Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be desperate for 'mum friends '

139 replies

Zumma · 08/08/2023 15:52

DS is 12 weeks old. We moved to a new area last year so don't know loads of people apart from a few neighbours and acquaintances from the pub we went to before he was born.

A few people have commented about joining local baby groups etc and said it will be great for me to meet 'mum friends'. I've signed up for some already mainly as I think they'll be beneficial for DS. I'll also happily chit chat casually to other mums there as you do, but I can't imagine that I'll find really strong friendships there nor am I that bothered.

I didn't bother with an NCT group, partly due to distance of nearest one but also not keen on the idea that you all have to be 'friends' after and keep up with eachother in a Whatssapp group. A few friends have told me about various dramas with their NCT friends and it sounds quite childish and exhausting.

I mentioned this to a cousin the other day and she thought I was being antisocial and unfriendly. I've reflected on my attitude as I can see where she's coming from.

I think over the years growing up, I had some bad experiences with groups of girls (mild bullying, gossip etc) so the idea of actively seeking out groups of mums to be good friends with fills me with dread in case there's any bitchiness or horrid dynamics. I know we're all adults but it still happens - I've read a few threads on here about NCT groups and mums at the school gate to see what goes wrong. It's my idea of hell and I think it would take me back to feeling like an inadequate young girl again so I actively avoid it.

When I was younger I was often making friends with people due to having one thing in common eg on the same course or houseshare but beyond that there was nothing else so friendships were so superficial and fizzled out quickly. I imagine it's similar if the only thing you have in common with someone is you had kids at the same time?

I do have old friends of 5 or 10 years who are mums and I've connected well with them on motherhood although they don't live close by.

I'm probably overthinking the whole thing and I will obviously be friendly and chatty at the baby groups and if a genuine and nice friendship emerges then great but I suppose I'm much more selective and reserved about closer friendships these days and don't want to feel like I have to be everyone's friend and force pointless mum friendships as it hasn't worked well for me in the past. I'm also OK with my own company mostly as I often see family and old friends at weekends even though they're not local.

I'm sure as DS is older they'll be more happening with playmates and parties but for now I'm not desperately seeking out mum friends.

YABU - motherhood is a great time for new friendships and you're overthinking and missing an opportunity

YANBU - you're right to be reflective and cautious about these friendships and do what feels comfortable and genuine

OP posts:
ChestnutGrove · 17/08/2023 10:37

You could apply the same logic to any situation.

Just because people do the same job, doesn't mean they have anything else in common. I don't want any work friends

Just because people went to the same school, doesn't mean they have anything else in common. I don't want any school friends. Etc etc

Beezknees · 17/08/2023 10:28

YANBU. I've never been bothered about having "mum friends." I am not opposed to having friends who are mums, but I never specifically set out to make friends with them.

I was in a slightly unusual situation in that I was only just 18 when I had a baby and I was a single mum early on, and lived in a hostel for a bit. I genuinely did not have much in common with married women in their 30s with cars and mortgages. There was no one my age or in my situation.

My friends who are people I've known since school. Some of them are now parents.

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 10:21

I don't think people are hanging out with other mums that they have NOTHING else in common with other than being mums..

What's so wrong with making friends with people who are in the same situation as you? It makes perfect sense to me, you're going through the same things at the same time, it's like making 'work friends' you obviously don't make friends with EVERYONE at work - just the ones you happen to also get one with!

ChestnutGrove · 17/08/2023 09:58

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/08/2023 08:14

Just because women have a baby doesn't mean they have anything else in common.

I've never bothered with mum friends. I have friends.

Will you ditch your friends if any of them become mums?

CurlewKate · 17/08/2023 09:53

@Fizbosshoes One of the Mumsnet tropes I hate most is the awful attitude to "school-gate mums". As if they are somehow a different species.

Fizbosshoes · 17/08/2023 09:27

Agree - I'm not sure why adding the word "mum" to friends makes it a negative thing? And why do other women change personality once they have given birth??
I know MN can be a bit funny about friends in general but I can't really understand how or why making a friend at the school gate or baby group is a different process to making friends anywhere else.
The mum at the school gate might have been someone you got to know at an exercise class/bar/through another friend/book club...at a different stage in your life....but the stage you're both at now means you're likely to meet and start friendship at something based around children.
Or if you want to make friends exclusively with people who arent mums that would exclude a fairly large % of women! (And then what if they didn't want to be friends simply because you were a mum....?)

CurlewKate · 17/08/2023 08:57

@DinnaeFashYersel
"True but the 'mum' friends thing is based on the premise that mums should be friends with other mums because they are mums"

To me "mum friends" were people who were in the same situation as me, so would probably be up for a cup of coffee or a trip to soft play. Some became friends-I had cocktails with some on Saturday 25 years on-some just drifted away as circumstances changed. But never undervalue having someone to keep an eye on the pram while you nip to the loo in the park. Or who watched something that wasn't The Tellytubbies" last night.

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 08:47

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/08/2023 08:14

Just because women have a baby doesn't mean they have anything else in common.

I've never bothered with mum friends. I have friends.

The reverse is equally as true. Just because they have a baby doesn't mean you won't have other things in common with them. Unless you think all women become personality-less drones after birth.

I would go as far as to say all new mums have friends. What they usually don't have are friends who have absolutely no work commitments Monday-Friday during the day for the duration they are on maternity leave.

Tinybrother · 17/08/2023 08:30

Is it? “Mum friends” is not a phrase I use but I’ve never interpreted it as meaning you are supposed to be friends with all mothers. Just that finding people you can get on with who are at the same stage of life is nice. But anything with the word “mum” in it as a descriptor is usually used sneerily and pejorative isn’t it, and I don’t think that should be the case.

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/08/2023 08:23

@Tinybrother

True but the 'mum' friends thing is based on the premise that mums should be friends with other mums because they are mums

Tinybrother · 17/08/2023 08:16

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/08/2023 08:14

Just because women have a baby doesn't mean they have anything else in common.

I've never bothered with mum friends. I have friends.

equally, just because they have a baby doesn’t mean you won’t have anything else in common with them

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/08/2023 08:14

Just because women have a baby doesn't mean they have anything else in common.

I've never bothered with mum friends. I have friends.

CurlewKate · 17/08/2023 07:51

So long as you're friendly and open you'll be fine. It's nice to have people to have a cup of coffee with even if you're not best friends. And some small children absolutely adore having playmates. Just don't do the "Oh, I've got nothing in common with these mundanes" routine some people do!

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 07:48

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 07:41

The women who constantly bang on about other women, how they all behave like X, how female friendships are all like X are actually the red flags.

So many women on here have so much internalised misogyny and seem to feel on a high horse belittling “mum friends”, which ultimately are just women in the same situation as you. For most people only seeing their regular friends while on maternity leave doesn’t work because most people don’t have a plethora of friends who are free to walk around a park at 3pm on a Monday to get their baby to sleep or go for a coffee at 10am on a Wednesday.

Exactly! As if Mum friends are this special breed of people who just eat toddler snacks and sign wheels on the bus on repeat 🤣

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 07:41

The women who constantly bang on about other women, how they all behave like X, how female friendships are all like X are actually the red flags.

So many women on here have so much internalised misogyny and seem to feel on a high horse belittling “mum friends”, which ultimately are just women in the same situation as you. For most people only seeing their regular friends while on maternity leave doesn’t work because most people don’t have a plethora of friends who are free to walk around a park at 3pm on a Monday to get their baby to sleep or go for a coffee at 10am on a Wednesday.

Tinybrother · 17/08/2023 07:35

Mummadeze · 17/08/2023 07:14

I didn’t want ‘Mum friends’ either. I had lots of friends already and when I met up with them it was nice to talk about other things than baby stuff. I went to classes though and did make one Mum friend organically because she was my type of person anyway.

do you think what you did is different to what everyone else is doing?

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 07:18

If you work part time or on mat leave good luck just sticking with your current non 'mum friends', I would have been very lonely during those times where my other friends were at work.

TexasMomma · 17/08/2023 07:16

The whole idea of having a "tribe" is not very appealing to me. I went to a lot of mom groups when my kids were infants and toddlers. I developed a couple of friendships because those two moms insisted on spending time with me and my kids and I enjoyed time with them, but once all of the kids started full time school they didn't seem as interested in keeping in touch and I was ok with that.

I think just do what you want to do. The older I get the less energy I have to waste on things that aren't important to me. No two moms need to live the same way or the same lifestyle. You live the way you want to and need to live and be the best mum you can be and you're doing great.

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 07:16

Mummadeze · 17/08/2023 07:14

I didn’t want ‘Mum friends’ either. I had lots of friends already and when I met up with them it was nice to talk about other things than baby stuff. I went to classes though and did make one Mum friend organically because she was my type of person anyway.

There's a funny assumption that people who are 'mum friends' are not the kind of people you'd make friends with if you didn't have kids.

Mummadeze · 17/08/2023 07:14

I didn’t want ‘Mum friends’ either. I had lots of friends already and when I met up with them it was nice to talk about other things than baby stuff. I went to classes though and did make one Mum friend organically because she was my type of person anyway.

eggsinonetamborine · 17/08/2023 07:11

The only friends I've made at mum groups are people who I got chatting to because I knew their partners. Don't think I've met a stranger at a mum group who I've then progressed to be good friends with.
I was quite lucky as my best friend had a baby 3 months after me, as did an ex colleague- who I then became good friends with after she messaged when she saw me at work and said she knew it was random but would I fancy going out with her and her DS with mine being the same age, shes now a very close friend. I'm very grateful for those friends, I do find it hard meeting and talking to people who you don't know from Adam at groups and forming bonds with them.

WelcomingGnome · 17/08/2023 07:10

I just stayed friends with my usual friends when my DC was born. Didn't do NCT or anything. Continued to see them after she was born. Now she's at school, I'd describe some of the school mums as friends but we don't do stuff without the DC!

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 07:10

They are also the ones who will be up for unless playground, soft play, toddler theatre shows, whatever else, that non 'mum friends' will either have to be dragged to or will get bored of within 10 mins

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 07:06

No one I know has had any problems with NCT, can't imagine why they would it's just a way to get adults to get to know each other, what you describe sounds quite childish??

Ilikepinacoladass · 17/08/2023 07:05

'Mum friends' doesn't have to mean you only have the children in common though does it. The ones I've made friends with tend to have other common interests too like similar career, or hobbies. But having those people there (similar other interests or not) who have kids similar age and who really 'get it' in my opinion is really helpful.