Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To assume this about people who hit their kids...

218 replies

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

OP posts:
ThroughGraceAlone · 07/08/2023 21:47

I seriously am not understanding the question.
So does this count for all forms of discipline.
"AIBU to think that people who take away their children's phones, take away their colleagues' too when they do something wrong?"
"AIBU to think that a mother that goes down on her haunches and gentle parents 'I understand you're frustrated Johnny, it must be really hard, I would feel like that too, you can't hit your sister though. Here hit this pillow instead." woulk it be unreasobe to exprapolate that she would go down on her knees and say to another adult." I get that you're angry, I would be too, but it's not okay to send a rude email, here write a rude message on this paper and crumple it up "
Wth op, you don't use the same methods for adults so why would you extrapolate it?

thinkkook · 07/08/2023 21:46

I was smacked as a child - rarely as it worked as a deterrent.

My parents were not abusive in any other way to me or my sibling or to each other.

I don't hold it against them.

I've never hit my kids.

RudsyFarmer · 07/08/2023 21:45

Cowlover89 · 07/08/2023 20:48

I got a smack on the bum and didn't do me any harm. I got brought up right. Was never grounded. I love my parents very much and don't hold it against them. I was a little shit at times

Same

MamaGhina · 07/08/2023 21:45

I absolutely hate the ‘didn’t do me any harm’ argument. Surely that makes you lucky not right?
I was hit by both my parents. All the time. Yes I ended up in an abusive relationship. Yes I think my upbringing was partly to blame. Yes I resent my parents and have a distant relationship with them. And no, they’ve never looked after my children unsupervised because I don’t hit my children and wouldn’t trust them not to.

TheMoth · 07/08/2023 21:44

According to my local fb group, things were better in the old days when you could discipline children. I'm often confused as to what these old days were, as many of those on there are similar age to me. By discipline, they inevitably mean smack. Which always makes me want to ask them whether poor behaviour has only existed since the demise in smacking.

I would argue that the worst behaved kids are those who are regularly smacked for misdemeanours, because if your own parents are hitting you, what have you got to fear from people who, you know, aren't allowed to hit you? Most people smack their kids for naughty behaviour because THEY are angry; which implies a lack of control. And as an adult, we should beyond that.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:43

Neyon · 07/08/2023 21:40

No-one is talking about tapping, though. If you're thinking of a tap on the legs, the same as you might tap someone's shoulder to get their attention, it's not an issue.
If you're minimising an actual smack as a "tap", controlled or not it's still hitting.

I’m minimising with the word tap and you're exaggerating with the word hit.

Zanatdy · 07/08/2023 21:43

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:05

I don’t think my parents smacking me was abuse- sorry I don’t! I was never hit but I was smacked on the bum as a punishment.

Agreed, my parents weren’t bullies, neither were my friends parents. It was fairly normal in the 80’s when I was raised. Times have changed, I don’t judge decisions taken in a different era with today’s standards. I didn’t smack my children as time has moved on, but certainly don't view my parents as abusive bullies, anyone who assumes everyone who smacked a child in the 80’s was a bully is wrong. Very wrong

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 21:42

YABU - giving a child a smack bottom does not mean you beat your partner up and pets.

Comparing it to a partner is not an equal comparison. There's lots you would do with children but not with partners. It's a completely different dynamic.

It's also dependant on the generation. Giving children a smack was the norm say 50 years ago. That was just what everyone did. Even police officers would give kids a clip round the ear.

I smacked my children on occasion when growing up but was usually for something very dangerous that they hadn't previously listened to me about. Young children are not capable of reasoning on matters or using words.

I disagree it breeds violence.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:42

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 21:38

So it’s ok to hit a kid, who is smaller, but an adult who is bigger gets more respect … and no violence.

You’ve just explained perfect why hitting is wrong.

Hitting is wrong- I’m not justifying hitting, I’m saying I don’t believe smacking was abusive- but comparing apples and oranges isnt an argument. I wouldn’t breastfeed my boss, doesn’t mean breastfeeding is wrong.

DinoRoar14 · 07/08/2023 21:42

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:27

Well I disagree- in years to come I wonder if people will say removing a child’s favourite toy by way of punishment is damaging.
My parents never lashed out at me in anger is was a prewarned punishment, issued after a boundary was pushed. It wasn’t constant, it was occasional around the age of 4.

Sometimes I do wonder if all these other methods of punishment are any better or in fact cause greater emotional turmoil for a child. I think What most people say when they mean don’t punish your children is have perfectly behaved children.

...No need to wait years. That would be wrong

And I don't know about you but I like to know better and do better.

Neyon · 07/08/2023 21:40

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:37

I’m not justifying hitting- I’m pointing out that people keep saying hitting as if lashing out at a child’s face in anger is the same as a controlled decision in the 80s to smack a kid on the bum for bad behaviour they were forewarned about. I’m pointing out that times have changed, but to label everyone’s parents in the 80s who tapped them on the legs as abusive isn’t true- and life isn’t black and white.

No-one is talking about tapping, though. If you're thinking of a tap on the legs, the same as you might tap someone's shoulder to get their attention, it's not an issue.
If you're minimising an actual smack as a "tap", controlled or not it's still hitting.

IamAlso4eels · 07/08/2023 21:40

Neyon · 07/08/2023 21:37

I wonder if those defending smacking/hitting kids as acceptable punishment would be okay with me doing it in a professional capacity? If your child acts up when I'm trying to teach, can I smack them as punishment? I'd be interested to know why not.
To add - I never actually would raise my hands to a child, my own or anyone else's.

Exactly!

IME of working with children, the ones who are smacked at home are almost always the children who exhibit the lowest levels of behaviour control and are most likely to hit other children when angry or frustrated. Wonder what smacking is teaching them...?

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 21:38

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:34

No I’d walk away, put in an official complaint and resign

So it’s ok to hit a kid, who is smaller, but an adult who is bigger gets more respect … and no violence.

You’ve just explained perfect why hitting is wrong.

Neyon · 07/08/2023 21:37

I wonder if those defending smacking/hitting kids as acceptable punishment would be okay with me doing it in a professional capacity? If your child acts up when I'm trying to teach, can I smack them as punishment? I'd be interested to know why not.
To add - I never actually would raise my hands to a child, my own or anyone else's.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:37

GiantPandaAttacks · 07/08/2023 21:34

in years to come I wonder if people will say removing a child’s favourite toy by way of punishment is damaging

It is scientific fact that hitting your children is damaging and causes long term psychological damage.

How on earth are people justifying hitting their children? Your children look to you for safety and security and you’re dreaming up explanations for why you using your superior strength to attack someone smaller, weaker and more vulnerable than you is acceptable. It’s awful how entrenched the idea that you can abuse children to force them to ‘behave’
or because you can’t regulate your own emotions in a moment of fear or anger.

I’m not justifying hitting- I’m pointing out that people keep saying hitting as if lashing out at a child’s face in anger is the same as a controlled decision in the 80s to smack a kid on the bum for bad behaviour they were forewarned about. I’m pointing out that times have changed, but to label everyone’s parents in the 80s who tapped them on the legs as abusive isn’t true- and life isn’t black and white.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 07/08/2023 21:35

I voted YABU, but because my mum smacked us as children. She never raised her hands or voice to anyone else and was adamantly against any kind of violence between adults or even between children. She was raised to see smacking as an acceptable form of punishment for children.

She was very wrong of course, I don’t and never would smack my children. I don’t believe it teaches what I want them to learn and I don’t believe in making them too scared to come to me when they fuck up or when they have a problem. But she believed it was ok and believed it was the right thing to do. It didn’t make her ok with violence in other aspects of her life though.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:34

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 21:32

So if you were to take this analogy seriously we’d discuss an adult exhibiting adult behaviour: a boss/colleague/patient shouting in someone’s face or harassing them.
In these situations you would hit the other person @OnlyFoolsnMothers ?

No I’d walk away, put in an official complaint and resign

GiantPandaAttacks · 07/08/2023 21:34

in years to come I wonder if people will say removing a child’s favourite toy by way of punishment is damaging

It is scientific fact that hitting your children is damaging and causes long term psychological damage.

How on earth are people justifying hitting their children? Your children look to you for safety and security and you’re dreaming up explanations for why you using your superior strength to attack someone smaller, weaker and more vulnerable than you is acceptable. It’s awful how entrenched the idea that you can abuse children to force them to ‘behave’
or because you can’t regulate your own emotions in a moment of fear or anger.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 07/08/2023 21:34

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 21:25

Yes theories are absolutely squashed the moment a single person has a personal, alleged anecdote. That's how it works. Gold star.

Well making blanket statements that because I did A , I obviously did B is just as logical right Hmm

I could tell you "why" but I simply CBA . You don't need to know and I really don;t have to say .
Like I said I defend my action to my last breath .

IamAlso4eels · 07/08/2023 21:34

Teaching about acceptable behaviour shouldn't be about punishment though. A far healthier approach is to think about actions/choices and consequences so children learn to manage and regulate their behaviour. "Good" behaviour attracts positive consequences like praise, people wanting to play with you, being a good friend, treats, etc which reinforces it. Negative behaviour should have consequences that match the behaviour so that the child makes the connection between the two - e.g., throw a toy at the TV then the TV goes off and the toy goes away, shove your brother out of the way to get the last available swing then your brother goes on it first and you go last (if at all), draw on the wall then your pens go away and you will be given the cloth to clean the wall, lose your PE kit through carelessness then your pocket money will buy a new one, etc.

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 21:32

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:29

If My boss threw his food at my wall, or pulled my hair or hit my other child then this would be a fair comparison. I hate these comparisons, aside from young children, any other such situation would be abuse and the person ie. The parent could walk away. Do people resign from their kids?

So if you were to take this analogy seriously we’d discuss an adult exhibiting adult behaviour: a boss/colleague/patient shouting in someone’s face or harassing them.
In these situations you would hit the other person @OnlyFoolsnMothers ?

Neyon · 07/08/2023 21:32

Rathouse · 07/08/2023 21:27

@MillicentBystandr that's kids for you though you basically are implying the same as OP. Its not a debate .. kids today are unruly, they probably hit their parents and they have no manners! The behaviour in schools today was unheard of in my primary school (90s). I think life is all about balance and its not as simple as what OP is saying.

Nice generalisation, but as a parent and educator of many years, you're clutching at straws.

YANBU OP, ridiculous when people say they wouldn't hit an adult, only their child. Basically, it's okay to hit the smaller, more vulnerable ones that won't hit back.
I also say hit because smacking is hitting, no point in trying to minimise it.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 07/08/2023 21:31

For a very long time it was considered a suitable act of discipline. There were children that were abused and beaten, whose parents may well have walloped each other and animals, but there were very many more loving parents who used a smack as discipline because that was considered the most effective way. It didn't make our parents bullies, lazy parents, violent psychopaths or anything else other than loving parents doing their best and following guidelines. Exactly the same as all you parents who complain about smacking are doing now. And if in 20 or 30 years time the guidelines change to something different which they will, you will be the ones being described as bullies, lazy parents, thick parents who couldn't be arsed to parent properly. You cannot judge the past by todays norms

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:29

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 21:26

People who hit kids tends to argue that they are ‘teaching’ them. So far none have answered a simple question.
If hitting is a good teaching tool, do they let their boss hit them when they’ve done something wrong at work? If no, why not?

If My boss threw his food at my wall, or pulled my hair or hit my other child then this would be a fair comparison. I hate these comparisons, aside from young children, any other such situation would be abuse and the person ie. The parent could walk away. Do people resign from their kids?

RLmadmum · 07/08/2023 21:28

I was only ever smacked twice as a child. One because I ran out into the road to get to the ice cream van and nearly got hit by a bus. The second time was for laughing at the smack I got and telling my mum it didn't hurt... 🙈