Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Email sent by colleagues addressed to 'Gents'

232 replies

funkymonkey55 · 07/08/2023 13:18

AIBU to be annoyed by a male colleague starting an email chain to other male colleagues where he addresses them as "Gents" and then he loops me in a few days later - when the actions around the original email topic (gathering information together) need to be picked up (by me of course!)?

It annoys me because I feel 1) I should have been cc'd in the first instance, 2) Isn't starting an email chain where you know females will have to be cc'd in / included with the phrase Gents a little rude?

I don't know if I am being a bit overly sensitive.

OP posts:
Giveuprobot · 07/08/2023 16:16

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 14:19

Nether 'Dear Gents' or 'Dear Ladies' is appropriate professional communication.

Dear Colleagues / Team / All / Names.

I can't believe people use this anachronistic language still.

This, in spades.

If I got an email that started 'Dear Ladies', I'd think the sender had completely lost their head.

funkymonkey55 · 07/08/2023 16:14

ReadingSoManyThreads · 07/08/2023 15:40

Your new manager has now turned your workplace into "boys club".

I'd watch your back with this colleague who has not only left you out of communication that concerned you and needed action by you, but has acted like a snake.

Think there is logic in this, between the other female colleagues pay issue not being acknowledged for 5 days, this and other things I have witnessed I have started to keep a log - incase required.

From responses - I think the 'Gents' addressee point in isolation may not be perceived as much of a big deal, but this coupled with the fact that Mr Gents knows that I have steered / led this task in the two previous instances and not bothered to include me in the email in the outset leads me to think -

  1. maybe just forgot in the outset and decided to include me afterwards (which leads me to think he doesn't have great EQ / sensitivity or awareness)
  2. thinks this type of behavior is more acceptable in the new regime
  3. is a bit chauvinist

If I bring it up he will plead 1 but I wonder if 2/3 are underlying factors also... in any event I doubt I will get a straight answer.

OP posts:
Tanith · 07/08/2023 16:12

Of course you're not being over-sensitive!

I once sat in a training course where the trainer repeatedly referred to "Guys" and "Gents". Everyone else there was male and the trainer was a friend of our new director.
That director then had a reorganisation and renamed every woman's job title in authoritiy to "Supervisor" and every man's to "Manager". It was blatant. Subsequent responsibilities and associated pay rises were affected.

If more people were prepared to call this out more often, we'd have less sexism, and less discrimination and less of a pay gap because of it.

aperolspriitz · 07/08/2023 16:10

Collaborate · 07/08/2023 15:44

That is a different matter entirely (diversity in the workplace).

Addressing a group consisting entirely of men as "gents" is perfectly reasonable. Complaining about it devalues the real complaints women still have in the workplace.

No. Highlighting it is directly relevant to the 'real complaints women still have in the workplace'.

Croneyism between men is very much alive and kicking in many so-called 'modern' workplaces. If you don't call out the small things, you will never fix the big issues.

EzraJones · 07/08/2023 16:09

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 07/08/2023 13:36

Actually @funkymonkey55, I don't think you're being oversensitive.

1- would it have been appropriate to include you in the email initially? Do you feel that not including you to start with was a deliberate omission, or were you just copied in later for info?

2- in my first leadership role 15 years ago, I sent an email to my team addressed "Guys". I was very quickly pulled up on this by a couple of women who pointed out that 1- they are not make, 2 - "Guys" is not inclusive, and makes them feel overlooked 3- that's just casual, lazy sexism.

I've since started informal emails to my teams as "Morning All", "Team" or "Folks".

Or go with "Folx" which appears designed to be even more(!) gender neutral than "Folks" 😅

PollyPandas · 07/08/2023 16:06

This made me laugh!

Outdamnspot23 · 07/08/2023 16:05

Btw I also hate “folks” etc so I go with “Hi all” “Hello” or “Good morning” etc

Oloi · 07/08/2023 16:05

Depending on how many 'gents' were in the original email, it's not that strange to collectively identify them as such.

In my department in a school, we have a a small leadership team of four different roles, all occupied by women and it's normal for us all to address the different combinations of two or all three others involved in different topics as ladies, but we wouldn't do this in the mixed wider team.

Outdamnspot23 · 07/08/2023 16:04

This is reminding me of the time some colleagues and I were working on a project related to breast cancer. My boss, wanting us all to come with her to a meeting, stood up and went “Come on them Team Breast!”. We just so happened to all be women (and quite booby for the most part). None of us really noticed and we were quite surprised when colleagues near us who didn’t know about the project were shocked to their very cores.

(this doesn’t help the OP unless the project she was excluded from was Male Toilet of the Year though)

PollyPandas · 07/08/2023 16:03

aperolspriitz · 07/08/2023 15:27

There is an issue though.

The person who has sent that email has looked at each person they are sending it to and realised that they are all male and though 'Oh, isn't that nice, I can label us all as 'Gents'! We're all Gents together! ho ho!'

That's fucking awful - it's really, really old fashioned and has no place in the workplace.

I completely disagree and think this is a bit bonkers. I also don't think 'old fashioned' automatically means wrong or problematic.

Referring to a group of men as 'Gents' or 'Gentleman', or similar is just a nice, polite plural noun where I'm from, like "Ladies" not a "Tally ho, rah rah, let's form a London club on the Mall and keep out the wimmin!"

I'm probably biased by the fact I can't bear infantilising, cutesy inclusives like "Folks", but I accept that that is my personal preference and don't feel the need to "pull people up" on it because it doesn't conform to my idea of the ideal.

What I thought you were going to say is that if by the time of sending the email the sender realised he'd only included men (so could say 'Gents'), that should have tipped him off that he hadn't copied the OP and probably needed to. Which I'd probably agree with and have much more sympathy for as a position!

But then we're back to simply the issue being that OP should have been included from the start. Which only warrants a "Hi colleague, I'd appreciate being copied on these emails from the beginning, please, as its easier for me to keep track of what's needed. Thanks, OP", in the first instance.

MrReflection · 07/08/2023 16:02

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 15:52

it was addressed in an acceptable manner to the (then) intended recipients.

Using 'gents' in a professional work place is not acceptable.

The underlying point OP is making is it was exclusionary to start with, which the choice of term 'gents' confirms.

Using 'colleagues' or [names] ensures appropriate inclusivity, in a standard way. Regardless of who you are addressing, and what their sex, or position, they are addressed the same way.

Spot on. It's not acceptable.

And I've had a conversation with a male colleague before about the use of the term.

I play it as safe as I can when I am emailing a group and use "Dear All". It is wholly inclusive, whatever the recipients gender.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 15:52

it was addressed in an acceptable manner to the (then) intended recipients.

Using 'gents' in a professional work place is not acceptable.

The underlying point OP is making is it was exclusionary to start with, which the choice of term 'gents' confirms.

Using 'colleagues' or [names] ensures appropriate inclusivity, in a standard way. Regardless of who you are addressing, and what their sex, or position, they are addressed the same way.

andymary · 07/08/2023 15:48

Please tell me how an email that was sent in the past, that got sent to a group that was all males, and was addressed with the word "Gents" is an annoyance.

At the time that the email was sent, it was addressed in an acceptable manner to the (then) intended recipients. You have been CC'd into it afterwards... it was not originally addressed to you.

You can't complain about something that happened in the past, that you weren't originally involved or included in, and so wasn't addressed to incorporate you at the time🙄

MrsElsa · 07/08/2023 15:46

Everyday sexism, absolutely not ok, it's 2023 fgs.

Sorry you are having to deal with this nonsense OP.

I work in a technical field which is male dominated. Even the "good" bosses and colleagues I've had, have publically and privately made sexist comments and assumptions which have absolutely no place in the workplace. It is ridiculous.

Solidarity.

ilovemydogmore · 07/08/2023 15:45

Gents, ladies, guys... none of these words are appropriate in the modern workplace. Same for 'manning' as in running, e.g. 'are you manning the exhibition stand'. It's gendered language and as small as it seems, it makes it more difficult for people other than men to be seen as equals to men.

Times change, we evolve language as we learn more and we should be open to doing so. Workplaces should feel inclusive, and we know gender is a really important characteristic to protect because of the stark pay gap.

Responses that suggest otherwise in this thread are from people that don't work in a corporate environment, people that worked a long time ago or people that work in a very outdated company with outdated leadership. Or you're just outdated yourself.

Collaborate · 07/08/2023 15:44

aperolspriitz · 07/08/2023 15:33

What about when "The Gents" start to feel like a little group, and decide to start going on little socials together which exclude women, and then it just so happens that they start talking shop? And, oh look, now they've started talking promotions? Because they can talk about the "Gents" things when the women aren't around.

Language might seem like nothing, but it is powerful, and this is divisive.

"Hi everyone" is not difficult. There's really no need to state whether the people you are addressing are male or female.

That is a different matter entirely (diversity in the workplace).

Addressing a group consisting entirely of men as "gents" is perfectly reasonable. Complaining about it devalues the real complaints women still have in the workplace.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 15:43

CitizenofMoronia · 07/08/2023 15:40

my lot do a lot of "guys" so i go ... since you're unable to remember its guys and gals i suggest we go with the gender neutral and merge them ... we are henceforth "Gays"... that stopped em.

Dear God.

Your response is worse again. Utterly cringeworthy.

CitizenofMoronia · 07/08/2023 15:40

my lot do a lot of "guys" so i go ... since you're unable to remember its guys and gals i suggest we go with the gender neutral and merge them ... we are henceforth "Gays"... that stopped em.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 07/08/2023 15:40

Your new manager has now turned your workplace into "boys club".

I'd watch your back with this colleague who has not only left you out of communication that concerned you and needed action by you, but has acted like a snake.

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 07/08/2023 15:36

I'm guessing the people who haven't seen emails addressed gents or ladies in the last 20 odd years work in the public sector, where its a little more enlightened. The old engineering company I worked for would circulate everything addressed "gentlemen", and then cc one of the "girls" for the facilitation (staff were either gentlemen or girls! 🤮).
Addressing an email to male colleagues as "gents" seems harmless, but it perpetuates the old old boy's club mentality and makes it a little more hostile for women. I'm 50 now, but in my early working life, business jollies would end up in strip clubs, women in management were seen as over promoted secretaries. Secretaries and admin were employed by their looks, with the most attractive on reception. Addressing an email to the gentlemen seems to harp back to the 90s somehow.

Snowpaw · 07/08/2023 15:35

I work in a group of only women but regularly correspondence is sent to us as "Dear Sirs..." - all the time.

aperolspriitz · 07/08/2023 15:34

Collaborate · 07/08/2023 15:32

But all the recipients of the initial email were men.

Yes, but the point is, why did the sender of the email feel the need to acknowledge this?

HarrietJet · 07/08/2023 15:34

Collaborate · 07/08/2023 15:32

But all the recipients of the initial email were men.

Because op was deliberately left off...

aperolspriitz · 07/08/2023 15:33

Collaborate · 07/08/2023 15:31

So he emails a number of colleagues, all of whom are male. He starts the email addressing them as "gents". Later on you get copied in to this email. At that point he does not readdress everyone as gents, but you are upset that he initially emailed a group of men and decided to call them "gents"?

I'm sure there are many things for you to reasonably feel aggrieved about as a woman in the workplace but this is not one of them.

What about when "The Gents" start to feel like a little group, and decide to start going on little socials together which exclude women, and then it just so happens that they start talking shop? And, oh look, now they've started talking promotions? Because they can talk about the "Gents" things when the women aren't around.

Language might seem like nothing, but it is powerful, and this is divisive.

"Hi everyone" is not difficult. There's really no need to state whether the people you are addressing are male or female.

Daphnis156 · 07/08/2023 15:33

It sounds like something from the 1950s, when the "Ladies" were at home dusting and baking cakes.
Not really what you want in the 2020s.