Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am so over pronouns.

179 replies

TheDogAndDogAtCrutchley · 08/08/2023 01:09

I don’t care if I never hear another pronoun again. It’s not like they’re moving grammar along nicely now, is it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
NeverMrsAgain · 08/08/2023 08:25

Maybe, just maybe, a culture of declaring pronouns does some people good and does you no harm at all

People who think it does no harm have not looked into how this is working out in the real world.

When Kristi Hannah, a Canadian female survivor of male sexual violence living in a women only addiction recovery Centre, complained to a civil rights legal Centre about a male who identified as a woman ( and who looked make, had stubble and openly spoke about their sexual attraction to women) being placed in her small bedroom with her, the legal Centre told her they would not support her as she misgendered that person, but that they would support the male person if they complained about Kristi for misgendering then. This is madness. You tell me how a female survivor of male sexual violence can express their fear of being housed with a male without calling that person he/him.
Or the women in the refuge corrected for misgendering when complaining about the men who identify as women living there who masturbate next to them and ask them for blow jobs.

And what about the degradation and humiliation of survivors of male violence and rape having to hear people talk about that person as she/her: that contemptuous disregard for the victim’s experience of male violence.

Or how about how it influences decisions when officials sit around to discuss the new prisoner Isla and where she should be housed?

Or female prisoners told they will be punished with loss of privileges if they don’t refer to the makes housed with them who they are intimidated by as she/her. How does that effect their confidence and ability to raise fears and concerns about that person’s presence and behaviour.

I could go on and on, about the ability of school girls to object to the presence of males on overnight trips or in changing rooms and showers, when everyone calls that person she/her. You get the idea.

She/her for males provides a huge barrier to women and girls being able to talk about their valid fears and concerns.

It’s naive beyond belief to pretend this is a harmless nicety we should all adhere to.

Naunet · 08/08/2023 08:25

HiHoHiHoltsOffToWorkWeGo · 08/08/2023 01:49

You used 6 pronouns in your opening title and post - I, I, I, it's, they're, it.

Good luck constructing a normal sentence without using he, she, his, hers, they, their, we, I, our, my, mine, you, yours, us, it, or variations thereof.

YABU.

🙄 yes that’s exactly what OP was talking about and not the boring, self obsessed twats who sign off their emails with she/her and they/them etc.

cocoloco117 · 08/08/2023 08:23

What I don’t understand about pronouns is that (she/her) etc. are third person pronouns, so you would never use them when writing a email or speaking to a person, you’d just say ‘you’. You only use third person when referring to them when they’re not there. So the person wouldn’t even know which pronoun you’re actually using about them. So what’s the point of stating them?

sashh · 08/08/2023 08:21

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 08/08/2023 07:23

Volunteering pronouns is inclusive of the transgender community, which is why it bothers people like OP.

It is the same as stating if you voted leave or remain. It is a political statement and no one needs to know.

It's a breach of the Yogyakarta Principles, not inclusive at all.

jeaux90 · 08/08/2023 08:18

If someone asks at work I say "I am post pronouns"

I love the confusion on their face, like they've missed out on something.

I won't be gaslit.

FOJN · 08/08/2023 08:17

ChubbyMorticia · 08/08/2023 07:47

Could be just my experience, but I’ve found that people who talk about how tired they are of pronouns, etc, get fairly upset if someone refers to them by the wrong one.

Really? As in office based meltdown, accusations of someone committing literal violence, making a tearful tiktok about the trauma caused?

I call bullshit.

I've received plenty of letters and phone calls over the years from people looking for Mr FJON because they made an assumption about my sex. I've managed to simply correct them and move on without drama.

WhiteFire · 08/08/2023 08:16

I've noticed 'she/her' is a lot more common than 'he/him' on sites like LinkedIn, which I find both strange and worrying.

This is my experience also, and your thoughts on it are shared. It is less about support for a group of individuals and more about #BeKind (#shutupandputup) and keeping women in line. I find it more worrying when it is women professionally involved with VAWG.

GreenWheat · 08/08/2023 08:15

It's nearly always either people trying to highlight how speshul they are, or workplaces trying to showcase woke capitalism. Thankfully nobody has ever asked me to use they/them and I would not be pandering to it if they did.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/08/2023 08:14

This is why calling a man she/her can get in the bin

I am so over pronouns.
Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/08/2023 08:13

Kilopascal · 08/08/2023 08:09

people think being referred to as male when you’re not or vice versa is ooooh so traumatising

Isn't it more the people being referred to as male when they are male but don't see themselves that way?

Yes but that’s not what PP was saying. PP were saying that it was pppl who complained most about pronouns were upset if ‘misgendered’ implying we are hypocrites

but you’re right - the ppl who push pronouns the hardest are ppl who want everyone to lie about biological sex

GreenWheat · 08/08/2023 08:12

ChubbyMorticia · 08/08/2023 07:47

Could be just my experience, but I’ve found that people who talk about how tired they are of pronouns, etc, get fairly upset if someone refers to them by the wrong one.

Have you really found that or would it just be convenient for your narrative. I am a woman, have an obviously female. definitely look like one, nobody has ever referred to me as he. I don't know why they would but I wouldn't care. And I am definitely tired of pronouns.

FiddleLeaf · 08/08/2023 08:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

User1367349 · 08/08/2023 08:12

TheDogAndDogAtCrutchley · 08/08/2023 01:09

I don’t care if I never hear another pronoun again. It’s not like they’re moving grammar along nicely now, is it?

And yet you used a pronoun four times in your original post.

FOJN · 08/08/2023 08:12

I recently visited a free women's legal service in a professional capacity and their practice is to use their pronouns (she/her- it's an entirely female organisation) in all publications and on their website as a way to reassure women that when they seek legal advice they will be speaking with a woman.

She/her pronouns do not mean you will speak to a woman. In fact they signal that the organisation has bought into gender ideology which increases the chance you will end up speaking to someone who is male but using she/her pronouns.

Pretending it's to reassure women when it doesn't mean women seeking legal advice will speak to a woman is gaslighting. It also signals that you are not welcome if don't believe humans can change sex. Asserting that it costs nothing is also gaslighting.

Kilopascal · 08/08/2023 08:09

people think being referred to as male when you’re not or vice versa is ooooh so traumatising

Isn't it more the people being referred to as male when they are male but don't see themselves that way?

CurrentHun · 08/08/2023 08:08

Not one female I know who has been called a bloke mistakenly, gives a crap about that. Much more worried (rightly) about everyday homophobia/lesbophobia which definitely affects them negatively.

User63847484848 · 08/08/2023 08:08

It’s absurd. And immediately makes the person using them at the end of their email etc (when it’s voluntary) go down in my estimations and gets an eye roll. Especially if they’re over 21. The young uns I cut more slack.

Cowlover89 · 08/08/2023 08:05

Yanbu

MockneyReject · 08/08/2023 08:01

ChubbyMorticia · 08/08/2023 07:47

Could be just my experience, but I’ve found that people who talk about how tired they are of pronouns, etc, get fairly upset if someone refers to them by the wrong one.

I'd say it is just your experience.
I'm frequently called Sir and referred to by incorrect sex pronouns, by people who embrace them. They assume that because 'misgendering' would traumatise them, that it would do the same to me. It doesn't. I'm yet to see a GC feminist upset by this silly, transparent attempt to upset them. I've seen plenty roll their eyes and move on, though.
When I was younger, and 'presented' neutrally, just like most of my social group did, I was frequently mistaken for a man/lad. Never once did it upset me. It mildly amused me, if anything.

JudgeAnderson · 08/08/2023 08:01

Could be just my experience, but I’ve found that people who talk about how tired they are of pronouns, etc, get fairly upset if someone refers to them by the wrong one.

Wrong. I don't care at all.

TheOpeningActofSpring · 08/08/2023 07:55

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/08/2023 07:50

I recently visited a free women's legal service in a professional capacity and their practice is to use their pronouns (she/her- it's an entirely female organisation) in all publications and on their website as a way to reassure women that when they seek legal advice they will be speaking with a woman.

well that’s total bollocks to start with! I work with a TW who uses she/her & describes themself as a lesbian so no the use of she/her doesn’t mean you’ll get an actual woman. I mean ffs this is basic stuff - how do people not understand this?

Yes, especially as these days gender identity tops biological sex when it comes to pronouns and sexuality. Absolute ridiculous.

CurrentHun · 08/08/2023 07:55

I recently visited a free women's legal service in a professional capacity and their practice is to use their pronouns (she/her- it's an entirely female organisation) in all publications and on their website as a way to reassure women that when they seek legal advice they will be speaking with a woman.

No. Are you for real?
Any organisation using gender identity markers (ie requiring pronouns to be given as standard) is doing the literal opposite of ‘reassuring’ any service user that any staff member who uses female pronouns will be actually of the female sex.

Either this organisation is very confused about what gender identity is and doesn’t realise that it has nothing whatsoever to do with biological sex, or you are.

This is a massive problem because for some women, knowing that they can definitely only deal with a woman at that service, will be the difference between using that service which they really need, or not using it at all.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/08/2023 07:54

I find it hilarious that people think being referred to as male when you’re not or vice versa is ooooh so traumatising - again ffs! I used to have really really short hair - my sisters new bf looking at old photo albums saw a photo of me from behind wearing a bomber jacket & asked who that boy was. Astonishingly I survived this appalling misgendering without collapsing onto my fainting couch clutching my pearls. I just laughed and said “I look a bit different now”

AdoptedBumpkin · 08/08/2023 07:53

I've noticed 'she/her' is a lot more common than 'he/him' on sites like LinkedIn, which I find both strange and worrying.

TheOpeningActofSpring · 08/08/2023 07:52

timetorefresh · 08/08/2023 04:38

I'd actually assume that would mean I may not speak with a woman, but end up with someone identifying as a woman. If they make it clear they are a female only organisation, using the biological definition, then there's no need for the pronouns

This. With bells on!

Swipe left for the next trending thread