Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To literally BEG women to set themselves up, financially?

782 replies

CallieRedux · 07/08/2023 14:14

Typed out a long post full of personal details, then deleted, but, honestly, the specifics don't matter. What DOES matter is that you save every tiny bit you can, because having FUCK YOU money is - by far - the most important thing you can do for yourself.

It's saved me from everything from wrong relationships, shit jobs, from natural disasters... I have both made lots of money, and not, but having savings, and the ability to walk away is having POWER, and the best "self care" a woman can have.

Shit happens. Things change. Even to you. Yes, you can save - even a little - when you are poor.

Do it. Please.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
OlympicProcrastinator · 07/08/2023 16:30

I agree. I know lots of people think a marriage is about sharing finances but fuck that. We both pay half the bills and share food / kids costs but he’s shit with money and I save. I am building my career and enjoy spending my money on whatever the hell I like. If he runs up a credit card that’s on him. No joint account, not my problem. And if I ever needed to leave I have my savings, my account, nobody else has access too. Nobody can fuck me over.

That said, we are very happy and I love him to bits but financial independence helps me sleep at night.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 16:28

@Lillygolightly

I agree with you.

However, I don't think it has to be a Fuck Off fund, per se.

My siblings are all well off & happily married. They all approach money differently.

What's needed is women to
a) understand 🚩 (don't minimise them - which I did)
b) see childcare as a shared cost not 'oh it's not worth it for me to work'
c) have honest discussions about money before marriage, and keep checking both are on the same page, regarding priorities, debt & savings. (I have a SIL who is a high earner. She is brutal with money. Before marriage she & DB split up about it. Ultimately they got back together & have a system. They are both high earners, but he earns more. She has access to a certain amount of money freely. He manages most of the rest. She can pretty much have anything she wants but he is in control basically. They agreed she would save. Her salary & savings are hers. I don't think I could live like that. However, it works for them & the point is - they addressed it head on & before marriage)

The reality is women will spend more time having & caring for DC. This will almost certainly impact their career & earning potential, at least for a time.

Women need to be cognisant of this & ideally both people need to plan for & around this. But certainly women do.

JorisBonson · 07/08/2023 16:28

parliamoglesga · 07/08/2023 14:57

Absolutely yes to this.

not popular on MN but my husband and I only pay the bills jointly and have our own bank accounts. We half the shopping and expenses. Been married for 10 years and it works so don’t @ me 😂

i have my own savings and investments and I know I can support myself if the marriage ends.

Same here. I wouldn't give up that financial freedom for anything. I don't understand why so many women think it should all be joint just because of marriage etc.

Eastie77Returns · 07/08/2023 16:26

Combusting · 07/08/2023 15:50

The biggest bizareness i hear on MN is -

"But my earnings would be wiped out by the nursery fees - so "we" decided it was best for me to stay home as I earn so little anyway - it's what made sense for us xxx"

Hang on.

  1. First - you don't work just to see how many pennies are left after childcare during nursery years. You work for you. Your pension, Your independence. Your career trajectory. Your skills.
  2. Second - "they are only ickle for only so long xxx" works for dad too. Yet, remarkably - they appear to only stay ickle for so long for mums....because of the age old "but he earns 5x more than me" ..so..
  3. We as a society need to genuinely be asking what's happening here, where mums are magically seemingly ending up earning 5x less anyway, than dads. WHat's happening at school, at GCSE and A level subject choices, further ed and skills choices - that we have a glut of people (apparently) - where men make 5x more money than the women they are partnered with.

I cant ever be bothered to respond to the "but that's what WE decided for US, because my wages would wipe out with nursery/they are only ickle for so long" because of the sheer lack of foresight involved.

Yep. See and hear this ALL the time and I genuinely don’t get it. Why do so many women fall for this nonsense?! Giving up work because their wages won’t cover childcare costs. I mean WTAF.

One friend explained to me that her ‘D’H felt it was better for to become a SAHM as her £36k would barely cover nursery fees. So she gave up a job she loves and is at home bored witless with 2 young DC.

Meanwhile he earns £175k but “pays the bills and the mortgage” so it’s fair. He is building up a pension, his career and has a wad of disposable income at the end of the month. None of which has to be spent on childcare because his money is too precious for that.

The sad thing is my friend feels grateful. After all he gives her shopping money each month and reminds her that the kids are only young once. I truly despair.

Marwoodsbigbreak · 07/08/2023 16:26

saltrocking · 07/08/2023 15:35

I opened an account in my sons name and kept it hidden

I did the same. It had less than £2k in it, but when the shit hit the fan, I really was so grateful for it.

Several years later I had £20k to fall back on when I could no longer teach (burnout) and spent a year doing freelance lecturing. Without that money I wouldn’t have been able to leave a job that was likely to kill me.

Both my DC save as well as they can given COL crisis.

peachgreen · 07/08/2023 16:25

Yup. Even if you know your partner would never screw you over. My DH was the most wonderful man and would never have left me/cheated etc but he DID die, and not knowing if I could keep a roof over my daughter's head was terrifying. I will never own a house again that I can't afford on my own.

RudsyFarmer · 07/08/2023 16:25

When women have children they make themselves on incredibly vulnerable. So my advice is don’t have children with men you hardly know or those who have proved themselves untrustworthy.

Dashel · 07/08/2023 16:25

To have ISAs, pensions or premium bonds, the money has to be in your single name and I have those.

My DH is kind and caring and has shown no sign of cruelty, abuse or temper or anything other than being a bit too long on his work laptop occasionally, but if he snaps I have money in there and enough in my current account to get me out of the house and to safety without worrying. I would never tell him it’s a safety net for me as I think he would be upset I felt I needed it.

It might be part of the marital pot but he has the same and tbh if I needed to get out of there I would worry about it later anyway.

Everyone should have a running away fund male or female as you just don’t know when you need to get away

Octosaurus · 07/08/2023 16:24

Amen

ScribblingPixie · 07/08/2023 16:21

In my first job, when I was very young and ditsy, two women once sat me down and told me that my priority should be to create lifelong security for myself so that I could be completely independent. They were so earnest and insistent that I took it 100 per cent on board. They'll never know that what they did for me.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 16:20

Usernamen · 07/08/2023 15:58

I completely agree with you but this is not a popular view on MN.

IRL, I have never come across any woman who has abandoned her career and made herself financially dependent on a man after having children, but on MN this seems to be very common. Even in 2023. It has been quite the eye opener.

I have. Lots of them. And if they divorced (and some have), they would get a decent level of maintenance (and some have). These are all high earners.

BUT

That's entirely based on the exH being a decent person & father.

SOME ARE NOT. Abusive men will use this as a tool to control the exW.

I was not financially dependent on my exH. But I kept paying off his debts & was left with nothing spare. Then he left and has paid sporadic maintenance ever since. I'm in Ireland so no CMS etc. Court proceedings are protracted & nightmarish.

Essentially I did leave myself in a position of dependency, albeit unintentionally.

Hankunamatata · 07/08/2023 16:20

I think there's nothing wrong with being a sahp if that's what you want but I agree if possible to have savings and private pension - sadly not everyone's budget stretches to that

BarryistheNewHarry · 07/08/2023 16:19

parliamoglesga · 07/08/2023 14:57

Absolutely yes to this.

not popular on MN but my husband and I only pay the bills jointly and have our own bank accounts. We half the shopping and expenses. Been married for 10 years and it works so don’t @ me 😂

i have my own savings and investments and I know I can support myself if the marriage ends.

We are the same. We have a joint account and both contribute to that which pays mortgage/bills/food/petrol etc but then we have our own money.

I have always been self sufficient. However, one good thing is my husband is incredibly canny with money and he has actually invested my pension for me and made me an awful lot more than I could have done myself. He has also set up other investments for me (in my name only) so my financial future is secure. I will always be very grateful for him in that respect.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 07/08/2023 16:16

I honestly blame romance movies, and a lack of education on the reality of divorce.

Even I fucking fell into it - I went freelance, kept earning, but 'we prioritised his career' - with the result that post-split, I'm still the one doing all the childcare, and earning pretty well (burning myself out to do so), and he's swanning off earning 10 times what I do - because I let him take no responsibility for our children. I could be in his position if I'd acted like the bastard he is (well, maybe not, because a lot of it has involved male bonding that I wouldn't be invited to)

And if you can't afford a Fuck Off fund, at least don't work against yourself by giving up your job. There may not be spare money, but at least you're keeping your hand in and maintaining the ability to earn money - getting back into work is so much harder than upping your hours at your existing job.

Jk987 · 07/08/2023 16:16

OhComeOnFFS · 07/08/2023 14:59

I agree with you. I'm also horrified by the number of women here who have children without getting married and then end up so vulnerable, often without a pension or an income.

You can be more vulnerable by being married if you are the higher earned or if you have more assets. Being married is not by default the best thing.

Usernamen · 07/08/2023 16:16

Combusting · 07/08/2023 15:50

The biggest bizareness i hear on MN is -

"But my earnings would be wiped out by the nursery fees - so "we" decided it was best for me to stay home as I earn so little anyway - it's what made sense for us xxx"

Hang on.

  1. First - you don't work just to see how many pennies are left after childcare during nursery years. You work for you. Your pension, Your independence. Your career trajectory. Your skills.
  2. Second - "they are only ickle for only so long xxx" works for dad too. Yet, remarkably - they appear to only stay ickle for so long for mums....because of the age old "but he earns 5x more than me" ..so..
  3. We as a society need to genuinely be asking what's happening here, where mums are magically seemingly ending up earning 5x less anyway, than dads. WHat's happening at school, at GCSE and A level subject choices, further ed and skills choices - that we have a glut of people (apparently) - where men make 5x more money than the women they are partnered with.

I cant ever be bothered to respond to the "but that's what WE decided for US, because my wages would wipe out with nursery/they are only ickle for so long" because of the sheer lack of foresight involved.

One of the best posts on MN.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 16:16

@SerafinasGoose

A tough post but huge amounts of wisdom there.

With regard to working, the only thing that has saved me in the shitshow the last decade has been for me is that I was a well-educated professional. Prior to my marriage ending, I ( as had H) been severely affected by the recession, losing an very good job while pregnant with DC2. So many people said - oh take the time & stay home with the 2 DC. Thank God I didn't listen.

Financially I made little, as I was working contract roles for not great money but they were professionally relevant & when the marriage ended, I could work. I still had to do less than ideal jobs as I'd 3 v small DC, and no help. I lost money each summer as I paid more in childcare than I earned so had to borrow to live.

At the moment, finances are a mess. Protracted & adversarial divorce proceedings have cost so much. But I've a good job & ultimately have the potential to earn more / take on different roles when DC are older. And it kept me sane, a little.

SAHM really really need to think what they'd do financially & personally if their marriage ended.

Eastie77Returns · 07/08/2023 16:15

EllenVannen · 07/08/2023 15:08

This is just sound common sense.

So many women on MN seem to be trapped with crappy men in bad relationships that they can't afford to leave.

So, get skilled-up ladies and learn to be financially independent and self-supporting - your increased self-respect will pay you back in spades.

I would also say to any women considering motherhood - do not even consider having a child unless you are prepared emotionally, financially, physically and psychologically to bring that child up alone.

100% agree and I’ll be instilling this in DD when she’s older. IMO any woman who has a child must be prepared for the possibility that that she might be left to raise him/her alone. Ideally it’s better to have a child when you have a secure, independent financial footing.

However I’ve seen threads on MN where this view is criticised because it suggests “poor people are not allowed to have children”

Apparently the desire to have a child supersedes the rights of that child to not live in abject poverty.

MamaGhina · 07/08/2023 16:15

Learnt this the hard way. Never again and I’ll make sure my DC always have one too.

Testina · 07/08/2023 16:14

overitunderit · 07/08/2023 15:14

I agree with this but I'm also amazed by how many people think having personal savings in a marriage is your own money. If you're married, your savings are marital assets (other than in a small number of limited cases). If your husband was saving money on the side which he then hid from you on divorce you might be a bit irritated. Having said that I do think it's helpful to have some savings in case, as you say, you need to escape for eg DV reasons.

“Marital assets” only comes into play the minute your Consent Order is sealed and you have a courts instructions on when to act on it.

Accessing your personal money within a marriage to put a deposit down and pay moving costs into another home can happen a year before you get anywhere near that point, just following pretty average divorce timelines.

Or spending it keeping the marital home mortgage / rent paid and kids fed after he fucks off.

Lakeyloo · 07/08/2023 16:14

Once bitten.
I would NEVER put all of my money into a joint account again. Joint account for bills, emergencies and little extras each month. The rest goes into our own accounts. I don't want to be answerable to anyone about how I spend or save my money and I don't want DP to be either. Appreciate everyone is different but It's worked for us for the last 25 years.
No one ever goes into a long term relationship or marriage thinking its going to go wrong.......

Jackydaytona · 07/08/2023 16:12

If you are going to be sahp or carer, then marriage is a must. It is a legal commitment and gives certain protections.

Testina · 07/08/2023 16:11

coxesorangepippin · 07/08/2023 15:21

Totally agree

Where are the best hiding places for money if you are married?

In plain sight. You should never to hide money in a good marriage, you should have individually accessed money that neither of you have to bat an eyelid at. If you’re in an abusive relationship and having to hide the money you’re squirrelling away to enable you to leave (and go for it on that) you didn’t follow the OP’s advice not to get into that situation in the first place. No-one knows if their relationship will turn abusive. So don’t lose access to the money / your earning power in the first place.

EllenVannen · 07/08/2023 16:10

Combusting · 07/08/2023 15:50

The biggest bizareness i hear on MN is -

"But my earnings would be wiped out by the nursery fees - so "we" decided it was best for me to stay home as I earn so little anyway - it's what made sense for us xxx"

Hang on.

  1. First - you don't work just to see how many pennies are left after childcare during nursery years. You work for you. Your pension, Your independence. Your career trajectory. Your skills.
  2. Second - "they are only ickle for only so long xxx" works for dad too. Yet, remarkably - they appear to only stay ickle for so long for mums....because of the age old "but he earns 5x more than me" ..so..
  3. We as a society need to genuinely be asking what's happening here, where mums are magically seemingly ending up earning 5x less anyway, than dads. WHat's happening at school, at GCSE and A level subject choices, further ed and skills choices - that we have a glut of people (apparently) - where men make 5x more money than the women they are partnered with.

I cant ever be bothered to respond to the "but that's what WE decided for US, because my wages would wipe out with nursery/they are only ickle for so long" because of the sheer lack of foresight involved.

This ^ will big brass balls on.

No 3 is a real puzzler.

I hope we can have some info from those in education but in the meantime from the Guardian -

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/10/a-level-results-top-5-data-takeaways#:~:text=4%20The%20gender%20gap%20is%20at%20its%20highest%20level%20in%20a%20decade&text=In%20fact%2C%20girls%20attained%20higher,outperformed%20males%20in%20every%20subject.

A-level data shows record grades and biggest gender gap in a decade

Number of students reaching A or A* doubles in 12 subjects since 2019 and girls beat boys in top maths grades

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/10/a-level-results-top-5-data-takeaways#:~:text=4%20The%20gender%20gap%20is%20at%20its%20highest%20level%20in%20a%20decade&text=In%20fact%2C%20girls%20attained%20higher,outperformed%20males%20in%20every%20subject.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 16:08

overitunderit · 07/08/2023 15:14

I agree with this but I'm also amazed by how many people think having personal savings in a marriage is your own money. If you're married, your savings are marital assets (other than in a small number of limited cases). If your husband was saving money on the side which he then hid from you on divorce you might be a bit irritated. Having said that I do think it's helpful to have some savings in case, as you say, you need to escape for eg DV reasons.

This is true.

However, if you separate, having a job, and access to reserve money, allows you to make decisions quickly eg get legal advice, pay essential bills, avoid debt, keep on top of house repairs.

In the final reckoning, yes, your savings will be assessed & it's a bitter pill that they may be 'lost' to you BUT you will still likely be in a better financial & personal situation, with one less avenue of stress, than if you hadn't got this option.

Also it avoids you having to maybe go cap in hand to eg parents when that might be difficult (if you are even lucky enough to have that option).