Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To assume this about people who hit their kids...

218 replies

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:18

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows sorry didn't realize you had the diagnosis too so you will understand how it impacts you more than most. My understanding is that childhood trauma can be all sorts of things- it sound like despite having a loving mum you have had some tough times too and been let down by other adults in your life that should have kept you safe.

Nowthenhere · 07/08/2023 23:15

I've overheard mums and dad's blackmail their children, empty threats and unnecessarily/not age appropriate conversations about behaviour.

An example was when a small boy was lying on the floor in a shop with his feet up and kicking and screaming. His father kept talking to the room "there's other children around you who are watching you. I'm going to pick you up now before you hurt someone" and lots of conversations that were just simply not the time or place.

Yet people are concerned about a sharp smack, correcting behaviour at the time and moving on?

Animals also correct their off spring's behaviour with quick snappy aggression and move on.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:13

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:08

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows just to pick up on what you say below about personality disorder being no one's fault and nothing to do with childhood.. again this isn't true. They're not something that people are born with like, say, autism (although autistic women are often wrongly diagnosed with borderline personality disorder but that's going really off topic here)

Personality disorders are a trauma response, usually develop as a result of attachment problems and living with chaotic caregivers, such as abusive or erratically neglectful households. We are social animals and the way in which we relate to each other has big impact and when this is messed up it can result in conditions that we give names to like personality disorders. I would urge you not to be so dismissive of the person you're talking about as there may be a lot of truth to what she's saying but it's likely she will be chaotic and not a 'good reliable victim' in that sense.

Ok, thanks. Just I have same diagnosis (EUPD) as her and we are very similar in some ways but didn't have any significant attachment issues at all, had a wonderful mum. Very gentle, hardly ever raised her voice at me. But I can see that maybe some people can go through stuff and be really scarred by it , I was not. I guess I'm fortunate.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:08

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows just to pick up on what you say below about personality disorder being no one's fault and nothing to do with childhood.. again this isn't true. They're not something that people are born with like, say, autism (although autistic women are often wrongly diagnosed with borderline personality disorder but that's going really off topic here)

Personality disorders are a trauma response, usually develop as a result of attachment problems and living with chaotic caregivers, such as abusive or erratically neglectful households. We are social animals and the way in which we relate to each other has big impact and when this is messed up it can result in conditions that we give names to like personality disorders. I would urge you not to be so dismissive of the person you're talking about as there may be a lot of truth to what she's saying but it's likely she will be chaotic and not a 'good reliable victim' in that sense.

BertieBotts · 07/08/2023 23:08

LaMaG · 07/08/2023 21:09

I think there are 2 distinct types - those that do it as a punishment because they believe it is a form of discipline and those that lash out when they lose their temper. The second category is by far the most dangerous IMO as they are not capable of control and could use excessive force, and are capable of hitting anyone who challenges them or upsets them. The first category are likely to use just enough force to stop the child repeating the action but not actually hurt or traumatise the child. It's not something I would do and I don't agree with it but all physical punishment isn't necessarily abuse IMO.

I agree with your distinction, but I don't think that people who use hitting as purposeful, thought through punishment are ALL using carefully the minimum amount of force/pain required.

In fact, I think that is quite unlikely - since using pain to punish is supposed to be a deterrent, part of that is meant to be fear, with the idea that the fear of being punished, being hurt, is what will keep the person in line. So I think that they are intending it to hurt (maybe you meant not actually injure?). Especially if you think about discipline like the old school canings, or Asian countries with beating as part of their justice system, or some of the fundamentalist Christian beliefs in parts of America. People administering/deciding on those punishments are totally calm and believe they are being measured and reasonable and logical. I have no problem in believing that someone who feels that this is a reasonable and logical step would also think it reasonable to take that step with absolutely anybody that they felt was lower than them in some kind of hierarchy and was not properly respecting that position.

And I don't think that you can necessarily know, as a parent, if your children find being hit and intimidated and frightened into compliance traumatic. Certainly many adults who have grown up with discipline of this type report that their parents think they did nothing wrong but they disagree. I do agree that corporal punishment isn't always and necessarily traumatic, and there is apparently some research suggesting that if everyone around you is getting hit and it's a cultural norm then it's less likely to be traumatic, but that also doesn't mean that it's never traumatic in that situation. People are simply going to experience things differently.

I also think it's very very possible (and probably extremely common) for otherwise good parents to occasionally lash out and hit a child maybe once or twice ever in their life, never hit anybody else and not be a danger to anybody (even, really, that child). Especially in the preschool/toddler years, young children can test your patience like really nothing else I've ever experienced before or since, and I think a great many good parents have a moment where they do something that they know is ultimately unhelpful.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:07

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:57

So sorry you went through this xxxxx

That's awful @Hivaluegirl I hope you now have a happier life. I am lucky because my dad was only occasionally violent to my mother and siblings . It was nasty when it happened, I used to be so very afraid he would kill us and as an older child I used to fantasize about suicide, running away and did self harm a lot. I felt there was no escape. I was afraid of men, and believe I had no future.

But I have to put it into perspective and remind myself I am lucky because it didn't happen daily (not the actual violence ) and most of it was more like threats, yelling, name calling. I've had a fortunate childhood for the most part and I know I need to remember that occasional violence is not the same as real systemic abuse. I can't imagine what that would feel like. I used to think I did, and felt very sorry for myself most of my life, but now I realise I wasn't seriously harmed by it in comparison to some. Flowers

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:02

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:56

What I didn't like about smacking was the way my clothes were pulled down so they could do it in my bare bottom. It made me feel very ashamed. Degraded. I was being sexually abused by a relative at the same period in my childhood though and completely blocked it out at the time, only to discover as an adult that my sibling remembered it happening to both of us in the same room very clearly. So maybe I was more sensitive about nakedness from that ? I was quite a sensitive child, took things to heart.

I'm so sorry you went through that x

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:01

@fullbloom87 I think every generation fantasizes about how when we were younger people respected their elders... like the lyrics in baz lurman sunscreen song! Even in Victorian times they were saying the kids are out of control with permissive parenting..

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 23:01

DatumTarum · 07/08/2023 22:44

I dropped a friend when I found out she hit her kids.

No excuse for it anymore.

We know it doesn't work (science).

We know it causes damage (science).

It kept me and my siblings out of trouble. We knew the consequences if we did anything stupid like get involved in drugs, involved in crime, police etc.

BottomFishBananas · 07/08/2023 23:00

Hitting a child it so very wrong. Yes my parents smacked me as a child and I vividly remember it making me angry and afraid to ever share things with them. I love them dearly, they were 1980’s parents so it was a tragic ‘norm’, but I run a ‘no smacking’ home for my children.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:59

Nevermay · 07/08/2023 22:56

I too come from a time when it was normal in the UK.

I am very glad that this is how I was disciplined. It was never out of anger.

This was also how I disciplined my children, but it won't be how I discipline my grandchildren - times have changed. That is not to say the old way was wrong and the new way right.

I hate hearing parents shout at their children - far worse, and far more damaging in my opinion than a short, light smack. Smacks do not have to be delivered in anger, but shouting always does. Smacks take a second, but shouting takes hundreds of times longer!

I expect the time will come when out culture embraces smacking again, but looks at horror at the parents who shouts, and labels them abusive and bullying.

The very worst and most abusive thing is no discipline at all, and that is seen all to commonly these days - this amounts to serious neglect, and the detrimental effects can last a life time

I have always considered verbal and emotional abuse to be extremely soul destroying and I hate the wayi sometimes hear kids being shouted at by their parents for nothing. It makes you wonder if they will bother having contact with their parents once they grow up.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:57

Hivaluegirl · 07/08/2023 22:38

Dad use to beat us, beat my mum and our cat so you aren't off

So sorry you went through this xxxxx

Cowlover89 · 07/08/2023 22:57

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 21:13

@Cowlover89 it did do you harm, you think it was OK. That is harm. Anyone who thinks they deserved to be assaulted has been harmed.

🙄

WedTheBed · 07/08/2023 22:57

I got a smacked bum as a kid. I also followed my dad temper wise, I only realised this as my DD got older, I did give her a smacked bum once when I lost control of trying to ‘gentle parent’. Not hard enough to hurt but hard enough to shock and seeing her upset was awful and made my chest hurt. It made me realise that it doesn’t work, yes they stop in that moment. But they stop because they fear the person who is meant to love them unconditionally. Never again. It’s also made me see my parents differently in a way. Because I had a few smacked bums as a kid and I just can’t imagine how they weren’t phased by doing it.

I do still lose my temper, and I feel myself making this really angry face that I don’t like and I’m still working on it, but I’d never smack their bums again; I learnt my lesson. I don’t want to bully my children into fearing me. As much as I think the full gentle parenting thing is a little unrealistic at times.. communication and creating a good understanding really does work better than any physical discipline.

Nevermay · 07/08/2023 22:56

I too come from a time when it was normal in the UK.

I am very glad that this is how I was disciplined. It was never out of anger.

This was also how I disciplined my children, but it won't be how I discipline my grandchildren - times have changed. That is not to say the old way was wrong and the new way right.

I hate hearing parents shout at their children - far worse, and far more damaging in my opinion than a short, light smack. Smacks do not have to be delivered in anger, but shouting always does. Smacks take a second, but shouting takes hundreds of times longer!

I expect the time will come when out culture embraces smacking again, but looks at horror at the parents who shouts, and labels them abusive and bullying.

The very worst and most abusive thing is no discipline at all, and that is seen all to commonly these days - this amounts to serious neglect, and the detrimental effects can last a life time

pbdr · 07/08/2023 22:56

My otherwise wonderful parents smacked me twice during my childhood. For literally years afterwards (into adulthood) I would sometimes lie in bed or stand in the shower and think about what happened. I can vividly remember those two occasions like I can remember hardly anything else in my life. No memory of what I did wrong, but the feeling of shocked betrayal, that the people who were supposed to love me most in the world would treat me like that stayed with me for a very long time.

So many people who smacked their kids are so blasé about it, saying their kids are fine and don't care etc. but my parents don't have the first clue how pervasively it impacted me. I'm sure they would say the same.
They really were great parents. Except for that. I will never ever make my daughter feel like that. I will never give her those memories to carry with her.

Smacking is culturally normalised child abuse, psychological as much as physical.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:56

What I didn't like about smacking was the way my clothes were pulled down so they could do it in my bare bottom. It made me feel very ashamed. Degraded. I was being sexually abused by a relative at the same period in my childhood though and completely blocked it out at the time, only to discover as an adult that my sibling remembered it happening to both of us in the same room very clearly. So maybe I was more sensitive about nakedness from that ? I was quite a sensitive child, took things to heart.

Friarclose · 07/08/2023 22:51

I was smacked loads as a kid. My dad would sometimes go too far and I did resent it.

My mum was a leg slapper, she'd call it a "hot leg" I hated it but it did me no harm and we have a great relationship.

I don't condone smacking but I do think that without that level of discipline, future generations are behaving much worse.

I have never smacked my child

greenspaces4peace · 07/08/2023 22:50

i don't think it's wise to judge others. and i think that each and every one of us, if pushed can turn to violence.
however i think some forms of physical punishment stems from lack of options and different techniques can be learned.

Ilovechocolate87 · 07/08/2023 22:49

I smacked my cat afew times when he did things like weed all over our bed (not proud of it, and I made the hard decision to rehome him and our other cat in the because I know i wasn't a good owner, for that and other reasons)

But I would NEVER hit my children, or my husband.

I was smacked as a child, DH was too and was also hit on the hand with a flipper.We swore we would never raise a hand to our own children as we remembered the fear it caused us, and we love them and each other too much to cross that line.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:47

When I was a child I saw my dad hit the dog with a lead. I hated seeing that. Really upset me. Hitting pets is horrible. I could never do that to a defenceless animal. I never liked my dad much and have many unpleasant memories of him.

fullbloom87 · 07/08/2023 22:47

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 07/08/2023 20:34

I think a large factor is culture - someone who for example is British by birth and has a few generations here then yes it’s abnormal behaviour. Eastern cultures not so much. It is seen as discipline and there is a different mentality attached to it. Not saying it’s right. But I don’t think they would be generally violent people but who knows.

Not that long ago physical punishment was the norm in the uk but it didn’t mean everyone was violent to other adults too. Pets probably yes.

Smacking your kids was only considered wrong in the last 15 years or so in the uk. In the 90's it was normal to see a mum smacking her kids in the supermarket, playground or wherever. Then in the 00's it tapered off to smacking a hand till eventually it became evil.

Pretty much everyone my age (I'm 36) that I know was smacked regularly as a child and nobody I know is psychopath. We love and respect our parents and harbour no bad feelings.
I don't smack my children though because it's considered bad and to be honest I'm more afraid of my kids then the other way round.
I don't agree with smacking but I think we've gone too far the other way. There's definitely less respect for adults now.

DatumTarum · 07/08/2023 22:44

I dropped a friend when I found out she hit her kids.

No excuse for it anymore.

We know it doesn't work (science).

We know it causes damage (science).

Jifmicroliquid · 07/08/2023 22:43

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 22:20

Your good relationship is in spite of they cane though surely. Not because of it. And probably because he no longer reaches for it now if you disagree with him (do you dare to these days?)

Yes a good relationship in spite of it. I suppose I’m trying to say that it didn’t affect my relationship with my father as I got older. Where some people have said that they never got over it or couldn’t forgive their parent for what they did, I didn’t feel experience that.
Actually if I’m honest, I don’t think he found the child days easy. He was a great dad and very hands on, but my relationship with him really blossomed in my teens and beyond and we probably became the closest in my twenties.
I think he just didn’t really know how to handle or communicate with younger children and his way of stopping a situation was to resort to a smack or a threat of one.
As I said, different times. If someone was hitting their kid with a garden cane these days…

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 22:41

I was smacked as a child, probably a total of 2 times as my dad raising his voice was enough to make me behave. My parents did not hit each other nor did they hit our dog.

I smacked my children, probably the same amount of times. I have never hit a partner or a pet. Never been in trouble with the police for anything, never had a fight with anyone etc so I don't think the theory is correct.