplum2015 · 13/08/2023 09:12

Interesting.
There's no particular reason why you should have mum friends but I wouldn't be without mine. I've got a massive range of mum friends built up over 18 years including one quite big group.

I have found it invaluable for social, practical and emotional support. And it's great to be able to share experiences with my kids friends and their parents.

I have 2 good friends with girls the same age as my oldest and we go away for weekends regularly. The girls are all 18 now and we have great fun!

Howmuchfurther · 13/08/2023 09:07

Little ones like little ones. When they are happily playing with each other, you get a break.

Maternity leave is a shock to the finances. Having coffee at each other’s houses is cheaper.

At a friend’s house, you worry less about safety and behaviour than you would in a public place.

See it as a friendly colleague thing, not a lifelong soul mate thing.

Kwasi · 13/08/2023 09:02

I moved to an area before I had my son. Everyone told me I would make friends once I had kids. I had a kid and still didn’t make friends; it just wasn’t that kind of area. When my son was 2, I moved to an area 25 miles away and have made mum acquaintances and non-mum friends. It’s a super friendly area where everyone says hello!

ChestnutGrove · 10/08/2023 13:49

ChestnutGrove · 10/08/2023 13:33

I haven't made friends with groups of mums but have made friends with individual women I've met since having kids. They are lovely and not bitchy. After my husband died I was really glad I had female friends I could meet up with rather than only socialising with couples. It was a godsend. Our kids are nearly grown up now.
I don't really hold with the "Women are bitchy/Men are lovely" cliché. I worked with a group of men who were quite bitchy and look at what men can be like online!

Forget to mention that two of my friends were women I met at toddler group and clicked with and one was a primary school mum. We've not met up with kids for years. I met plenty of women at toddler groups and school that weren't friendship material but the ones I did click with have been friends for 15-20 years and probably always will be.

ChestnutGrove · 10/08/2023 13:33

I haven't made friends with groups of mums but have made friends with individual women I've met since having kids. They are lovely and not bitchy. After my husband died I was really glad I had female friends I could meet up with rather than only socialising with couples. It was a godsend. Our kids are nearly grown up now.
I don't really hold with the "Women are bitchy/Men are lovely" cliché. I worked with a group of men who were quite bitchy and look at what men can be like online!

Fizbosshoes · 10/08/2023 13:15

There are different reasons for going to baby groups - I felt i needed to be out of the house most days when my dc were very small so a baby group filled up part of the week. Sometimes we just went to the park or went shopping but actually it was nice to have adult company/chat for an hour.

It's often easier to socialise with people at the same stage. Another mum with a toddler is probably more likely to spend the morning at soft play or the zoo than an elderly friend, or someone with teens. I have a good friend with children 10 years younger than mine. It's harder to arrange meet ups when teens don't necessarily have the same interests as toddlers.

Mary46 · 10/08/2023 11:49

I was glad of some company mid weeks. 2 friends off around same time. It can be lonely at home when everyone is working.

ChurlishGreen · 10/08/2023 11:41

fullbloom87 · 08/08/2023 20:59

Meh I never bothered with 'mum groups' didn't appeal to me. All women tend to do is show off about their lives and babies and let's face it all babies care about is boob and mum, they don't care about 'socialising' so it's not really for babies really.

I don’t think anyone thinks socialising is for the babies. And frankly, with an attitude like yours, I doubt other women, whether they’re parents or not, are beating down your door wanting to be friends.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/08/2023 11:37

fullbloom87 · 08/08/2023 20:59

Meh I never bothered with 'mum groups' didn't appeal to me. All women tend to do is show off about their lives and babies and let's face it all babies care about is boob and mum, they don't care about 'socialising' so it's not really for babies really.

'All women tend to do is show off'

Gosh! Not my experience at all. Lots of advice and sympathy shared between mums of babys of similar ages - they really get it when you're tired, struggling emotionally, unsure about feeding etc, more than other friends or family do.

There is a narrative about smug mums. Eg if a mum mentions her baby sleeps well she's smug. Mine does, and I've been terrified to tell people in case someone like this thinks I'm showing off!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/08/2023 11:33

I've loved making mum friends I kind of see them like colleagues- probably won't keep in touch with most of them forever but they get what I'm going through now and can give support and advice, and means I have people to see during the working week and don't bore my usual friends with chat of weaning and nappy brands!

Parker231 · 10/08/2023 11:30

I didn’t make ‘mum friends’ - I had friends pre DT’s and still have those friends. I continued to see those friends when DT’s were born. I didn’t go to any baby classes or groups. I was back at work full time when DT’s were six months old.
DT’s haven’t suffered from lack of play dates or friends - they still have some they made in nursery.

Bouledeneige · 10/08/2023 11:23

I also think that parenting young babies and young children is such an intense experience that, for a time at least, it drives a wedge between you and your friends without children. You just don't have the same time, the same freedom, you are used to interrupted conversations and life has a different focus. So having friends who are in the same boat as you fills a gap. You get very good at chatting with constant interruptions - and you don't bore them as you do your child free friends with the minutiae if family life. Over time that gulf recedes and the bond with your real friends sustains - but with the addition of your 'real' Mum friends.

reabies · 09/08/2023 11:21

I think you're overthinking it but also when you say:

'I will obviously be friendly and chatty at the baby groups and if a genuine and nice friendship emerges then great'

Then that's a totally normal approach to making friends. Speak to someone, see if you like them, see where it goes. No pressure to be friends with everyone you meet on mat leave (and if you go to groups, you will meet people) but if you get chatting to someone and eventually swap numbers and maybe go for coffee a few times then great. Nice way to pass the time.

IglesiasPiggl · 09/08/2023 07:18

I found my mum friends invaluable for the first decade of parenthood, and think it's worth making the effort to get to know people at the same lifestage as you. You won't be best friends with everyone you meet but that doesn't matter. I had people I just chatted to at particular baby groups but never more than that, people I was friendly with until they moved away, and a couple who are still friends now, when our children have moved on. If you do find yourself in a WhatsApp group you don't like, it's easy to step back by missing several meet ups in a row and not commenting in the group.

Fizbosshoes · 09/08/2023 07:14

I don't think you're obliged to be friends with people just because their children are the same age. But if you go to a baby group it's likely they'll be some people you gel or connect with and others you don't- just like anywhere else. (Work, hobbies, parties etc)
I found the first year of motherhood quite lonely and I was glad of having 1 or 2 good friends that I could meet on their own outside of the groups. And I met with a group that I'd done ante natal classes with. We're still in touch 17 years later.

NerrSnerr · 09/08/2023 07:14

I made some friends when on maternity leave. I'm still friends with them now and it's just nice to send a message saying 'we're going to the park if anyone's free' and then the children have people to play with. It's also nice to have someone you know at events, parties etc.

It can be a bit lonely on maternity leave at times. You don't need to go looking for a tribe but having people you're friendly with can help at times.

gothshot · 09/08/2023 07:12

I have a 4 month old and I'm a very introverted person myself. I didn't have great experiences with friends growing up, I was bullied throughout first/middle school and then there were times I was ditched by my "best friend" in high school. I definitely have issues trusting people and I always think people don't like me.
I joined a baby sensory class when DD was 9 weeks old, we really enjoy it and it's great to watch her learn however I haven't made any friends there myself. Yes I talk to other women, I'm friendly and they are too but there's still that voice in the back of my mind telling me they think I'm weird and don't like me.
I don't have a group of friends either, my best friend has her own life and we are such different people now. I basically just have my other half, his family and my family. And I'm ok with that!
I'm open to going to other classes/groups with DD as she gets older for her to socialise but I'm not bothered about making friends.
You have to do what you're comfortable with and don't let anyone pressure you into doing things you don't want to do.

MRex · 09/08/2023 07:10

If you don't want friends that's fine and just skip the groups. It's important to be friendly if you do go though, if you've been rude to people when your child was young, they may remember when it's those exact same people you come across at nursery and school. You may also find your child is different than you and wants social opportunities with their peers as they get older, so you'll need to navigate those situations. Is your DH a bit more social, would he be willing to create relationships with the parents to facilitate interactions for your child?

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 09/08/2023 07:07

museumum · 08/08/2023 21:02

You don’t have to be besties with other mums but if you’re off work for 3/6/12 months it’s good to have people to hang out with Monday to Friday and useful if the6 have the same kind of requirements you do in terms of baby friendly requirements etc.

I agree. I have been working part time for 4 years (DS is nearly 5) and 2 of my NCT mums plus 1 nursery mum have been invaluable on my days off to give DS, an only, someone to race about with. Especially in winter; you can go to each other's houses when it's freezing and raining.

DaisyWaldron · 09/08/2023 07:07

I met some amazing people through NCT, toddler groups etc, but there's nothing wrong with not wanting to do that.

I do think that beyond the friendship aspect, it's handy to have good relationships with a few people with similarly aged children in your area, not with a friendship relationship, but effectively as colleagues in parenting, who can share useful information and so you have someone to chat to during all the times you are hanging around waiting for your child.

ChurlishGreen · 09/08/2023 07:06

You’ve invented a set of imaginary scenarios in your head from other people’s comments, Mn threads about the school run or friendship dramas, and a few past experiences. While there’s absolutely no compulsion to befriend anybody, ever, your fear of what you imagine friendship groups to be like should absolutely not hold you back if you encounter people you like.

’Mum friends’ are not some separate category of human being and it’s one of Mn more damaging myths that they are, along with ‘school run mums’. My NCT group just didn’t much like one another, so never met much, then I moved to another part of the country while on mat leave, where I didn’t much care for the people I met socially, and made my friends at work. My ‘mum friends’ arrived in my life in another country when our children were 7/8, and one of the ones I’m closest to is a dad.