Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be cheesed off with shrieking kids on holiday?

642 replies

AnnoyedOnHoliday · 07/08/2023 14:26

Recently my DP took me on an amazing surprise holiday for my birthday a few weeks ago, 4 nights in a beautiful 5 star hotel - definitely a big treat and really outside of our normal budget so obviously wanted to enjoy it to the absolutely maximum. Hotel was absolutely beautiful and facilities/staff were pretty faultless.

I don't want to say it was ruined but definitely marred by the amount of unruly children. The main pool of the hotel had two pool - a smaller shallow one for kids and another larger one bit more suitable for being able to get a proper swim in. Everyday the main pool as well as the kids one was taken over by kids shrieking in rubber rings, splashing and jumping as well as just being smack bang in the centre of the pool so hard to swim. The area was basically taken over by the constant noise of shouting, screaming, crying and small children sprinting into your sun lounger every two seconds. I found it really hard to concentrate on unwinding and couldn't concentrate on reading my book as so noisy and chaotic and obviously found using the pool for swimming quite annoying also.

The hotel was very much in the countryside so we ate the really great hotel restaurant quite a few breakfasts, lunches and 2 dinners. Every single time, early in the morning, late at night children were sprinting up and down the dining room, running into waiters, more of that shrieking again. More examples but you get the idea.

It seemed to be happening in many different families and every single time I'd look over and they'd be just ignoring their kids or encouraging them to run around so they could have drinks/eat their meal without having to deal with them and 9 times out of 10, I'd never see them being reprimanded for being disruptive.

I get that looking after small children is full on and stressful (I'm really not talking about kids crying/distressed as I know that cannot be helped - referencing the running around shrieking behaviour) but AIBU to think to think it's a bit out of order to just zone out and let everyone have their meals and relaxing time ruined because you're in 'holiday mode' and want some time off parenting?

It just felt a bit jarring that we'd paid to be on holiday too and were basically having to endure everyone else kids.

OP posts:
Canisaysomething · 07/08/2023 17:54

There are plenty of 5 star hotels that restrict children's use of a pool to certain set hours for exactly this and these are far more common than fully child friendly 5 star hotels. You made the wrong booking. It would be like me booking a dog friendly hotel then complaining about the dogs.

Livelovebehappy · 07/08/2023 17:51

Yep. Mistake made going in school holidays. It shouldn’t be the case that people have to avoid school hols to avoid other peoples feral children, but unfortunately that’s the reality these days. I absolutely do not go anywhere on holiday during school holidays, and even avoid weekends too by going on mid week short breaks. I used to challenge parents who allowed their children to behave badly round other people, ie crawling under tables when I was eating a meal, screaming next to me when trying to have conversations, but you can’t argue with stupid unfortunately, and I just can no longer be arsed with trying to reason with people who don’t care……

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:50

There are plenty of boutique hotels and luxury hotels that are adults only for good reason.

Exactly

PastelFlowerJelly · 07/08/2023 17:49

YANBU but you must research the hotel next time. If it's advertising family friendly features, kids pool/entertainment then avoid it like the plague. We just came back from a 5* resort that's geared towards families. Had a fantastic time but I felt very sorry for the people without kids there. Every mealtime was full of shrieking kids, ipad and iphone videos blaring on tables, every pool taken over by pre-teens all day long. It's the reality of holidaying with kids. Splashing in pools or running around sun loungers is not forbidden so there's no reason for parents to forbid their kids to do so. A single child running or shouting isn't much of an issue but it's the multiplier factor that makes it unbearable.

There are plenty of boutique hotels and luxury hotels that are adults only for good reason.

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:49

*Family friendly" doesn't mean that manners and consideration for others can be dropped.

The pool is for the enjoyment of everyone; doing something so noisily that it infringes on others' enjoyment is rude an obnoxious. There is no automatic right for kids to shriek and scream, nor any need for it.**

There would be different noise expectations at different types of pool and if the higher percentage of customers are kids it will be noisier since the pool is for the enjoyment of everyone.

Be realistic and go to the type that suits you

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:48

*Family friendly" doesn't mean that manners and consideration for others can be dropped.

The pool is for the enjoyment of everyone; doing something so noisily that it infringes on others' enjoyment is rude an obnoxious. There is no automatic right for kids to shriek and scream, nor any need for it.*

There would be different noise expectations at different types of pool and if the higher percentage of customers are kids it will be noisier since the pool is for the enjoyment of everyone.

Be realistic and go to the type that suits you.

user1477391263 · 07/08/2023 17:46

Does anyone else feel like there has been a significant uptick in “moaning about children” posts since Mumsnet started the Childfree section?

I think it was always likely that this was going to happen. If you create a reason for childfree-by-choice people to hang around Mumsnet, it’s inevitable that they’re going to start threads/post on threads on other parts of the site as well, which will inevitably cause a shift in tone and in the balance of views.

As for the original post? Children shouldn’t be allowed to scream or run around in restaurants. However, in a swimming pool, it’s kind of what they do. Book an adults-only hotel in future if it bothers you.

TheaBrandt · 07/08/2023 17:46

Also the majority of children are fine it’s the LOUD families that are the true horror.

We had a shared pool for a few days last summer 3 families their kids quietly pootling and playing - absolutely fine. Then the LOUD family arrive and the place becomes intolerable.

We were a quiet family when ours were young and now our teens are pretty intolerant themselves of rackety kids. We’re self catering with our own pool this year.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/08/2023 17:45

ladeluge · 07/08/2023 17:40

Hotels should consider having "child and adult" pool time, and an "adult only" pool time, at various times during the day.

Also, I think there should be a sectioned off part of the restaurant for parents and kids at breakfast, lunch and dinner. Adults with no kids in one part, adults + kids in the other. Let the families drive each other mad, but leave the grown ups w/o kids on their own I say! At least your ears and legs will be safe.

Anyone who wants an adult break, should NEVER go in the six week long seventh circle of hell that is the school holidays. If it's not possible to go either side of that, then there are other options.

No hotel is safe from kids in the holidays.

Agree about the segregated times and areas. Should apply to planes as well.

Upwiththelark76 · 07/08/2023 17:44

Adults only every time

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/08/2023 17:44

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:07

That's a whole different question. Presumably OP hasn't gone to relax in a playground for her birthday break.

No she was at the pool in a family friendly hotel during the school holidays.

😂😂🤦‍♀️

"Family friendly" doesn't mean that manners and consideration for others can be dropped.

The pool is for the enjoyment of everyone; doing something so noisily that it infringes on others' enjoyment is rude an obnoxious. There is no automatic right for kids to shriek and scream, nor any need for it.

SweetcornFritter · 07/08/2023 17:44

You are not being unreasonable OP. There are too many rude, selfish, entitled cunts with children, dogs, power tools, sound systems, etc that absolutely give no fucks whatsoever about disturbing anyone else’s peace.

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:41

*I find all the 'children behave much worse now and I know because I was so much better as a child!' posts so funny. If you asked any if the children that annoyed OP if they were allowed to make lots of noise and disturb others they'd say of course not. They would assure you that their parents tell them off lots - in fact, they're very unfair and tell them off when they're doing nothing wrong at all! - and that they don't shout and scream. Children are not reliable witnesses, and 30+ years doesn't make the memory sharper either.

As for the 'children have started making some new noise that was unknown until recently' - don't be so ridiculous, children haven't started shrieking in a new pitch, you're just getting old. It's OK, it happens to everyone.*

👍🏻 Downfall of Society generally.

ladeluge · 07/08/2023 17:40

Hotels should consider having "child and adult" pool time, and an "adult only" pool time, at various times during the day.

Also, I think there should be a sectioned off part of the restaurant for parents and kids at breakfast, lunch and dinner. Adults with no kids in one part, adults + kids in the other. Let the families drive each other mad, but leave the grown ups w/o kids on their own I say! At least your ears and legs will be safe.

Anyone who wants an adult break, should NEVER go in the six week long seventh circle of hell that is the school holidays. If it's not possible to go either side of that, then there are other options.

No hotel is safe from kids in the holidays.

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:38

Nope, I just think children shouldn't shriek and be unruly in public and annoy others who have a right to be there too, no matter where it is. If you find that sarky and patronising then that's your problem.

You know I was talking about your rude questions earlier. But I expect manners apply to other people.

Presumably everyone was a paying guest and had a right to be there. No one was trespassing.

Kids around pools behave a certain way. And not in a "calm and spa like" way. High Summer brings the kids.

The OP was in the wrong hotel for her needs.

Conkersinautumn · 07/08/2023 17:36

Maybe don't hang around the one thing these tourist traps have for kids to do. I don't stay in hotels as I don't like crowded spaces, I don't like having to constantly pay attention to the demands of unconnected adults that can't figure out to avoid school holidays or work an earplug either. Children get downtime too. Sorry you don't like that their parents decided to "splash out" on the same resort as you. If you need your space to be without sections of society then look for that next time. Going to villas etc works best for me, but in a hotel it's going to be busy, loud and you've got to expect that.

Bandyarsia · 07/08/2023 17:35

Hardbackwriter · 07/08/2023 17:33

I find all the 'children behave much worse now and I know because I was so much better as a child!' posts so funny. If you asked any if the children that annoyed OP if they were allowed to make lots of noise and disturb others they'd say of course not. They would assure you that their parents tell them off lots - in fact, they're very unfair and tell them off when they're doing nothing wrong at all! - and that they don't shout and scream. Children are not reliable witnesses, and 30+ years doesn't make the memory sharper either.

As for the 'children have started making some new noise that was unknown until recently' - don't be so ridiculous, children haven't started shrieking in a new pitch, you're just getting old. It's OK, it happens to everyone.

Absolutely ridiculous post.

Hardbackwriter · 07/08/2023 17:33

I find all the 'children behave much worse now and I know because I was so much better as a child!' posts so funny. If you asked any if the children that annoyed OP if they were allowed to make lots of noise and disturb others they'd say of course not. They would assure you that their parents tell them off lots - in fact, they're very unfair and tell them off when they're doing nothing wrong at all! - and that they don't shout and scream. Children are not reliable witnesses, and 30+ years doesn't make the memory sharper either.

As for the 'children have started making some new noise that was unknown until recently' - don't be so ridiculous, children haven't started shrieking in a new pitch, you're just getting old. It's OK, it happens to everyone.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 07/08/2023 17:32

Nope, I just think children shouldn't shriek and be unruly in public and annoy others who have a right to be there too, no matter where it is. If you find that sarky and patronising then that's your problem.

Brefugee · 07/08/2023 17:32

dramoy · 07/08/2023 14:33

I think it's to be expected during school holidays

children running round restaurants and shrieking, and taking over a whole pool is not to be expected at any time. I never let my children behave like that and neither did any of my friends.

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:29

I'm more considerate of others than you appear to be.

No , you have no idea how considerate I am or not.

And actually the way you've spoken on here, and OP, snarky , sarcastic, and patronising doesn't really highlight your social skills very much.

I don't like badly behaved kids either.

But I think if there's one place you're going to get noisy, running, shouting, splashing, kids is around a pool in July. And I'm TOTALLY good with that.

OP was after a calm , spa like atmosphere.

You do the calculations.

OhwhyOY · 07/08/2023 17:27

Hmmm I am torn between YANBU and YABU. If you want a nice quiet luxurious stay (which I fully empathise with, having once stayed in a hotel for a spa package where they had kids swimming lessons in the pool all day!) then book an adults only hotel or go midweek during term time. That said parents should be controlling their kids and it drives me mad when they don't. But, easier said than done with very young ones sometimes. No matter how much we try to teach our two year old about 'inside voice' she will occasionally start yelling!

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 07/08/2023 17:23

I'm more considerate of others than you appear to be.

sunglassesonthetable · 07/08/2023 17:22

*It wasn't about the OP's hotel choice, it's about the unacceptable behaviour of children in public, family friendly venue or otherwise.

Let me guess, I bet you let your children watch phones/tablets with the sound up in public*

No I don't agree. I think it's about hotel choices.

And let me guess, you're generally a rude person?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 07/08/2023 17:21

It wasn't about the OP's hotel choice, it's about the unacceptable behaviour of children in public, family friendly venue or otherwise.

Let me guess, I bet you let your children watch phones/tablets with the sound up in public?