Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To assume this about people who hit their kids...

218 replies

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

OP posts:
Wenfy · 08/08/2023 02:44

SyncopatedRhythm · 08/08/2023 01:50

Apologies, haven't read entire thread.
Genuinely interested to hear from parents who do smack (on the bottom).
How would you deal with this scenario?

You witness your child no1 (aged 4) smacking child no2 (aged 3) hard on the bottom.

Child no2 bursts into floods of tears, shouting "He smacked me, he smacked me!"

What's your next move?

The worst hitters tend to be the kids who have never been hit. DS regularly gets walloped by DN who is the same age and so understands never to do it as it hurts.

RattleRattle · 08/08/2023 01:53

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

SyncopatedRhythm · 08/08/2023 01:50

Apologies, haven't read entire thread.
Genuinely interested to hear from parents who do smack (on the bottom).
How would you deal with this scenario?

You witness your child no1 (aged 4) smacking child no2 (aged 3) hard on the bottom.

Child no2 bursts into floods of tears, shouting "He smacked me, he smacked me!"

What's your next move?

RattleRattle · 08/08/2023 01:50

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

echt · 08/08/2023 01:44

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

I think hitting someone smaller than yourself about covers it.

I'm usually averse to whataboutery but would there be the same excuses offered on this thread, particularly about culture, had it been a woman being struck by a man?

About time children had the same rights as adults when it comes to being struck.

RattleRattle · 08/08/2023 01:35

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

RattleRattle · 08/08/2023 01:34

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

Abcdefgh1234 · 08/08/2023 01:18

Its cultural differences. You know that hitting child is not the same as whacking their bum. Maybe westerners think hitting its like abusive very hard hit. But in my culture its just smack on the hand or bum and its not hurt at all. My mum always said westerner children is badly behave because of lack of diacipline, they are talked back etc. to be honest i kinda agree, my DS is 7 and i see his friend lots of them talked back to their parents which never happen in my household.

i’ve been smacked by my mum and i love her very much. I dont feel her abusive me.

Tiredanddistracted · 08/08/2023 00:31

I got hit as a child. I wasn't a bad kid but I had my moments of idiocy. All it achieved was to make me so afraid of my parents that I didn't ask for help when I genuinely got into trouble. The situation got quite serious and by the time I admitted it, it was almost beyond their help.

It's a poor choice to make as a parent.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 08/08/2023 00:25

IamAlso4eels · 07/08/2023 23:58

I knew the consequences of "bad" decisions too - my dad would hit me. So from a young age I learned to try and cover up my mistakes and not ask for help or assistance even when in dire need of it because I was scared of being "smacked" (hit). It very often led to me getting myself even deeper into difficulty and into situations way above my head that could have easily been resolved at a much earlier stage had I been able to trust the adults around me to not physically hurt me and mentally humiliate me (because getting smacked is emotionally hurtful and humiliating)

IME, smacked children are far more likely to not only misbehaved they are also more likely to lie about it and try to cover it up because they don't want to be hit. Not only does it damage children, it damages their ability to make good behavioural choices.

I've also never met a parent who doesn't use some form of the word "no" so not sure where that myth comes from that parents now don't say no. I've met thousands in the course of my work, never ever met one who doesn't say it.

Yeah it's better to reach children empathy and natural consequences of making mistakes. I don't think smacking works for most day to day scenarios.

See I remember being smacked for being naughty and it didn't bother me because I deserved it except I hated the nudity part, felt ashamed having to have my clothes pulled down but I remember other far more horrible consequences than smacking not for deliberate naughtiness but for say getting an answer wrong in my schoolwork, or knocking something over, spilling or breaking something .

Not smacking but something more frightening and horrible (can't say it here) and it caused me to be so afraid of making mistakes I actually used to contemplate how I could hurt myself so I didn't have to face my dad's anger. And it made me someone who never said sorry but always blamed others for my actions . To this day I find it hard to admit I'm wrong or take blame for anything .I always act like I'm somehow above criticism and I believe that arrogance is a result of fear and an inability to process shame because shame makes me feel I'm annihilated. Like if I make a mistake I'm worse than dirt.

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 00:03

@IamAlso4eels It would seem from reading many experiences on this thread that it comes down to a persons perception of smacking.

There are some on here who don't have any resentment towards their parents and are grateful for the form of discipline they received. There are others who resent it and are hurt by it.

I personally hold no resentment towards my parents and it had the opposite effect with me. I could tell my parents anything and I wouldn't have dreamed of covering stuff up as if I got found out, it would have led to more consequences.

I suppose it all depends on the child in question. Some will be receptive to it but others won't. It's the hard job of being a parent and working out which method works best.

Notamum12345577 · 07/08/2023 23:59

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 23:32

@Notamum12345577 I feel one of the reasons is because children/teenagers are not disciplined effectively in some families. They are reasoned with at the age of 2 which is impossible, and are never told 'no' and everything is so gentle does it. Sometimes kids need a good telling off and I don't think there is anything wrong with that.

Agreed

IamAlso4eels · 07/08/2023 23:58

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 23:01

It kept me and my siblings out of trouble. We knew the consequences if we did anything stupid like get involved in drugs, involved in crime, police etc.

I knew the consequences of "bad" decisions too - my dad would hit me. So from a young age I learned to try and cover up my mistakes and not ask for help or assistance even when in dire need of it because I was scared of being "smacked" (hit). It very often led to me getting myself even deeper into difficulty and into situations way above my head that could have easily been resolved at a much earlier stage had I been able to trust the adults around me to not physically hurt me and mentally humiliate me (because getting smacked is emotionally hurtful and humiliating)

IME, smacked children are far more likely to not only misbehaved they are also more likely to lie about it and try to cover it up because they don't want to be hit. Not only does it damage children, it damages their ability to make good behavioural choices.

I've also never met a parent who doesn't use some form of the word "no" so not sure where that myth comes from that parents now don't say no. I've met thousands in the course of my work, never ever met one who doesn't say it.

RattleRattle · 07/08/2023 23:47

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

Gothambutnotahamster · 07/08/2023 23:36

Cowlover89 · 07/08/2023 20:48

I got a smack on the bum and didn't do me any harm. I got brought up right. Was never grounded. I love my parents very much and don't hold it against them. I was a little shit at times

Me too. Plus my parents never ever hit each other. We only got smacked when we were really badly behaved. It was never in their temper / bad mood but entirely related to our behaviour.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:35

fullbloom87 · 07/08/2023 23:33

Yes I agree, but it's getting worse. I dread to think how the young people will be in years to come. Gets worse every 10 years. Doesn't help that a lot of modern parents are too busy on social media 'living their best life' instead of being grownups.

You may be right but bear in mind every generation since the year dot seems to have felt the same about their current youth!

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:34

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 23:30

Your first ‘category’ sounds exactly like a perpetrator’s excuse for domestic violence. Made me wince.

I think if someone was disciplining an adult that would definitely be abusive ! Because your partner is your equal. I know in the old days wife beating was allowed but I am glad we know better now.

fullbloom87 · 07/08/2023 23:33

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:01

@fullbloom87 I think every generation fantasizes about how when we were younger people respected their elders... like the lyrics in baz lurman sunscreen song! Even in Victorian times they were saying the kids are out of control with permissive parenting..

Yes I agree, but it's getting worse. I dread to think how the young people will be in years to come. Gets worse every 10 years. Doesn't help that a lot of modern parents are too busy on social media 'living their best life' instead of being grownups.

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 23:32

@Notamum12345577 I feel one of the reasons is because children/teenagers are not disciplined effectively in some families. They are reasoned with at the age of 2 which is impossible, and are never told 'no' and everything is so gentle does it. Sometimes kids need a good telling off and I don't think there is anything wrong with that.

LongDarkTeatime · 07/08/2023 23:30

LaMaG · 07/08/2023 21:09

I think there are 2 distinct types - those that do it as a punishment because they believe it is a form of discipline and those that lash out when they lose their temper. The second category is by far the most dangerous IMO as they are not capable of control and could use excessive force, and are capable of hitting anyone who challenges them or upsets them. The first category are likely to use just enough force to stop the child repeating the action but not actually hurt or traumatise the child. It's not something I would do and I don't agree with it but all physical punishment isn't necessarily abuse IMO.

Your first ‘category’ sounds exactly like a perpetrator’s excuse for domestic violence. Made me wince.

Notamum12345577 · 07/08/2023 23:29

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

Breed more violence? I was smacked as a kid (not much at all really) and I haven’t grown up to be violent! People complain about how teenagers behave nowadays, some people say that is because they didn’t get smacked!

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:29

Snail, not email!

BertieBotts · 07/08/2023 23:29

My pet hate is parents who don't use the word no to their children. Wtaf?

TBF, I think this one is really weirdly misrepresented or misunderstood.

The idea behind it is to avoid sentences like "no running" "no hitting" "stop throwing your food" and replace them with the instruction of what you actually want them to do, like "wait, we're by a road" "come over here and play with me"

This is because if you keep saying "no doing this, stop that, don't do the other" well it's like saying "don't think about an elephant" - it gets you exactly the result you don't want.

It's more effective to tell somebody what you DO want them to do, and this is especially true for young children, if you say to an adult "don't touch that" they can instantly fill in the blanks - oh, it must be something precious, private, it might be dangerous/unstable, and they would automatically stop before they ask why. But a young child has much less developed impulse control. If you tell a 4yo "don't touch that" they will quite frequently continue to touch it WHILE asking why, because they haven't got that inhibitory control down yet. Whereas if you say something like "hands on your head" (especially if you've trained this like a game) they are already not touching whatever you want them to stop touching, so you're ahead of them and then you can either steer them away or block access or start to explain the why if you need to, and this is much nicer and more pleasant of an interaction than one where you get annoyed with them and bark at them because they haven't instantly stopped.

Also, we know that praise/reward is way more effective in cementing habits than fear of punishment is, so if you want something like that your kids don't run in the road, the most effective way to do this is to remind them/ensure that they stop at the edge and hold hands and praise them for doing that. This is much more effective than waiting until they have already run in the road and then smacking them for it.

The other concept around not saying no is about being more accepting and positive in general. It can be really easy to say no all the time to requests to play, to have something, to do something that requires effort on the parent's part and if you make an effort to say yes more often to these things then you can end up having some really lovely experiences that you might not have had otherwise. (This won't be right for everyone. I think there are some parents who already say yes too much and should say no more, instead - it needs to be a balance.)

But anyway in both of these concepts it's not a total ban, it's more of something to try and do less and do the alternative more. If people are taking it to an extreme then that's really on them, but I don't think it's ever been recommended by any expert.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:28

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/08/2023 23:18

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows sorry didn't realize you had the diagnosis too so you will understand how it impacts you more than most. My understanding is that childhood trauma can be all sorts of things- it sound like despite having a loving mum you have had some tough times too and been let down by other adults in your life that should have kept you safe.

I'm sorry I didn't make that clear earlier. It may be true that my friend was abused, the reason that I was sceptical is she gave an example of herself as a 10 year old girl stepping on a little snail out of spite and her father stepped on her foot to show her what the email must have felt like . That definitely doesn't fall into the category of abuse because she was acting up (she was bored and wanted to upset her dad because he was making jokes about her being a bit chubby). Her foot was a bit bruised at the time but I'm not sure whether that would count ? Not being goady, I don't claim any expertise in this area, but yeah I was a bit like "that isn't real abuse, it didn't traumatise you, you know well you were being naughty and unkind"

AliceUK · 07/08/2023 23:26

My dad used to smack me when I was a child and did something bad. It was never aggressive, he had a level headed manner about it, never in a rage. It wasn’t even to hurt us, just to sting a little and teach us a lesson. He’s never been violent to anyone and is a well respected man, it’s just how he was raised and that was normal discipline. I haven’t carried that practice through to my children because I felt it is outdated and unfair, I know a stern word or a conversation would’ve worked just as well to discipline me as a child and are easier to forgive if the parent got it wrong and the child wasn’t the one who misbehaved and it was perhaps a sibling or someone else that should’ve had the punishment. I don’t think smacking is okay, I think it’s lazy discipline and avoids the real lessons that should be taught and it is cruel, but I don’t think people who use it are inherently bad people. It’s how they were brought up and no one has shown them that there are better ways that work. Yes there will be some violent people who use it as an aggressive reaction, but for so long it was the norm (and you could still get the cane in UK private schools until the 1990s) that people don’t even consider that there’s anything wrong with it, especially the older generation. In the age of technology where there is a wealth of information about it and how it can affect development and mental health etc, there’s no excuse for it in modern society, but I don’t think everyone who uses physical punishment is a violent person and I think it’s unreasonable to assume that they are, just my opinion

Swipe left for the next trending thread