Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To assume this about people who hit their kids...

218 replies

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

OP posts:
Whatajokr · 07/08/2023 22:40

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:22

@Whatajokr I think your kids have turned out well despite the smacking not because of it

Think what you want.

I have great teens who were smacked as children.

I was an alright teen who wasn't smacked as a child.

I have an XH who wasn't smacked as a child and who has turned into a horrid man in his 40s.

You can read reports about how terrible many childhood discipline techniques are. How they affect you in later life. They're all on t'intermet if you look for them.

I know so many parents with feckless children. The current trendy ways to teach children how to behave are lacking in so many ways. My pet hate is parents who don't use the word no to their children. Wtaf?

AllOfThemWitches · 07/08/2023 22:39

I don't agree with hitting but i can certainly see how it happens. My child has severe ASD and is prone to violent behaviour. Being bitten, hit, kicked, pinched, etc. has really tested me.

Hivaluegirl · 07/08/2023 22:38

Dad use to beat us, beat my mum and our cat so you aren't off

Abouttimemum · 07/08/2023 22:35

Alwaysatfault · 07/08/2023 20:44

Maybe it's because they were hit themselves as a child & they don't know any different?

I understand the sentiment of course and it probably is that way for some people but my husband was absolutely battered as a kid and all it did was make him not want to be that way. And hate his parents, who he no longer speaks to.

Wider than that I have absolutely no idea why people think fear based punishment would ever work. No one smacks me when I make a mistake, don’t get something right or don’t entirely understand something so I don’t know why we think it’s alright to abuse tiny little children who are trying to learn. ultimately they learn based on the actions of those around them. It’s absolute madness.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:34

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:30

P.D. - personality disorder? Postnatal depression?

personality disorder. Not her fault, nor her parents fault not anyone elses. It is what it is.

nolamesallowed · 07/08/2023 22:32

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:29

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows you can definitely have one child abused as a scapegoat in the family and not the others it's pretty common. Have you read 'a child called it' or any of those other abuse autobiographies? Who knows what the truth is for that particular person you have in mind but needed to correct this for anyone else reading

This is very true

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:30

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:24

Not saying that people with PD diagnoses are bad, most of them are ordinary people who are struggling just like with any disability . Just this person likes to make our it's her parents fault it's the way she is, rather than that she had a disorder which isn't anyone's fault !

P.D. - personality disorder? Postnatal depression?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:29

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows you can definitely have one child abused as a scapegoat in the family and not the others it's pretty common. Have you read 'a child called it' or any of those other abuse autobiographies? Who knows what the truth is for that particular person you have in mind but needed to correct this for anyone else reading

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:27

nolamesallowed · 07/08/2023 22:25

Cultural like the 15 year old who was attacked with an iron bar and hit on the face for using makeup to hide the marks on her from a previous violent attack from her father?

Of course. Culture is always an excuse for people to behave like animals.

That was a horrifying case, really upsetting to read that poor girl. When I first heard about it what came to mind immediately was the FGM and honour killings that are excused by so called cultures. Very damaging to the majority of Muslims who don't engage in these practices.

nolamesallowed · 07/08/2023 22:25

user1471447924 · 07/08/2023 22:14

YABU, there are cultural and religious factors here.

Cultural like the 15 year old who was attacked with an iron bar and hit on the face for using makeup to hide the marks on her from a previous violent attack from her father?

Of course. Culture is always an excuse for people to behave like animals.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:24

Not saying that people with PD diagnoses are bad, most of them are ordinary people who are struggling just like with any disability . Just this person likes to make our it's her parents fault it's the way she is, rather than that she had a disorder which isn't anyone's fault !

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:23

@Simonjt it's not a goood thing it's a bad thing. I said it's not ok. Just that they're different.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:22

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:13

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows if your child bullied, a teacher smacking them wouldn't teach them anything except to hide it better!

Wouldn't you what the staff to work with their emotions and feelings to work out what's going on for them that means they feel the need to bully? Always a mental health or a anxious issue or lack of power in one part of their life that leads to bullying others in my experience.

That can be the case certainly. But in the case of the child I mentioned earlier the child did need to learn what it was to be on the receiving end of being physically hurt so she would not do it again. If she had ever known how it felt to be treated cruelly (as an adult she likes to tell people she was treated cruelly by her parents all the time but that's her version of events, her siblings aren't like her) she would have learnt empathy. Not only does she have a PD diagnosis but she claims it is because of "childhood trauma." I think she somehow had 're-written history in her mind! However she was not an average child. I can see that most children might bully because they actually are struggling .

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:22

@Whatajokr I think your kids have turned out well despite the smacking not because of it

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:20

Jifmicroliquid · 07/08/2023 22:15

I was hit as a child. My father also kept a garden cane on the top of the cupboard and would give me a whack with that occasionally. It got to the point that if he reached up to the cupboard I would panic and apologise, even if I hadn’t felt I’d done anything wrong.
Bit horrible really but I have a fantastic relationship with my Dad now so it definitely didn’t scar me for life or anything. I suppose they were just different times.

Your good relationship is in spite of they cane though surely. Not because of it. And probably because he no longer reaches for it now if you disagree with him (do you dare to these days?)

Simonjt · 07/08/2023 22:20

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:02

I think it does also depend on how it's done.

If it's ' we need to carefully tbink through a punishment, we will do a spank' that's still not ok but it's different from grabbing a child and hitting them out of frustration/anger. I think the first can be done but otherwise good but misinformed parents but the second is obviously a huge risk

How can sitting and planning how you’re going to assault a child ever be a good thing?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:19

user1471447924 · 07/08/2023 22:14

YABU, there are cultural and religious factors here.

Lots of cultures and religions enforce hitting wives too...

There is no excuse- just because other cultures or classes do it doesn't mean it should be allowed in the Uk. Look at female genital mutilation! I also don't think baby ear piercing should be legal (it's common in Asian and in white working class cultures so I could be accused of being a racist or snob) but that's not a hill I want to die on when there are other far more pressing issues!

nolamesallowed · 07/08/2023 22:18

Whatajokr · 07/08/2023 21:59

Ok, I'm biting

I was never smacked as an 80s child by my mum. I had no boundaries at all, as her talking to me and reasoning with me didn't work at all. Removing privileges had no effect on my behaviour either. I was an absolute shit at times.

XH and I decided one of our many early 2000s parenting tools in the box would be a short sharp controlled smack. Only when we were calm, never in temper. Our children would be warned it was coming if they continued in their behaviour. It was an extreme measure, but it was used. Other techniques were implemented before they were smacked. Not the "naughty step" or time out. I have several issues with that... Far worse than a smack imo.

As late teens, the children are now wonderful human beings. Empathetic, caring, understanding, loving, well rounded. I'm happy with the way we raised them.

What are you 'biting?'

Did it make you feel good abusing your children? You sound so proud.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:17

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 22:14

All the posts here saying that it's OK if it is a controlled and thought out manner - somehow that's even more disturbing. To actually sit and calmly decide that the most appropriate response to a behaviour is to hit a child is abhorrent to me. You could calmly think of a multitude of consequences that don't involve physical punishment, yet the best you can come up with is a warning and then violence.

Yup, I don't think it's ok at all just that those parents wouldn't have been modelling flying off the handle and being out of control. Definitely not ok just perhaps slightly less risky than the unregulated ones. You're absolutely right that there are about 900 other choices of consequence to choose
From rather than 'have a smack.'

Jifmicroliquid · 07/08/2023 22:15

I was hit as a child. My father also kept a garden cane on the top of the cupboard and would give me a whack with that occasionally. It got to the point that if he reached up to the cupboard I would panic and apologise, even if I hadn’t felt I’d done anything wrong.
Bit horrible really but I have a fantastic relationship with my Dad now so it definitely didn’t scar me for life or anything. I suppose they were just different times.

nolamesallowed · 07/08/2023 22:14

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:05

I don’t think my parents smacking me was abuse- sorry I don’t! I was never hit but I was smacked on the bum as a punishment.

You were 'never hit' just 'smacked.'

'Smacking' is hitting. Hitting is assault.

Katiemag · 07/08/2023 22:14

Lavender14 · 07/08/2023 21:11

I do think there is a generational difference and I think there's a lot more information and awareness of why children's bodily autonomy, respect and personal safety is so important and that it really starts at home. I'm not sure that was something my parents consciously thought about- I think they disciplined in the way they were disciplined because it was what they knew and what was familiar and maybe a little instinctive. I also think there's more awareness now of the pressures of being a parent and how important it is to self regulate and apologise when you get it wrong. I'm not sure my parents had that same encouragement to self reflect and I think there was more pressure to have children who 'behaved' than who were freer to just be children and make mistakes and have that accepted as part of children's learning and development. I think as well when you consider how desperately poor mental health supports for new parents were in the 80s and 90s for example, it's no wonder so many parents suffered with pnd with little support and who struggled with attachment to their child. I agree completely that by smacking/ being overly angry/ overly domineering you are being your child's first bully. But I have less tolerance for people who do that now because there's so much great info and education out there now that there's much less of an excuse not to be doing your research and educating yourself. Although generational trauma can also be a part of that as well.

I very much agree with this answer. There is so much literature nowadays documenting the long-term adverse effects that physical discipline has on children and their self-esteem. I don’t think any parent nowadays could honestly tell themselves that hitting a child is in the child’s best interests.

Im not sure that information was available a generation ago. I think there were perhaps some parents in 80’s and 90’s who genuinely thought that smacking their child would not harm them.

So, to answer OP, I think modern parents who hit their children are not able to regulate their negative emotions and may also hit pets when frustrated. Perhaps less likely to hit their partners as there are more likely to be consequences (there’s not the same power imbalance as with children & pets)

user1471447924 · 07/08/2023 22:14

YABU, there are cultural and religious factors here.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:14

GiantPandaAttacks · 07/08/2023 22:10

To those saying that it was the norm, therefore acceptable. It was also acceptable for a man to rape his wife, for a woman to not be able to hold property and to force the poor into workhouses. Why can we accept that those acts of oppression and violence were once normal and now considered appalling, but not the systematic bullying of a parent who hits their child/ren? Can we not learn from the past - it was the norm to hit your children but we recognise the massive impact it has on children? Or does preserving the rose-tinted view of your own parenting matter more?

Agree

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 22:14

All the posts here saying that it's OK if it is a controlled and thought out manner - somehow that's even more disturbing. To actually sit and calmly decide that the most appropriate response to a behaviour is to hit a child is abhorrent to me. You could calmly think of a multitude of consequences that don't involve physical punishment, yet the best you can come up with is a warning and then violence.