Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To assume this about people who hit their kids...

218 replies

NotDisciplineJustAbuse · 07/08/2023 20:31

That they're probably not above hitting their wife/husband/partner etc or indeed their pets.

I don't buy into the 'discipline' crap as there are just far better ways of dealing with things. I'm sure smacking my husband every time he forgets to replace the loo roll could work but I was thankfully raised to use my big girl words and not rely on violence which will inevitably breed more violence.

OP posts:
ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 09:29

@SyncopatedRhythm Thank you, I'm going to have a read of that as I've never read any research on the topic before

SyncopatedRhythm · 08/08/2023 09:28

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 09:20

Actually do you have any research links or study names that I can read? It would be interesting

This Harvard study is interesting:

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 09:20

Actually do you have any research links or study names that I can read? It would be interesting

Nanny0gg · 08/08/2023 09:18

Simonjt · 07/08/2023 20:57

They’re violent bullying thugs, if they’re willing to hit a child they supposedly love, I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if they hit a partner or became violent after a few drinks on a night out.

Well I was smacked from time to time as a child.

My parents never hit each other or became violent.

It's just what was the norm then.

Luckily it isn't now.

Katiemag · 08/08/2023 09:15

Some posters are trying to differentiate between those who smack in anger and those who do so in a “controlled” way.

I find this really problematic.

I expect there are some well-meaning parents (certainly my parents) who have given a small smack occasionally when they were overwhelmed. They did it as they felt helpless and out of control and you don’t automatically become perfect at emotional regulation as soon as you have kids. It’s still not right or acceptable but they realise it wasn’t great parenting and likely feel a lot of guilt. I have a lot of empathy for people who have found themselves in that position as I think most of us, if we’re honest, have felt close at one point as parenting is so hard. I’ve never smacked and hope I never will but I understand the feelings of frustration and overwhelm.

Then there are those who choose to smack their kids as, despite the body of scientific studies all saying it wrecks a child’s self-esteem, they think they know better. They are proud of their parenting choices. I have no empathy for these parents at all.

I hope the rest of the UK follows Scotland and makes smacking illegal. It’s bound to happen - it’s just a question of time.

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 09:14

@IamAlso4eels We will have to agree to disagree. I firmly believe that my parents techniques contributed to me being the law abiding and non violent person that I am.

I understand what you say about research but it's not applicable in my case. And my case is the only one I can have an opinion on.

IamAlso4eels · 08/08/2023 09:02

You won't get an answer @SyncopatedRhythm because that right there is the hypocrisy at the heart of hitting children.

SyncopatedRhythm · 08/08/2023 09:00

Wenfy · 08/08/2023 02:44

The worst hitters tend to be the kids who have never been hit. DS regularly gets walloped by DN who is the same age and so understands never to do it as it hurts.

How old is your DS, though?

And are your DN and DS both spanked by parent(s), as discipline.

Because I'm interested in learning the response from the parent in my scenario. Is their child who spanked a sibling subsequently spanked by the parent for doing the exact same thing they deem fair and appropriate as a consequence to bad behaviour?

How do you answer child A retorting "But you spanked me when I threw a toy in your face. He threw a toy in my face, so I spanked him"?

Am genuinely curious about how it's all dealt with.

IamAlso4eels · 08/08/2023 08:59

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 08:27

@MillicentBystandr I wasn't a bad kid. Neither were my siblings and I feel a huge part of that was due to knowing the consequences

Statistically, boys who exhibit persistent aggressive behaviour and girls with high levels of anxiety are more likely to become involved with drugs as are those with low self-esteem and those who have experienced childhood trauma.

Research has shown that smacking is ineffective and harmful to child development. It has been linked to low self-esteem, aggression and anxiety. Research has also shown that children who are smacked are more statistically more likely to try cover up their mistakes (basically lie or avoid seeking adult support) to avoid punishment and are also far more likely to engage in risky behaviours such as drug taking.

None of the research backs up your assertion that being hit by your parents was a good thing and prevented you from experiencing these things, the research shows that actually your parents placed you at greater risk of them by smacking you. You turned out how you did despite the smacking, not because of it.

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:37

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:28

I'm sorry I didn't make that clear earlier. It may be true that my friend was abused, the reason that I was sceptical is she gave an example of herself as a 10 year old girl stepping on a little snail out of spite and her father stepped on her foot to show her what the email must have felt like . That definitely doesn't fall into the category of abuse because she was acting up (she was bored and wanted to upset her dad because he was making jokes about her being a bit chubby). Her foot was a bit bruised at the time but I'm not sure whether that would count ? Not being goady, I don't claim any expertise in this area, but yeah I was a bit like "that isn't real abuse, it didn't traumatise you, you know well you were being naughty and unkind"

Now you’ve posted the rest of the story, yes she was abused.
Jokes about being chubby are not jokes, her dad was being verbally abusive and she likely stepped on the snail because she wanted to stop her dads torrent of abusive “you’re so fat” comments. Then he steps on her foot hard enough to bruise it to “teach her a lesson” about dont harm a snail? (But it’s ok for him to harm her)

I can see that he drove her to distraction with verbal abush and then used her misbehaving as an excuse to then physically assault her while gaslighting her into thinking it was her fault he hurt her.

CandyLeBonBon · 08/08/2023 08:33

Christ 'experts' niw tell us that time out on a naughty step is traumatising.

Each generation will tell the former they're parenting wrong.

In the meantime kids will still be kids, they will still push boundaries and on occasion be little shits, and sometimes parents will lose their rag. Parents aren't perfect. It was acceptable in the 80s (to coin a song), and it doesn't mean it's right, it just means it was of it's time. Mine have had the occasion tap on the hand or bum, and many if my peers did similar. Would I do it now? No but this was 22 years ago and my views and outlooks have changed.

What is your preferred method op?

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 08:27

@MillicentBystandr I wasn't a bad kid. Neither were my siblings and I feel a huge part of that was due to knowing the consequences

JMSA · 08/08/2023 08:27

I was smacked as a child. My parents were good people (still are!) but they were so young when they became parents, and lacked the strategies or experience to deal with things in a different way.
My upbringing was working-class Glasgow in the 70s/80s. I mean, it was the absolute norm!

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:26

@LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows
So sorry what you went through ❤️

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:25

ChiPawPrint · 07/08/2023 23:01

It kept me and my siblings out of trouble. We knew the consequences if we did anything stupid like get involved in drugs, involved in crime, police etc.

You probably would not have pursued a junkie life of crime if you hadn’t been smacked by your parents. It’s sad you still believe that you were such a bad kid you needed to be smacked to not turn into a criminal.

Lambiriyani · 08/08/2023 08:23

I assume these people know how to discipline a child. Would be useful if the child is troublesome and has constant tantrums

ChiPawPrint · 08/08/2023 08:20

I disagree it's abuse. I don't feel like I was abused by my parents. I understand why they did it on those occasions and I have no resentment towards them for it at all.

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:20

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 22:34

personality disorder. Not her fault, nor her parents fault not anyone elses. It is what it is.

Some personality disorders do have a high correlation to childhood trauma though.

Whingebob · 08/08/2023 08:17

LaMaG · 07/08/2023 21:09

I think there are 2 distinct types - those that do it as a punishment because they believe it is a form of discipline and those that lash out when they lose their temper. The second category is by far the most dangerous IMO as they are not capable of control and could use excessive force, and are capable of hitting anyone who challenges them or upsets them. The first category are likely to use just enough force to stop the child repeating the action but not actually hurt or traumatise the child. It's not something I would do and I don't agree with it but all physical punishment isn't necessarily abuse IMO.

I actually agree with this. I'm from a culture that hits. I had a second type but I know many people who had the first type.

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:17

Giraffeinaplane · 07/08/2023 22:14

All the posts here saying that it's OK if it is a controlled and thought out manner - somehow that's even more disturbing. To actually sit and calmly decide that the most appropriate response to a behaviour is to hit a child is abhorrent to me. You could calmly think of a multitude of consequences that don't involve physical punishment, yet the best you can come up with is a warning and then violence.

Me too, having been on the receiving end of it as a child. It’s abuse and the parents who do it are just rationalising to make themselves feel better.

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:11

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/08/2023 21:37

I’m not justifying hitting- I’m pointing out that people keep saying hitting as if lashing out at a child’s face in anger is the same as a controlled decision in the 80s to smack a kid on the bum for bad behaviour they were forewarned about. I’m pointing out that times have changed, but to label everyone’s parents in the 80s who tapped them on the legs as abusive isn’t true- and life isn’t black and white.

You’re right lashing out in a moment of anger as a loss of control/unintentional harm is very different than the cold, calculated, intentional spanking or caning while being gaslight about it hurting them more than you, and how horrible of a child you are.

Both are horrendous, it’s just a different flavour of abuse.

LongDarkTeatime · 08/08/2023 08:09

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:34

I think if someone was disciplining an adult that would definitely be abusive ! Because your partner is your equal. I know in the old days wife beating was allowed but I am glad we know better now.

So, you feel it’s ok to hit someone below/smaller than you, but not someone equal to you?!!
Did/do you allow a senior to hit you at work if necessary? Of course you would otherwise that would be hypocritical.

Personally I believe all assaults are wrong.

MillicentBystandr · 08/08/2023 08:08

Rathouse · 07/08/2023 21:27

@MillicentBystandr that's kids for you though you basically are implying the same as OP. Its not a debate .. kids today are unruly, they probably hit their parents and they have no manners! The behaviour in schools today was unheard of in my primary school (90s). I think life is all about balance and its not as simple as what OP is saying.

No, not really implying what the OP has said, my posts are about the racist assertion that it’s people of nonBritish cultures that hit their kids, unless they’ve “been here a few generations”, when it is a fact that hitting kids is part of British culture. My generation and all the generations before me in Britain were hit often by parents, by teachers, and it was culturally acceptable.

Thank god we have moved on from those bad old days, but it’s wrong to say hitting kids hasn’t been part of British culture when it has and is still legal in England.

Giraffeinaplane · 08/08/2023 07:42

@Wenfy I completely disagree, my child has never been hit and it wouldn't cross his mind to lash out at anyone. Anecdotally, the kids I have seen who are most violent either have been hit themselves, or have older siblings who are violent in front of them, or to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread