Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MIL's obsession with girls is bloody irritating.

70 replies

DoneAndDusted123 · 07/08/2023 19:32

So I'm currently 7 months pregnant with my first baby and we know that we're expecting a boy. We're over the moon and very happy that he's growing strong in there and can't wait to meet him. But my MILs constant comments surrounding his sex are starting to really bug me

When we called her to announce the sex she interrupted the announcement to say "oh is it a little girl?!" really excitedly which made our news seem disappointing even though it's not. She then called up extended family and her friends to tell them the news in what was apparently a very "yeah they're having a boy, bummer" kind of way..

On top of this she always finds ways to work into the conversation how disappointed she initially was when her three kids all turned out to be boys and that the third time she fell into a huge depression. We were discussing baby names the other day and she just kept talking about all the names that she wanted to call her imaginary daughter's 🙄

I get that after three boys it's normal that she might have had a slight preference but her attitude is just irritating at best and malicious at worst. Sometimes she makes it seem like she's not even excited to meet her first grandchild...

She's also fed me the "a son is a son until he takes a wife, a daughter is for life" line a few times. I maintain that this saying is really bloody weird and stupid...

I don't know if I'm just being overly sensitive and should just let her share her thoughts but I'm sorely tempted to ask her to not come over anymore if she doesn't stop.

Thoughts?

OP posts:
ChubbyMorticia · 07/08/2023 22:17

My MIL first was mad I was pregnant again (joke was on her, we had three more kids after she announced that God told her we were only to adopt from now on).

But when she found out we were having a girl?

She expected to name our daughter. I was a single parent when I met my husband, so since I already had a daughter, it was only fair that she got to name the new baby, since she didn’t get a turn.

Nope. We already had a name, not discussing it, no committee needed. Our baby was not her chance to live out her mommy daughter fantasies.

Firm boundaries, @DoneAndDusted123 You’re going to need them.

bellamountain · 07/08/2023 22:13

Sounds like she needs to see a psychiatrist.

littlelionroars · 07/08/2023 22:13

I have this problem with my MIL. She had 2 boys, they decided not to have a third child.

The very first time I met her she spoke about how desperate she is for granddaughters. It was awkward then and has not stopped being awkward since.

Of course we've gone and had 2 boys. The first was exciting as he was the first grandchild, but I could feel the intense disappointment when we had our second.

She loves our boys very much, but her and my FIL put a lot of pressure on us to try for a girl even though we have told them that will not be happening. We live in a different country from my parents and in laws. We have zero support and we aren't willing to make the financial sacrifice for another child, we just want to give our boys the best life possible.

She has been here visiting this week and she has said multiple times how much she regrets not having a third child because the third definitely would have been a girl, who she has weirdly named Lauren.

She moans that her sons don't call her enough and that 'Lauren' would have called her to ask her how she's doing. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I think it's really unfair to my DH and DBIL, who are actually both in regular contact with her.

I'm not sure what the answer is here, but I find it really upsetting when she's going on about how her greatest disappointment in life is not having daughters/granddaughters, especially infront of my DS1 who is old enough to understand.

Lavender14 · 07/08/2023 22:02

Call her out. "MIL, the way you're talking you almost sound disappointed? " hopefully it will rein her in. She sounds like she'd be a nightmare if you had a girl. Your baby is not her substitute. And I hate that line about boys being your boy until they take a wife. My dh is much closer to his family than I am to mine.

continentallentil · 07/08/2023 22:02

Have you tried telling her to button it?

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 07/08/2023 22:02

DoneAndDusted123 · 07/08/2023 19:32

So I'm currently 7 months pregnant with my first baby and we know that we're expecting a boy. We're over the moon and very happy that he's growing strong in there and can't wait to meet him. But my MILs constant comments surrounding his sex are starting to really bug me

When we called her to announce the sex she interrupted the announcement to say "oh is it a little girl?!" really excitedly which made our news seem disappointing even though it's not. She then called up extended family and her friends to tell them the news in what was apparently a very "yeah they're having a boy, bummer" kind of way..

On top of this she always finds ways to work into the conversation how disappointed she initially was when her three kids all turned out to be boys and that the third time she fell into a huge depression. We were discussing baby names the other day and she just kept talking about all the names that she wanted to call her imaginary daughter's 🙄

I get that after three boys it's normal that she might have had a slight preference but her attitude is just irritating at best and malicious at worst. Sometimes she makes it seem like she's not even excited to meet her first grandchild...

She's also fed me the "a son is a son until he takes a wife, a daughter is for life" line a few times. I maintain that this saying is really bloody weird and stupid...

I don't know if I'm just being overly sensitive and should just let her share her thoughts but I'm sorely tempted to ask her to not come over anymore if she doesn't stop.

Thoughts?

So what? Of course, like any normal person, she'd rather a girl.
It can't be helped and she'll probably still like the kid even if not ideal.
A baby is a baby.

EnjoyingTheSilence · 07/08/2023 22:00

I would tell her that talking like that is a sure fire way to make her son, dil and gs back away from her

She needs to get a grip and grow up

happygolucky42 · 07/08/2023 21:57

Same here. 3 boys and baby who is a girl. we have so many clothes for the girl and the boys got some t-shirts and some shorts...once!

Bandyarsia · 07/08/2023 21:44

Mine is the opposite, only likes boys, girls are invisible.

Olika · 07/08/2023 21:35

pictoosh · 07/08/2023 19:37

Just tell her. "I know you wanted our baby to be a girl and you're disappointed that we're having a boy...but your comments are upsetting me now. I'm starting to feel like our baby is being held in a negative light before he's even here."

I would say this. She is being ridiculous. I would not take any of it from her.

Createausername1970 · 07/08/2023 21:23

I think I would say something like

Listen, MIL, I do get that you would have liked a daughter, but honestly, DH and I are really happy to be having a boy. Can you just be pleased for us? But actually it's making me a bit worried, because we would like future son to spend time with you and for you to be his nan, but what would happen if we had a daughter later, would you be all over her and ignore him? That would be a bit sad for him wouldn't it, if he lost out on his nan that he loved just because he had a sister?

Lay it on a bit thick and try to get her to see that she is potentially making it awkward for herself if she carries on the way she is as she might end up not seeing a long awaited granddaughter very often if she didn't treat all your children equally.

Waffle19 · 07/08/2023 21:19

Oh and my MIL literally quoted the whole ‘a son is a son until he takes a wife’ thing at the weekend (my DS is now 4). I just ignore any comments like that.

BungalowBuyer · 07/08/2023 21:19

lanthanum · 07/08/2023 19:40

If she's overbearing anyway, it might be a very good thing he's a boy, rather than the girl she's been waiting 30 years for.

My exMIL has several boys, wanted a girl every time, my DD was the first grandchild and she was obsessed, thankfully more DGDs arrived.

Waffle19 · 07/08/2023 21:18

Your MIL sounds like my MIL. Three sons, depressed after the third, desperate for a girl, loves talking girls names etc.

Fortunately my BIL & SIL have now had a daughter so she gets her girl fix from them, and I can honestly say she doesn’t love her granddaughter anymore or less than her grandson. I’m sure once your DS is born she will be besotted.

Marcipex · 07/08/2023 21:12

My mother who is nearly 86 will still tell people that she only wanted boys.
Young women I know all say they only want girls.
It’s sad either way.

Cloudsandrainnotsunandsand · 07/08/2023 21:07

Bil had 3 x ds's. We had 3 x ds's. Next dc was a dd. Mil was a bit ott...
The Grand Day arrived. I had a gift in their car..
It was a Tefal frying pan.

Don't hold out for any special treatment op!!
Oh and dh got me a sack of potatoes
.
Exh now

TheWayoftheLeaf · 07/08/2023 21:01

Well it's the sperm that decides ge sex. So it's her husband and son that are having so many boys and she can stop being rude.

Isitsixoclockalready · 07/08/2023 20:59

WhatDoIKnowAboutThis · 07/08/2023 20:28

Well, at least somebody wants girls 😅

Usually there is such a strong preference to boys.
Even on MN so many women!! so anti-baby-girls, makes me sad.

That's not the most helpful response ever.

ImperfectAlf · 07/08/2023 20:54

@JMSA
You're right about the fool!

I had two boys. So he thought he'd won 🙄.

I made him wait to meet them though, and he didn't repeat it the second time round.

We never got on

Jamtartforme · 07/08/2023 20:44

Ugh this really annoys me. Why try to bring down your special time because of her own unresolved issues? I think it’s time to find your mama bear and put her straight before this ridiculous attitude spoils your precious newborn time - next time she says something, tell her if your DS is such a disappointment to her then no doubt she won’t want to meet him. That’ll shut her up.

Lemonademoney · 07/08/2023 20:34

WhatDoIKnowAboutThis · 07/08/2023 20:28

Well, at least somebody wants girls 😅

Usually there is such a strong preference to boys.
Even on MN so many women!! so anti-baby-girls, makes me sad.

Gosh in my experience it’s literally the complete opposite! I couldn’t tell you of a single time I’ve been made to feel that there was a preference for boys ever… whereas most women I know happily admit they’d love to have a little girl

Clefable · 07/08/2023 20:28

My gran had three boys (she said she cried when they told her the last one was a boy 😬) and was desperate for a granddaughter. My dad did play a trick on her and tell her it was a boy on the phone when I was born and she was suitably pleased and happy the baby was healthy, but then he said actually it's a girl and the scream nearly blew his ear off.

She's a lovely, kind woman who helped my mum out to no end with childcare when I was a baby etc., so I think it was mostly just unresolved issues over her own situation and lack of a daughter that she really craved (she was one of three girls and they were all very close their entire lives). Hopefully when your lovely boy is here, MiL will be besotted with him. But in the meantime perhaps your husband can have a quiet word with her!

WhatDoIKnowAboutThis · 07/08/2023 20:28

Well, at least somebody wants girls 😅

Usually there is such a strong preference to boys.
Even on MN so many women!! so anti-baby-girls, makes me sad.

DelurkingLawyer · 07/08/2023 20:23

I might be a bit relieved that you’re not having a girl. If she is that obsessed and you were having a girl I reckon you’d have all sorts of problems with her wanting to have a second go at being mum with your daughter.

Cyclistmumgrandma · 07/08/2023 20:22

My first (and, so far, only) grandchild is a girl. Yes, I admit it, I was hoping for a grandson but certainly never told son and daughter-in-law that. She is now here and is delightful. Hopefully your MIL will feel the same once the baby is born. Until then, yes, tell her that her attitude is upsetting you.