Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To literally BEG women to set themselves up, financially?

782 replies

CallieRedux · 07/08/2023 14:14

Typed out a long post full of personal details, then deleted, but, honestly, the specifics don't matter. What DOES matter is that you save every tiny bit you can, because having FUCK YOU money is - by far - the most important thing you can do for yourself.

It's saved me from everything from wrong relationships, shit jobs, from natural disasters... I have both made lots of money, and not, but having savings, and the ability to walk away is having POWER, and the best "self care" a woman can have.

Shit happens. Things change. Even to you. Yes, you can save - even a little - when you are poor.

Do it. Please.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Thepeopleversuswork · 07/08/2023 17:31

@SerafinasGoose

The numerous, bitterly contested SAHM vs. WOHM threads on this site are testimony to this issue. I have no reason to care how other women structure their paid and domestic labour and I dont' care, but the deeply personal commentary surrounding this issue is something else. The objections run pretty much along the lines of: 'SAHMs are 'hated' on MN '. No more than other random groups of people: MiLs, DiLs, etc. 'They are undervalued by society'. What's their value to me? They can knock themselves out living exactly as they please and I'll offer no judgement or comment: just don't expect me to endorse your choices. I DGAF. 'Women should support other women's choices'. Why? Women owe no one 'support' for their decisions on the basis of shared XX chromosomes. Especially when they happen to think those decisions are really stupid.

Brilliant post and well done for saying it.

I also couldn't give a tinker's cuss how people structure their households/domestic labour and I understand that many women on both sides of this dilemma don't have much choice and have to deal with the hand they are dealt. And I do think, in the spirit of fairness, that there is a strand of spitefulness sometimes directed at SAHMs which is not always constructive.

But the oft-repeated idea that SAHMs are "undervalued" by society and should be valued more makes me cringe with embarrassment.

Why are we expected to not only endorse but actively celebrate a model which institutionalises financial weakness in women and which rewards them for ceding financial agency either to a man or to the government. If women are able to give up work to spend time with their children and have sufficient funds to do so, or if they are forced to do so for reasons beyond their control I'm completely fine with that. I have no judgement whatsoever.

I don't, however, believe I or "society" or anyone else owes them special status for having cut themselves off at the knees financially and weakened not only their own bargaining power in their own families but our broader bargaining power as women in society.

BatheInTheLight · 07/08/2023 17:28

My wife is a SAHM but has €15k of child benefit in her account. Maybe I should be worried about starting again if I need to because I certainly don't have access to that kind of cash! 😁 For the record, no, I'm not in the least bit concerned.

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:21

Usernamen · 07/08/2023 15:58

I completely agree with you but this is not a popular view on MN.

IRL, I have never come across any woman who has abandoned her career and made herself financially dependent on a man after having children, but on MN this seems to be very common. Even in 2023. It has been quite the eye opener.

Same here

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:19

Combusting · 07/08/2023 15:50

The biggest bizareness i hear on MN is -

"But my earnings would be wiped out by the nursery fees - so "we" decided it was best for me to stay home as I earn so little anyway - it's what made sense for us xxx"

Hang on.

  1. First - you don't work just to see how many pennies are left after childcare during nursery years. You work for you. Your pension, Your independence. Your career trajectory. Your skills.
  2. Second - "they are only ickle for only so long xxx" works for dad too. Yet, remarkably - they appear to only stay ickle for so long for mums....because of the age old "but he earns 5x more than me" ..so..
  3. We as a society need to genuinely be asking what's happening here, where mums are magically seemingly ending up earning 5x less anyway, than dads. WHat's happening at school, at GCSE and A level subject choices, further ed and skills choices - that we have a glut of people (apparently) - where men make 5x more money than the women they are partnered with.

I cant ever be bothered to respond to the "but that's what WE decided for US, because my wages would wipe out with nursery/they are only ickle for so long" because of the sheer lack of foresight involved.

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

DisquietintheRanks · 07/08/2023 17:17

LivingDeadGirlUK · 07/08/2023 15:45

That's only a problem if she becomes a stay at home parent.

Or becomes disabled/ incapacitated to the point of not being able to work. Or has a disabled child with high care needs.

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:17

SerafinasGoose · 07/08/2023 15:39

I'm less shocked.

The numerous, bitterly contested SAHM vs. WOHM threads on this site are testimony to this issue. I have no reason to care how other women structure their paid and domestic labour and I dont' care, but the deeply personal commentary surrounding this issue is something else. The objections run pretty much along the lines of: 'SAHMs are 'hated' on MN '. No more than other random groups of people: MiLs, DiLs, etc. 'They are undervalued by society'. What's their value to me? They can knock themselves out living exactly as they please and I'll offer no judgement or comment: just don't expect me to endorse your choices. I DGAF. 'Women should support other women's choices'. Why? Women owe no one 'support' for their decisions on the basis of shared XX chromosomes. Especially when they happen to think those decisions are really stupid.

As for the myriad 'waiting for a romantic proposal' threads, thus handing over a major decision for the future structure of their lives to a man, well frankly anyone daft enough to do so a thing is the author of their own misfortune. You want a thing, ask for it. If you don't get it then at least you know where you stand and can make your own decisions accordingly.

I CBA to waste time judging other women's choices, but nor can I pretend sympathy when choices such as the ones above have the predictable result. Actions have consequences. If a woman wants to live without considering the implications of these - and on top of it gets all pissed off or complains of feeling patronised when the reality is pointed out to her - all I will say is on her head be it.

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:15

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 07/08/2023 15:30

Absolutely agree.

Especially don't sacrifice your employment ability (I'd say career - but people take that wrong - I mean Jobs as well as Careers) in favour of your partner's on the promise/belief that they'll do right by you/you won't split up - it's harder to get back into work than it is to keep your hand in.

It can come as an absolute shock, and Fuck You money gives you the cushion to think clearly if it does happen.

100%

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:14

Zipps · 07/08/2023 15:28

Well said. So many on here and in real life don't. Absolutely zero excuse these days. I know plenty of women with disabilities and disabled dc that still work, invest and have their own finances but this seems to be the number excuse for women on MN not to work. Number two being that their partner is an high earner. Plenty more excuses get trotted out.
Too many also think inheritance or other people's will save them.
I don't understand why some women in 2023 think they should somehow be protected from being involved in sorting themselves out financially.
I have contributed equally financially and am as well off as my DH. We have separate as well as joint investments, savings and our own pensions.

I agree, they just don’t want to work and be funded.

NewNextOfKin · 07/08/2023 17:14

I think this is right. I wouldn't allow myself to be financially dependent on another adult... I mean I'm close to my oldest friends, but conflict of interest would arise if I depended on them and expected them to know what's best for me. Sadly the overlap of interests you have with a man even after having a child together isn't necessarily that great.

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:13

EllenVannen · 07/08/2023 15:08

This is just sound common sense.

So many women on MN seem to be trapped with crappy men in bad relationships that they can't afford to leave.

So, get skilled-up ladies and learn to be financially independent and self-supporting - your increased self-respect will pay you back in spades.

I would also say to any women considering motherhood - do not even consider having a child unless you are prepared emotionally, financially, physically and psychologically to bring that child up alone.

100%!

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 17:12

OhComeOnFFS · 07/08/2023 14:59

I agree with you. I'm also horrified by the number of women here who have children without getting married and then end up so vulnerable, often without a pension or an income.

That’s because they become SAHM

crazeekat · 07/08/2023 17:09

yip i'm agree. i've always been a spender, not a huge earner, nhs nurse. only now i'm kinda like i really should be saving. we moved to a run down house. money has ran out and still need loads done.so wish i had saved more so now totally listening to you all who have been smart. like u said it's having power and choices. wish me luck, always something needed, but need to be ruthless and just save. i can actually save money that i can get straight out. need more places like this to put money away.

PinkWatermelon88 · 07/08/2023 17:09

WhateverMate · 07/08/2023 16:55

It's a great idea OP but there's no point in 'literally BEGging' women who are turning to foodbanks to feed their families.

I agree. While the idea is wonderful, and we’d all love savings to fall back on, the reality is very different. People on the poverty line are barely making ends meet. Contrary to the OP’s post, poor people can not always save. Even a little.
Poverty too is often cyclical and takes a big shift, generally, to break.

NatashaDancing · 07/08/2023 17:08

parliamoglesga · 07/08/2023 14:57

Absolutely yes to this.

not popular on MN but my husband and I only pay the bills jointly and have our own bank accounts. We half the shopping and expenses. Been married for 10 years and it works so don’t @ me 😂

i have my own savings and investments and I know I can support myself if the marriage ends.

Same here. Been together since 1984. We've never had a joint bank account.

Tartareistasty · 07/08/2023 17:07

I am not fan of the hiding money bit though. We are not hiding money, we know each has savings and approx how much etc. We just keep our separate access to them.

Tartareistasty · 07/08/2023 17:05

The fact that your own savings will obviously be matrimknial asset, however, that doesn't mean thay they cannot be used to move out or pay current rent/mortgage if the other moves out and pay for solicitor. That's the point. It allows options for the person.

DH and I have separate finances. If we were to divorce of course these would all be counted and split fairly as agreed or secided by the judge, but before you get to that point it takes quite a while and the money provide the option to leave.

AliceOlive · 07/08/2023 17:00

Yes Yes Yes to this!

Money creates power over your own circumstances. Money equals independence. We all need and deserve this.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/08/2023 16:57

Marry if you are likely to be the lower earner in your relationship, don't if you're going to earn more.

Having a crystal ball would be useful. I was the higher earner when we got married, later spent years being the lower earner and am now equal earner.

Starseeking · 07/08/2023 16:57

This is so true.

Oh how I laughed when my then DP suggested I give up work when our DC was born, despite the fact that I earned 2 x what he did, was a very high earner, and paying two thirds of the household bills.

All because he was uncomfortable that I earned more than he did, not only would our household income have shrunk considerably, I would have put myself at an awful disadvantage being unmarried, and having no job, if we ever split up.

Lo and behold that's exactly what happened 6 years and another DC later. Not only was I able to walk away from the emotional abuse, I was able to buy my own house in a lovely area, and continue in my full-time job, as well as secure even better roles.

I thank my lucky stars that I have always maintained financial independence, having started work at 16 (in part-time jobs alongside studying). I am going to teach my DD to do exactly the same; never ever rely on a man to save you, and have your secret stash ready to go!

JANEY205 · 07/08/2023 16:57

I will add tho that I wanted to be a SAHM to support my child with additional needs and also as I worked in childcare for years and they will never treat your children as well as you can. I was in nursery from 6 weeks old and with childminders on the holidays I HATED IT. I was so envious of my friends who got to be home after school and at the holidays from school. I was also abused by my childminders child. Sorry if this is controversial, but many posts are crapping on women who choose to be SAHM’s, but I never wanted my children looked after by someone else. Even in nice nurseries your child is still vulnerable and not getting the love and care they would from you. Look on the Reddit childcare boards if you don’t want my word for it (and I do think there is benefit to children attending part time nursery over age 3 but research suggests no benefit before then).

Kabbalah · 07/08/2023 16:56

coxesorangepippin · 07/08/2023 15:21

Totally agree

Where are the best hiding places for money if you are married?

I'm sure a lot of men would like to know that too.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 07/08/2023 16:55

overitunderit · 07/08/2023 15:14

I agree with this but I'm also amazed by how many people think having personal savings in a marriage is your own money. If you're married, your savings are marital assets (other than in a small number of limited cases). If your husband was saving money on the side which he then hid from you on divorce you might be a bit irritated. Having said that I do think it's helpful to have some savings in case, as you say, you need to escape for eg DV reasons.

@overitunderit yes, exactly. DH and I have everything in joint names - current account, savings account, mortgage, house. We are married so everything would go into one pot anyway, so not sure there would be much point me having a separate savings account?

I have considered this. I suppose the one thing that it would really help with would be if I thought there was a risk he was about to empty the joint accounts and/or I needed access to a bit of money fast that he didn't have access to.

TiredCatLady · 07/08/2023 16:55

100% this.

Literally anything you can scrape together and put away. Something is better than nothing.

WhateverMate · 07/08/2023 16:55

It's a great idea OP but there's no point in 'literally BEGging' women who are turning to foodbanks to feed their families.

AmyFl · 07/08/2023 16:55

Regardless of whether you have your own savings account, it will go into the matrimonial pot to be split between you if you divorce. I speak from experience, it made absolutely no difference whose name each account was in, all the assets were tallied up and divided- that's the law. Worries me to see how many women think that any money in their name won't be accessible to their husbands on divorce - that's just not the way a marriage works in the eyes of the law.

Swipe left for the next trending thread