Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be desperate for 'mum friends '

139 replies

Zumma · 08/08/2023 15:52

DS is 12 weeks old. We moved to a new area last year so don't know loads of people apart from a few neighbours and acquaintances from the pub we went to before he was born.

A few people have commented about joining local baby groups etc and said it will be great for me to meet 'mum friends'. I've signed up for some already mainly as I think they'll be beneficial for DS. I'll also happily chit chat casually to other mums there as you do, but I can't imagine that I'll find really strong friendships there nor am I that bothered.

I didn't bother with an NCT group, partly due to distance of nearest one but also not keen on the idea that you all have to be 'friends' after and keep up with eachother in a Whatssapp group. A few friends have told me about various dramas with their NCT friends and it sounds quite childish and exhausting.

I mentioned this to a cousin the other day and she thought I was being antisocial and unfriendly. I've reflected on my attitude as I can see where she's coming from.

I think over the years growing up, I had some bad experiences with groups of girls (mild bullying, gossip etc) so the idea of actively seeking out groups of mums to be good friends with fills me with dread in case there's any bitchiness or horrid dynamics. I know we're all adults but it still happens - I've read a few threads on here about NCT groups and mums at the school gate to see what goes wrong. It's my idea of hell and I think it would take me back to feeling like an inadequate young girl again so I actively avoid it.

When I was younger I was often making friends with people due to having one thing in common eg on the same course or houseshare but beyond that there was nothing else so friendships were so superficial and fizzled out quickly. I imagine it's similar if the only thing you have in common with someone is you had kids at the same time?

I do have old friends of 5 or 10 years who are mums and I've connected well with them on motherhood although they don't live close by.

I'm probably overthinking the whole thing and I will obviously be friendly and chatty at the baby groups and if a genuine and nice friendship emerges then great but I suppose I'm much more selective and reserved about closer friendships these days and don't want to feel like I have to be everyone's friend and force pointless mum friendships as it hasn't worked well for me in the past. I'm also OK with my own company mostly as I often see family and old friends at weekends even though they're not local.

I'm sure as DS is older they'll be more happening with playmates and parties but for now I'm not desperately seeking out mum friends.

YABU - motherhood is a great time for new friendships and you're overthinking and missing an opportunity

YANBU - you're right to be reflective and cautious about these friendships and do what feels comfortable and genuine

OP posts:
Noodles4Me · 14/08/2023 17:14

I think it depends on if you go back to work full time too OP. I did, none of my other mum friends did so they could all socialise and I couldn’t.

Having said that, I made mum friends because we all lived in the same street and were pregnant at the same time. Without having same age kids I wouldn’t be friends with them - all we have in common is toddlers.

I’ll make more effort in groups next time. Not NCT - sounds awful to me - but deffo baby groups.

Courgeon · 14/08/2023 17:01

YANBU. I like friends but not "friendship groups". I'll only be in WhatsApp groups if it's for a shared interest or a specific activity. I've removed myself from a fair few WhatsApp groups.

Did nct as felt pressurised into it by other people but hated it and had a bad experience. I like seeing people 1 on 1 and am quite self contained so it doesn't bother me. Have a few friends I've met via the kids but am not part of a big group. With first child felt obliged to do all the baby groups and stuff and hated it. With second we just did our own thing and we were a lot happier for it.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 14/08/2023 16:55

that phase of my life was so fake and forced.

I can relate to that for some friendships. I cringe at how long I kept one going. We've now stopped bothering and I think would both be relieved.

mightymam · 14/08/2023 16:48

Good for you OP. I wish I'd had your confidence when I first had my DC. It was almost expected to go out and relentlessly socialise. I'm a social person anyway but that phase of my life was so fake and forced. I can hand on heart say, I didn't make any meaningful 'mum friends' or friendships with mum in those early years. My friendships came as they children got older and I met people through their weekend clubs where you could drop them off and have time for a chat!

Beachwaves127 · 14/08/2023 16:47

I’m in the middle! I didn’t join nct because I didn’t want to force friendships or be caught up in a group. I did the same as you - signed up for classes that I thought would benefit my Dc. I wasn’t fussed about friends. However I would say I’ve organically made good friends with some of the mums As I see them every week. Some of the mums I just chat to, but some I’m definitly friends with. It’s been nice as it wasn’t forced it was all organic. So I’d say Yanbu or anti social, but do keep an open mind at the classes you have signed up for.

Fizbosshoes · 14/08/2023 15:24

AmazingSnakeHead · 14/08/2023 14:28

Exactly. As if it isn't hard enough to be a woman and a mum, you then have to contend with this idea that you are [insert sexist pejorative] purely because you have a child, and hang around in places where other women with children are.

We are the same people that we were pre-children, we don't go from being interesting and compassionate friends (or whatever qualities the OP is after in a friend) to cliquey judgemental unkind superior "bicthes" (hate that word!) overnight, just because we now walk around with the person we made strapped to us.

The school mum thing intrigues me. Lots of people sneer at "school mums" but surely once your child is between 4 and 18 , unless you home school, then all mums are school mums... aren't they?? (But the poster never includes themselves in this group...)

AmazingSnakeHead · 14/08/2023 14:28

MissedItByThisMuch · 14/08/2023 11:34

Make friends or don’t make friends as you see fit, why would that be a matter you need anyone’s advice on?
But god I’m so fucking sick of this obnoxious self-defeating misogynistic narrative on here that women at NCT classes/toddler groups/school gates/insert gathering place for “mums” are bitchy/cliquey/unfriendly/insert pejorative.
They’re just a random group of people who happen to have children the same age. No more likely to be bitchy etc than any other random group of people. I’m pretty sure some people on here just see what they expect to see. You’ll probably click with some and not with others. It’s a bit bizarre making up your mind whether you’re going to make friends or not before you’ve even met them.

Exactly. As if it isn't hard enough to be a woman and a mum, you then have to contend with this idea that you are [insert sexist pejorative] purely because you have a child, and hang around in places where other women with children are.

We are the same people that we were pre-children, we don't go from being interesting and compassionate friends (or whatever qualities the OP is after in a friend) to cliquey judgemental unkind superior "bicthes" (hate that word!) overnight, just because we now walk around with the person we made strapped to us.

MissedItByThisMuch · 14/08/2023 11:34

Make friends or don’t make friends as you see fit, why would that be a matter you need anyone’s advice on?
But god I’m so fucking sick of this obnoxious self-defeating misogynistic narrative on here that women at NCT classes/toddler groups/school gates/insert gathering place for “mums” are bitchy/cliquey/unfriendly/insert pejorative.
They’re just a random group of people who happen to have children the same age. No more likely to be bitchy etc than any other random group of people. I’m pretty sure some people on here just see what they expect to see. You’ll probably click with some and not with others. It’s a bit bizarre making up your mind whether you’re going to make friends or not before you’ve even met them.

MariaVT65 · 14/08/2023 10:57

Blueroses99 · 14/08/2023 10:56

That’s nice for you. Many people, like myself, will find pre-baby friends are working Mon-Fri or are a significant distance away, so not having activities, classes, coffee/play dates to fill the days can lead to isolation, boredom or loneliness on mat leave.

Yes this is a really good point. I depend on my mum friends for playdates during the week.

Diddykong · 14/08/2023 10:57

Mum friends are useful for intel on what people consider good schools (they're not always right), events happening, what clubs might be useful as DC grows. I found mat leave pretty isolating so meeting up with people helped.

Blueroses99 · 14/08/2023 10:56

Parker231 · 10/08/2023 11:30

I didn’t make ‘mum friends’ - I had friends pre DT’s and still have those friends. I continued to see those friends when DT’s were born. I didn’t go to any baby classes or groups. I was back at work full time when DT’s were six months old.
DT’s haven’t suffered from lack of play dates or friends - they still have some they made in nursery.

That’s nice for you. Many people, like myself, will find pre-baby friends are working Mon-Fri or are a significant distance away, so not having activities, classes, coffee/play dates to fill the days can lead to isolation, boredom or loneliness on mat leave.

MariaVT65 · 14/08/2023 10:55

I think it may be depend on the specific friends you already have, or your ability to make new ones.

I lost a couple of childfree friends when I had my son as they just didn’t want to hang out with me.

I also find it tricky to make new friends at work who don’t have young kids as I am much less able to go socialising after work etc due to childcare, or generally being exhausted.

I have found it much easier to make new friends who also have kids, due to the new lifestyle we have in common. I have also kept/made a couple of new friends without kids, but they have a lot of relatives with smaller kids so understand a bit more. And one of them is now pregnant so coming to me for lots of support.

CheersLove · 14/08/2023 10:51

When I had my first son, none of my friends had children. I went to baby groups and would chit chat which was always nice but I never put in the effort to make friends as such because I thought it would be a bit odd to build a friendship over the fact that we were Mums. I was a SAHM at the time and I'd say it was a pretty lonely time!

After my second I made a lot more effort. When my eldest started pre-school I made a group of friends, when it came time for school we all broke off to different schools so I pushed myself to get chatting to mums at the school and I have a really lovely group of mum friends. I do think you need more of a connection than just being Mums but that comes over time, you just have to build on that initial connection.

I don't think you're being unreasonable. I see it from both points. Those friendships can be so important in that time of your life though, they really understand what you're going through when others don't. Just stay away from the 'perfect parents/my children can do no wrong' sort!!

FanFckingTastic · 14/08/2023 10:46

Motherhood (particularly in the early years) can be quite lonely and also incredibly monotonous - you are literally doing the same shit all day every day. I found that having friendships with other people that were in the same boat as me was incredibly useful. As well as being nice to have a wider social circle it's also really useful to see what other people do, pick up tips or just know that you are not alone with particular issues. My Mum friends were invaluable and whilst some where just acquaintances a few are now close friends.

The other benefit to having a wider social circle of mum-friends is that your little one will also get some exposure to a wider circle of baby-friends as they get older and start interacting more.

prescribingmum · 14/08/2023 10:41

They can be. Dealing with school gate mums is like being back at school yourself. Yuck!

People you meet in every environment have the potential to be immature or unkind. Applies to colleagues, university friends, hobby friends, both males and females. If you believe this only applies to Mums, it is more a reflection on you than anyone else

AmazingSnakeHead · 14/08/2023 10:09

Listen, it's entirely up to you. Of course you don't have to be friends with anyone, you might like spending most of the day just you and your child. But for many, maternity leave is long and it's nice to have friends that you regularly meet up with. Also as your baby gets older they will be less easy to chuck in a sling and go and do the things that you want to do, it's nice to have people you can talk to at softplay or whatever.

Saying you don't want mum friends in particular is a bit strange. Mums are just women who have children at the same time. It's like saying you don't want work friends, pub friends or running friends. There is very little that this group has in common. For my part, I was friendly to everyone, but obviously didn't make friends with everyone. I sought out the women who I had things in common with and who parented in ways that were compatible with my parenting. I really valued my "mum friends" - they are fantastic women and we supported each other through the trials of early motherhood.

And I have to say that this comment reeks of internalised misogyny. "I had some bad experiences with groups of girls (mild bullying, gossip etc) so the idea of actively seeking out groups of mums to be good friends with fills me with dread in case there's any bitchiness or horrid dynamics."

Why on earth are you comparing adult women to school children? The idea of women being "bitchy" is just self-hating misogyny, stemming from the idea that the standard for women is to be kind to everyone. Some women are nice, some are not. There is nothing about being a woman that makes you awful to others - only people who think that women are inherently awful would think this (i.e. only misogynists thinks this).

toodledo · 14/08/2023 09:34

It's absolutely up to you if you'd like mum friends or not. Maternity leave and looking after a small baby can be very lonely and repetitive - it's really nice to chat and meet up with others going through the same. So for me it was a lifeline. My childless friends just couldn't get it in the same way. But if you feel like you'd rather not of course that's entirely your prerogative! You don't have to do anything you don't want to.

Happiestinmygarden · 14/08/2023 09:32

I think most people acquire friendships from a whole host of different periods in your life, some will be around for a time and drift away, others will stick with you. Still my best best friends are those I met as a baby (the ones my Mum was Mum friends with their Mums!) I agree with the colleague analogy. Personally I would’ve struggled without those Mum friends who are going through the same thing. Those pregnancy/baby groups kept me sane, the days can be soooo looooong and boring with a baby and meeting mum friends and going to groups gives your week routine and structure and a bit of adult company. 14 years on some of these ‘colleagues’ have developed into lifelong friendships and can’t imagine life without them, keep in some contact with others, and a few I was glad to see the back of!

Fizbosshoes · 14/08/2023 09:25

They can be. Dealing with school gate mums is like being back at school yourself. Yuck!

I don't understand that "school mums" are a certain type of person different from the person describing them
At the school gate there will likely be a selection of people who have 1 thing in common - their child's age. There will be some you get on with and some you don't...surely like any other situation where you meet a group of people....? (Sports clubs, hobbies, work, weddings, parties etc)

JazbayGrapes · 14/08/2023 08:29

been there, done that, stopped bothering. Focus on friendships that are wholesome to you.

But a bit sad that you assume groups of mothers will be bitchy and childish.

They can be. Dealing with school gate mums is like being back at school yourself. Yuck!

Tinybrother · 14/08/2023 08:17

Luciferlooloo3 · 14/08/2023 07:17

I can relate to this quite well. I had my daughter 2 weeks before the initial lock down, having only relocated a year before. I had some work friend's from my new job but obviously they were all at work during the day. By the time I could go out my daughter was 14 months. I also couldn't be bothered with NCT groups, and knew no one else with a baby anywhere near me. I found a Gym Tots group in a village but found the group very cliquey. I also went back to work 3 days a week so felt like my opportunity to meet mum friends passed me by.
Tbf, I felt not having friends with babies the same age, saved me from all of the comparisons and worries that she wasn't developing at the right times (she was). My daughter is now 3.5 and I have a friend with a baby 1 year younger and another with one 3 years older. It suits me fine. Xx

Conversely, I had a newborn in lockdown plus a toddler and really felt the lack of contact with other mothers of children the same age. Perhaps I would have felt differently had I only had the baby.

Samlewis96 · 14/08/2023 07:20

Parker231 · 10/08/2023 11:30

I didn’t make ‘mum friends’ - I had friends pre DT’s and still have those friends. I continued to see those friends when DT’s were born. I didn’t go to any baby classes or groups. I was back at work full time when DT’s were six months old.
DT’s haven’t suffered from lack of play dates or friends - they still have some they made in nursery.

This exactly. I had friends I still have many of those sane friend from be DC and eldest is 32 I've also since made friends with people who are Mums and their kids were in school with mine but not THROUGH the kids. Met them at other events. Tbh I didn't change my interests when kids were born so I wasn't really going to start attending things that i wasn't interested in just because I had a baby. And maternity leave wasn't do bloody long then so not as much time to get bored. My DD2 has a nearly 6 year old She was back at work just before he was 5 months old and never really died the baby group circuit either. And the boy is taxied to and from school so she doesn't need to do the school run meetings with other parents either

It's not obligatory to do these things. Purely matter of choice

Luciferlooloo3 · 14/08/2023 07:17

I can relate to this quite well. I had my daughter 2 weeks before the initial lock down, having only relocated a year before. I had some work friend's from my new job but obviously they were all at work during the day. By the time I could go out my daughter was 14 months. I also couldn't be bothered with NCT groups, and knew no one else with a baby anywhere near me. I found a Gym Tots group in a village but found the group very cliquey. I also went back to work 3 days a week so felt like my opportunity to meet mum friends passed me by.
Tbf, I felt not having friends with babies the same age, saved me from all of the comparisons and worries that she wasn't developing at the right times (she was). My daughter is now 3.5 and I have a friend with a baby 1 year younger and another with one 3 years older. It suits me fine. Xx

Curseofthenation · 13/08/2023 21:31

I really valued my small NCT group. We didn't all stick it out as one group and there was a 'character' in the group that got dropped as she tried to cause drama and another wasn't too interested in remaining friends but wasn't unfriendly.

I remained friends with two people from the group on a one to one basis. What I'm trying to say with all of this is that they were all individuals, not just generic mums, and therefore some friendships lasted and others didn't. We all had some lovely chats in the early newborn days when the world was our babies but as others have said, you need more than that to make a good friend.

I don't regret putting myself out there and making the effort, as I got two friends in the process. My toddler DS also has two little friends.

Playgroups are a good place to make more casual friends that you don't have to see outside of the sessions.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 13/08/2023 20:37

Colleagues is a great way of describing it. My closest "colleague" has a little girl who is DS4's best friend and they are as energetic, loud and boisterous as each other. We get on well enough for a weekly 2 hour meetup. But they're going to 2 different schools and the differing interests are starting to interfere, so I'm fairly confident we'll have finished our "joint project" by Christmas and be down to a friendly wave.