Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To assume this about people who hit their kids...

218 replies

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:27

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 21:15

@OnlyFoolsnMothers "smack" is another word for "hit". You were hit. And it was so normalised that you think it was OK.

Well I disagree- in years to come I wonder if people will say removing a child’s favourite toy by way of punishment is damaging.
My parents never lashed out at me in anger is was a prewarned punishment, issued after a boundary was pushed. It wasn’t constant, it was occasional around the age of 4.

Sometimes I do wonder if all these other methods of punishment are any better or in fact cause greater emotional turmoil for a child. I think What most people say when they mean don’t punish your children is have perfectly behaved children.

Rathouse · 07/08/2023 21:27

@MillicentBystandr that's kids for you though you basically are implying the same as OP. Its not a debate .. kids today are unruly, they probably hit their parents and they have no manners! The behaviour in schools today was unheard of in my primary school (90s). I think life is all about balance and its not as simple as what OP is saying.

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 21:26

People who hit kids tends to argue that they are ‘teaching’ them. So far none have answered a simple question.
If hitting is a good teaching tool, do they let their boss hit them when they’ve done something wrong at work? If no, why not?

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 21:25

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 07/08/2023 21:15

You can think what you like but I hit my DS across the rump once and I will defend that decision to my grave . My son is not in the least bit traumatised and it prevented another vunerable person being injured so I care not a fig what you think .

And I have never hit my parents , DH or animals . So there goes your theory .

Yes theories are absolutely squashed the moment a single person has a personal, alleged anecdote. That's how it works. Gold star.

OP posts:
MillicentBystandr · 07/08/2023 21:23

Rathouse · 07/08/2023 21:21

@modgepodge the kids in the 80s managed though. People didn't go around hitting their peers nor did this take place in the 90s

🤣 Yeah we loved being smacked around by teachers and never ever once had a fight on the playground.

Rathouse · 07/08/2023 21:21

@modgepodge the kids in the 80s managed though. People didn't go around hitting their peers nor did this take place in the 90s

JethroTullandhishorse · 07/08/2023 21:20

modgepodge · 07/08/2023 21:02

Hmm, I am British as far back as can be traced and I was smacked as a child. It was normal in the 80s/90s I think, I definitely remember seeing other friends being smacked too.

I don’t agree with it, I have never hit my daughter and never will. I consider it abusive behaviour. And how can I teach my child that hitting is wrong if I hit her when she does something wrong/I lose my temper? Why wouldn’t she copy that behaviour with her peers?

I was smacked on the bum as a child and also told that violence begets violence and doesn’t really solve anything.
I don’t agree with hitting one’s children, but conversely I don’t hold it against my parents.

In my view, it shows people for what they are: inconsistent.

Rudderneck · 07/08/2023 21:18

Well, no, people who see smacking as reasonable discipline aren't generally going to hit their spouses, because they are adults, and not their own kids.

They probably aren't taking away their video games or grounding them either.

Of all the arguments against physical punishment, that is about the silliest.

IamAlso4eels · 07/08/2023 21:18

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 07/08/2023 21:15

You can think what you like but I hit my DS across the rump once and I will defend that decision to my grave . My son is not in the least bit traumatised and it prevented another vunerable person being injured so I care not a fig what you think .

And I have never hit my parents , DH or animals . So there goes your theory .

Obviously being hit as a child did harm you because it made you think it was okay to hit your own child.

Smacking is nothing more than domestic abuse dressed up as discipline.

MillicentBystandr · 07/08/2023 21:16

I think a large factor is culture - someone who for example is British by birth and has a few generations here then yes it’s abnormal behaviour. Eastern cultures not so much. It is seen as discipline and there is a different mentality attached to it.

Corporal punishment, as in teachers hitting children and HT caning children, wasn’t banned in U.K. schools until 1987. Hitting a child still is not a criminal offence in England.

Hitting children is part of British culture.

If anything, it’s a generational difference not a cultural difference.

IamAlso4eels · 07/08/2023 21:16

From a safeguarding point of view, smacking is always a red flag. If any child at work mentions to me (or other staff) that they've been smacked for any reason then we have to fill in a cause for concern form and pass it to our safeguarding lead for follow up.

Smacking children is wrong. It has nothing to do with discipline and everything to do with fear and control. I want my DC to make 'good' behavioural choices because they've been taught to think about their actions alongside potential consequences of those actions, I don't want them making choices based on avoiding being hit. It wouldn't be legal to do it to an adult.

GiantPandaAttacks · 07/08/2023 21:16

There is now quite a lot of research that shows that hitting children damages them and causes long term psychological damage. To those who say that it didn’t do them any harm, I do wonder about the links between physically abusing children (which is what it is) and the high levels of anger in our society. Hurt people hurt people.
Hitting children

Hitting Children Leads to Trauma, Not Better Behavior — Developmental Science

Hitting a child for "discipline" doesn't work. New research shows that it actually leads to trauma.

https://www.developmentalscience.com/blog/2022/2/10/hitting-children-leads-to-trauma-not-better-behavior

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 21:15

@OnlyFoolsnMothers "smack" is another word for "hit". You were hit. And it was so normalised that you think it was OK.

DinoRoar14 · 07/08/2023 21:15

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:05

I don’t think my parents smacking me was abuse- sorry I don’t! I was never hit but I was smacked on the bum as a punishment.

I don't like to think of my favourite cake as unhealthy and calorific. But it is.
Thinking its not doesn't make it so.

And you were hit. That's the littoral definition of being hit.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 07/08/2023 21:15

You can think what you like but I hit my DS across the rump once and I will defend that decision to my grave . My son is not in the least bit traumatised and it prevented another vunerable person being injured so I care not a fig what you think .

And I have never hit my parents , DH or animals . So there goes your theory .

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 21:13

@Cowlover89 it did do you harm, you think it was OK. That is harm. Anyone who thinks they deserved to be assaulted has been harmed.

ForestGoblin · 07/08/2023 21:12

No, I think smacking children is understandable. It's illegal in some parts of the UK now, though, which I think a lot of people don't realise.

Mamai90 · 07/08/2023 21:11

I don't agree with it but I got the odd slap round the legs growing up, it did me no harm. I wouldn't hit my child but it was more acceptable in the 80s/90s but I do remember my Dad being really apologetic after smacking me and I really played on that guilting him even more. I had a pretty much idealic childhood with very loving parents. I remember friends being smacked too, one Mum used the wooden spoon. My Mum never smacked me though but I was no more afraid of my Dad for giving me the odd slap, I think it was only around 2 or 3 times ever though.

Its different now though, I think society accepts it as being wrong.

roarrfeckingroar · 07/08/2023 21:11

It's a sign of a weak minded bully with no self control. Or worse.

Lavender14 · 07/08/2023 21:11

I do think there is a generational difference and I think there's a lot more information and awareness of why children's bodily autonomy, respect and personal safety is so important and that it really starts at home. I'm not sure that was something my parents consciously thought about- I think they disciplined in the way they were disciplined because it was what they knew and what was familiar and maybe a little instinctive. I also think there's more awareness now of the pressures of being a parent and how important it is to self regulate and apologise when you get it wrong. I'm not sure my parents had that same encouragement to self reflect and I think there was more pressure to have children who 'behaved' than who were freer to just be children and make mistakes and have that accepted as part of children's learning and development. I think as well when you consider how desperately poor mental health supports for new parents were in the 80s and 90s for example, it's no wonder so many parents suffered with pnd with little support and who struggled with attachment to their child. I agree completely that by smacking/ being overly angry/ overly domineering you are being your child's first bully. But I have less tolerance for people who do that now because there's so much great info and education out there now that there's much less of an excuse not to be doing your research and educating yourself. Although generational trauma can also be a part of that as well.

Sodthebloodypicnic · 07/08/2023 21:10

YANBU

Annaishere · 07/08/2023 21:10

I couldn’t care less I got hit there were more important lasting things that were wrong

tt9 · 07/08/2023 21:10

culture definitely is a factor here. but I also think that in cultures where hitting is normalised, the parent child dynamic is often unhealthy/dysfunctional. People also grow up with internalised aggression.

in my culture children are beaten, they are bullied and it is all normalised. even as an adult, people older than you somehow hold a trump card. this can lead to awful situations.

Sceptre86 · 07/08/2023 21:10

Often is cultural. If you're coming at this from a British angle then of course you'll be like, 'oh how horrid'. I'm south asian, my dad never hit us and wouldn't encourage us to hit our kids to discipline them either. He believes it desensitises kids and they'll act out anyway so better to deal with the root cause of the behaviour. My mum wasn't beyond wacking me on the back of my hand when I answered back. It was few and far between but did happen. Longterm it hasn't done me any harm. I don't hit my children because I don't think it's an effective way to mange their behaviour. My mil used to hit her boys when they were badly behaved, again rare and as a last resort in her words. They've turned out fine and do recognise her as a fab mum as is mine.

LaMaG · 07/08/2023 21:09

I think there are 2 distinct types - those that do it as a punishment because they believe it is a form of discipline and those that lash out when they lose their temper. The second category is by far the most dangerous IMO as they are not capable of control and could use excessive force, and are capable of hitting anyone who challenges them or upsets them. The first category are likely to use just enough force to stop the child repeating the action but not actually hurt or traumatise the child. It's not something I would do and I don't agree with it but all physical punishment isn't necessarily abuse IMO.