Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Give nanny a kiss goodbye"

406 replies

coverp · 07/08/2023 23:40

Looking for impartial views on whether I am letting my generally strained relationship with MIL impact my response.

Whenever MIL sees the kids (aged 4 and 2), she tries to insist on big kisses and cuddles to say hello and goodbye. Sometimes they are cuddly kids and other times they are not - they interact with her well. I've always said "do you fancy a hug, high five or a wave?" And let them choose.

Today, MIL tried to insist on kisses - "why don't you want to kiss nanny, you're making nanny feel so sad, nanny is going to think you don't love her if you don't kiss her". To which I said "Enough". 2yo then said "how about a wave" and waved and blew a kiss. Which I thought was adorable.

Anyway, MIL has just texted saying "Hi, you really hurt me earlier. Its not too much to ask for the kids to cuddle their grandmother, your approach is ridiculous and they'll end up being rude brats".

I haven't replied, but am spitting. I know she'll have been drinking so definitely won't be engaging tonight. But sense check - AIBU to say they can choose to interact with her on their own terms?!

OP posts:
ODFOx · 08/08/2023 19:04

She is overstepping but it is a generational thing. There's a subtext in your OP which suggests a difficult relationship. If you can set aside the nderlting tension you can diffuse this problem, at least:
'. Hi X, please don't feel hurt. The issue with adult physical contact isn't a reflection on you at all. It's, sadly, a reflection of the times we live on that we have to teach our children the right to say no from such an early age to protect them. We are trying to teach them to tread that fine line between being polite but also being firm with their own boundaries and having the right to avoid physical contact. Something mes they will want a hug and kiss, sometimes they won't, but we need to teach them that they can always say no to physical contact. Thanks for your understanding. it will be great to have you onboard as we take this forward: sometimes hugs for all of us; sometimes not; but always their choice. Lunch on Sunday ? Etc etc

LolaSmiles · 08/08/2023 18:53

It's absolutely bizarre to still want someone, anyone to hug or kiss you when you know theydon't want to do so.

Who on earth would enjoy that hug or kiss?!
Exactly!

I don't love everything she writes but I think Sarah Ockwell-Smith is right on the idea of child-ism.

Take this topic and write them as AIBU/relationships posts for Mumsnet.

^DH doesn't respect my personal space. I'm not against physical contact but I don't want him to be pawing at me when I'm in the middle of cleaning or I'm planting my seedlings out. He interrupts what I'm doing to prod me or put his arms around me. He knows I don't like it, but he says he's just showing love. Is it unreasonable of me to say he needs to give me some space and I'll let him know when I'm open to contact?"

"DP wants to do something in the bedroom. I don't want to do it but am happy with other things. He gets moody, sulks and tells me that I'm upsetting him, rejecting him and being a brat. What should I do moving forward?"

My teenager has a gf/bf. They've said they feel pressured to send nude photos/have sex. Their gf/bf seems to think that just because they've been intimate once, that every time they're alone and have the chance will lead to sex, or closer to sex. Their gf/bf says if teen loved them then they would do it. Teen says that's just how things are but I'm trying to explain to them that consent needs to be enthusiastic and not give reluctantly after manipulation. What would you say to your teen?"

monsteramunch · 08/08/2023 18:45

When you think about it in the cold light of day it's actually really weird when an adult would look at a child, KNOW the child doesn't want a certain kind of physical contact, and STILL push and push to get the contact the adult wants.

This.

It's absolutely bizarre to still want someone, anyone to hug or kiss you when you know they don't want to do so.

Who on earth would enjoy that hug or kiss?!

LolaSmiles · 08/08/2023 18:43

I want them both to know that no means no and stop means stop.

At the moment, that might mean stop tickling or stop pushing the swing. One day it might mean stop penetration. And it has to be adhered to.

This starts early and they HAVE to know that no matter who or what is involved, they call the shots with their bodies.

Agree with this ^^

When you think about it in the cold light of day it's actually really weird when an adult would look at a child, KNOW the child doesn't want a certain kind of physical contact, and STILL push and push to get the contact the adult wants.

What's the worst that will happen by an adult saying "sure we can High 5 to say hello today", "you'd like to wave goodbye. Sure! Let's give some big waves! See you soon."?

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 08/08/2023 18:34

I do the same with my 2 year old. It's more important to me that he learns about bodily autonomy than pleasing other people

ButterflyBitch · 08/08/2023 18:32

JenniferBarkley · 08/08/2023 06:49

Hi Brenda, hope the trip home was ok. The thinking these days is that children shouldn't be asked to give hugs and kisses if they don't want to. The idea is that by practising as kids with safe grown-ups, they'll be more comfortable saying no to unwanted approaches as adults. I think this is really important, so we'll be sticking with allowing them say no. It's nothing personal, they love their nanny, just sometimes they don't feel like a kiss and that's ok.

This.
my son was massively uncomfortable with physical touch when he was smaller and will still not kiss anyone including me. Haven’t had a kiss since he was a toddler. I explained to my mum when he was small that he doesn’t always want hugs and she asked him every time. Sometimes he did and sometimes he didn’t. He is a massive hugger now and voluntarily hugs her which she loves but if he didn’t she would still ask. And that’s how it should be.

slithytoveisascientist · 08/08/2023 18:30

I feel so strongly about this

Not just because of risk of abuse as a child

But as a teenage girl I don't want my daughter to think love = physical affection, and guaranteed some horny boy will use the line "if you loved me you would.."

As a teenage boy I don't want my son to think love = physical affection, or use that line.

As a woman I want her to know she can advocate for herself.

I want them both to know that no means no and stop means stop.

At the moment, that might mean stop tickling or stop pushing the swing. One day it might mean stop penetration. And it has to be adhered to.

This starts early and they HAVE to know that no matter who or what is involved, they call the shots with their bodies.

Justwingingit2005 · 08/08/2023 18:25

I say to mine say goodbye to Grandma and Grandad. This gives my kids a choice. One always cuddles, the other two say bye and high five or a funny handshake.

phoenixrosehere · 08/08/2023 18:23

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

My friends mother in law died two weeks ago, her little one will never have a hug or kiss from her granny again.

I’m 100% in agreement about not forcing kids or hug and kiss adults etc

but this is their Grandmother and it’s a special relationship they only have for so long.

Way to say f-k a child’s consent because family’s feelings trumps their bodily autonomy.

Where does it end? What age are we allowed bodily autonomy?

We preach consent but it only seems to be allowed once you hit some magical unsaid age to some and babies and children don’t meet that requirement. We have to allow strangers to touch babies because strangers are just being “social”, we can’t speak up for our babies and children and should force them to hug, kiss family members because it may hurt their feelings despite it being well-known knowledge that such behaviour can and does lead to children being assaulted by family members for years because they were always made to do such things and if they didn’t they were “bad”, not behaving, being disobedient, etc...

nosmallfeet · 08/08/2023 18:10

Forcing small kids to kiss adults really annoys me, firstly not all adults want a kiss and not all kids want to kiss every grandparent, auntie or uncle! Parents often insist on it saying give your auntie a kiss and I always say how about a fist bump or hug especially if the kids looks like they don't want to do it.

BadgerFace · 08/08/2023 18:09

I’m with you OP, I have two DDs and have always given them the choice whether to hug or not with relatives, and I always ask my nieces as I do not want them to feel they have to hug or kiss if they are not comfortable to do so. I apply the same rule to myself and my husband with our DDs. Their bodies, their choice!

SplendidUtterly · 08/08/2023 18:09

This brings back memories of my childhood :[

"Unless you kiss nana, there won't be any Christmas presents for you."

"You don't love nana anymore, do you?" (me refusing to kiss)

"Give granny a cuddle, she will soon be dead and gone" (WTF)

"I don't have foot and mouth" (after refusing to kiss)

"go give gramps a big kiss goodbye" (him sitting there smelling of extra strong mints and cigarettes)

FUCK OFF granny!

pigsDOfly · 08/08/2023 18:06

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

My friends mother in law died two weeks ago, her little one will never have a hug or kiss from her granny again.

I’m 100% in agreement about not forcing kids or hug and kiss adults etc

but this is their Grandmother and it’s a special relationship they only have for so long.

The fact that people might die soon doesn't give them carte blanche to force children to hug and kiss them, regardless of the relationship and how short that relationship might be.

pigsDOfly · 08/08/2023 18:01

*no uncertain terms, that should be

pigsDOfly · 08/08/2023 17:59

I had a bit of a falling out with my, then, brother in law over one of my DDs not wanting to kiss her grandmother, his mother, goodbye.

He refused to kiss my DD goodbye, which she wanted to do, unless she kissed her grandmother goodbye as well.

I told him he was being unkind and wrong to withdraw his affection from my DD because she wouldn't be forced to kiss someone she didn't want to kiss.

DD stuck to her guns and left not kissing either of them.

She was only about 3 at the time.

Can't stand this idea that adults have the right to demand kisses and hugs from children. It sends such an unhealthy message to small children.

Your MIL needs to be told, in not certain terms, that you will not have your children forced by emotional blackmail into kissing and hugging anyone.

nokidshere · 08/08/2023 17:48

I've always found that if children aren't put under pressure to do something they are more likely to do it.

My boys would never kiss/hug my mum. She was always on at them for something, "give me a hug, give me a kiss, show me your toy etc" all the time. MIL. On the other hand never asked and always engaged positively with what they did want to do with her, they loved her and always kissed/hugged her without having to be asked.

Maaate · 08/08/2023 17:46

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

My friends mother in law died two weeks ago, her little one will never have a hug or kiss from her granny again.

I’m 100% in agreement about not forcing kids or hug and kiss adults etc

but this is their Grandmother and it’s a special relationship they only have for so long.

Manipulative much?

GoldDuster · 08/08/2023 17:46

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

My friends mother in law died two weeks ago, her little one will never have a hug or kiss from her granny again.

I’m 100% in agreement about not forcing kids or hug and kiss adults etc

but this is their Grandmother and it’s a special relationship they only have for so long.

All grandmothers are going to die. It doesn't mean that they get to manipulate the family around them, most of all the children, using emotional blackmail in order to get what they want regardless of the wishes of the other parties. She's doing nothing but shooting herself in the foot with her behaviour.

Who wants a hug and a kiss they've had to extract from a child by telling them you won't be their friend if they don't, anyway?

bakewellbride · 08/08/2023 17:45

I had a relative exactly like this. It was bad, absolutely awful. Many years of no contact, it's bliss. She doesn't even know my second child exists!

Words · 08/08/2023 17:41

I thought this would be about Jacob Rees-Mogg.

CoteDOpale · 08/08/2023 17:40

YANBU. You’re teaching them healthy boundaries and allowing them their bodily autonomy. MIL can F off.

Ask her what message she’s setting, telling them they owe someone physical contact to represent ‘love’.

Igowalkininmasleep · 08/08/2023 17:38

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

My friends mother in law died two weeks ago, her little one will never have a hug or kiss from her granny again.

I’m 100% in agreement about not forcing kids or hug and kiss adults etc

but this is their Grandmother and it’s a special relationship they only have for so long.

And that is how CSA happens

It's only....

But they're family....

You're asking a child to go against their instincts and giving an adult autonomy over their body. This is NOT ok. If a child is told an adult can touch them and they're not allowed to verbalise discomfort think of what else can be internalised and not discussed.

Empowering your child to say no to a grown up is important. Empowering your child to recognise and listen to their instincts is important.

So no. I will not be forcing my children to give grandma a kiss just in case she dies tomorrow.

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

*to

SherbetDips · 08/08/2023 17:34

My friends mother in law died two weeks ago, her little one will never have a hug or kiss from her granny again.

I’m 100% in agreement about not forcing kids or hug and kiss adults etc

but this is their Grandmother and it’s a special relationship they only have for so long.

jellybe · 08/08/2023 17:20

Your MIL need to cut that shit out asap. Make it clear to her that if she try's and emotional blackmail your kids in to unwanted physical contact again then she won't be seeing them for a long time. You are totally doing the right think letting the kids set their boundaries. If she can't see that than screw her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread