Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not forgive colleague?

157 replies

pampaspot · 07/08/2023 21:38

I applied for a new role it’s a few bands higher but I am qualified within that field just haven’t had much hands on experience.

The position is a secondment so it is a learning opportunity also.

Colleague showed me her screen today and previous message was to our manager of her saying “s is not a band 5” so she feels im not good enough.

I called her out on this and she started crying right away and apologising.

we work together once a week but now I just feel very off about her.

Manager didn’t pull her up on this until I said which is also very shitty.

Aibu to not forgive her so easily? I don’t want to create a bad atmosphere but I just feel so angry.

OP posts:
Mikimoto · 08/08/2023 03:01

Maybe ask her why you're not band 5 level?
Because maybe you're not band 5 level.

londonba · 08/08/2023 02:32

AliceOlive · 08/08/2023 02:08

With the emoji and the other additional info, it’s obviously quite shitty.

However, do you want to really level up? Ask her for feedback. “I’ve thought about what you wrote and wanted to know what you think I should be doing differently? Where do you think I can improve?”

Then make note and objectively evaluate her comments. Her response could be complete nonsense (in fact, I’ll bet it’s coming from a place of envy) but if you can do this without becoming emotional about you’ll be ahead of most everyone on the planet.

Don’t do this.

Only ask people for feedback if you find them insightful or aspirational in some way. This colleague might be on the same level as OP. They might not be able to provide any valuable feedback. Not everyone’s opinion is useful after all, especially when you have witnessed them behaving unprofessionally. Asking people for feedback feeds their ego.

Asking her for feedback in my view might make her feel legitimised in making the initial comment. She could can justify saying OP is not ready for promotion by twisting it to infer she gave OP feedback around the time that comment was posted. Suggesting OP was aware and she provided feedback to help her reach the promotion expectations. It’s enough to paint the situation in a different light if she makes it seem like she gave OP career advice and was a confidant.

Fraaahnces · 08/08/2023 02:21

Why are recruitment talking out of school too? This place sounds incredibly unprofessional! I don’t understand why she knew at all.

AliceOlive · 08/08/2023 02:08

With the emoji and the other additional info, it’s obviously quite shitty.

However, do you want to really level up? Ask her for feedback. “I’ve thought about what you wrote and wanted to know what you think I should be doing differently? Where do you think I can improve?”

Then make note and objectively evaluate her comments. Her response could be complete nonsense (in fact, I’ll bet it’s coming from a place of envy) but if you can do this without becoming emotional about you’ll be ahead of most everyone on the planet.

Mojodojocasahaus · 08/08/2023 01:59

Fuck her and your manager.

Get out of there and on with your career.

Id be polite but keep the both of them at arms length.

Honestly what is wrong with women. We have enough to contend with the patriarchy.

ReturnoftheMuck · 08/08/2023 01:40

Internally you don't have to forgive her but you do have to be professional. Any "do you forgive me? I'm so sorry" should be met with "I don't wish to discuss it any further" and leave it at that. Breathe and move on.

Step back from the over friendliness, it sounds like they were both bitching about you. Just make a note of it in case they were to act unfavourably against you in future and it builds a picture.

Work colleagues are usually not friends, no matter how much you might want them to be and they seem that way.

TeenLifeMum · 08/08/2023 00:26

Go for it, learn from it and keep aiming for what you want.

TeenLifeMum · 08/08/2023 00:26

I assume nhs. I work with a lady who is a band 6 (for the last 6 months and the promotion went to her head) and talks about everyone not being good enough to be a 6 because she does her role so much better, including her immediate colleague who has been a 6 sense 2016. I’ve suggested she use her leadership skills to develop colleagues in the team. She thinks everyone is too rubbish to develop. Thankfully I don’t directly manager her.

Testina · 08/08/2023 00:25

The OP initially looked like your manager had legitimately sought her opinion which (possibly correctly) was too much of a jump.

But it seems it’s nothing to do with either of them or their roles - they’re just mates who got told by someone in recruitment breaking confidentiality?

Those are two really different things.

Good luck going for it!

Flossiemoss · 08/08/2023 00:16

I have no idea whether you are band 5 material or not , however I would echo pp and suggest you rise above it. If this was a deliberate ploy on her part then you’ve reacted to it and she’s enjoying seeing that reaction.

id be concerned people in recruitment have told her you’ve applied. That’s quite the unprofessional breach of confidentiality.

PictureConsequences · 08/08/2023 00:10

So it's not that she was asked for her opinion, she just gave it as gossip? No, that's wrong and absolutely go for it.

ikno · 08/08/2023 00:10

WutheredOut · 07/08/2023 23:35

I feel your pain

Except I got the job - then afterwards saw an email from my boss to the MD saying he didn’t think I was ready

I was so so upset and it has taken me nearly 20 years to realise how right he was and now I wonder why he didn’t push it and why I was still promoted into a job I was obviously not qualified to do

Fortunately - it was so awful, so much pressure that I only managed a year - resigned and totally changed my life around

Probably wouldn’t be where I am today hd that not all happened - and I’m really happy now!

Maybe you seeing that message might be a good thing

I question why you shared this as I’m not sure what OP is supposed to take from it aside from withdrawing their application.

Surely your manager could have put things in place to support you in adjusting to the role or alleviate pressure and not lead to you resigning 1 year in. That’s really sad. Unless you lied in your application, surely your manager would be aware of your previous experience before making the judgement to hire you. With the right adjustments you could have thrived in that role, or a similar position on same hierarchy/salary.

I don’t think your story should put people off applying for roles.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/08/2023 00:03

pampaspot · 07/08/2023 22:33

I know trying not to be too outing as she uses MN but I think it’s too late for that.

In which case you should have this deleted.

Look I have no idea if you are band 5 material or not (I don’t even know what band 5 is!) but the fact that you are posting here about an upsetting job thing is adding fuel to the fire. The fact is the higher you go the less ‘work friends’ you have and the less you can actually share to the outside world about your job.

My advice… put her on the cool but professional list, get this thread deleted, and move on in your career.

MentholLoad · 07/08/2023 23:48

if it has nothing to do with her or your manager....they hadn't been asked for references for example? and she found out via gossip, then I think you should report the lot of them. was it just a mocking back and forth between the 2 of them? on work emails? very unprofessional

Autumntree · 07/08/2023 23:43

That's a massive betrayal OP and I'd be mad too. My revenge would me working on myself tirelessly and moving up the career ladder. Leave her and her pettiness behind. It's awful that some people on here think there's nothing wrong with what she had done. That means those very people would do the same to their friends and colleagues. Massive decline in values!

Whelm · 07/08/2023 23:42

@pampaspot Fifteen years ago, a temporary manager decided that rather than following the usual process of only inviting people to apply for jobs at their current grade, he would make the applications open to anyone.
An extremely capable grade 4 applied for the grade 8 role and was able to demonstrate almost all of the requirements. However, within our organisation he had never controlled a budget. When asked about this shortcoming, the lad pointed out that he personally organised an annual event related to his hobby, so had plenty of practice at managing budgets.
Sniggering, one of the interview panel asked how much he spent on his event. £600,000 he replied, explaining that it had greatly increased in size over the five years he had been doing it.
The callow youth got to the final two, but was pipped by someone who was carrying out an almost identical role.
Later, at an event attended by senior management, the hiring manager asked if the unsuccessful applicant would be attending. My boss scoffed, explaining that he was a mere grade 4, to which she was told in no uncertain terms that it was no surprise that we were in such a mess if we kept people of his calibre down.
Apply away, your colleague clearly has neither the skills, ambition or get up and go to progress. Don't let her pathetic attitude hold you back. Good luck.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:40

She cried? Manipulative. Playing the victim. She sounds awful!

WutheredOut · 07/08/2023 23:38

Having now RTFT rather than just the first post - possibly you are not being unreasonable

If she had no reason to share her opinion of you and your manager doesn’t need to know her opinion then maybe she’s just being a bitch

WutheredOut · 07/08/2023 23:35

I feel your pain

Except I got the job - then afterwards saw an email from my boss to the MD saying he didn’t think I was ready

I was so so upset and it has taken me nearly 20 years to realise how right he was and now I wonder why he didn’t push it and why I was still promoted into a job I was obviously not qualified to do

Fortunately - it was so awful, so much pressure that I only managed a year - resigned and totally changed my life around

Probably wouldn’t be where I am today hd that not all happened - and I’m really happy now!

Maybe you seeing that message might be a good thing

ikno · 07/08/2023 23:20

I have unfortunately had to deal with similarly catty workplace environments. Ultimately you get paid to be nice to her, so leave it at that and keep communication brief. You don’t need to be friends with her, and you treat her with suspicion that she will gossip about you and won’t keep it confidential. If you feel more comfortable, you could ask her to put anything to you via email going forward to cover your back.

SuperiorM · 07/08/2023 23:19

pampaspot · 07/08/2023 21:46

No I’m not a band 5, a secondment has came up which I applied for.

Colleague found out I had an interview and told our manager that she doesn’t think I’m a worthy of a band 5.

They are behind g unprofessional. Crying is ridiculous. Should not have discussed it in an email

HamBone · 07/08/2023 23:15

Mirroring PPs- be professional but you don’t need to talk to her about anything other than work. Never do her favours either. If she wants to talk shit then she can ask someone else if she ever needs help.

This ^^ Be polite and professional, but that’s it. From your update, she’s been completely unprofessional.

Willmafrockfit · 07/08/2023 23:14

if you are good enough for an interview you should be good enough to get the job, which i hope you do!

YouOKHun · 07/08/2023 23:14

Ampharos · 07/08/2023 23:03

I’d use this as a lesson well learned to be honest. You now know you can’t trust her so at least you’ll never make the mistake of telling her anything she can use against you.

The fact she started crying is hilarious to me as well. Total attention seeker but can’t reap what she sows.

Mirroring PPs- be professional but you don’t need to talk to her about anything other than work. Never do her favours either. If she wants to talk shit then she can ask someone else if she ever needs help.

It’s a shitty thing to find out but my experience of all workplaces is there’s always going to be someone talking shit about you at some point. It’s not nice but it’s reality. No one is liked by every single colleague 100% of the time.

I agree with @Ampharos . Try not to dwell on it but instead use this insight into your colleague’s professionalism or lack there of, to decide a strategy to deal with her from now on (and the other colleague). I’d go for emotionless polite formality and share nothing with them about your work life or home life. Just focus on your goal. Rise above them in both behaviour and job band!

londonba · 07/08/2023 23:12

Extremely unprofessional for recruitment staff to inform their mates about who has applied for a role, especially as the vacancy hasn’t been filled yet and presumably hiring ongoing. Doesn’t provide confidence in an unbiased recruitment exercise, they’d likely struggle to justify the business need of their disclosure.

I could see how someone might jump up a few bands. You could be in a NHS Band 1 entry role but trying to get your first Band 5 medical position for example. Ultimately if you have the qualifications, you could directly start at the higher band like most graduates. It isn’t necessary to work your way up every band along the way. You might have come in at the wrong level, so you can’t let the people in a stop gap role dictate your potential. Keep applying and looking elsewhere. The people who you aspire to be, the successful band 6s or whatever, are not concerning themselves with the opinions of others like this. The more successful you get, the more people will have unsolicited opinions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread