Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To literally BEG women to set themselves up, financially?

782 replies

CallieRedux · 07/08/2023 14:14

Typed out a long post full of personal details, then deleted, but, honestly, the specifics don't matter. What DOES matter is that you save every tiny bit you can, because having FUCK YOU money is - by far - the most important thing you can do for yourself.

It's saved me from everything from wrong relationships, shit jobs, from natural disasters... I have both made lots of money, and not, but having savings, and the ability to walk away is having POWER, and the best "self care" a woman can have.

Shit happens. Things change. Even to you. Yes, you can save - even a little - when you are poor.

Do it. Please.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/08/2023 20:28

Totally agree. Even squirelling little bits away will help - fiver saved on shopping etc.

I've always been the higher earner, but now it's even and I hope he keeps earning more. We have our finances set up so we each have the same personal spending money - many heated arguments when he wanted to keep a bonus payment for himself when I'd been making sure he had equal access to my money for years. But we're there now. Money goes in one pot and everything comes out of that, leaving ourselves x amount each month for personal spending.

He wastes his on cigarettes and rubbish, I have a small investment amount set up each month and some savings...building slowly.

Actually, the joint savings are in my name too - but I'd change them to joint if he wanted me to. He just doesn't bother getting involved in it.

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 20:27

Anyway my savings are staying in my sole account and I act like I’m poor. If I need to leave I can, by the time it gets to court the money will have been spent. How will he find out something he never knew about and has disappeared?

anonymousxoxo · 07/08/2023 20:26

@SouthLondonMum22 I agree with what you said here: *So very true.

Like you said, if someone wants to be a SAHM go ahead but I'm not going to value it or support it just because I'm also a woman.

Why should I? SAHM's who facilitate their husband's career make it harder for me and women like me to compete against those men to further my own career.*

I work in a male dominated industry, I’m the only women in my team. These SAHM are contributing to gender pay gap, gender pension gap and reasons why lack of women in senior positions.

I don’t understand how SAHM is the hardest job in the world bullshit.

It really isn’t.

Mmhmmn · 07/08/2023 20:23

"never ever rely on a man to save you, and have your secret stash ready to go!"

Not least because most of the time they're either dragging you down or screwing you over 🙄 😂

ScarlettSunset · 07/08/2023 20:23

I think everyone should try to have some savings of their own wherever possible (I know it can be difficult especially in times like these). Both women and men too. It's not just a safety net for women who may be in financially vulnerable situations but anyone can find themselves in a difficult situation.
It only takes one change of manager for a lovely job to turn into a toxic working nightmare and just knowing you COULD walk away can help give you more strength to search for another one when you're being worn down by it.

Tartareistasty · 07/08/2023 20:21

Serenglas · 07/08/2023 20:15

Our society would be much healthier if everyone worked out of the home in some respect and men and women shared the financial, child rearing, housework, life admin 🤮 loads. I don’t mean children in FT childcare, I mean 2 parents that equally contribute to the family pot and spend equal time with their children. Men and women working flexibly. That is the society that we need.

That won’t happen because of women.

Why are so many women bothering to go to university when they really yearn for for the 1950s?

I think 4 day week would be so good for this.

I did 4 day week once a month an that extra day was great. Sorted everything that needed sorting and had a weekend still. No one day ret because you spend 1 days sorting crap.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 07/08/2023 20:20

@Mmhmmn and @coxesorangepippin just in a bank account that only you know about and keep it paperless.

The purpose of a running away fund is so that you have the ability to leave the relationship, it will pay for renting a new property, solicitors fees, transport etc. if you have a massive amount saved then it's possible there will still be some left by the point you get to the financial disclosures/division of assets stage of a divorce but you could always prepay 6 months/12 months rent if you needed to dispose of it in a way that secured your financial position and prevents it being handed to your ex.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 20:20

@Frazzledmum123

find it bizarre that people go into marriage planning on having an escape,

This isn't what it's about. It's about backing yourself. Ensuring your needs aren't ignored or subjugated as part of marriage / child rearing & possible reduction in earnings or career opportunities.

The specific arrangements are based on your own circumstances but the priority is making sure you are not in an excessively vulnerable position compared to your spouse.

I think the problem is that people rush into these things without making sure they are with the right person

Do you? Do you really?

This may happen sometimes. However, many times, the nature of an abusive spouse is not revealed until after you have DC.

I knew my H 7 years before we got married. In retrospect there were red flags. Unfortunately these weren't apparent to me until well into our marriage & having children.

I know his character/soul enough to know he 100% does not have it in him to screw me over completely.

Oh god love you. I'm sure you your DH is lovely. However, believe me, any man (and presumably any woman, if the circumstances permit) is capable of shitty exploitative behaviour, when relationships end.

I am very independent so could totally live on my own if I had to quite easily,

Well, you've just talked about him supporting you & paying for everything when you were on mat leave. What if he'd ended it then? How easy would it be to support yourself while caring for small DC in a stage of shock?

It's easy to think you could manage easily - but when everything that's certain is taken away from you, it's not easy at all. Hence the need for access to finance & earnings.

Serenglas · 07/08/2023 20:15

Our society would be much healthier if everyone worked out of the home in some respect and men and women shared the financial, child rearing, housework, life admin 🤮 loads. I don’t mean children in FT childcare, I mean 2 parents that equally contribute to the family pot and spend equal time with their children. Men and women working flexibly. That is the society that we need.

That won’t happen because of women.

Why are so many women bothering to go to university when they really yearn for for the 1950s?

Mmhmmn · 07/08/2023 20:14

@ScribblingPixie

In my first job, when I was very young and ditsy, two women once sat me down and told me that my priority should be to create lifelong security for myself so that I could be completely independent. They were so earnest and insistent that I took it 100 per cent on board. They'll never know that what they did for me.

I love that. Good on those fabulous women.

Mmhmmn · 07/08/2023 20:12

coxesorangepippin · 07/08/2023 15:21

Totally agree

Where are the best hiding places for money if you are married?

Pfff, well if he's entitled to anything that's in a bank, I guess .. to be truly hidden it would need to be a risky in form of cash in a storage unit or bank vault? But you must have to declare what you're storing (?) Other than that .. selling your rings ...? Curious to see other (more sensible?!) replies.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 07/08/2023 20:10

And if you do move in with someone who has their own property in their name don't out any money into it unless you're on the deeds. Share the bills only and use the opportunity to squirrel away a deposit to buy a cheap, rental property for yourself. That way if things do go tits up as you reach retirement age as they often do you don't have to worry about keeping a roof over your head and have something to fall back on.

LucyGru · 07/08/2023 20:09

I wish someone had explained this when I was young. I don't even want to leave my husband, but I was such a little idiot - "Oh, you earn more than me so it makes sense for me to give up my job and bring up the children - cheaper than childcare!".
No no no no no no. I am now in my 40s and starting again career-wise. No one explained to me the concept of keeping your hand in, and future-proofing, and I wasn't clever enough to work it out for myself. I just did what I had seen the women in my family do before me and stayed home with the children. Idiot.

Mmhmmn · 07/08/2023 20:07

parliamoglesga · 07/08/2023 14:57

Absolutely yes to this.

not popular on MN but my husband and I only pay the bills jointly and have our own bank accounts. We half the shopping and expenses. Been married for 10 years and it works so don’t @ me 😂

i have my own savings and investments and I know I can support myself if the marriage ends.

Same. It works. And totally agree with OP - YADefinitelyNBU!

carly2803 · 07/08/2023 20:06

i agree. especially those women who are not married, do not work and depend on a partner - and the house is in his name!
just absolutely stupid in this day and age - no excuses for this and ive literally no sympathy for women who put themselves in this position

onthebrink23 · 07/08/2023 20:00

Wish I'd thought of this/ not trusted my oh. 20 years on & I don't even have control of my own wages from my respected career! I'll teach my children this 100%. I've learned my lesson.

Nimello · 07/08/2023 19:57

CattyCattle · 07/08/2023 15:42

Depends on the length or marriage, if it went in to paying for a house etc. Inheritance if kept seperate is usually the only guaranteed money you won't have to share.

There are many cases in which inheritance (and pre-marital assets) have to be shared. It depends on how much there is in the pot and whether it is sufficient for everyone's needs or not.

mealtickett · 07/08/2023 19:56

do not even consider having a child unless you are prepared emotionally, financially, physically and psychologically to bring that child up alone.

--
I also say EXACTLY this. As young as I was, I even warned my darling older sister with a regular job that if she thought getting married was her licence to birth as many kids as she could, she would be mistaken and she should only give birth to kids SHE believed she could support on her own. She stopped at 2 kids and she thanks her lucky star for that as although she ideally wanted 3, she stopped at 2 as marriage started unravelling anyway, and her 'D' H turned out to be a dick fathering multiple kids (3) outside the marriage.

I had to warn my sister because as a family, we can be considered wealthy, however, we each work hard for our money. We largely assisted her- one chid moved in with us (main family home) as theirs wasn't a happy home according to child, and sis, for a while still felt we should just dish out money to her, until she eventually got a grip. She is fine now and happily raising her younger child as the other one stayed with us permanently.

venusandmars · 07/08/2023 19:56

Oh yes!

When I left my abusive marriage 30+ years ago, my Mum said that the problem was that we had too much money.. If I'd not had enough to leave I would have just have to do what she did and lay on the bed that I'd made Sad

Fortunately, I was working, and could break free!

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 07/08/2023 19:56

@SouthLondonMum22^* "So very true.

Like you said, if someone wants to be a SAHM go ahead but I'm not going to value it or support it just because I'm also a woman.

Why should I? SAHM's who facilitate their husband's career make it harder for me and women like me to compete against those men to further my own career."*^

Agreed, it's very frustrating when I'm having to do conference calls on Bluetooth while driving to pick up DD from holiday club and still be professional and insightful using information I've had to memorise because I can't refer to my notes. While male colleagues with SAHM wives are sat at their desks, with their notes on the call that they scheduled out of hours because they can because they have someone else facilitating their ability to opt of of caring for their child.

Usernamen · 07/08/2023 19:55

PurpleWisteria1 · 07/08/2023 19:19

What about bringing boys up to not be men who are total arseholes and leave the woman in the shit?
What if you are a women who wants to actually look after her children rather than pay someone else to do it? (And as a couple that is financially viable due to husbands wages?)
All I ever wanted was to be with my kids day to day both whilst they were very small and before school/ straight after school every day. Yes I did get a profession first but I never wanted any childcare of any kind. My one dream was to spend every day with them.
I’ve been lucky enough to do that so far (they have finished primary school) and it’s been worth it 100x. If I never achieve anything again it will be been 100% worth it because I’ve had the most incredible 14 years- best of my life with them.
But no, I haven’t saved for myself. I’m married. Didn’t want my career- hated it anyway and being with my kids was a million times better.
Have worked at home and earned a bit whilst they are at school but that goes in the joint pot along with DH wages.
Not really sure where that leaves me? However I do have a good DH who I am as sure as I can possibly be that he wouldn’t leave us in the shit if we ever split.
I could never have earned anywhere near as much as he can anyway- so could lot have afforded this house or the life style we have. Would have had to work all through my kids being little which to me was my absolute worst eventuality.

This is fair enough and I do appreciate MN for opening my eyes to views like yours because (and with all due respect) I literally know no one in real life who is like you.

The parents I know love the break from their children that going to work affords them, they like the balance and variety that having a career and children provides, they enjoy the economic benefits of a dual income household, they value jointly financially providing for their family, they love that they haven’t lost their identity to parenthood and have retained a sense of themselves despite having to think about little people now.

I am sure you have contingency plan in place if things go wrong in your marriage, but this thread is about women who don’t - this is a big risk and worth discussing at length on a women-only forum (well mostly women-only!).

LivingDeadGirlUK · 07/08/2023 19:50

Skye109 · 07/08/2023 19:35

But how????
This post is aimed at high earners, surely??
I'm a registered nurse. I am well educated, went to University, did really well. I work every day whilst DC are at school, which means I don't work full time. I can't, because I need to collect primary school aged DC from school and look after them. If I were to put DC in to after school childcare it costs either the same as what I take home or sometimes more, so it's financially pointless. Aside from childcare costs, one of my DC has SEN so needs masses of input each and every day from me after school. My other DC needs very high levels of input. They both really need my support daily after school.
My pay is never going to increase; I'm at the top of my pay band. To go up another pay band it'd be a promotion in to a senior role where I'd be expected to increase my hours, which I can't do because of the above. And so it goes round in a circle, always going back to childcare issues.
I'm bright, intelligent, clever at what I do, have brilliant interpersonal skills, receive no end of positive feedback from patients, and I am a super hard worker. But no amount of these skills is going to earn me any more money, because in my job the pay is capped once you reach the top of your band/pay spine.
So the money I take home is woefully inadequate for living in the SE with a young family to provide for, and now the cost of living crisis is killing me financially. I'm poor. Really, really poor. I live on money borrowed from the bank every month. And it's beyond stressful. So how can I save??? I use my money to pay towards my mortgage, shopping, my car, everything else goes on my DC financial needs, and then it's gone. And I'm really sensible and careful with money.
Meanwhile, my DH has no career ambition, is a middle earner, lives in debt every month because he can't meet our monthly financial outgoings, works 14 hours a day, is rarely at home, leaves all childcare, household organisation, domestic chores to me because I work part time, drinks beer every night, spends a lot of time snapping, sneering and shouting at me, has a million different things about him that I hate....and ive noticed recentlythat I've lost my smile. I used to have such a radiant, glowing smile. It's gone now. Worn away.
But I'm financially trapped. I can't escape.
If I leave my husband, I literally wouldn't be able to afford to live or support my DC.
I can only dream of having savings! Instead I have nightmares about the level of stress we're about to face in a few months when our fixed rate mortgage ends and increases by hundreds a montb due to interest rate rises. I'm scared about this. We have no extra money.
We have a joint mortgage. I can't afford to buy him out. He can't afford to keep paying for his half of the mortgage and household bills and food whilst paying to live somewhere else. It would catapult him in to financial poverty which would negatively impact on DC, as he literally couldn't afford to support me and DC separately from supporting himself.
Financially, we need to all live together.
Which is miserable.
So tell me. What can I do????????
Your post reads like a different world to mine.
You must be a very high earner.
The people in my situation - we're trapped.
I was so bright eyed, radiant, enthusiastic and confident for my future when I was a young adult. That's long gone now, as DH regularly reminds me.

This sounds like a really tough situation, but ultimately it sounds like you need to look at when you can realistically leave your husband and start planning towards that. It might not be for 10 years depending on how young your kids are, but you need to keep your eye on the prize.

In the future your kids will be able to take themselves to and from school and the time will be right for that promotion, keep your head in the game and your skills up to date so you can seize that as soon as possible.

Research all the benefits you may be entitled to should you separate so you know exactly what the deal would be, it may be that once you weigh up against your husbands beer money its not that much of a difference. Are you aware of the tax free childcare scheme? You get 25% of childcare costs including after school clubs paid for by the government which may help.

How much equity is there in the house, should you separate and sell is there enough for a smaller place for you and DC?

If your husband was a team player he would see you doing all this work and try and pull his weight by getting a better paid job that doesn't involve 14 hours days but it sounds like he doesn't give a shit and therefore you need to stop worrying about him after a split. Just assume you won't get any CM as men like that will do anything they can not to pay.

IveHadItUpToHere · 07/08/2023 19:49

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 16:40

But what you have in your favour is not actually your separate savings & pension (tho these are great) - you have a spouse who you are financially compatible with, that you can communicate well with & is open to this way of being.

All of this hopefully means that you'll have a long-lasting happy marriage!

Because your higher pension absolutely would be taken into account in a divorce settlement, as would your savings.

My point is - it's not only about money. It's about thought processes, backing oneself & having honest & open conversations about money.

In a 17 year relationship my ex & I never had one conversation about money that didn't end in a row. There were so many 🚩🚩🚩🚩 and I ignored them, to my ultimate detriment.

I think one of the benefits was we both knew what our personalities were like and how they interacted with each other. As a recovering people pleaser, I knew that I'd be more reticent to spend money from a joint account and that any throwaway remarks by DH could have impacted my attitude to spending.
Our spending and saving habits are actually quite different. DH has always been more materialistic than I am. But yy, on big purchases we either agree or trust the one who is pushing for the purchase iyswim.
I watched friends lie to their DHs about what items cost and knew I didn't ever want that in a relationship. And equally, DH watched his friends worry about discussing purchases with their partners - and didn't want that dynamic. We're open about what we spend and about what we save. And DH always knew that even though my DM adored him (and he adored her back) that she'd advised me to keep separate money and assets.

Terraria · 07/08/2023 19:48

Great post, so many parents put themaelves in such vulnerable position, it worth rising awareness.

I was a sahm to three dc for 10 years. I was lucky, i have access to dh's income, I am in control of household finanace. However, I missed out 10 years of pension contribution and had zero saving.

During dh's midlife crisis, we almost end up divorce. It never happened because I was unemployed, I am financially dependent on him, that was Dec 2016. In Jan 2017, I found a 25k job, childcare for 3 kids costed more than what I earned during the holidays, however, I kept going even if it was a lost. Now I am on 52k, have saving and catching up on my pension pot. I am financially dependent should anything happen.

I most definitely will discourage my children to be in the same situation as I was.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 07/08/2023 19:45

Tbh I think its high time that laws around marriage were modernised, if they havent had children then they should just take out what they've put in. It's ridiculous that in this day and age women (( and men )) who have sat on their arses for years can claim money they haven't earned and pensions they haven't paid into. Inheritance and separate savings should be ringfenced and allowed to be kept.

If kids are involved then a 50 / 50 split is fairer.......but I still don't think Inheritance or savings from either side should be on the table.........and no, I'm not a man. I'm a woman who wasn't stupid enough to get married because I'd have more money to lose if things went tits up which I've seen time and time again. If my partner and I split he'll take what he has in the bank and pensions, I'll take mine and we'll split the house. That's fair. I don't think I'm entitled to more because I popped a couple of kids out.