Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this legal in employment?

117 replies

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 18:50

An hourly paid job that has a 'bonus rate' attached to the hourly rate. Paid monthly, each month you'll be paid the bonus rate as long as you aren't off sick. If you're sick or absent, you'll lose the bonus rate.
Aibu to think this is not legal? It's punishing people for being sick.
Ofc there are always people who take the piss and skive sometimes but we're human, sometimes we are unwell and it cannot be helped.
I find it outrageous and have never heard this before.

OP posts:
Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:10

Anyway, I guess it's just one of those things.

OP posts:
Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:09

I just don't believe in incentives around sickness. Normally if you have more than 3 days in 6 months or whatever it requires a meeting to address why. It's barely anything to begin with.

OP posts:
Mumof2teens79 · 07/08/2023 19:08

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:05

Having previously worked in care, there was another dodgy practice.
You had to ring the on call number to ring in sick, fair enough. However the on call team would then put you through to the management who would beg and persuade you to come in as they were 'really short staffed ".
It was manipulative and took advantage of people.

Trying to persuade you to come in is out of order....but In my workplace you have to call your manager that's the rule.

Testina · 07/08/2023 19:07

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:02

Lose one day's bonus, fair enough. Lose the entire month's bonus is too far. Fair enough it is legal, I certainly don't see it as ethical though.
Imagine that suddenly a family member passes away and you need a day off? Should you lose the entire month's then?

Where’s the incentive not to call in sick then? I’m sure if the employer found losing ons day bonus was incentive enough, they’d do that.

In many jobs, last minute sickness puts extra work onto those who are present. So perhaps the bonus is also inadvertently rewarding them for picking up the slack - for both genuine and fake colleague sickness.

I think that conscientious employees can be completely unrealistic about some people. We used to actually record in a book who had died when people needed time off for funerals, after a few conversations between shift managers revealed that one guy seemed to have more than the average number of grandparents! 🤣

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:07

True.
They should do something like 95%, I don't think striving for 100% perfection is fair or realistic.

OP posts:
Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:06

If we take a day or two off, we already lose pay with it being zero hours, as SSP is only paid after day 3 I think.

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 07/08/2023 19:06

I'd be thinking along the lines of indirect discrimination against disabled people and pregnant women.

Blossomtoes · 07/08/2023 19:05

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 18:56

Sometimes sickness can't be helped. I just think it's wrong to penalise people for it.

That isn’t what’s happening. It’s incentivising people for perfect attendance.

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:05

It came under 'absence' so honestly not sure if compassionate leave would be accepted. I think it's basically anything that isn't a pre booked holiday.

OP posts:
BiscuitsandPuffin · 07/08/2023 19:05

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:01

Well it is if you've been in every other single day with the intention to achieve this bonus. Then because of something out of your control you lose it.
I imagine a lot of these posters saying it's right do not have this in their own jobs.

Look I think it's a stupid policy and I'd hate for it to be pushed on me, but (and this is a big but) it's a bonus, you're not losing basic pay if you go off sick. I used to work in insurance sales which was basic pay plus commission. Basic pay was bare minimum, but that's what you counted on and budgeted for each month and you worked towards hitting your targets. If a sales person doesn't hit their targets, they don't lose their pay, they lose their bonus. This is just a different type of target. It's entitled to expect a bonus for not hitting a target, sorry.
Again, I think it's a stupid policy and your employers are clearly dicks.

Mumof2teens79 · 07/08/2023 19:05

In an hourly paid job, especially on a zero hours contract or similar I expect they get quite a lot of absence.
They specifically are not punishing sickness, they are rewarding commitment. Anyone who is genuinely sick once in a while will be fine, but it will really discourage those people who take a day every month.

RoseAndRose · 07/08/2023 19:05

donkra · 07/08/2023 18:54

Why wouldn't it be legal? As long as the regular rate is above minimum wage, an employer can choose to financially reward any behaviour they like unless said behaviour is itself illegal or the incentive discriminates against a protected class. They can choose to pay people with long hair bonuses if they want to.

You may not like it or think it's a good idea. But that's a long way from "illegal".

How does that work if the medical condition is covered by DDA?

ThrappleApple · 07/08/2023 19:05

I've worked in a factory with an attendance bonus. Friday hours were 8-2pm and sometimes people decided to start their weekend early and just get docked 5.5 hours. An issue when you're running a production line. The attendance bonus was to ensure people turned up for shifts five days a week. (It worked)

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:05

Having previously worked in care, there was another dodgy practice.
You had to ring the on call number to ring in sick, fair enough. However the on call team would then put you through to the management who would beg and persuade you to come in as they were 'really short staffed ".
It was manipulative and took advantage of people.

OP posts:
pumpkin1212 · 07/08/2023 19:04

I used to get an attendance bonus. My train was late one day, I was late by about 5 mins and that's it, no bonus that month. It is what it is.

Beetlekiwi · 07/08/2023 19:04

Family member passing would be compassionate leave - not sickness. That’s how it works at my company.

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:03

That's a good point.
And I have never been a fan of 100% absence incentives in school.
I hate this whole shaming and stigma around being off sick.

OP posts:
GoodChat · 07/08/2023 19:03

What happens if you're on annual leave?

Testina · 07/08/2023 19:03

In the 90s I worked in HR for a global firm which introduced “HAP” Holiday Attendance Payment. If you had no more than 5 sick days in a year, you were given 2 days pay as a “bonus” to spend on holiday. (or wherever you wanted, that was just the name)

The employees were all for it, though the union reps complained it was penalising sick people. The employees told the reps to STFU when the management said, “OK, too controversial - we’ll ditch it.” It was certainly legal then, though I appreciate that’s years ago!

I was very junior in HR at the time and mostly compiling and interpreting data. So I was the one doing all the graphs to show that sickness peaked the month before the end of the “sickness absence procedure” year re-set. And no, it’s not because the end of the year was flu season - the year varied between departments. Half the managers came from the shop floor and everyone had been part of the, “I’ve got 4 more sick days to use” conversations.

Rewarding attendance in the workplace isn’t penalising people who are sick. They’re still getting their contracted basic plus (rightly) getting sick pay and keeping their jobs. They’re not losing anything they signed up for.

In 40 years working so far, I’ve come across far more take the piss sick time than genuine.

GoodChat · 07/08/2023 19:02

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:01

Well it is if you've been in every other single day with the intention to achieve this bonus. Then because of something out of your control you lose it.
I imagine a lot of these posters saying it's right do not have this in their own jobs.

To be fair it would encourage me to take longer off if I was genuinely ill on the first day because I'd not get the bonus anyway.

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:02

Lose one day's bonus, fair enough. Lose the entire month's bonus is too far. Fair enough it is legal, I certainly don't see it as ethical though.
Imagine that suddenly a family member passes away and you need a day off? Should you lose the entire month's then?

OP posts:
Youcancallmeirrelevant · 07/08/2023 19:02

You haven't lost anything as its a bonus. Most people are only ill enough to call i sick a few times a year max, so out of 12 months everyone ahould be able to get 8 or 9 months of the payments

GoodChat · 07/08/2023 19:01

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:00

The work is looking after sick people as a matter of fact. So suggesting people need to come in and potentially infect vulnerable people because they will lose over £100 that month if they don't.

They wont lose it, though. They'll just gain it if they do choose to go in.

What's the pay like as standard? Crap?

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 07/08/2023 19:01

No maybe not, but unfortunately that’s the system

Isthebusstillrunning · 07/08/2023 19:01

Well it is if you've been in every other single day with the intention to achieve this bonus. Then because of something out of your control you lose it.
I imagine a lot of these posters saying it's right do not have this in their own jobs.

OP posts: